AdventAI

Luke 24:41

And while they yet believed not for joy, and wondered, he said unto them, Have ye here any meat?

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

14 sources

In the upper room at Jerusalem soon after the Emmaus disciples arrived, Jesus himself stood among them as the risen Christ and asked whether there was anything at all to eat, for the word for meat means food in general.CTBH 169.5Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–633SP 225.2 They still struggled to believe because they were so full of joy, wonder, amazement and astonishment at seeing Him alive, and His appearance dispelled their fear and brought gladness.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 1878 To prove He was truly risen bodily and not a spirit, He ate before them to show His body had not seen corruption and that He was living and not dead, and they gave Him broiled fish and honeycomb, while another account describes the food as bread and honeycomb.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 1878Ms 40, 1903, par. 19 With the meal He also removed unbelief by explaining the straight chain of prophecy concerning Himself in Moses and the prophets, showing His wounded side and pierced hands and feet, letting them handle Him, and teaching them from the Scriptures to give them new and sacred hope.Ms 203, 1898, par. 93SP 234.115MR 23.4Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19 Their wonder and uncertainty then gave way to calm faith and joy with no room for unbelief among the eleven, and this eyewitness testimony of seeing Him, talking with Him, and finding the empty sepulcher was a decided triumph that made of no effect the falsehood of the priests.DA 802.1–803.2COS 184.3–185.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 9

Words and Setting

The word rendered as meat means food in general rather than animal flesh in particular, so the question is whether there is anything at all to eat.CTBH 169.5 The scene is the upper room at Jerusalem after the resurrection, with the doors shut for fear of the Jews.Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–633SP 225.2 It came soon after the two disciples from Emmaus arrived to report that they had found Jesus, when Jesus Himself came in and stood among them and revealed Himself as the risen Christ.Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63

These appearances in the upper room at Jerusalem occurred twice, and there He told the disciples to remain in Jerusalem for a time.3SP 225.2 On the same day as this meal He had also joined two disciples walking to Emmaus and opened to them in Moses and all the prophets the things concerning Himself.Ms 203, 1898, par. 9

Bodily Risen, Joyfully Believed

They yet believed not for joy, for they were so full of joy and wonder and amazement and astonishment at seeing Jesus alive that they still struggled to believe it was truly He risen from the dead.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 18783SP 217.1–3Ms 40, 1903, par. 19 His appearance among them dispelled their fears and brought them joy and gladness, yet their joy itself at first left them unable to believe.ST Sep 26, 1878DA 802.1–803.2COS 184.3–185.315MR 23.4 The joyful amazement that kept them from believing was met by His own gracious proof, for to show He was truly Jesus risen bodily and not a spirit He asked for something to eat and ate before them.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 1878DA 802.1–803.23SP 217.1–3 By eating and drinking in their presence He gave abundant evidence that the Saviour was living and not dead and that His body had not seen corruption.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 223SP 217.1–3Ms 40, 1903, par. 19Ms 203, 1898, par. 9

They gave Him broiled fish and honeycomb, which He ate in front of them, and by this eating they recognized Him as their risen Saviour and not a spirit.Ms 113, 1897, par. 22 Another account of the same meal describes the food as a piece of bread and a honeycomb, eaten before them so they saw it was Jesus, and describes Him as both eating and drinking before them.Ms 40, 1903, par. 19Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63 Along with eating, He removed unbelief by explaining the straight chain of prophecy about Himself, showing His wounded side and His pierced hands and feet, and letting them handle Him.3SP 234.1 In the upper room He taught them from the Scriptures concerning Himself, giving them a new and sacred hope and joy.15MR 23.4Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19

Their wonder and uncertainty and unbelief gave way to calm faith and joy when He ate food in their presence, and their doubt gave way to faith and joy as they were convinced He was truly risen.DA 802.1–803.2COS 184.3–185.3 Because of that proof there was no room for unbelief in the minds of the eleven so that none of them doubted, while other followers were only partially convinced.3SP 234.1 They became calm and joyful in belief of the truth, leaving no room for unbelief.DA 802.1–803.2COS 184.3–185.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 93SP 234.1 This eyewitness testimony that they had seen Him and talked with Him, that early in the morning of the first day of the week they went to the sepulcher and found it empty and saw the shroud but did not find Him, was a decided triumph that made of none effect the falsehood of the priests and established Christianity by evidence that could not be controverted.Ms 203, 1898, par. 9 Their surprise came because they did not accept Him by faith, and if they had had faith they would have enjoyed the joyful time much better.Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63

