Luke 19:40
And he answered and said unto them, I tell you that, if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.
Translations
And he answered and said to them, I tell you that, if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And he answered and said unto them, I tell you that, if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.
And he answered and said to them, I tell you, that if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he answered and said, I tell you that, if these shall hold their peace, the stones will cry out.
and he answering said to them, 'I say to you, that, if these shall be silent, the stones will cry out!'
And he answering said to them, I say unto you, If these shall be silent, the stones will cry out.
And he answered and said—I tell you—If, these, shall hold their peace, the stones, will cry out.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ I tell you,” He answered, “ if they remain silent, the very stones will cry out.”
He answered them, “ I tell you that if these were silent, the stones would cry out.”
And he said in answer, I say to you, if these men keep quiet, the very stones will be crying out.
But he answered, and sayd vnto them, I tell you, that if these should holde their peace, the stones would crie.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
To whom he said: I say to you, that if these shall hold their peace, the stones will cry out.
Pictures

Cross-references
- Zechariah 9:9
Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion; shout, O daughter of Jerusalem: behold, thy King cometh unto thee: he is just, and having salvation; lowly, and riding upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass.
Foretells Zion’s King arriving humbly on a donkey, as Jesus enters Jerusalem.
- Matthew 21:9
And the multitudes that went before, and that followed, cried, saying, Hosanna to the Son of David: Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord; Hosanna in the highest.
The crowd’s Hosanna praise as Jesus entered Jerusalem.
- John 12:12-16
On the next day much people that were come to the feast, when they heard that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem,
The crowd acclaims Jesus as King as he enters Jerusalem.
- Mark 11:9-10
And they that went before, and they that followed, cried, saying, Hosanna; Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord:
The crowd acclaims Jesus and welcomes the coming kingdom of David.
- Psalms 118:26
Blessed be he that cometh in the name of the LORD: we have blessed you out of the house of the LORD.
The crowd’s acclamation echoes the blessing of the one who comes in the Lord’s name.
- Matthew 21:15-16
And when the chief priests and scribes saw the wonderful things that he did, and the children crying in the temple, and saying, Hosanna to the Son of David; they were sore displeased,
Children praise Jesus, and he answers the leaders who object.
- Habakkuk 2:11
For the stone shall cry out of the wall, and the beam out of the timber shall answer it.
Stones are pictured as crying out in testimony.
- Matthew 21:4-5
All this was done, that it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the prophet, saying,
Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem fulfills prophecy of the King arriving meekly on a donkey.
- Psalms 8:2
Out of the mouth of babes and sucklings hast thou ordained strength because of thine enemies, that thou mightest still the enemy and the avenger.
Jesus applies its words about praise from children.
- John 12:19
The Pharisees therefore said among themselves, Perceive ye how ye prevail nothing? behold, the world is gone after him.
The Pharisees’ frustration reflects the unstoppable public response to Jesus.
- Matthew 21:10-11
And when he was come into Jerusalem, all the city was moved, saying, Who is this?
Jerusalem reacts to Jesus’ arrival and identifies him as a prophet.
- John 12:16
These things understood not his disciples at the first: but when Jesus was glorified, then remembered they that these things were written of him, and that they had done these things unto him.
The disciples later understood that Jesus’ entry fulfilled Scripture.
- John 12:15
Fear not, daughter of Sion: behold, thy King cometh, sitting on an ass’s colt.
The King’s arrival on a colt frames the crowd’s praise.
- Genesis 4:10
And he said, What hast thou done? the voice of thy brother’s blood crieth unto me from the ground.
Abel’s blood cries out from the ground, as the stones would cry out.
- Job 12:8
Or speak to the earth, and it shall teach thee: and the fishes of the sea shall declare unto thee.
The earth teaches, while stones are pictured as speaking.
- Luke 3:8
Bring forth therefore fruits worthy of repentance, and begin not to say within yourselves, We have Abraham to our father: for I say unto you, That God is able of these stones to raise up children unto Abraham.
Both texts describe God bringing forth children of Abraham from stones.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
61 sources
Jesus spoke these words during His triumphal entry into Jerusalem as the promised King riding the colt amid the rejoicing hosannas of the multitude.DA 569.3–4Ms 49, 1890, par. 12Ms 122, 1909, par. 24–26 When the Pharisees demanded that He silence His disciples, He answered that the praise could not be stopped, for if the people held their peace God would give voice to lifeless stones to proclaim Him.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–11Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–3Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–224RED 119.2–120.1 The acclamation had to go forward because it was appointed by divine providence and foretold by the prophets, even though the disciples expected a temporal kingdom and did not understand He was going to death.COS 93.6–95.2Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–114SP 496.1GC 404.2–405.2ST Jul 22, 1886 As at that time children in the temple took up the cry when the crowd was silenced, so in the proclamation of the second advent God raises other voices when appointed messengers are hindered.COS 102.5RCOC 19.2HSFM 206.4GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 God must receive glory from a people on earth, so His work and the warning message for this time cannot be silenced by human opposition but will go forward in greater power, even by stones if every human agent should hold his peace.EW 88.2–3SCEV 28.1–29.221MR 237.4GW 304.2Lt 31a, 1894, par. 11–14
Triumphal Entry Setting
The saying was spoken during the triumphal entry into Jerusalem, when Jesus rode the colt and donkey as the promised King and heir to David's throne and was welcomed by a rejoicing crowd with the hope of a new kingdom rising.DA 569.3–4Ms 49, 1890, par. 12Ms 122, 1909, par. 24–26DA 569.1–2DA 569 It belongs to the account of Christ riding into the city for the Passover, and the events of that scene point to similar scenes in the last great day.Ms 49, 1890, par. 12Ms 122, 1909, par. 24–26Ms 54, 1886, par. 4–7
