Matthew 28:13
Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
Translations
Saying, Say you, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
King James Version, Webster Bible
Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
saying, 'Say ye, that his disciples having come by night, stole him — we being asleep;
saying, Say that his disciples coming by night stole him [ while] we [ were] sleeping.
saying—Say ye, His disciples, coming, by night, stole him, while we were sleeping;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
and instructed them: “ You are to say, ‘ His disciples came by night and stole Him away while we were asleep.’
saying, “ Say that his disciples came by night and stole him away while we slept.
Say, His disciples came by night and took him away secretly while we were sleeping.
Saying, Say, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Saying: Say you, His disciples came by night, and stole him away when we were asleep.
Cross-references 20 of 27
- Matthew 27:62-66
Now the next day, that followed the day of the preparation, the chief priests and Pharisees came together unto Pilate,
The tomb is sealed and guarded to prevent the disciples from taking Jesus’ body.
- Matthew 28:2-4
And, behold, there was a great earthquake: for the angel of the Lord descended from heaven, and came and rolled back the stone from the door, and sat upon it.
The guards witness the angel’s arrival at the tomb and fall in fear.
- John 20:1-10
The first day of the week cometh Mary Magdalene early, when it was yet dark, unto the sepulchre, and seeth the stone taken away from the sepulchre.
Listed as a parallel account of the resurrection.
- Luke 24:1-3
Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulchre, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.
The women find Jesus’ body missing from the tomb on the first day of the week.
- Matthew 28:6
He is not here: for he is risen, as he said. Come, see the place where the Lord lay.
The angel announces that Jesus has risen, contradicting the claim that his disciples stole him.
- Mark 16:1-8
And when the sabbath was past, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome, had bought sweet spices, that they might come and anoint him.
Both recount the events surrounding Jesus’ resurrection and the empty tomb.
- Matthew 27:52-53
And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose,
Raised saints appeared in the city, witnessing to Jesus’ resurrection.
- Matthew 27:66
So they went, and made the sepulchre sure, sealing the stone, and setting a watch.
The tomb was sealed and guarded before the resurrection.
- 1 Corinthians 15:5-6
And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
Jesus appeared to the apostles and to more than five hundred at once.
- Matthew 16:21
From that time forth began Jesus to shew unto his disciples, how that he must go unto Jerusalem, and suffer many things of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and be raised again the third day.
Jesus foretold that he would rise from the dead on the third day.
- Acts 2:24
Whom God hath raised up, having loosed the pains of death: because it was not possible that he should be holden of it.
Peter preaches that God raised Jesus from the dead.
- 1 Corinthians 15:14
And if Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain.
The false report attacks belief in Christ’s resurrection, the foundation of Christian hope.
- John 10:18
No man taketh it from me, but I lay it down of myself. I have power to lay it down, and I have power to take it again. This commandment have I received of my Father.
Jesus said he had power to take up his life again.
- Matthew 27:64
Command therefore that the sepulchre be made sure until the third day, lest his disciples come by night, and steal him away, and say unto the people, He is risen from the dead: so the last error shall be worse than the first.
The priests feared the disciples would steal Jesus’ body.
- Matthew 28:4
And for fear of him the keepers did shake, and became as dead men.
guards saw the resurrection yet spread the lie
- Matthew 28:1
In the end of the sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week, came Mary Magdalene and the other Mary to see the sepulchre.
The women come to Jesus’ tomb after the Sabbath.
- Matthew 27:57-60
When the even was come, there came a rich man of Arimathæa, named Joseph, who also himself was Jesus’ disciple:
Joseph received and buried Jesus’ body.
- John 20:1
The first day of the week cometh Mary Magdalene early, when it was yet dark, unto the sepulchre, and seeth the stone taken away from the sepulchre.
same early dark morning seeking missing Jesus
- John 20:19
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
The disciples were hiding in fear, undermining the claim that they stole Jesus’ body.
- Luke 24:9-10
And returned from the sepulchre, and told all these things unto the eleven, and to all the rest.