Sources

  1. CTBH 169.5 Christian Temperance and Bible Hygiene — FOOD, AIR, AND EXERCISE. Ellen G. White, 1890
  2. Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904) — Ms 155, 1904 Ellen G. White, written September 4, 1904
  3. 3SP 225.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — JESUS AT GALILEE. Ellen G. White, 1878
  4. 6RED 35.1–3 Redemption: or the Resurrection of Christ; and His Ascension — IN THE UPPER CHAMBER. Ellen G. White, 1877
  5. Ms 113, 1897, par. 22 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 113, 1897 Ellen G. White, written October 14, 1897
  6. ST Sep 26, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 36 — IN THE UPPER CHAMBER Ellen G. White, Fifth-day, September 26, 1878
  7. Ms 40, 1903, par. 19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Ms 40, 1903 Ellen G. White, written May 4, 1903
  8. Ms 203, 1898, par. 9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 203, 1898 Ellen G. White, written January 10, 1898
  9. 3SP 234.1 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — MEETING OF THE BRETHREN. Ellen G. White, 1878
  10. 15MR 23.4 Manuscript Releases, vol. 15 [Nos. 1136-1185] — MR No. 1141—Cautions About Making Doctrinal Differences Prominent; Contemplating the Marvels and Mysteries of the Incarnation Ellen G. White, written February 18, 1887; published 1990
  11. Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 5 (1887-1888) — Lt 37, 1887 Ellen G. White, written February 18, 1887
  12. DA 802.1–803.2 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER EIGHTY-FOUR. Ellen G. White, 1898
  13. COS 184.3–185.3 Christ Our Saviour — WITNESSES. Ellen G. White, 1896
  14. 3SP 217.1–3 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — IN THE UPPER CHAMBER. Ellen G. White, 1878

Pioneers and periodicals

76 sources

On the evening of the resurrection day in Jerusalem, the risen Jesus stood among his fearful disciples in their own upper lodging as they shared the common evening meal, and finding them disbelieving for joy and wonder and supposing him a spirit, he asked whether they had any food there and took broiled fish and honeycomb from their own supply and ate it before them.RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 4, 1899 The word for what he asked is anything eatable, food in general and not flesh only.RH Feb 20, 1872ST Apr 8, 1875RH Aug 1, 1871 By eating with being seen and handled and showing the wounds in his hands and feet and side, he proved he was risen bodily with a real, material, tangible body of flesh and bones, his real self, and not a spirit, ghost or merely figurative presence.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900RH Jun 25, 1861 He is therefore the same literal, personal, corporeal Jesus who lived, died and rose, the pattern and pledge of the resurrection of the saints and of eating in God's kingdom, so he ascended as he rose and will come again in like manner as visible and literal as his first advent.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Nov 8, 1910ST Feb 11, 1886ST Nov 8, 1910ST May 15, 1907 On that evening he opened their understanding to see that all written of him in Moses and the prophets and psalms had to be fulfilled, that Christ had to suffer and rise the third day, and that repentance and remission of sins must be preached in his name among all nations beginning at Jerusalem.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Jun 25, 1894ST Jan 30, 1912RH Aug 1, 1871ST May 28, 1896 That gathering was an ordinary meal at home behind closed doors in unbelief, mourning and disputing, with nothing said or done to bless or hallow the first day or institute its observance, so it gives no warrant for Sunday keeping, while those who held otherwise taught that his resurrection appearances and the Spirit's descent honored the first day and made it his own.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882RH Nov 14, 1871ST Oct 28, 1908RH Apr 29, 1873

Wording and Request

The word rendered meat means food in general, not animal flesh only.RH Feb 20, 1872ST Apr 8, 1875RH Aug 1, 1871RH Mar 4, 1875 It literally denotes anything to eat.RH Feb 20, 1872RH Aug 1, 1871RH Mar 4, 1875 It includes fruits, grains and vegetables as fully as flesh and never means flesh exclusively.RH Feb 20, 1872

The verse does not employ the usual New Testament word for meat, broma, but brosimos, which literally signifies anything eatable.RH Feb 20, 1872 Like broma, that term takes in plant foods as fully as flesh and never signifies flesh alone in the modern sense of meat, so the request is for food in general.RH Feb 20, 1872

He asked whether they had any food there or with them.RH Nov 16, 1916ST May 9, 1878ST May 28, 1896RH Jun 8, 1869 He joined them in their own private quarters where they were eating a common evening meal and asked to be supplied from their own supply on the table.RH Nov 19, 1872 His asking led to their giving him food, which opened the way to his further proof by eating before them that he was really and bodily risen with flesh and bones.ST May 9, 1878ST May 28, 1896RH Nov 19, 1872

Setting and Timing

The appearance took place in Jerusalem on the evening of the resurrection day, the first day of the week.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Nov 14, 1871ST Apr 12, 1883 It was the third day after his crucifixion on the sixth day.ST Oct 4, 1899 It came after the two disciples had returned from Emmaus to Jerusalem and joined those gathered there.ST May 24, 1910ST Feb 23, 1915RH Nov 14, 1871 That return was a journey of eight miles, reckoned by others as up to fifteen miles of travel.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Dec 11, 1901 The risen one entered unseen with them into the room and manifested himself with a greeting of peace.

