Matthew 15:33
And his disciples say unto him, Whence should we have so much bread in the wilderness, as to fill so great a multitude?
Translations
And his disciples say to him, From where should we have so much bread in the wilderness, as to fill so great a multitude?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And his disciples say unto him, Whence should we have so much bread in the wilderness, as to fill so great a multitude?
And his disciples say to him, Whence should we have so much bread in the wilderness, as to satisfy so great a multitude?
And the disciples say unto him, Whence should we have so many loaves in a desert place, as to fill so great a multitude?
And the disciples say unto him, Whence should we have so many loaves in a desert place as to fill so great a multitude?
And his disciples say to him, 'Whence to us, in a wilderness, so many loaves, as to fill so great a multitude?'
And his disciples say to him, Whence should we have so many loaves in [ the] wilderness as to satisfy so great a crowd?
And his disciples say unto him—Whence, to us, in a wilderness, loaves in such numbers as to fill a multitude, so great?
The disciples replied, “ Where in this desolate place could we find enough bread to feed such a large crowd?”
His disciples replied, “ Where in this desolate place could we find enough bread to feed such a large crowd?”
The disciples said to him, “ Where could we get so many loaves in a deserted place as to satisfy so great a multitude?”
And the disciples say to him, How may we get enough bread in a waste place, to give food to such a number of people?
And his disciples saide vnto him, Whence should we get so much bread in the wildernes, as should suffice so great a multitude!
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the disciples say unto him: Whence then should we have so many loaves in the desert, as to fill so great a multitude?
Cross-references
- Matthew 14:19-20
And he commanded the multitude to sit down on the grass, and took the five loaves, and the two fishes, and looking up to heaven, he blessed, and brake, and gave the loaves to his disciples, and the disciples to the multitude.
Jesus feeds five thousand with loaves and fish, and twelve baskets of fragments remain.
- Mark 8:4
And his disciples answered him, From whence can a man satisfy these men with bread here in the wilderness?
The disciples ask where bread can be found to feed the multitude in the wilderness.
- Matthew 16:10
Neither the seven loaves of the four thousand, and how many baskets ye took up?
Jesus reminds the disciples of the feeding with seven loaves and the baskets left over.
- Matthew 15:37
And they did all eat, and were filled: and they took up of the broken meat that was left seven baskets full.
seven baskets gathered in this feeding
- Exodus 16:3
And the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
Moses questions whether God can provide food in the wilderness.
- John 6:35
And Jesus said unto them, I am the bread of life: he that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth on me shall never thirst.
Christ is the living bread who satisfies hunger.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
8 sources
The question is that of the disciples asking where enough bread could be found in the wilderness, in a lonely place, to fill so great a hungry multitude.DA 404.1–405.2Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–15Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34Lt 302, 1906, par. 5 It came after thousands had stayed with Christ three days with nothing to eat, having forgotten the wants of nature while listening with deepest interest to His ministry of truth and gracious words.Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–1518MR 115.3Ms 132, 1902, par. 14 They had only a few loaves and fishes, seven loaves and a few little fishes, and doubted He would multiply their small supply, though they had seen Him feed a multitude before.DA 404.1–405.2Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34 Their response was also shaped by prejudice against the Gentile crowd, after Christ had for a time acted out the narrow and exclusive ideas controlling many followers.DA 404.1–405.2Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–15
The setting reveals His tender solicitude as a pitying father mindful of human need and of the wants of others even when often hungry Himself.18MR 115.3Ms 132, 1902, par. 14 He had compassion, knew the people were hungry and must have something to eat, and would not send them away fasting lest they faint in the way.18MR 115.3Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34Ms 132, 1902, par. 14 He understood that faintness from His own long fast in the wilderness of temptation, when He had fainted and angels had ministered to Him.18MR 115.3Ms 132, 1902, par. 14 Without hesitation He worked a miracle to feed the thousands who had followed Him to hear the gracious words proceeding from His lips.18MR 115.3Ms 132, 1902, par. 14
He had the multitude sit on a grassy spot, broke the seven loaves and few little fishes into small pieces, and passed the food through His disciples to the four thousand men besides women and children until all ate and were filled.Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–15Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34 Then He had the fragments gathered that nothing be lost, with seven baskets full remaining in this feeding while twelve were gathered on the other occasion.Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34 The miraculous feeding was a means to impart spiritual truths of vital importance to the salvation of souls.Lt 93, 1892, par. 4–5 His power to furnish food in a miraculous way does not teach that no effort should be put forth to provide the necessities of life.Lt 93, 1892, par. 4–5