Women report the empty tomb and the angels’ message to the apostles.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
59 sources
The verse is the paid lie the chief priests and elders put into the mouths of the Roman guards after some of them reported all that had happened at the tomb, promising them money and protection from the governor if they would say the body was taken by night while they slept.Lt 248, 1906, par. 4–10Ms 61a, 1906, par. 16–21Lt 318, 1906, par. 5–8 Those guards had kept weary, sleepless watch and had witnessed the resurrection itself, seeing a mighty angel remove the sealed stone, hearing Him proclaimed the Son of God and King of glory, and falling as dead men in fear.DA 779.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15 The story is self-contradictory and miserable scheming, for sleeping men could not know how the tomb became empty or who took the body, and soldiers would never admit sleeping on duty under penalty of death unless bought and protected.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6DA 781.2–782.1 It did not triumph, for the empty tomb, Christ's appearances to His disciples and to more than five hundred, and the testimony of the captives raised with Him established the resurrection beyond doubt.Ms 204, 1899, par. 6–76RED 41.2–42.2SG1 100.1 It stands as a Satan-inspired falsehood meant to conceal God's power, suppress testimony, and turn people from Christ, illustrating how those who reject light fasten themselves in deception and believe the lie they wish were true.SG1 75.2ST Aug 15, 1878SG1 177.1–178.1
Guarded Tomb Setting
Matthew 28:13 belongs to the guarded-tomb account, where a Roman seal was set in place, Roman guards kept watch, and angels guarded the tomb while hostile forces sought to keep it sealed because they feared the disciples would take the body and claim He had risen.DA 779.1SG1 65.1 The guards kept their weary watch with sleepless vigilance and witnessed the resurrection itself rather than a theft by night.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15Ms 106, 1897, par. 21–22 A mighty angel removed the sealed stone, Christ was called from the grave and came forth, and the soldiers fell as dead men and were overcome with fear.DA 779.3Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–1518MR 76.3 They heard the angel proclaim the crucified One as the Son of God, the Majesty of heaven, the King of glory, so their later claim that the body had been stolen was a false explanation of what they had seen.DA 779.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15
The verse stands in the brighter resurrection chapter that follows Christ's sufferings and presents a risen Saviour, with Matthew 28:1-20 joined to Matthew 17, Matthew 26:26-75, and Matthew 27 in that presentation.Ms 29, 1909, par. 1 The precautions taken to prevent the tomb from being tampered with make the theft explanation unconvincing.DA 778.4ST Aug 1, 1878 Roman arms could not keep Jesus in the tomb, and strict discipline made sleeping at post punishable by death.DA 778.4ST Aug 1, 1878 The sealed tomb and the watch were intended to prevent any deception about His body, but those efforts instead strengthen the testimony that He rose and make the triumph of the resurrection more complete.DA 778.4ST Aug 1, 1878
Bribed False Report
Some of the guard came into the city and told the chief priests all that had happened at the tomb, and the chief priests gathered with the elders, took counsel together, and gave the soldiers large money to say His disciples came by night and stole Him away while they slept.Lt 248, 1906, par. 4–10Ms 61a, 1906, par. 16–21Ms 204, 1899, par. 6–7 They promised that if the matter came to the governor's ears they would persuade him and keep the soldiers safe, and the soldiers took the money and did as they were taught.Lt 248, 1906, par. 4–10Ms 61a, 1906, par. 16–21Ms 204, 1899, par. 6–7 This saying was commonly reported among the Jews and spread throughout the country, continuing to circulate as the false explanation for the empty tomb.Lt 248, 1906, par. 4–10Ms 61a, 1906, par. 16–21Ms 151, 1906, par. 1–4
The report was a deliberate falsehood, not denial for lack of evidence or knowledge, for the leaders paid to hide the facts, suppress testimony, and prevent people from learning the truth.Lt 318, 1906, par. 5–8EW 151.1ST Nov 8, 1883 It was circulated to conceal God's power revealed in the resurrection and to keep people from learning that Jesus had risen as He had said.Ms 151, 1906, par. 1–4Ms 105, 1901, par. 7–9ST Nov 8, 1883 The truth would have exposed them as Christ's murderers and brought blame upon them for putting Him to death, so they sought to protect themselves, to escape the people's anger, and to persist in calling Him an impostor and denying that He had risen.Lt 318, 1906, par. 5–8EW 151.13SP 195.3ST Nov 8, 1883