He entered on the first day of the week after sending two disciples to bring a colt upon which no man had sat, and seated upon it with their garments spread over it He accepted homage He had never before permitted.2SP 384.1–385.1 The multitude gave Him the worship of happy hearts without outward pomp, hailing Him as Messiah and King, spreading their outer garments as a carpet in His path and strewing olive and palm branches in the way.2SP 384.1–385.1 They waved palm boughs as nature's emblem of victory and rent the air with loud shouts of triumph and hosannas repeated again and again and echoed from hills and valleys.2SP 384.1–385.1 The crowd continually grew with Passover travelers and with thousands from Jerusalem who came with palm branches and sacred song to meet Him and conduct Him to the city, while spectators asked who He was and what the commotion signified, astonished because He had declared His kingdom was not of this world, and while the temple trumpet for evening service went largely unanswered.2SP 384.1–385.1
The acclamations were a fitting response to His merciful works and to the evidence of divine power among the people that they had witnessed and remembered.Ms 122, 1909, par. 24–26Ms 128, 1899, par. 13–14Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–22 They praised His healings, His raisings of the dead, and all His good works, and especially after the raising of Lazarus a large enthusiastic crowd had gathered.Ms 122, 1909, par. 24–26Ms 128, 1899, par. 13–14Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–22Ms 128, 1899, par. 1 The same entry is solemn because it includes His weeping on the crest of Olivet over the doomed city, for His mercy and love were rejected.Ms 54, 1886, par. 4–7Ms 85, 1893, par. 3 That mercy and love are seen in His dying for sinful man so that man might not perish in his sins, and His weeping looked beyond the destruction of Jerusalem to an impenitent world doomed to destruction.Ms 54, 1886, par. 4–7Ms 85, 1893, par. 3
Divinely Appointed Acclamation
The outburst of praise at the entry into Jerusalem was set in place by God's special providence as part of the divine plan, revealed beforehand to the prophets of old, and appointed to go forward as the public acclaim of Jesus as King.COS 93.6–95.24RED 119.2–120.1ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886 No human threat, command, or earthly power could prevent what God had ordained or keep that welcome from being given.COS 93.6–95.2ST Jul 22, 1886DA 572.3 The prophetic vision of the King coming to Jerusalem had to be fulfilled, and no one could turn it aside.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886
If the disciples and the multitude had held their peace and been made quiet, God would have given voice to inanimate and lifeless stones to take up the shout in their place.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–11ST Dec 23, 18974RED 119.2–120.11T 57.3–58.1DA 572.3 Those stones would have hailed His Son with acclamations of praise and proclaimed Him, and the proclamation to be made was Behold your God.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–11ST Dec 23, 18974RED 119.2–120.1 The shouting that praised His healings, His raisings of the dead, and all His good works that the people remembered could not be silenced.Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–22ST May 9, 1878DA 570.1–571.1
Priests, elders, and Pharisees with blunted understanding pressed through the crowd and demanded that He rebuke and silence the disciples for their loud and excited praise.Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–34RED 119.2–120.11T 57.3–58.1ST May 9, 1878 They could not see the fulfillment of prophecy, and they acted from envy and fear that the multitude would lift Him to be king, offering haughty reproof and wanting the joyful praise condemned as fanatical, wild, extravagant, and mesmerism.Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–34RED 119.2–120.1SCEV 28.1–29.2 His answer defended the loud praise and silenced and defeated their effort to repress the enthusiasm of the people.4RED 119.2–120.1SCEV 28.1–29.2
Men were powerless to turn aside God's purposes for His Son.4RED 119.2–120.1ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886 God's work goes forward despite human efforts to hinder or destroy it.COS 93.6–95.2
Prophecy Fulfilled Despite Misunderstanding
The entry fulfilled the prophetic vision of the King coming to Jerusalem, with Israel's King coming lowly and riding on a donkey as heir to David's throne.DA 569.3–4DA 569.1–2DA 570.1–571.1 The people crying Hosanna to the Son of David as Christ rode in fulfilled that prophecy.Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–3EW 206.4 Jesus accepted the multitude's homage as He entered Jerusalem as the promised King and Messiah.DA 569.3–4DA 569.1–2DA 570.1–571.1
Prophecy had to be fulfilled and God's purpose accomplished, so the acclaim could not be silenced.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–114SP 496.1GC 404.2–405.2GC88 404.2–405.24SP 253.2 Jesus refused to stop the praise because if the people had been silent the stones would immediately have cried out in their place.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–11GC 404.2–405.2GC88 404.2–405.2Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–22 That shouting praised His healings, His raisings of the dead, and all His good works that they remembered, and the proclamation to be made was Behold your God.Ms 36, 1897, par. 9–11Ms 123, 1909, par. 21–22
The disciples acted on the mistaken belief that He was entering as a victorious temporal prince to be crowned earthly king.4SP 496.1EW 206.41T 57.3–58.1 They expected Him to take David's throne and free Israel.4SP 253.21T 57.3–58.1 They did not understand that He was going to judgment and death.GC 404.2–405.2GC88 404.2–405.24SP 253.2
Within a few days those who expected His reign saw their beloved Master stretched on the cruel cross before mocking Pharisees.GC 404.2–405.21T 57.3–58.1CET 56.1 Their high hopes were bitterly disappointed by His death, with the darkness of death closing about them.GC 404.2–405.2EW 206.41T 57.3–58.1SG1 149.2 Yet He remained true to His promises with sweet consolation and rich reward for the true and faithful.1T 57.3–58.1 Only after His death and resurrection did they understand that prophecy had foretold His suffering and rising.4SP 253.2
Praise Continued Through Others
The praise could not be silenced, for prophecy had to be fulfilled, and if the people had stopped proclaiming him the stones would have cried out in their place.HSFM 206.4GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 As the crowd entered the city the people were intimidated by priests and rulers and under threats ceased their proclamation at the gates of Jerusalem.HSFM 206.4GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 God then provided other voices, and children in the temple courts took up the cry with palm branches.HSFM 206.4GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 Their rejoicing fulfilled the prophecy of praise from children.HSFM 206.4GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2