The feeding of this multitude together with the feeding of the five thousand provides an example of Christ's methods to study in carrying forward food work.Lt 302, 1906, par. 5 It shows what Christ can do, calling for more faith in Him as the One who can do all things, minister, teach, and guide into truth.Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34 The verse gives a lesson for His people today to take part in His work of healing the sick multitudes and supplying the wants of the needy.Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–15Lt 28, 1909, par. 16 The healing part is to be done in connection with health institutions, which did not exist in the early days of the message but now exist.Lt 28, 1909, par. 13–15Lt 28, 1909, par. 16 For miraculous healing of the sick in answer to prayer is no sign those institutions for the benefit of the suffering should be abolished, since the Lord will not always work miracles to keep people alive, the afflicted are to be placed where they can have hygienic living and treatment, and these agencies must not be despised.Lt 28, 1909, par. 16Lt 93, 1892, par. 4–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
15 sources
In a deserted place where ordinary supply was out of reach, the disciples wondered how enough bread could be found to satisfy a vast hungry crowd that lacked strength to reach the villages.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 12, 1911ST Sep 22, 1881 Moved by compassion lest the people faint on the way, Jesus fed four thousand men besides women and children from seven loaves and a few small dried fish until all ate and were filled, with seven baskets of fragments left over and gathered so nothing would be wasted.ST Sep 23, 1908ST Jun 28, 1899ST Oct 22, 1902ST Sep 22, 1881ST Aug 5, 1886 Where Christ is present there can be no lack, for he is the living bread whose spoken word can become material food, and the Lord is not limited in resources or means by which he sustains his people.ST Oct 22, 1902ST Jun 28, 1899 Though as Creator he could have provided food miraculously in any way, he chose to use the little that was offered, while the disciples, though they had already witnessed his feeding power, were dismayed at their small supply and measured his ability by ordinary limits instead of trusting him.ST Aug 5, 1913ST Jun 28, 1899ST Feb 11, 1886ST Sep 22, 1881ST Jun 21, 1899
Wilderness Feeding Account
The disciples asked where so much bread could be found in a deserted wilderness place to fill so great a multitude.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 12, 1911ST Sep 22, 1881ST Feb 11, 1886 Their question arose because the provisions of the large crowd had run short in that wilderness setting.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 12, 1911ST Sep 22, 1881 Ordinary supplies were inaccessible there, and the people lacked strength to reach villages for food.ST Sep 22, 1881ST Feb 11, 1886
Jesus then fed four thousand men, besides women and children, from seven loaves and a few small dried fish.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Oct 22, 1902ST Sep 22, 1881 All ate and were filled without stint, with seven baskets of fragments left over after everyone had eaten.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Oct 22, 1902ST Sep 22, 1881 The feeding was miraculous, and the remaining fragments were gathered so that nothing would be wasted.ST Sep 22, 1881ST Jan 11, 1877
He fed the thousands twice because he had compassion on them.ST Sep 23, 1908ST Aug 5, 1886 He was mindful that the multitude had gone without food and acted to keep them from fainting on the way, showing tender concern for physical needs.ST Sep 23, 1908ST Aug 5, 1886 After this wilderness feeding he came to Dalmanutha, near Magdala, where the Pharisees questioned him and demanded a sign from heaven.ST Jul 7, 1898
Christ's Provision and Faith
The feeding of four thousand people with seven loaves and a few small fish, with seven baskets left after all had eaten and been filled, shows that Jesus can provide for the hungry and that the Lord is not limited in the resources or means by which He sustains His people.ST Oct 22, 1902 Where Christ is there can be no lack, for He is the living bread whose spoken word can become material food that nourishes the body.ST Jun 28, 1899 Though as Creator He had power to provide food miraculously in any way, He chose to use the few loaves and fishes that were offered to satisfy the hungry people.ST Aug 5, 1913
Standing just before His question, How many loaves have ye, the disciples' question shows strict continuity of God's work in the natural world and in the spiritual world.ST Aug 5, 1913 Tomorrow must in some wise come out of today, the present has come out of the past and is a product of the past, and the future is to be formed from the present, so that what is to be must come out of what has been.ST Aug 5, 1913 Even where the old is to be enlarged or renewed or to receive great and startling changes, even a revolution, God makes the greater things more fully to His purpose out of the little and insignificant and forever inefficient.ST Aug 5, 1913
The disciples were dismayed that their small supply could not feed the great multitude in the wilderness and were concerned that they had no bread.ST Aug 5, 1913ST Jun 28, 1899 Ordinary supplies were inaccessible and the people lacked strength to reach villages, so they saw no way to obtain enough bread.ST Feb 11, 1886 Their difficulty in believing He could provide came despite miraculous feedings they had already witnessed, which Jesus later reminded them of, because their reasoning focused on lack of bread instead of on His power to provide.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 22, 1881 Their question is an example of human doubt that measures God's ability by ordinary limits, and it teaches hope and trust in God's ability to work through what seems insufficient.ST Aug 5, 1913ST Sep 22, 1881ST Jun 21, 1899
Sources