The soldiers sold their integrity for money and bore false witness instead of reporting the truth they had seen with sleepless vigilance and quaking hearts.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15ST Aug 15, 1878 They had kept weary watch, seen the circumstances of the resurrection, heard an angel proclaim the crucified One as the Son of God, the Majesty of heaven, the King of glory, and seen a mighty angel remove the sealed stone and Christ called from the grave to come forth.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15 They were horrified to deceive the people and perjure themselves, because sleeping at post was an offense punishable with death and placed their own lives in peril, and they took up the lie only after the priests promised to secure their safety.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Aug 15, 1878DA 782.2–3 They came in before the priests burdened with a most startling message of truth and went out burdened with money and a lying report on their tongues, exchanging their truthful report for a falsehood spread far and near.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15DA 782.2–3Ms 94, 1897, par. 15–16
Pilate heard the guards' full true account, for after a private interview in which they told him all the particulars and dared conceal nothing for fear of losing their lives, he questioned them and learned the truth.ST Nov 8, 1883DA 782.46RED 16.2 He was filled with terror and shut himself in his home.6RED 16.2 Yet when the priests came to him and urged him to make no investigation of the sentinels' affirmed sleeping at their post but to overlook their failure and let the matter pass, he consented and did not prosecute the matter farther.ST Nov 8, 18833SP 198.16RED 16.2 From that time he had no more peace or comfort.6RED 16.2
Theft Claim Refuted
The story put into the soldiers' mouths was that the disciples came by night and stole the body while the guard slept.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6DA 781.2–782.16RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.2 It is miserable scheming and overreaches itself, for it contradicts itself on its face.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6DA 781.2–782.16RED 41.2–42.2 Sleeping men could not know how the tomb became empty or who took the body.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–66RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.2ST Aug 15, 1878 Every thinking mind not blinded by bigotry sees the falsehood, though the lie was spread hard until very many believed it.6RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.23SP 223.2
The soldiers knew it was false because they had kept their weary watch with sleepless vigilance and had seen the circumstances of the resurrection and heard an angel proclaim the crucified One as the Son of God, the Majesty of heaven, the King of glory.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Aug 15, 1878 They had witnessed the angel roll away the stone and found the tomb empty, and were then paid to deny what they had seen and repeat the theft claim.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–63SP 197.1–2ST Aug 15, 1878 They were horrified to bear this false witness, deceiving the people and perjuring themselves.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6 They came in burdened with a most startling message of truth and went out with a burden of money and a lying report on their tongues.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6
Falsely claiming to have slept on duty placed their own lives in peril, since sleeping at post while on sentry duty was an offense punishable with death without pardon.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Nov 8, 18833SP 197.1–26RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.2 Soldiers would never proclaim their own fault of that kind about themselves.6RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.2 They took up the lie only for money after large bribes were offered and protection was promised to secure their safety.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Nov 8, 18833SP 197.1–26RED 15.3–16.1 The priests said Pilate would not want the facts of the resurrection circulated any more than they did, and promised to persuade him and keep the soldiers safe.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Nov 8, 18833SP 197.1–2
The priests showed they had no faith in their own story by what they did not do.6RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.23SP 224.1–2 One waking guard would have waked the rest.6RED 41.2–42.2 If the disciples had been proved to have stolen the body, the priests would have condemned and punished them.DA 781.2–782.16RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.2 If the guards had slept on duty, the priests would have accused them to Pilate and demanded investigation and full punishment, and would never have passed sleeping guards lightly.DA 781.2–782.16RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.23SP 224.1–2 Their failure to call the disciples to account and punish them, and to investigate and punish the guards, proves the disciples innocent and proves the story was invented to meet the growing proof that Jesus rose as the divine Son of God, including the testimony of persons raised with Him who were seen and heard saying Jesus lives.DA 781.2–782.16RED 41.2–42.26RED 61.2–62.23SP 224.1–23SP 223.2