The priests and rulers had refused the privilege of heralding Christ and advancing His work.COS 102.5DA 592.2–4 For that reason God moved the children to witness to His glory.COS 102.5DA 592.2–4 Their praise as King could not be suppressed, for prophecy that Christ would be proclaimed as King had to be fulfilled.COS 102.5RCOC 19.2DA 592.2–4 If the rejoicing children had been silenced, even the stones would have cried out, and the very pillars of the temple themselves would have sounded His praise.COS 102.5RCOC 19.2DA 592.2–4
As it was at the first advent in Jerusalem, so it is in the proclamation of the second advent.GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 God's word must be fulfilled that the coming of the Saviour be proclaimed to all peoples and tongues and nations.GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 When His servants and adult messengers were silenced He put His Spirit upon children to accomplish the work.GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2 In Scandinavia God enabled children to carry forward the message of Jesus' second coming so that it could reach all peoples, tongues, and nations.GC 367.1–2GC88 367.2
Application to Present Mission
God must receive glory from some who dwell on earth and will have a people who praise and glorify Him rather than remain cold and silent, so His true people cannot be cold and dead but must praise Him even with a loud voice.EW 88.2–3SCEV 28.1–29.2RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 18525MR 201.3 If His chosen people should hold their peace even the stones would immediately cry out and speak in their place, for praise to Christ cannot be silenced.EW 88.2–3SCEV 28.1–29.2RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 18525MR 201.3 The only company on earth from whom God is to get glory and who can praise and honor Him are those who keep His commandments and have the faith of Jesus.EW 88.2–321MR 237.45MR 201.35MR 237.3–238.2Ms 5a, 1850, par. 4 They must rise together in unity, gain victory over the powers of darkness instead of dragging one another down, and sing and shout to His glory to help drive away those powers.5MR 201.35MR 237.3–238.2
Attempts to silence joyful praise as fanaticism, extravagance, wildness, or mesmerism repeat the Pharisees who wanted the disciples rebuked and silenced for their loud and excited praise.RH Jun 10, 1852EW 88.2–3SCEV 28.1–29.2RH Jun 10, 1852 A large portion of those who profess to look for Christ yet are cold and dead want loud praise rebuked in the same way, opposing or ridiculing open praise.RH Jun 10, 1852SCEV 28.1–29.2 Even if Christ's followers hold their peace, God will still receive praise, and even His commandment-keeping people cannot rightly be forbidden to praise Him.RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852 The prospect now is far more glorious than the disciples' prospect at the first advent and gives all the more reason to praise aloud.SCEV 28.1–29.2RH Jun 10, 1852 This is because of the redemption Christ has purchased and the hope of His coming in the glory of the Father with all the holy angels to raise the sleeping saints immortal and catch up the changed living to meet Him, a hope full of immortality and glory.SCEV 28.1–29.2RH Jun 10, 1852
The truths now due must be proclaimed by a people crying its very words and no man can stop that proclamation any more than men could stop the Hosanna cry.Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–3 This includes the warning message and the third angel's message declaring God's commandments and the faith of Jesus to prepare people for Christ's coming, joined by a mighty angel to lighten the whole earth with glory, which is the future work shown to John on Patmos.Ms 43, 1886, par. 83MR 90.2–3HSFM 234.1Ms 129, 1901, par. 1–4 It is an eternal law that he who accepts the truth must make it his first work to proclaim it to the world, and if those chosen refuse or hinder it or hold their peace God can give it to the stones of the field to proclaim, so the message will still be given because prophecy has pointed out this work as a work that must be accomplished.Ms 129b, 1901, par. 2–6RH Aug 11, 1903HSFM 234.1Ms 129, 1901, par. 1–4 If people fail to proclaim God's warning, even the stones will give voice to it, and God's message will be proclaimed despite human neglect.RH Aug 11, 1903HSFM 234.1
The work does not depend on keeping any particular men in their positions, so wrongdoing among workers must be corrected without fear that if those men drop the work the cause will fail.Ms 13, 1893, par. 3Ms 129b, 1901, par. 2–6Ms 129, 1901, par. 1–4 God can do without hindering, faultfinding, unconverted men who refuse to cooperate and put stones in the way, though it is for their own interest to reform.Ms 129b, 1901, par. 2–6Ms 129, 1901, par. 1–4 Those who claim to believe the truth must show zeal proportionate to it with self-sacrificing effort, prayer, and daily consecration instead of waiting, finding fault, and blocking those pushing the work forward.Ms 129b, 1901, par. 2–6Ms 129, 1901, par. 1–4 When God raises up men to give the world a message to prepare people to stand in the great day of God, no human influence can stop the work or close the mouths of the messengers.GW 304.2Lt 31a, 1894, par. 11–14Lt 61, 1893, par. 11–13 If every human agent should hold his peace God would put a voice into the stones and they would speak and the message would go forward in greater and still greater power, and no one can silence the messenger God sends or repress the message, for the Lord will be heard through His human agencies; if no human voice gives it the stones themselves will cry out.GW 304.2Lt 31a, 1894, par. 11–14Lt 61, 1893, par. 11–13
In every age many kinds of labor are needed and each person should do the work suited to ability rather than be silenced by those with greater gifts or experience, for even a person with one talent can reach people whom workers with greater talents cannot.RCOC 19.25T 461.2GW 304.2 No one should condemn or discourage willing workers merely because they do not follow the same methods, since God can work through people of every ability and the message entrusted to Spirit-endued messengers must not be obstructed.RCOC 19.25T 461.2GW 304.2 Those who have received great light and earthly comfort and blessings must use their voices and abilities to save souls and go forth as God commands as missionaries.8T 55.3SPBC 129.1–3STGC 32.2–4Lt 9a, 1893, par. 24–25 If selfish comfort and love of ease keep them silent God will make the stones speak and will hold them accountable with condemnation despite the great light received, a warning applying especially to Battle Creek whose members must use their gifts and go out and share the truth and lead others to the light.8T 55.3SPBC 129.1–3STGC 32.2–4Lt 9a, 1893, par. 24–25 The image of stones crying out means God will make opposition heard against an attempt to place all the work under the control of a confederation of Battle Creek institutions to make them the power to bring every other line of work under their control, for that consolidation cannot be done because God Himself will raise a protest when unconverted men mold and fashion the work for display.17MR 231.2–3Ms 66, 1898, par. 33