They were gathered together in their regular gathering place, the upper chamber and common dwelling and private quarters where they lived.ST May 24, 1910RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882RH Nov 14, 1871 It was where they habitually ate, drank and slept, not in the temple or synagogue.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882 They were behind closed doors for fear of the Jews, while eating the common evening meal or supper at home.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882RH Nov 14, 1871ST Aug 24, 1888 The whole company and the eleven were present, but Thomas was absent.RH Nov 14, 1871 Few of the apostles yet believed, for they were still doubting and disputing about the resurrection.ST Oct 28, 1908ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888

The meeting came after sunset when the day was far spent at Emmaus.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Dec 11, 1901 It was in the very last moments of the day, near the close of the first day of the week.ST Jul 1, 1880ST Mar 24, 1909 It came after the first day had passed into the second day, on the second day of the week.ST May 24, 1910ST Feb 23, 1915ST Oct 28, 1908ST Mar 24, 1909 So the whole day went by uncelebrated, unkept and unobserved.ST Dec 11, 1901

Joyful Unbelief Described

While they still could not believe for joy and wondered, their joy and amazement and astonishment at seeing the risen Jesus alive and truly present overwhelmed them and made it hard to believe their own eyes.RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST May 9, 1878 That joyful unbelief persisted even after his greeting and his words and his efforts to assure them and his showing his hands and feet and the reports that he was risen.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Nov 16, 1916ST Oct 4, 1899 His question whether they had any food there was met by their giving him food, which he took and ate before them in their presence.RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST May 9, 1878 His eating before them helped confirm and demonstrate that he was bodily risen with a real body of flesh and bones, not a spirit.ST Sep 26, 1878ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST May 9, 1878

They were terrified and frightened and discouraged and fearful and doubting and in hardness of heart, thinking he was a spirit or ghost or apparition.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Oct 28, 1908ST Aug 14, 1893 They were mourning and weeping and disputing, with few believing, and they had refused to believe the testimony of Mary Magdalene and of the two who had seen him at Emmaus.ST Oct 28, 1908ST Apr 12, 1883ST Jul 1, 1880 He entered unseen with them into the room where the others had shut themselves in for fear of the Jews and manifested himself with the greeting of peace after they had shown unbelief toward the report of his resurrection. He showed his hands and his feet and invited them to handle him to prove he was a real being having a literal, tangible body composed of flesh and bones, and then he called for food and ate a piece of fish and honeycomb in their presence because they would not believe their own eyes that he was truly alive and risen.ST Oct 4, 1899

Their incredulity shows they did not expect the resurrection or readily accept testimony to it, which supports the reality of the resurrection.RH Nov 15, 1906 They were still not believing he had risen though joy and wonder filled them, and at the very close of the first day they were mourning and weeping rather than rejoicing over the resurrection or celebrating it as an event they believed had happened.ST Oct 17, 1878ST Feb 20, 1879ST Jul 1, 1880 The testimony of Mary Magdalene and of the two who had seen the Lord at Emmaus had no effect on them, but they refused to believe.ST Jul 1, 1880

Eating Proves Bodily Resurrection

When asked whether anything to eat was at hand, they gave him from their own store and from the table before them a piece of broiled fish with honeycomb, or honey, and he took it and ate it before them in their presence.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST Oct 4, 1899 His request was met from what they themselves had provided for their own meal, and his eating was done openly where all could see.ST Sep 15, 1887RH Oct 21, 1862

With that eating went being seen and handled, for he showed them his hands and his feet and his side with the prints of the nails and the wound of the spear, bade them handle him, and spoke and walked with them.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Jun 25, 1861ST Dec 17, 1896ST Nov 18, 1886 The showing of hands and feet came even before the request for food, yet they still wondered, so the further proof of eating was added to sight and touch.RH Jun 25, 1861ST May 28, 1896ST Jun 11, 1896ST Apr 11, 1900

His asking for food and eating it proved he was risen bodily with a real, material, tangible body of flesh and bones, his real self.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST May 9, 1878 He was no spirit, ghost, phantom, or merely spiritual or figurative presence, but the same living person with a body that could take and use food.ST Sep 26, 1878ST Dec 17, 1894ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 4, 1899RH Jun 25, 1861

That eating convinced them, so doubt gave way to faith and joy after joy and wonder had held them back from believing.ST May 19, 1909ST Nov 18, 1886 By seeing, touching, talking, walking, and eating with him they were made eyewitnesses who had seen him and eaten with him after he rose, chosen witnesses furnished with many incontrovertible and infallible proofs that he was alive after his suffering.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Jun 5, 1866ST Dec 17, 1896ST Nov 18, 1886 Such witness was able to refute the lying testimony of the Jews and the hired soldiers, because only a living Saviour could be preached.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Nov 18, 1886