Resurrection Truth Confirmed
The soldiers themselves had seen what truly emptied the tomb, and their first true report contradicts the theft story and confirms that Jesus rose as He said.DA 779.33SP 195.4–196.1ST Aug 15, 1878ST Nov 8, 1883 They had kept weary watch with sleepless vigilance and were overcome with fear when a mighty angel came, removed the sealed stone, and Christ was called from the grave and came forth alive, which they witnessed with quaking hearts.DA 779.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15 They heard the angel proclaim the crucified One as the Son of God, the Majesty of heaven, the King of glory, and they found the tomb empty because the angel had rolled the stone away, not because the disciples had taken Him.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Aug 15, 1878ST Nov 8, 1883 The claim put on their tongues that the disciples came by night and stole the body while they slept was therefore miserable scheming and self-contradictory, for sleeping men could not know how the tomb became empty or who took the body.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6ST Aug 15, 1878 They were horrified to bear this false witness and perjure themselves at peril of their lives, having come in burdened with a most startling message of truth and going out burdened with money and a lying report after selling their integrity.Ms 203, 1898, par. 3–6Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15
The lie did not triumph, because the multitude of captives raised with Christ went into the city, appeared to many, and testified that Christ was risen and that His power had called them from the grave.Ms 204, 1899, par. 6–7 This testimony of persons raised with Him, seen and heard saying Jesus lives, weakened the effect of the report that was spread hard until very many believed it and established the certainty of the resurrection beyond doubt.6RED 41.2–42.2SG1 75.2EW 156.2 God made the resurrection certain and impossible for the priests and elders to conceal, even though Satan inspired the lie and the people were ready to believe it.SG1 75.2EW 156.2 The priests showed they had no faith in their own story, for one waking guard would have waked the rest and they never called the disciples to account and punished them, which proves the disciples innocent and proves the story was invented to meet the growing proof that Jesus rose as the divine Son of God.6RED 41.2–42.2
The resurrection was further confirmed by Jesus' appearances to His disciples and to more than five hundred people, together with the witnesses who had risen with Him and declared that He was alive.SG1 100.1EW 173.2 The disciples' testimony and the powerful evidence of the resurrection contradicted the claim meant to conceal the facts, and the false story was challenged when Peter and John preached that Jesus had risen from the dead.SG1 85.2AA 60.3–5 Testimony from the soldiers and from those who had seen the risen dead could not be silenced, though the report was spread far and near to deny the resurrection and make Jesus appear an impostor.Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15ST Feb 3, 1914DA 785.1 The priests had ordered the guard to tell no one what they had seen, yet witnesses to the soldiers' true testimony remained.Lt 195, 1903, par. 12–15ST Feb 3, 1914
The resurrection is the event on which salvation depends, and God gave incontrovertible proof that the crucified One was the Son of God.EW 156.210MR 155.1–3 The multitude of captives who rose when Jesus was raised and revealed themselves to many defeated the effort to conceal His resurrection and established the certainty that Christ Himself had risen from the dead.10MR 155.1–3Ms 69, 1912, par. 35–39 From that time men have believed that it was the Son of God who was crucified.10MR 155.1–3
Wider Lessons and Warnings
The saying is a lie inspired by Satan and put into the mouths of the Roman guards by the chief priests and elders to deny the miraculous reality of the resurrection.SG1 75.2ST Aug 15, 1878SG1 177.1–178.1EW 226.1–2 It was spread after the guards reported what they had witnessed at the tomb, to hide the facts, avoid the anger of the people, and turn minds away from Christ and the Bible.ST Aug 15, 1878SG1 177.1–178.1EW 6.3–72.1SCEV 8.1–10.2 The people were ready to believe it because they wanted it to be true, and the same kind of deception is used to deny the miraculous nature of His birth, death, and resurrection.SG1 75.2EW 156.2EW 152.3EW 226.1–2 Later false claims about Jesus that obscure Him and make Him seem no more than an ordinary man belong to this same work of turning attention away from Him and the Scriptures.SG1 177.1–178.1EW 226.1–2SCEV 8.1–10.2