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
137 sources
At his triumphal entry into Jerusalem in the last week of his life, as the throng praised him as King for his mighty works, the Pharisees demanded that he rebuke his disciples, and he answered that the acclaim could not be silenced, for if they held their peace the stones would immediately cry out.ST Sep 17, 1894ST Sep 27, 1899ST Dec 23, 1886ST Nov 27, 1879ST Nov 8, 1883
That praise was fitting and necessary because it fulfilled what was foretold centuries before in Zechariah 9:9, so no human silence or opposition could prevent God's appointed word from coming to pass.RH Jul 30, 1857ST Jun 5, 1879RH Feb 28, 1854RH Sep 17, 1914
The disciples and the multitude proclaimed the right message at the right time, yet they mistakenly expected him to take David's throne at once and begin a temporal reign, and within days their hopes were drowned in bitter disappointment at his crucifixion.ST Nov 20, 1884ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 16, 1889LDT 183.2–184.1
God's truth and work do not depend on human messengers and cannot fail, so if his people refuse or are silenced he will still bring his purpose to pass by other means, even giving voice to stones and sending angels to carry the message.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Feb 7, 1911ST Aug 26, 1897RH Jan 14, 1904
Therefore those who know what Jesus has done must speak openly and proclaim the warning messages without fear, while the stones themselves testify in favor of his Word through ancient monuments, inscriptions, and buried records brought to light to confirm Scripture and leave critics without excuse.RH Jan 13, 1910ST Apr 15, 1880ST Mar 8, 1899
Triumphal Entry Setting
The verse belongs to Christ's triumphal entry into Jerusalem in the last week of his life, only a few days before his crucifixion, when he journeyed from Bethany over the Mount of Olives toward the city, the day after his last Sabbath at Bethany.ST Dec 23, 1886ST Nov 8, 1883ST Apr 14, 1898ST Feb 14, 1878ST Nov 17, 1898 It stands among the principal events of Luke 18:24 through Luke 21, closely joined to the weeping over the city.ST Apr 21, 1909 As he descended the Mount of Olives a throng met him with palm branches and spread garments, with loud hosannas to the Son of David as King coming in the name of the Lord, praising God for the mighty works they had witnessed.ST Nov 27, 1879ST Those works included healings and deliverances, with the recent raising of Lazarus giving ample proof that he was Messiah, heir to David's throne and King of Israel, and even the children joined in songs of praise.ST Jan 21, 1897ST Nov 8, 1883 People flocked from all the region about, and crowds joyfully welcomed him with public acclaim as he approached the city.ST Apr 20, 1876ST
Some Pharisees in the multitude, with the priests and elders, demanded that Jesus rebuke his disciples and still the multitude, telling him to silence their shouting of his praises.ST Apr 20, 1876ST Sep 27, 1899ST Dec 23, 1886 He refused to silence them and answered that if the disciples held their peace the stones would immediately cry out, so the loud acclaim of him as King coming in the name of the Lord could not be suppressed.ST Sep 17, 1894ST Sep 27, 1899ST Dec 23, 1886GSAM 66.1–2ST Sep 17, 1894 The Lord had declared that the occasion should be marked by shouting, and his word would be fulfilled even if he had to give voice to the stones in the street.GSAM 66.1–2ST Sep 27, 1899 The disciples' hosanna was itself inspired by the same Spirit who could give a message to inanimate stones, showing God's power.ST Jul 2, 1894
Luke 19 gives the fullest account of that entry scene with its hallelujah cry over Jerusalem, an entry also found in Matthew 21, Mark 11, and John 12, showing welcome turning to rejection in the experience of Christ and coming just before the institution of the Lord's Supper.ST It was the one instance in his life when he allowed the crowds full sway in their demonstrations of honor.ST Jul 22, 1886 The procession halted on the Mount of Olives as Jesus approached Jerusalem, when Jerusalem still had opportunity to repent and be saved but its day of mercy was nearly over and judgment was near, and he continued to plead for the city even though it had rejected his warnings and was about to reject him.ST Jun 22, 1882ST Apr 21, 1909 The enthusiastic throng accompanied him down through the valley, up the slope to the gate and into the city, and when he came near and beheld the city he wept over it, then after entering the city he entered the temple and cast out the traffickers.ST Nov 3, 1898 The event also warned that privileges and warnings were being neglected while the time of probation was nearing its end.ST Feb 14, 1878
Hosanna means save now, and Jesus is able to save, so the loud cry was a fitting tribute of praise, thanksgiving and honor to Christ the coming King and fulfilled prophetic words.ST Jul 2, 1894 His triumph was unlike the conquest of earthly rulers, because its trophies were people rescued from suffering, death and Satan's power through his works of love.ST Jan 21, 1897 The image of stones crying out is personification, a figure in which what is without life is represented as active or speaking and does not mean stones literally speak.RH Feb 11, 1873 At the same time inanimate creation, by fulfilling its purpose, exposes human ingratitude and rebellion against God, and shows that God's word cannot be broken but will come to pass however improbable the means.RH Apr 7, 1868ST Sep 27, 1899 The disciples received him as King with shouts of joy, but the unconverted nation rejected him and scorned his lowliness, so the promised protection of the city and nation was withdrawn.ST Nov 8, 1883
Prophecy That Had To Be Fulfilled
The shouting at the entry fulfilled Zechariah 9:9, where Zion and the daughter of Jerusalem are commanded in the imperative to rejoice greatly and to shout at the coming of her king.RH Jul 30, 1857ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jul 4, 1871 That command written centuries beforehand was a prediction sure to be fulfilled in its season, and its fulfillment came when Christ rode in just and lowly upon an ass and a colt amid spreading of garments and cries of Hosanna to the King.RH Jul 4, 1871RH Jun 10, 1858 The praise had to occur because prophecy had commanded it, so that even if the people had been silent the stones would have cried out, and human opposition could not prevent it.RH Jul 30, 1857RH Jul 30, 1857 The disciples did what was written of him by divine impulse without knowing it at the time, remembering and understanding only after Jesus was glorified.ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jun 10, 1858