Prophecy Witness Mission

On that evening of the first day of the week he came to convince them that he had truly risen bodily that very day, the third day after his crucifixion on the sixth day, in fulfillment of prophecy concerning the Messiah and according to Scripture.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905 Though terrified and supposing him a spirit, and though he had shown his hands and feet, they still could not believe for joy and wonder at seeing him alive.ST Oct 4, 1899ST May 28, 1896 So he asked for food and took a piece of broiled fish and honeycomb from their own supply and ate it before them, proving he was his real self with flesh and bones and not a phantom.ST Oct 4, 1899ST May 28, 1896 Having thus proved himself, he told them that all things written about him in the law of Moses and in the prophets and in the psalms concerning his birth, life, mission, death and resurrection had to be fulfilled.ST May 28, 1896 By that use of the prophecies he convinced them that he was the true Messiah, reviving their hope and readiness to accept him.ST Jan 30, 1912 The purpose was to make them eyewitnesses who had seen him on that day and eaten with him after he rose, able to refute the lying testimony of the Jews and hired soldiers, and not to consecrate Sunday as a day of worship.ST Oct 4, 1899

He opened their understanding to understand the Scriptures and taught that Christ had to suffer and rise from the dead the third day, remaining present with them as they struggled to grasp what had happened.ST Jun 25, 1894ST May 28, 1896 That interview was the same prophetic teaching work he had done before his crucifixion, resumed on the very day of his resurrection and kept up during the forty days until he was taken up, so he did not cease from the work of redemption on the first day of the week.RH Aug 1, 1871 The resurrection changed their conception of his mission, showing he truly came to bring repentance and remission of sins to be preached in his name among all nations beginning at Jerusalem.ST Jun 11, 1896ST May 28, 1896 It also showed he will come again in the near future to abolish all sin and re-create the earth as an eternal, actual, tangible dwelling place for his saints.ST Jun 11, 1896

The encounter was a proclamation of his resurrection that brought new life and lively hope to those who had mourned.RH Jun 24, 1873 It turned disappointment and misunderstanding into renewed joy as further light about his work dawned on them.RH Dec 1, 1874 Though they had been sorely disappointed because they expected him to be crowned as king and instead saw him crucified, that disappointment did not prove Christianity false, for after his resurrection he himself showed them that his death was only fulfillment of prophecy, so disappointment does not disprove the doctrine of his soon coming.RH Dec 8, 1874 Luke's account differs from Matthew, Mark and John without contradicting them, for each writer recorded true particulars as the Spirit directed, including some events the others omitted and omitting some the others included, with no effort to harmonize their statements, so the four accounts can be harmonized.ST Mar 5, 1912 Luke did not witness the events himself but received them through Peter, and he probably wrote first.ST Mar 5, 1912 The church's existence and spiritual vitality is the primary evidence for the resurrection, while the views that deny his physical resurrection treat material in Luke beyond Mark as possibly true but unreliable.ST Mar 13, 1907RH May 11, 1916ST Oct 20, 1909

The verse belongs to the closing record of his suffering, crucifixion and resurrection, which includes the lesson taught to the two disciples who journeyed with him to Emmaus without recognizing him. It is part of his discourse to the unbelieving and amazed disciples when he appeared to them on the evening of the first day, linked to the question he asked the disciples by the water, in which he showed his astonished disciples that the one who had appeared to them was Jesus himself.ST Apr 28, 1909 One list places it among the fifth, sixth and seventh appearances, taking place several days after the day of his resurrection on the northern shore of the Sea of Galilee near Capernaum where the disciples had often fished, following his appearances to Mary alone, to the women, to Peter, to the two on the way to Emmaus, and to the twelve eight days after the first meeting, with the last meeting of the series to the seven apostles by the Sea of Galilee.ST May 30, 1895 The Jerusalem meeting is distinguished as the first assembled meeting, not the appointed meeting in Galilee described in John 20:19.RH Apr 8, 1873

Nature of Risen Body

The risen Jesus is the same real, substantial, corporeal, personal, visible Being who lived and died and was buried and was brought again to life by the power of God.ST Nov 8, 1910RH Oct 7, 1862ST May 15, 1907 He remains in the form of the Son of Man, triumphant and immortal, not an invisible, ethereal, non-corporeal spirit but flesh and bones.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Nov 8, 1910 He could be seen and touched and handled, talked and walked with, and ate and drank with men, and he broke bread and declared it is I myself.RH Oct 7, 1862ST Nov 8, 1910ST May 15, 1907 He gave abundant proof by many incontrovertible proofs and sure signs that he was literally risen and was the same Jesus, appearing and showing the wounds in hands and feet and side with the spear mark and the prints of the nails still present.ST Dec 17, 1896ST Aug 17, 1876 The disciples saw and handled him, spoke with him, watched him eat, and saw him ascend to heaven.RH Oct 7, 1862ST Dec 17, 1896