The saying shows how those who reject light conceal truth, promote error, and deny facts they cannot undo, fastening themselves in deception to sustain sin.Ms 151, 1906, par. 1–4Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21 The soldiers took money and repeated the paid-for account that the disciples stole the body while they slept, suppressing clear and convincing evidence that Jesus had risen as the Son of God, and the claim continued to circulate among the Jews.Ms 151, 1906, par. 1–4Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21RH Jun 8, 1911 Sleeping men could not know who took the body, yet those who wanted the lie to be true accepted it and were ready to believe it.Ms 94, 1897, par. 17–21SG1 75.2EW 156.2EW 152.3 That pattern of suppressing testimony and accepting falsehood despite incontrovertible proof will recur even among those who once knew and believed the truth.Ms 151, 1906, par. 1–4RH Jun 8, 1911
The false charge gained ground on the first day of the week after the Master died on the sixth day, that the disciples had stolen His body away by night to practice deception upon the people.3SP 205.2–36RED 23.2–24.1 It belongs to the history of the professedly pious Jews and left the disciples resting under stigma as deceivers.Ms 150, 1906, par. 1–33SP 205.2–36RED 23.2–24.1 Deprived of His body and fearing they could never correct the false impression, their depression and perplexity were deepened.3SP 205.2–36RED 23.2–24.1
The saying stands in the brighter resurrection chapter that follows Christ's sufferings and presents a risen Saviour.Ms 29, 1909, par. 1Ms 29, 1909, par. 19–21 That chapter shows the infinite sacrifices the Lord of glory made to open the way whereby sinners might be saved, unto a life that measures with the life of God.Ms 29, 1909, par. 19–21 Faithful study of the gospels blesses those who think they suffer more than Christ suffered or pay a higher price for faith than He paid for them, so none should feel the price too high.Ms 29, 1909, par. 19–21 Only those willing to make special sacrifices to save souls ready to perish can be counted worthy to enter the city of God.Ms 29, 1909, par. 19–21
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
59 sources
After His rising the chief priests gave the soldiers large money and put false words in their mouths to say His disciples came by night and stole Him away while they slept, to hide the resurrection and keep others from believing.RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904 The tale condemns itself, for sleeping men could not know what happened while they slept, and it is unbelievable that a Roman watch would sleep on duty under pain of death while a noisy breaking of the seal and carrying away of the body went on unpunished and unproved.ST Nov 8, 1883ST Jun 8, 1904ST Jun 2, 1898ST Aug 12, 1880ST Jun 8, 1904 It is further disproved by the linen cloths left carefully folded in order and by the disciples themselves, who were fearful and unbelieving and had no heart to face an armed guard to steal a body to preach a resurrection.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Aug 12, 1880RH Oct 14, 1862 The soldiers were in truth the first witnesses of the resurrection, and their honest report before the bribe, with the sealed and guarded tomb meant to prevent fraud, made theft all but impossible and made the triumph of the resurrection more complete.ST Nov 8, 1883ST Aug 1, 1878RH Oct 14, 1862RH Jan 18, 1912ST Apr 3, 1901 Satan led the priests in this hiring of the watch to break the power of the resurrection, yet the lie did not defeat Christ and His gospel, and His rising on the first day of the week proved Him alive without making that day holy or commanded as a rest.ST Aug 15, 1878ST Nov 8, 1883ST Apr 23, 1902RH Jan 8, 1861ST Aug 6, 1912
Setting and Wording
The tomb was sealed with the king's signet so that to touch it endangered life, and a watch was set near the close of the Sabbath because the leaders remembered His words about rising after three days and wanted to keep the disciples from stealing the body and declaring Him risen.ST Aug 1, 1878ST Jul 16, 1912RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 5, 1901 Every possible means was used to keep the body entombed, with the seal and the guard intended to prevent any deception about it.ST Aug 1, 1878RH Oct 14, 1862 The precautions instead helped establish the truth of the resurrection and made its triumph more complete.ST Aug 1, 1878
An angel of the Lord descended, rolled back the stone, and sat upon it with countenance like lightning and raiment white as snow, and the keepers shook for fear and became as dead men.RH Oct 14, 1862 Some of the watch then went into the city on the morning of the first day of the week and told the chief priests everything that had happened.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Feb 13, 1866
The chief priests assembled with the elders, took counsel, and gave the soldiers large money to keep the Jews from believing that Jesus was raised from the dead.RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904 They instructed them to say His disciples came by night and stole Him away while they slept, promising to persuade the governor and keep them safe if he heard of it.RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904RH Feb 13, 1866ST Jun 2, 1898 The soldiers took the money and did as they were taught, repeating what they had been instructed to say as a false explanation of the empty tomb.RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 2, 1898ST Jun 2, 1898 This saying was spread abroad and continued to be commonly reported among the Jews until Matthew wrote his Gospel thirty to thirty-five years after Christ's death.RH Oct 14, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904