The entry fulfilled God's appointed time for the King to come as foretold centuries earlier, and the Lord had declared that this occasion should be marked by shouting.RH Sep 17, 1914GSAM 66.1–2 That included the humble arrival and the children joining by the Spirit of God when the time came for the people to rejoice at the world's Deliverer.RH Sep 17, 1914RH Oct 22, 1903 If the people had been silent God would have made even inanimate nature announce the fulfillment, giving voice to the stones in the street.RH Sep 17, 1914GSAM 66.1–2RH Oct 22, 1903 God's prophetic commands are fulfilled at their appointed time, and human unbelief, silence, or opposition cannot prevent them or stop God's purpose and appointed time for proclaiming the triumph of Christ.GSAM 66.3–67.1RH Oct 22, 1903RH Jul 30, 1857
The praise was fitting and necessary and part of God's appointed plan and providential purpose, fulfilling Scripture and the prophetic vision of the King coming to Jerusalem.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886ST Apr 1, 1889GSAM 191.3 No one could turn aside or thwart God's purposes for His Son, and the priests and elders could not prevent this adoration because prophecy had to be fulfilled.ST Dec 23, 1897ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886 The proclamation would be Behold your God, and if people failed to praise Him even the stones would have voiced the acclamation.ST Dec 23, 1897ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886ST Apr 1, 1889 Though those who praised misunderstood the event and expected Jesus to become a temporal king, their praise was still required by the prophetic command.ST Jun 5, 1879GSAM 191.3
Because prophecy had to be fulfilled, the praise could not be silenced: if the disciples, the multitude, or the children were quiet, the stones would at once cry out.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Jan 30, 1912 God's living word would give them voice and do the work of proclaiming Him, so His word about that occasion would not fail even when people opposed the predicted event or refused their assigned part.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Sep 17, 1894ST This was necessary because prophecy had described the event centuries beforehand, including the humble arrival, and its fulfillment was assured and certainly would come to pass.ST Jan 30, 1912ST Even if professed people refuse their part He can use other means, for God's word cannot fail.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Sep 17, 1894
The scene fulfills the part of Zechariah's prophecy describing the king's humble entry into Jerusalem, while the promise of Christ's worldwide dominion and the end of war remains to be fulfilled.RH Dec 11, 1866 The entry during the last week of His life on earth points forward to His final glorious triumph when He enters His kingdom to reign.RH Dec 11, 1866ST Apr 14, 1898 On the way to Jerusalem the parable of the nobleman who receives a kingdom and then returns to have his enemies who would not have him reign brought forth and slain pictures Christ receiving the kingdom as the closing event of His priestly ministry and then returning at His second advent with accompanying judgments.RH Apr 15, 1858ST Nov 27, 1879 That return will dash the nations in pieces like a potter's vessel rather than convert them, which is also the time of the marriage of the Lamb.RH Apr 15, 1858 The parable was spoken to correct the impression that the kingdom of God should immediately appear, an impression shown by the rejoicing with palm branches and shouts of triumph as to the son of David, yet it did not fully remove the mistake about time and order.ST Nov 27, 1879 The talents and pounds in Matthew 25 and Luke 19 represent gifts of the Spirit, bestowed at the same time, for the same purpose, by the same giver, and to the same people.ST Jul 8, 1889
Right Praise With Wrong Expectation
The disciples and the crowd and people from all the region announced the message at the right time as Jesus entered Jerusalem, yet they mistakenly expected the kingdom of God to immediately appear.ST Nov 20, 1884ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 16, 1889LDT 183.2–184.1ST Jul 21, 1898 They rejoiced before Jesus as a king in his triumph, hailing him as the Son of David with palm branches and shouts of triumph and crying Hosanna, because they expected him then to be crowned King on David's throne and to begin a temporal reign in Jerusalem.ST Nov 27, 1879LDT 183.2–184.1ST Jul 21, 1898 The parable of the nobleman was spoken on the way to Jerusalem to correct that impression, but it did not fully remove it, for they still acted as if he came to reign rather than to be condemned and crucified as a malefactor, which proves they labored under mistakes about the time and order of future events and did not understand that he was going to suffer and die before entering his glory.ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 16, 1889 Their mistake about the event became clear only after their disappointment, when they learned that Christ had to suffer before coming in his kingdom, yet the message was true and had to be proclaimed, so that had the people stayed silent the stones would have announced it, for prophecy must be fulfilled.ST Nov 20, 1884LDT 183.2–184.1ST Jul 21, 1898
Within days their high hopes were drowned in bitter disappointment and the darkness of death when instead of taking David's throne Jesus was crucified as a malefactor.LDT 183.2–184.1RH Jun 10, 1858ST Apr 8, 1875ST Feb 26, 1880 Those same disciples saw their beloved Master stretched upon the cruel cross above the mocking, taunting Pharisees, and their disappointment threatened their faith until the risen and glorified Christ corrected their understanding and gave them gospel work.LDT 183.2–184.1 Their shouting as they spread their garments and cried Hosanna to the King fulfilled what Zechariah had said hundreds of years before about the King coming just, lowly, and riding on an ass and a colt, and Jesus would not rebuke them because that fulfillment could not be stopped, so that if they had held their peace the stones would have cried out.RH Jun 10, 1858 Their hopes soon ended in bitter disappointment when Jesus died, yet prophecy was fulfilled through their joyful hosannas despite their mistaken expectations, and their misunderstanding and later disappointment did not prevent prophecy from being fulfilled through their hopes and praise.ST Apr 8, 1875ST Feb 26, 1880
Their mistaken expectation about time and order did not make their praise wrong or the prophetic event a failure.RH Mar 26, 1867ST Jan 9, 1893RH Sep 18, 1855RH Oct 12, 1869RH Jun 10, 1858 Moved by the Spirit without knowing it at the time, they did what was written of him and fulfilled prophecy through joyful hosannas, praising him in ignorance of his coming suffering and death, and only remembered and understood after Jesus was glorified.RH Oct 12, 1869RH Jun 10, 1858RH Feb 16, 1869 Their disappointment when Jesus was crucified did not prove that he was not the Christ or that God was absent, and their later disappointment did not make their witness wrong, for they had mistaken the event, not the truth about Jesus.RH Mar 26, 1867ST Jul 19, 1883 Their acclaim and the possibility that the stones themselves would cry out were part of the foretold event, so disappointment did not mean prophecy failed.ST Mar 3, 1890ST Feb 11, 1903ST Apr 8, 1903ST Oct 2, 1893ST Apr 10, 1907 Although he entered Jerusalem not to take a throne but to die, and although their public proclamation that his kingdom was being set up was tied to the mistaken belief that he would establish a temporal reign in Jerusalem, their role in fulfilling the prophecy of the King arriving humbly remained.ST Apr 8, 1903ST Oct 2, 1893ST Apr 10, 1907ST Jul 19, 1883