His glorified, spiritual body kept the same form as the natural body that was laid in the tomb.ST Aug 17, 1876 He was a real person with flesh and bones who could eat and drink even in that glorified, spiritual body, asking for food and eating it before the disciples to assure them he was truly bodily risen.RH Apr 4, 1871ST Aug 17, 1876 There was no blood in it, for his blood was shed on the cross, and flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, so its life principle was something else.ST Aug 17, 1876 As being in the image and form and express image of God's person, this eating spiritual body gives the idea of the form of God.ST Aug 17, 1876

His asking for food and eating material food proves he had a real body of flesh and bones and was not a disembodied spirit.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Feb 11, 1886 That eating demonstrates that resurrected immortal beings are real, personal, material and corporeal beings, and proves by example that angels are material beings and that the saints after the resurrection will likewise have flesh.ST Jul 23, 1874 His spiritual body is the pattern after which the spiritual bodies of the saints will be fashioned.ST Aug 17, 1876 His resurrection in a body that could be seen and handled and watched eating and drinking is the example and pledge of the resurrection of the dead.ST Feb 11, 1886 His eating after his resurrection supports that the resurrected saints can eat in God's kingdom and will be like him.ST Jan 28, 1875

His appearance and actions describe a bodily resurrection, not the resurrection of an immortal, disembodied soul, for death and resurrection apply to beings who are not immortal. He spoke with the disciples and ate in their presence in a bodily and tangible way, not merely in a spiritual or figurative sense.RH Jun 25, 1872 He invited them to touch his hands and feet and ate broiled fish and honeycomb before them. He stands as a personal, embodied Being who appeared and asked for food while they yet disbelieved for joy, a biblical testimony to his distinct personality.RH Jun 25, 1861

Promise of Literal Return

The request for food and the eating of part of the evening meal in the upper room removed absolutely all doubt regarding His personality, proving He was the same real, substantial, corporeal Being who had died, been buried, and been brought again to life by the power of God, still bearing the form of the Son of Man triumphant and immortal.ST Nov 8, 1910 He was not an invisible, ethereal, non-corporeal spirit but flesh and bones that could be seen and touched and handled, who broke bread and declared It is I Myself.ST Nov 8, 1910ST Nov 8, 1910 That bodily and literal resurrection proves the Jesus of the resurrection is the Jesus of the ascension who was taken up into heaven.ST Nov 8, 1910 Therefore His promise to come again means the same literal, personal, corporeal Jesus will come again in the midst of real, substantial, corporeal beings, in like manner as He was seen to go, as visible and literal as His first advent.ST Nov 8, 1910ST Nov 8, 1910ST May 15, 1907

He was the same Jesus who lived, died, and rose again, a literal, personal, visible Being who could be seen and handled, talked with, walked with, and ate with men.ST May 15, 1907 During the forty days after His resurrection He was seen and heard by them, spoke with them, and ate and drank with them, an actual man among men though God incarnate.RH Oct 7, 1862RH Oct 7, 1862ST Apr 15, 1897 Their joy and wonder left them struggling to believe He had risen, yet the eating and speaking with His followers is evidence that He truly rose and was present with them bodily.RH Oct 7, 1862RH Oct 7, 1862 The disciples saw and handled Him, ate and drank with Him, spoke with Him, and saw Him ascend, showing the risen Jesus was the same person who had been crucified and buried.RH Oct 7, 1862

His manifestation overcame their doubts and sorrow, filling them with faith and hope.ST Mar 8, 1905 The gathered disciples overwhelmed with joy and wonder were refreshed together by His appearance as a shower of blessing.ST Nov 11, 1908

No Authority for Sunday

The gathering was an ordinary common evening meal at home in their lodging and private quarters, the upper chamber that was their common dwelling where they habitually ate, drank and slept, not a religious assembly for worship or observance in temple or synagogue.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882RH Nov 14, 1871ST Aug 24, 1888ST Mar 16, 1882 There was no mood, custom or principle of worship begun, for they were discouraged, fearful, doubting and disbelieving that he had risen, gathered behind closed doors for fear of the Jews in anxiety and hiding because of danger.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Oct 28, 1908ST Mar 16, 1882 It was held after a day of feverish excitement, hurrying to and fro and constant activity from morning till night, and after the first day had passed into the second day.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Oct 28, 1908 His asking for food and eating broiled fish and honeycomb before them from their own supply and from the table was a simple familiar transaction such as might have been repeated many times during the forty days.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882 It gives no evidence that by joining them under those circumstances he meant to authorize a great innovation upon the practice of ages or to make the resurrection day a day for religious assemblies or Sunday worship.RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882