The guards had not slept but kept watch, and their truthful report of the angel and the empty tomb before the bribery contradicts the theft claim.ST Nov 8, 1883ST Feb 7, 1911ST Nov 25, 1889 Pilate heard their full account but, after the priests urged him not to investigate, agreed to let the matter pass.ST Nov 8, 1883 Despite the bribe and the promise of protection, some soldiers did not remain silent, and other witnesses to their testimony could not be silenced, while the women testified that the tomb was empty and that they had seen the risen Jesus.ST Feb 3, 1914ST Feb 7, 1911
The word for slept uses the Greek verb koimao of ordinary natural sleep, whose literal meaning is sleep, repose, rest.ST Feb 11, 1903 The same word is also used figuratively of death because natural sleep and death are similar and both end in a similar awaking.ST Feb 11, 1903
His rising was invisible to them and no eye saw Him rise, for the resurrection had already taken place before the gray twilight summoned the women and before the earthquake and the angel's descent.ST Nov 25, 1889 The stone was rolled away after He was risen, and He passed from the sealed grave as on the evening of that day He appeared in the closed chamber, leaving the secured tomb empty with the keepers standing before it.ST Nov 25, 1889 The guards were assigned to prevent the disciples from taking the body, not to know the exact hour He arose, so the verse does not establish the time of the resurrection or by itself decide which day should be kept as the Sabbath.RH Jan 8, 1861 To place His rising in Sabbath daylight would absurdly require the guards to claim they slept in daylight while the body was taken in broad daylight, when their own report and the timing of their arrival in the city show they knew they were not asleep.RH Feb 13, 1866RH Feb 7, 1871
Fabricated Theft Story
The saying is a deliberate false lie and fabrication put into the guards' mouths by the representatives of the nation to explain the open and empty tomb.ST Nov 25, 1889ST Jun 2, 1898ST Aug 12, 1880 Much money was paid to conceal the resurrection, to deny that Jesus was raised, to keep the Jews from believing, to make Him appear an impostor, and the people accepted that lie, rejecting the risen Christ.ST Nov 25, 1889ST Jun 8, 1904ST Oct 28, 1913ST Aug 12, 1880 It acknowledges that Jesus had truly died and been buried and that His body was missing on Sunday morning, so the dispute concerns His body, not a spirit leaving it.ST Aug 12, 1880 The bribed story was spread abroad among the Jews and continued until Matthew wrote his Gospel thirty to thirty-five years after the death of Christ.ST Jun 8, 1904 This false explanation was the Jews' rejection of the final evidence about Jesus and the supreme climax of their refusal to believe, fulfilling the parable's portrayal of Israel's rejection of God's message.ST Oct 28, 1913
The story exposes itself as deception because sleeping witnesses could not know what happened or who took the body.ST Aug 15, 1878ST Jun 8, 1904ST Aug 12, 1880ST Jun 8, 1904 They could testify only that the body was there before they slept and gone when they woke, and could not have seen the theft or testify to it.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 Sleeping guards could not have witnessed who took the body, so the allegation lacks evidence and cannot establish that the disciples took it.ST Jun 8, 1904RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 The missing body therefore cannot be explained as a proven theft by the disciples.RH Oct 14, 1862 The guards had actually witnessed the angel roll away the stone and found the tomb empty, yet were paid to deny what they had seen and repeat the theft claim.ST Aug 15, 1878
The claim is further implausible because Roman discipline made sleeping on guard a crime punishable by death, and the priests had to promise protection and to persuade the governor to keep the soldiers safe.ST Nov 8, 1883ST Aug 15, 1878ST Jun 8, 1904ST Jun 2, 1898 Telling the truth about the resurrection would have exonerated the guard from carelessness, while admitting to sleeping on guard invited the death penalty.ST Jun 8, 1904 A noisy lengthy theft by several men would have awakened a trained watch, and breaking the seal also carried the death penalty.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Dec 21, 1882ST Aug 12, 1880 Pilate heard the guards' full account but at the priests' urging agreed to let the matter pass and not investigate.ST Nov 8, 1883 Yet no effort was ever made to find and punish the supposed thieves, nor was the claim ever presented in court or officially defended and repeated, although proving it would have destroyed the disciples' testimony to the resurrection.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Dec 21, 1882ST Aug 12, 1880