Like William Miller, they were mistaken about the event at the end of prophetic periods, not about the truth of Jesus as Christ and King, which shows that people can correctly recognize a prophetic truth yet misunderstand what will happen when it is fulfilled.RH Mar 26, 1867RH May 5, 1874 The same certainty applies to the first angel's message announcing the hour of God's judgment: God's Spirit moved people to proclaim the warning at the right time, and even if they had been silent voices would still have risen to announce it.RH Mar 17, 1859RH Sep 13, 1853 The same principle applies to the seventh-month movement of 1844 and the midnight cry: its proclaimers were right to give the warning even though they were disappointed about the event they expected, and they should not be ashamed of the experience that led them to become Adventists, for their proclamation was timely and justified like the multitude's praise when Jesus rode into Jerusalem.RH Jun 9, 1851RH Aug 15, 1854 That movement was doing God's will with a proclamation so necessary that had its people kept silent even the stones would have cried out.RH Aug 27, 1857
God's Purpose Beyond Human Silence
God's truth and work and word do not depend on human messengers and cannot fail, for if people refuse their part or oppose the predicted event he can use other means and give voice to stones and still bring his purpose to pass by everlasting power.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Feb 7, 1911RH Nov 14, 1912ST Oct 31, 1911 If those entrusted with the message refuse to speak for him, even the stones will bear witness rather than let it be silenced, and their refusal cannot make his word fail.ST Feb 7, 1911ST May 14, 1902RH Nov 14, 1912ST Oct 31, 1911 What was spoken about the rejoicing at the entry into Jerusalem had to be fulfilled and could not be silenced, for if the people stopped praising him the stones would at once cry out.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Aug 26, 1897 If people fail to testify to his sure and enduring word, even stones will bear witness to it and confirm that his word will accomplish its purpose and that Christ's words will surely come to pass, as the preserved Arch of Titus stands as such a witness.ST May 14, 1902 God may choose people as instruments, but if they fail to act even the stones will cry out, since his living word is self-fulfilling and its divine life and truth mean creation itself would bear witness.RH Nov 14, 1912ST Oct 31, 1911
He is not dependent on poor mortal man to keep his throne and life and word and oath secure, and though some depart from the faith and teach error, and though all men should apostatize and fail to witness for him, the foundation stands sure and he is found true.RH Nov 23, 1905ST If need be he can raise up stones to proclaim his message, so human unfaithfulness cannot make his faithfulness of none effect, and his work does not depend on human agents or their offerings.RH Nov 23, 1905ST When the reforming time comes at his appointed hour to intervene in the affairs of the world, the divine life must clear a passage for itself and is able to create of itself the humble instruments by which that life is communicated to the human race, so that truth will be proclaimed even if men are silent.ST Dec 28, 1876RH Aug 16, 1870 A real reformation is prepared during many ages as the work of his Spirit and is not made arbitrarily like charters and revolutions, and before that hour even the greatest geniuses and most faithful servants cannot produce it.ST Dec 28, 1876RH Aug 16, 1870
The same law now holds for the irresistible progress of his truth in the earth, which has reached the hour to go with power to all lands with delay no longer, and the time when things ought to be or might be to hasten his work is past and the time is reached when all things necessary to its progress will be, so the work can be hastened but can no longer be hindered.RH Jan 14, 1904 As the praise of the disciples at the triumph could not be silenced, so the foretold warning message about the second advent will go to the world and cannot be silenced or fail, but must be proclaimed despite bitter opposition.ST Aug 26, 1897RH Jan 14, 1904RH Mar 11, 1875 The loud cry of the everlasting gospel will go to the whole world despite scoffing and attacks from religious leaders and attempts to stop it by civil laws, and the greater the opposition the louder the message will sound, for opposition cannot silence the proclamation he has appointed.ST Jul 9, 1894 The proclamation of the Lord's coming in this generation cannot be silenced, and if those entrusted with the third angel's message held their peace the very stones would cry out the words of warning and angels would carry the message instead, giving assurance that the last-day gospel of the kingdom will be preached throughout the world as a witness to every nation through a faithful body proclaiming his soon return.RH Jan 14, 1904RH Dec 16, 1902RH Aug 27, 1914 If his disciples and the children were quiet even the stones would cry out, for he must be honored and his message cannot finally be silenced.RH Mar 11, 1875
Death may silence the human voice but cannot silence witness to him, for praise of him cannot finally be silenced and even if people are quieted the earth still cries out.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Apr 11, 1911 When he who is the Master of Life touches the stones by his voice at his coming they will respond, thus pointing to his power over death and to the resurrection in which his victory of life over death is made manifest.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Apr 11, 1911 The same image applies to the stones of his temple raising their voices in joy as the King comes to dwell with his people, since praise of the King cannot be silenced.RH Feb 24, 1916 When his own people are unfaithful and fail to carry his message to the world, others may carry it forward, as Darius proclaimed his greatness to the nations.ST Jan 30, 1912
Stones Testifying Through Discoveries
When human voices cease to uphold the truthfulness of God's word or deny what is recorded in it, the stones themselves testify in its favor and leave the world without excuse.ST Aug 11, 1909ST Dec 7, 1915ST Nov 22, 1910 Ancient monuments, tablets, inscriptions, mounds, and records hidden for ages are brought to light when needed to confirm Scripture, answer claims made against the Bible, and expose critics as false.ST Aug 11, 1909ST Dec 7, 1915ST Nov 22, 1910 Facts confirming Scripture thus emerge like a voice that cannot be suppressed, for if the disciples' praise were made quiet the stones would at once cry out.