They met in fear, unbelief, hardness of heart, mourning and disputing, still not believing he had risen despite the reports of Mary Magdalene and of the two who had seen him at Emmaus, with few believing and with joy and wonder overwhelming them so they struggled to believe their own eyes.ST Oct 28, 1908ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Feb 20, 1879ST Nov 18, 1886 He came not to commend a celebration of his resurrection or to honor the first day, but to rebuke their unbelief and to convince them by being seen, handled and eating before them that he was truly risen and bodily present.RH Nov 14, 1871ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Feb 20, 1879ST Nov 18, 1886 They were in no fit state for worship and had not met to worship him, which proves the meeting was evidence of his rising, not a religious gathering or instruction to honor the first day.ST Oct 28, 1908ST Aug 24, 1888 An event cannot be commemorated the same day it happens, and their actions give no apostolic example for observing the first day.RH Nov 14, 1871ST Apr 12, 1883 Their unbelief itself shows they were not keeping that day to commemorate the resurrection, since they did not yet believe it had happened.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Feb 20, 1879

He said nothing about the first day, gave no command for its observance, breathed no blessing upon it, and gave no hint, sanctification to holy use, or intimation of changing the Sabbath to the day of his resurrection or to any other day of the forty days.RH Nov 14, 1871ST Oct 21, 1897RH Nov 14, 1871RH May 5, 1851 He expressed no intention to institute a new Sabbath and did not enforce the first day as a Christian Sabbath, though it would have been a favorable time to do so, and he laid no blame on those who had walked fifteen miles to Emmaus and back that day but met them with peace.RH Nov 14, 1871RH May 5, 1851 His conduct did nothing inconsistent with the commandment that the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord.RH Nov 14, 1871 What he did was something done on the day, not to the day, conferring no title of Lord's day and doing far less to the first day than the Father did to the seventh by rest, blessing and appointment to holy use.RH Nov 14, 1871RH May 5, 1851 His appearance was to show that he was alive and had risen, not to establish that day as holy.ST Aug 6, 1912

The example gives no warrant for rest, sacredness or Sunday keeping and disproves a first-day Sabbath, giving no command to keep the first day and no divine example of Sunday keeping.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Mar 16, 1882ST Oct 21, 1897 The day was filled with visits and activity rather than Sabbath rest, described in connection with anxiety and activity, not as a holy day or day of worship.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Sep 10, 1896 The interview is cited to show the character of Sabbath-keeping on that day.ST Jul 2, 1894ST Sep 10, 1896 Those who held the differing position taught that those repeated meetings after the resurrection honored the first day of the week and, with his resurrection, the descent of his Spirit, and the weekly assemblies for communion, preaching, prayer and giving, hallowed the first day and made it properly his own day, while after his resurrection he paid no regard to the seventh day.RH Apr 29, 1873