That claim is disproved by the napkin and linen cloths left in the tomb carefully folded and laid aside in perfect order.ST Dec 21, 1882 Thieves in a hurried theft would hardly have left all the burial wrappings behind at all except by accident from something dropped, and never in such order. The orderly grave-clothes do not fit a hurried theft and are evidence of His resurrection, for God never leaves Himself without witness.ST Dec 21, 1882
The disciples had no good reason to steal the body, for they were timid, afraid of the Jews, unbelieving about His rising despite His words, and their actions at the empty tomb show surprise and ignorance rather than a plan.ST Aug 12, 1880RH Oct 14, 1862RH Sep 14, 1869 It is unlikely that the eleven would suddenly risk confronting Roman guards and stealing the body in order to preach a resurrection with no prospect of reward.ST Aug 12, 1880RH Oct 14, 1862 They themselves did not believe He had risen, and Jesus rose despite their expectations and unbelief.RH Sep 14, 1869 The verse's accusation therefore fails to explain the missing body or disprove the resurrection.ST Aug 12, 1880
Satan was anxious that Jesus should not be raised and determined to break the influence of the resurrection if it occurred, so he led the priests to hire the watchmen to say the disciples stole the body at night while the guard slept in order to squelch all faith in Christ.ST Aug 15, 1878ST Jun 5, 1901 They used this accusation to deny that Jesus had risen and to escape the people's anger after their role in His death and after the guards reported what they had witnessed at the tomb.ST Nov 8, 1883ST Aug 15, 1878 The guards, though convinced by what they witnessed, exchanged their truthful report for money and a lie under promise of protection for reputation and life from the death penalty for sleeping on duty.ST Aug 15, 1878RH Apr 18, 1871 The soldiers took money to help shield this lie, but lies and error enlisted to shield falsehood will eventually pass away.ST Apr 23, 1902
Resurrection Evidence Confirmed
The soldiers were enemies, yet they were the first witnesses of the resurrection, for the angel descended, rolled back the stone, sat upon it with countenance like lightning and raiment white as snow, and shook the keepers till they became as dead men, after which some of the watch went into the city and told the chief priests everything that had happened.RH Oct 14, 1862 The chief priests assembled with the elders, took counsel, gave large money, instructed the soldiers to say the followers took the body at night while the guard slept, promised to persuade the governor and keep them safe if he heard of it, and the soldiers took the money and did as taught, so that the saying was commonly reported among the Jews.RH Oct 14, 1862 That bribed account contradicts the guards’ earlier truthful report of the angel and the empty tomb, and testimony given after money was accepted is less credible than testimony given before the bribery.ST Nov 8, 1883RH Oct 14, 1862 Against the paid lie stands the women’s testimony that the tomb was empty and that they had seen the risen Jesus, together with the disciples’ open testimony about seeing Him, while the guarded and sealed tomb itself stands against the rulers’ proposed explanation meant to keep people from believing He had risen.RH Jan 18, 1912ST Feb 22, 1899
The theft claim itself acknowledges that Jesus had truly died and been buried and that His body was missing on Sunday morning, offering alleged theft to explain the empty tomb and deny the resurrection.ST Aug 12, 1880ST Apr 3, 1901 The dispute concerns His body, not a spirit leaving or escaping from it, and therefore supports that the resurrection claimed was physical and bodily.ST Apr 3, 1884RH Aug 4, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879 It did not deny that Jesus had died.ST Apr 3, 1901
The sealed tomb and the watch were intended to prevent any deception about the body, yet those precautions instead helped establish the truth of the resurrection and made its triumph more complete.ST Aug 1, 1878 Theft was made highly unlikely by the sealed tomb and armed guard, and severe penalties guarded sleeping on duty and breaking the seal.ST Aug 1, 1878ST Apr 3, 1901 Roman discipline made sleeping at a post punishable by death, so the claim that the disciples stole the body is an absurd explanation.ST Aug 1, 1878ST Apr 3, 1901
The resurrection is a fact of history attested by evidence that in any ordinary case would be deemed not only competent but overwhelming.ST Jun 15, 1904 The real historical evidence is that the resurrection was believed, preached, propagated, and produced its fruit and effect in the new phenomenon of the Christian church long before any Gospel was written, with faith in the resurrection prevalent and immensely powerful before any New Testament book was written, so that not one of them could ever have been written without that faith.RH May 11, 1916 The evidence is the New Testament itself and the life throbbing in it from beginning to end, the life that fills with wonder and that the risen Saviour quickened in Christian souls, and the existence of the Christian church and the existence of the New Testament in that extraordinary spiritual vitality are left without adequate or convincing explanation if the resurrection is denied.RH May 11, 1916 The empty-tomb story in Matthew 28:1-20, along with the accounts of Jesus appearing in Jerusalem and in Galilee, is not the primary evidence for the resurrection.RH May 11, 1916