Babylonian antiquities buried twenty-five hundred years ago and now resurrected from the grave speak as one risen from the dead to bear God's message to the living that the Most High rules in the kingdom of men.ST Nov 21, 1900 Their stony faces and translated inscriptions are literal stones made to cry out His truth when men are silent.ST Nov 21, 1900 Deciphered Egyptian inscriptions and records on stone declare the truth of the Bible, while inscriptions and artifacts uncovered from mounds and ruins illuminate the Old Testament setting.ST Nov 30, 1915RH Jun 25, 1901 Ancient Assyrian and Babylonian records carved on stones confirm the historical accounts in Kings and Chronicles like voices from the past, and ancient tablets and monuments uncovered by archaeologists corroborate the Scripture record as though the stones themselves testified to its truth.ST Jan 4, 1916RH Feb 22, 1912
Stone carvings over the portals of the Nurnberg city hall are such speaking stones that proclaim God's truth for the present time by portraying the four universal kingdoms of Daniel 7.RH Nov 2, 1905 Carved as early as 1617, they show the winged lion with Nebuchadnezzar, the bear with three ribs in its mouth with Darius, the four-headed leopard with Alexander, and the great and terrible beast complete with the little horn with Augustus.RH Nov 2, 1905 Their detail proves the artists understood the meaning of the beasts.RH Nov 2, 1905
The Hittite empire, once dismissed because no records outside the Bible were known, was confirmed by Egyptian and Assyrian inscriptions and by discovery of records of the Hittites on ancient rocks, exposing the critic's denial as false.RH Sep 3, 1908 When professed friends of the Bible who owe everything to its influence dispute its ancient history, calling creation an allegory, the deluge a myth, and declaring the Hittites never existed, the ruins of Assyrian and Egyptian temples and palaces yield cylindrical tomes and brick records that utter their voice.ST Jan 2, 1901 Those stones confirm that the Bible is not alone in its story of creation, that the flood is a tradition among all nations, and that the Hittites were a nation of power as the Bible indicates.ST Jan 2, 1901 Boastful old heathen records that exalt their heroes into gods and demigods and magnify age and length of reign still confirm the Word and make world-wise scholars foolish.ST Jan 2, 1901 The same crying of the stones goes on in excavating buried Mugheir, Ur of the Chaldees, the early home of Abraham and Sarah, a confirmation not needed by those who know Christ but helping doubters and manifesting the folly of those who rise up against the Word of truth.ST Jan 2, 1901
Petra's ancient stones and inscriptions testify to the truth of Scripture, and the preserved Arch of Titus serves as a witness that God's sure and enduring word will accomplish its purpose and that Christ's words will surely come to pass.ST May 14, 1902ST Jul 5, 1910 Monuments and tablets in Egypt, old Babylon, and elsewhere preserved by God's providence give unquestionable authentic record that the Bible account is true and the teaching of critics is false, showing God has been carefully guarding His sacred word through every adverse criticism so it remains the firm foundation for faith and hope.ST Jan 11, 1916 This stone testimony covers even the sixth century B.C., the time of the historical events of the book of Daniel, at the close of the period when monumental records cease just before abundant historical material and first-hand information begin with the science of historical writing in the fifth century B.C.ST Jan 11, 1916 Ancient monuments and inscriptions serve as witnesses to the historical truth of the biblical account of Genesis 14, and clay records attest that Belshazzar was Nabonidus's son and co-ruler.ST Dec 14, 1915 Historic evidence of ancient Sabbath observance is God's testimony to the Sabbath's truth at a time of doubt, while the children's witness to Christ's divinity could not be silenced and the stones of ancient nations also serve as witnesses to the inspiration of the Old Testament Scriptures.ST May 3, 1910ST Jan 28, 1886
God could raise children for Abraham even from stones, so Abraham's descent did not depend on natural lineage.ST Jan 18, 1899
Call To Proclaim Boldly
Christ's praise cannot be silenced, and the present missionary message must go forth and cannot be held back.RH Jan 13, 1910RH May 19, 1859 The proclamation of truth cannot be suppressed, for if those called to speak hold their peace even the stones would cry out, which lays a compelling duty on the preacher as though silence itself would bring testimony against him.ST Apr 15, 1880RH Dec 8, 1874 Those who know what Jesus has done for them must tell it openly and must not stay silent through fear of priest and people, for if they hold their peace the Lord will make the rocks speak in their place.ST Mar 8, 1899
Each professed believer has a mission and should do what can be done to spread the truth through personal example, sharing publications, giving means, and testifying to God's goodness, since professing present truth excuses no one from labor in the harvest.ST May 20, 1880RH Oct 12, 1869RH Jun 23, 1874 If people who can bear witness remain silent the stones themselves would cry out, so the truth will still be carried even without them.ST May 20, 1880RH Jun 23, 1874RH Mar 4, 1902 God's word will be honored and His purposes fulfilled even if people refuse their part, for the cause does not depend on human service to triumph, yet neglecting the entrusted duty risks salvation and loss of crowns.ST Nov 9, 1882 The very possibility that stones would speak underscores the urgency of dedicating human voices to the gospel message.RH Mar 4, 1902
When religious teachers were silent, children proclaimed the appointed message by the Spirit, showing that God's living word is self-fulfilling and moves someone to proclaim what prophecy contains when a special announcement is due.ST Jul 23, 1896 The prophetic proclamation of Christ as King in Jerusalem had to be made even when authorities tried to silence it, with children's voices joining to fulfill the sure word, and so also the judgment-hour message had to be proclaimed in 1844.RH Nov 7, 1912 When authorities in part of Sweden tried to suppress it, children preached and urged preparation for the judgment, and convicting and converting power attended their work.RH Nov 7, 1912