Sources

  1. RH Nov 16, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 57 — The Bible Year J. Anderson, November 16, 1916
  2. ST Dec 17, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 58 — THE ASCENSION Editor, Monday, December 17, 1894
  3. ST Sep 15, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 36 — APOSTOLIC EXAMPLE September 15, 1887
  4. ST Oct 4, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 40 — THE RESURRECTED LORD AND THE LORD'S DAY G. E. Fifield, October 4, 1899
  5. RH Feb 20, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 39, No. 10 — Meat and Flesh Uriah Smith, February 20, 1872
  6. ST Apr 8, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 22 — Bible Hygiene James White, April 8, 1875
  7. RH Aug 1, 1871 Review and Herald, Vol. 38, No. 7 — Bible Hygiene William Smith, August 1, 1871
  8. ST Apr 11, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 15 — LESSON III.—SABBATH, APRIL 21, 1900 April 11, 1900
  9. RH Jun 25, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 5 — PERSONALITY OF GOD Third-Day, June 25, 1861
  10. ST Jul 23, 1874 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 5 — Frankness D. M. Canright, July 23, 1874
  11. ST Nov 8, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 44 — The Master's Coming Charles L. Taylor, November 8, 1910
  12. ST Feb 11, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 6 — The Coming of a Literal Christ Editor, February 11, 1886
  13. ST Nov 8, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 44 — The Master's Coming Charles L. Taylor, November 8, 1910
  14. ST May 15, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 20 — The Manner of Christ's Coming Abdiel, May 15, 1907
  15. ST Jun 25, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 33 — SUGGESTIONS IN LESSON STUDY Monday, June 25, 1894
  16. ST Jan 30, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 5 — The Testimony of Jesus George W. Reaser, January 30, 1912
  17. RH Aug 1, 1871 Review and Herald, Vol. 38, No. 7 — The Sabbatism of Hebrews IV Uriah Smith, August 1, 1871
  18. ST May 28, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 22 — Jesus Crucified May 28, 1896
  19. RH Nov 19, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 23 — THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT: W. H. L., November 19, 1872
  20. ST Oct 5, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 38 — The Sunday, the Sabbath, and the Change William Henry Littlejohn, October 5, 1882
  21. RH Nov 14, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 22 — EXAMINATION OF T. M. PREBLE'S FIRST-DAY SABBATH John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, November 14, 1871
  22. ST Oct 28, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 35, No. 13 — With Our Inquirers Editor, October 28, 1908
  23. RH Apr 29, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 20 — THE STATESMAN ARTICLES John, April 29, 1873
  24. RH Mar 4, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 10 — Health Department James White, March 4, 1875
  25. ST May 9, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 18 — The Sonship of Christ Dudley Marvin Canright, May 9, 1878
  26. ST May 28, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 22 — Jesus Crucified May 28, 1896
  27. RH Jun 8, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 24 — THE HOPE THAT IS IN YOU A. C. Bourdeau, Third-day, June 8, 1869
  28. ST Apr 12, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 15 — Sunday Not the Sabbath April 12, 1883
  29. ST May 24, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 20 — 3132.— When Our Lord Met with His Disciples H. A., May 24, 1910
  30. ST Feb 23, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 8 — 87—THE LORD'S DAY C.; W. B. D., February 23, 1915
  31. ST Dec 11, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 50 — NOT ALWAYS “FACTS.” December 11, 1901
  32. ST Aug 24, 1888 Signs of the Times, Vol. 14, No. 33 — THE APOSTLES AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK August 24, 1888
  33. ST Jul 1, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 25 — DOCTOR BENSON'S SUNDAY BOOK Dr. Benson; Mark, July 1, 1880
  34. ST Mar 24, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 12 — Question Corner March 24, 1909
  35. ST Sep 26, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 36 — IN THE UPPER CHAMBER Ellen G. White, Fifth-day, September 26, 1878
  36. ST Aug 14, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 40 — DID THE RESURRECTION OF CHRIST AFFECT THE SABBATH? Elder William Covert, Monday, August 14, 1893
  37. RH Nov 15, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 46 — Modern Biblical Criticism and Missions Arthur T. Pierson, November 15, 1906
  38. ST Oct 17, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 39 — SUNDAY NOT THE SABBATH Dudley Marvin Canright, October 17, 1878
  39. ST Feb 20, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 8 — SUNDAY NOT THE SABBATH Dudley Marvin Canright, February 20, 1879
  40. RH Oct 21, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 21 — Evidences of Christianity Moses Hull, Third-Day, October 21, 1862
  41. ST Dec 17, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 50 — SUGGESTIVE QUESTIONS ON THE TEXT December 17, 1896
  42. ST Nov 18, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 44 — Why Should Sunday Be Kept? November 18, 1886
  43. ST Jun 11, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 23 — INTERNATIONAL SUNDAY SCHOOL LESSON June 11, 1896
  44. ST Apr 11, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 15 — LESSON III.—SABBATH, APRIL 21, 1900 April 11, 1900
  45. ST May 19, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 20 — Did Jesus Change the Sabbath? Luella A. Harmon, May 19, 1909
  46. RH Jun 5, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 28, No. 1 — Infidelity and Prophecy Third-Day, June 5, 1866
  47. RH Apr 20, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 16 — A Good Criticism on “The Third Day” W. A. S., Thursday, April 20, 1905
  48. RH Jun 24, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 42, No. 2 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, June 24, 1873
  49. RH Dec 1, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 23 — Prophecy—No. 12 W. H. Baisdell, December 1, 1874
  50. RH Dec 8, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 44, No. 24 — LETTER TO A MOTHER Dudley Marvin Canright, Third-day, December 8, 1874
  51. ST Mar 5, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 10 — 3680 — Questions of the Resurrection and the Bible Editor, March 5, 1912
  52. ST Mar 13, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 11 — THE PARTING OF THE WAYS The writer of the article, March 13, 1907
  53. RH May 11, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 24 — The Resurrection James Denney, May 11, 1916
  54. ST Oct 20, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 41 — Conditions in the Nominal Christian World George W. Rice, October 20, 1909
  55. ST Apr 28, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 17 — Suggestive Notes April 28, 1909
  56. ST May 30, 1895 Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 21 — LESSON XI.—SUNDAY, JUNE 16, 1895 May 30, 1895
  57. RH Apr 8, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 41, No. 17 — For Those Who Desire the Truth D. H. Lawson, April 8, 1873
  58. RH Oct 7, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 19 — Evidences of Christianity Moses Hull, Third-Day, October 7, 1862
  59. ST Aug 17, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 35 — Is the Soul Immortal?—No. 5 C. W. Stone, August 17, 1876
  60. RH Apr 4, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 37, No. 16 — Terrible Results from Believing in the Literal Destruction of Sinners John Matteson, April 4, 1871
  61. ST Jan 28, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 14 — The Saints' Inheritance J. N. Loughborough, January 28, 1875
  62. RH Jun 25, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 2 — REMARKS Third-day, June 25, 1872
  63. RH Jun 25, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 5 — PERSONALITY OF GOD Third-Day, June 25, 1861
  64. RH Oct 7, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 19 — Evidences of Christianity Moses Hull, Third-Day, October 7, 1862
  65. ST Apr 15, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 15 — CHRIST IS COMING AGAIN April 15, 1897
  66. RH Oct 7, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 19 — Evidences of Christianity Moses Hull, Third-Day, October 7, 1862
  67. ST Mar 8, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 10 — JESUS LOCKED OUT H. A. St. John, March 8, 1905
  68. ST Nov 11, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 35, No. 15 — Showers of Blessing H. A. St. John, November 11, 1908
  69. ST Mar 16, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 11 — Constitutional Amendment W. H. Littlejohn, March 16, 1882
  70. ST Nov 18, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 44 — Why Should Sunday Be Kept? November 18, 1886
  71. ST Oct 21, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 41 — The Sabbath Question in Methodism Abbie C. Morrow, October 21, 1897
  72. RH Nov 14, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 22 — EXAMINATION OF T. M. PREBLE'S FIRST-DAY SABBATH John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, November 14, 1871
  73. RH May 5, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 10 — THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK Unknown, Monday, May 5, 1851
  74. ST Aug 6, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 30 — 3819 — The Change of the Sabbath August 6, 1912
  75. ST Sep 10, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 36 — THE SABBATH AND THE SUNDAY September 10, 1896
  76. ST Jul 2, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 34 — CHARACTERISTIC OF SUNDAY ARGUMENT Monday, July 2, 1894