The verse belongs to Matthew’s account of the resurrection, one of several Gospel accounts that report different details.ST Mar 5, 1912 Its report that the guards were told to say the disciples stole the body while they slept illustrates that the Gospel narratives preserve separate, unharmonized accounts rather than editorially adjusted versions.RH Apr 11, 1871 Differences and omissions between the accounts do not by themselves mean they contradict one another, for each account can state what is true while recording events the others leave out.ST Mar 5, 1912RH Apr 11, 1871
Sabbath and Doctrinal Implications
The record to which this saying belongs is the record of the Lord's resurrection, and that resurrection is the end and consummation of the true rest foreshadowed by the ancient Sabbath, the same day bringing the shadows to an end so that Christians do not cling to a shadowy ceremony.ST Jan 2, 1879 It affirms that Jesus rose on the first day of the week and appeared alive to His disciples, yet those appearances showed only that He was alive, not that the day itself had become holy.RH Jan 8, 1861ST Aug 6, 1912ST Mar 9, 1882 It does not establish that the first day became holy or that Christ commanded its observance as a day of rest.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Mar 9, 1882 The guards had been set to prevent the disciples from taking the body, not to know the exact hour He arose, and the theft explanation they were instructed to give was a falsehood and is not reliable testimony about the resurrection, so the saying does not by itself establish the time of the resurrection or decide which day should be kept as the Sabbath.RH Jan 8, 1861 Paul's practice cannot be used to disprove the theft charge by making him a Sunday observer, because Paul observed the seventh day, not Sunday.
If the charge that the disciples stole the body were true, Paul would not have preached Christ's resurrection, kept the day of worship, or joined the church. The bribery and deception by which the priests procured and spread the proposed explanation were sinful acts for which they stood accountable under God's law.ST Sep 9, 1913 Against the report that the disciples had taken the body, to confess faith in the resurrection openly through baptism as burial in the likeness of Christ's death was a severe test of loyalty.ST Sep 20, 1883 The tomb presented the starting point of a kingdom that seemed doomed, with the King lying dead, His followers having lost faith, and grieving women standing near a Roman guard, yet a few days later came the commission to preach the gospel throughout the world, turning apparent failure into the beginning of a mission that gathered a vast multitude.ST Sep 20, 1883RH Jun 8, 1911
Those who judged and mocked Jesus, secured His tomb, and then spread this lie about His resurrection will nevertheless rise and see Him in the royal glory of His return, when He comes to judge the world and reign forever.RH Nov 17, 1868
Scripture Links and Application
This saying belongs to the account of the risen Lord and of Christ's victory over Satan, in which the grave could not hold Him.ST Jun 9, 1898 It records the chief priests' account that His disciples stole His body while the guards slept, a lie devised by the chief priests and elders and spread by the soldiers.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Feb 22, 1899 It stands against the women's testimony that Jesus had risen and the confirmation that His tomb was empty.ST Feb 22, 1899 That false claim circulated amid competing reports after the resurrection, for the women testified that the tomb was empty and that they had seen the risen Jesus, while some Roman soldiers, despite the priests' bribe, did not remain silent, and these reports circulated widely.ST Feb 7, 1911
After paying the soldiers, the chief priests told them to claim that Jesus' disciples had stolen His body while they slept.ST Oct 28, 1913 This paid false explanation was the Jews' rejection of the final evidence about Jesus and the supreme climax of their refusal to believe.ST Oct 28, 1913 It fulfilled in their lives the parable's portrayal of Israel's rejection of God's message.ST Oct 28, 1913 The same claim is taken up by Spiritualist teaching to deny that Jesus was raised from the dead.ST May 31, 1877
That denial of the resurrection is like the friends of Voltaire denying the reports of his deathbed.RH Dec 17, 1872 The accusation that the disciples stole the body was among the dangers they feared after their Lord had been slain.ST May 11, 1915 The soldiers took money to help shield this lie intended to discredit the resurrection, but lies and error enlisted for that purpose will eventually pass away.ST Apr 23, 1902RH Nov 15, 1864 It did not use up or defeat Christ and His gospel.RH Nov 15, 1864
Sources