The third angel's message, the Sabbath-reform message, the warning of Christ's coming in this generation, and the closing mediatorial work of Christ as Mediator at the right hand of the throne as minister of the sanctuary and true tabernacle in the decisive period of atonement must be given throughout the world to earth's millions.RH Dec 16, 1902ST Mar 30, 1876RH Jul 3, 1900RH Jun 3, 1902ST Oct 14, 1889 If Seventh-day Adventists or others who should proclaim it held their peace, the very stones would immediately cry out, angels would carry the message instead, and message and deliverance would come from another place.RH Dec 16, 1902RH Dec 14, 1905RH Jul 3, 1900ST Oct 14, 1889 Preaching that closing work at the right time is a necessary work giving a right to exist, as hosannas welcomed the King at the first advent while His second coming near is now preached in the order expressly foretold.ST Mar 30, 1876 A trumpet-voiced body of believers must lift up the voice to give Old and New Testament prophecies of the second coming and warn of their certain fulfillment, because popular churches are not watching, not preparing, nor seeking to prepare the world, so that stones would already be crying in men's ears if no more were being done, and they are silent only because such an actively proclaiming people exists.RH Dec 14, 1905 Spreading that message quickly with life and means is the surest investment, since money given now is worth far more than money given later, and those who know or could know the warning must speak it lest people remain unwarned with responsibility for their loss.RH Dec 16, 1902RH Jul 3, 1900
God's resources for spreading the gospel are limitless, for if His people neglect the work through books and tracts others may be called to do it and the message will still be given.RH Apr 21, 1903 When earnest adult canvassers are absent, street newsboys buying gospel papers to resell lend a hand in spreading truth, and when professed believers leave a great dearth of canvassers God can just as easily use men not of the faith to sell the books containing the message for this time.RH Jul 29, 1902RH Mar 7, 1907 Opposition cannot stop the Sabbath agitation, through which God can stir secular papers to speak, including a religious newspaper declaring the seventh day the true Sabbath and leading German and Hungarian papers copying a Hungarian nobleman's article, while restored Sabbath truth is vindicated against the beast that changed the law.ST May 14, 1894 The warning of the Lord's coming taught among the Karens cannot be silenced, and duty to support that work remains, so that refusers are themselves the losers.RH Dec 7, 1911
God will have a people who praise and glorify Him rather than remain cold and silent, for if disciples were made quiet the stones would immediately cry out.RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852 God's people must shout praise from pole to pole and let hallelujahs ring, for joyful heartfelt shouting in praise of God and of the coming King is fitting and pleasing to Heaven.RH Oct 21, 1858RH Dec 12, 1865 Opposing shouting in God's house as out of date, out of time, out of fashion, and impolite in polished society is fastidious and pharisaical, treating rejoicing as fanaticism or extravagance, and springs up as a root of bitterness by which many are defiled and churches are split apart.RH Jun 10, 1852RH Oct 21, 1858 Even commandment-keeping people cannot rightly be forbidden to praise Him for the glorious hope and redemption Christ purchased, full of immortality and glory beyond the disciples' praise at the entry.RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852
Those who have received grace and seen the light are to bear witness willingly and lovingly, for it is their privilege to do God's will and be glorified in Him, and if they remain silent even the stones would cry out.ST Aug 9, 1910 When scribes and Pharisees would not proclaim Christ, children praised Him in the temple, showing that when people refuse to proclaim His coming and truth prepared for hearts, God's word will still be fulfilled rather than let testimony be silenced. The duty is to defend the third angel's message in meekness, answer objections to the commandments and the Second Advent rather than remain silent, speak plainly against sin, teach the whole law and gospel, and serve as missionary teachers for children.RH Jul 8, 1852RH Aug 13, 1857 The proclamation does not depend on human willingness, human carelessness cannot stop the work, and human silence cannot prevent the Advent work from being finished quickly, yet loyalty means life or death and indifference can become the point of turning by degrees and finally wholly away in the final struggle.RH Feb 21, 1907RH Dec 17, 1903 The work is possible when God leads and will go forward despite doubt and obstacles.RH Dec 17, 1903
The disciples' praise could not be silenced, for if made quiet the stones would at once cry out, which illustrates that facts confirming Scripture emerge like a voice that cannot be suppressed. The people's praise at the entry had to be heard to fulfill promise concerning the coming King, so the promised rejoicing could not be suppressed, and the same certainty applies to the promised warning before the day of the Lord which must be sounded.ST Feb 19, 1880 The entry and the message declaring Him King had to fulfill prophecy, and if God's people failed to use their privilege the stones would give the message and do the work instead. Their hosannas fulfilled prophecy even though their hope that Jesus would immediately take David's throne was not fulfilled and He was soon crucified, and so also God's Spirit moved people to proclaim the first angel's message announcing the hour of judgment, where even if appointed messengers had been silent other voices would have risen to give the warning.RH Mar 17, 1859RH Mar 17, 1859
The loud hosannas accompanying His approach did not mean hearts truly loved Him, for outward celebration stood in contrast to absent hearts without love, and Jerusalem faced judgment for faith without love.RH Feb 18, 1875 If God's people give cause through neglected duty even the stones will cry out against them, calling church and ministers to do duty to God and others.RH Aug 13, 1857
Sources