Cross-references 20 of 35

  1. Mark 16:14

    Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.

    Jesus appears to the disciples and rebukes their unbelief.

  2. John 20:19

    Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.

    Records Jesus appearing to the disciples on resurrection evening.

  3. Luke 24:13-35

    And, behold, two of them went that same day to a village called Emmaus, which was from Jerusalem about threescore furlongs.

    fuller Emmaus account behind continued unbelief

  4. Acts 1:3

    To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God:

    Eating gave proof that Jesus was alive after his suffering.

  5. John 21:5

    Then Jesus saith unto them, Children, have ye any meat? They answered him, No.

    The risen Jesus asks the disciples whether they have food, as in Luke’s account.

  6. Acts 10:41

    Not to all the people, but unto witnesses chosen before of God, even to us, who did eat and drink with him after he rose from the dead.

    The risen Jesus ate and drank with chosen witnesses.

  7. John 20:26-29

    And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them: then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.

    Jesus appears to Thomas, who believes after seeing his wounds.

  8. 1 Corinthians 15:5

    And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:

    Both recount appearances of the risen Jesus to his disciples.

  9. Luke 24:30

    And it came to pass, as he sat at meat with them, he took bread, and blessed it, and brake, and gave to them.

    both show risen Jesus eating with disciples

  10. John 20:20

    And when he had so said, he shewed unto them his hands and his side. Then were the disciples glad, when they saw the Lord.

    The disciples rejoice when they see the risen Jesus and his wounds.

  11. Mark 16:12-13

    After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country.

    The disciples hear reports of Jesus’ resurrection but still do not believe.

  12. Luke 24:37

    But they were terrified and affrighted, and supposed that they had seen a spirit.

    The disciples’ startled reaction shows they did not believe Jesus had risen.

  13. Luke 24:1

    Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulchre, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.

    Places the resurrection events on the first day of the week.

  14. Acts 2:31

    He seeing this before spake of the resurrection of Christ, that his soul was not left in hell, neither his flesh did see corruption.

    Christ’s resurrection included his flesh not seeing corruption.

  15. Luke 24:32

    And they said one to another, Did not our heart burn within us, while he talked with us by the way, and while he opened to us the scriptures?

    Jesus’ opening of Scripture stirred the Emmaus disciples’ hearts.

  16. John 20:25

    The other disciples therefore said unto him, We have seen the Lord. But he said unto them, Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the print of the nails, and thrust my hand into his side, I will not believe.

    Thomas doubts the resurrection report and demands tangible evidence.

  17. John 21:1

    After these things Jesus shewed himself again to the disciples at the sea of Tiberias; and on this wise shewed he himself.

    Jesus shows himself again to his disciples after the resurrection.

  18. Luke 24:13

    And, behold, two of them went that same day to a village called Emmaus, which was from Jerusalem about threescore furlongs.

    Describes two disciples traveling to Emmaus that same day.

  19. Luke 24:46-48

    And said unto them, Thus it is written, and thus it behoved Christ to suffer, and to rise from the dead the third day:

    The meal precedes Jesus commissioning the disciples as witnesses to his death and resurrection.

  20. Mark 16:11

    And they, when they had heard that he was alive, and had been seen of her, believed not.

    The disciples disbelieved the report that Jesus was alive.