Numbers 15:33
And they that found him gathering sticks brought him unto Moses and Aaron, and unto all the congregation.
Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
And they that found him gathering sticks brought him to Moses and Aaron, and to all the congregation.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And they that found him gathering sticks brought him unto Moses and Aaron, and unto all the congregation.
and those finding him gathering wood bring him near unto Moses, and unto Aaron, and unto all the company,
And they that found him gathering sticks brought him to Moses and Aaron, and to the whole assembly.
And they who found him gathering sticks, brought him near, unto Moses and unto Aaron and unto all the assembly.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Those who found the man gathering wood brought him to Moses, Aaron, and the whole congregation,
Those who found him gathering sticks brought him to Moses and Aaron, and to all the congregation.
And those who saw him getting sticks took him before Moses and Aaron and all the people.
And they that found him gathering sticks, brought him vnto Moses and to Aaron, and vnto all the Congregation,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
That they brought him to Moses and Aaron and the whole multitude.
Pictures

Cross-references 20 of 28
- Exodus 20:10
But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates:
The command forbids work on the Sabbath, the law the stick-gatherer violated.
- Exodus 31:14-15
Ye shall keep the sabbath therefore; for it is holy unto you: every one that defileth it shall surely be put to death: for whosoever doeth any work therein, that soul shall be cut off from among his people.
Both prescribe death for profaning the Sabbath.
- Exodus 35:2-3
Six days shall work be done, but on the seventh day there shall be to you an holy day, a sabbath of rest to the LORD: whosoever doeth work therein shall be put to death.
The Sabbath law forbids work and kindling fire, carrying a death penalty.
- Matthew 12:11-12
And he said unto them, What man shall there be among you, that shall have one sheep, and if it fall into a pit on the sabbath day, will he not lay hold on it, and lift it out?
Lifting a sheep from a pit is lawful Sabbath work, illustrating mercy and necessity.
- Leviticus 24:11-14
And the Israelitish woman’s son blasphemed the name of the LORD, and cursed. And they brought him unto Moses: (and his mother’s name was Shelomith, the daughter of Dibri, of the tribe of Dan:)
Both cases are held for judgment and resolved by stoning under God's direction.
- Exodus 16:29
See, for that the LORD hath given you the sabbath, therefore he giveth you on the sixth day the bread of two days; abide ye every man in his place, let no man go out of his place on the seventh day.
Israel was forbidden to go out and gather on the seventh day.
- Genesis 2:2-3
And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.
God rested, blessed, and sanctified the seventh day at creation.
- Matthew 12:3-5
But he said unto them, Have ye not read what David did, when he was an hungred, and they that were with him;
Jesus distinguishes blameless acts of necessity from Sabbath-breaking.
- Mark 2:27
And he said unto them, The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath:
Both texts concern Sabbath observance and its purpose for mankind.
- Exodus 35:2
Six days shall work be done, but on the seventh day there shall be to you an holy day, a sabbath of rest to the LORD: whosoever doeth work therein shall be put to death.
Both prescribe death for Sabbath work.
- Exodus 16:23
And he said unto them, This is that which the LORD hath said, To morrow is the rest of the holy sabbath unto the LORD: bake that which ye will bake to day, and seethe that ye will seethe; and that which remaineth over lay up for you to be kept until the morning.
Both forbid cooking on the Sabbath and direct preparation beforehand.
- Exodus 20:8
Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
states the commandment the wilderness act violated
- Leviticus 23:3
Six days shall work be done: but the seventh day is the sabbath of rest, an holy convocation; ye shall do no work therein: it is the sabbath of the LORD in all your dwellings.
The seventh-day Sabbath’s rest is set beside the stick-gatherer’s violation.
- Exodus 31:16
Wherefore the children of Israel shall keep the sabbath, to observe the sabbath throughout their generations, for a perpetual covenant.
The Sabbath is a perpetual covenant, and gathering sticks transgressed it.
- Luke 6:1-5
And it came to pass on the second sabbath after the first, that he went through the corn fields; and his disciples plucked the ears of corn, and did eat, rubbing them in their hands.
Jesus defends his disciples for plucking grain on the Sabbath.
- Isaiah 58:13
If thou turn away thy foot from the sabbath, from doing thy pleasure on my holy day; and call the sabbath a delight, the holy of the LORD, honourable; and shalt honour him, not doing thine own ways, nor finding thine own pleasure, nor speaking thine own words:
Both identify the Sabbath as the Lord’s holy day.
- Exodus 31:15
Six days may work be done; but in the seventh is the sabbath of rest, holy to the LORD: whosoever doeth any work in the sabbath day, he shall surely be put to death.
The Sabbath violation carries a death penalty.
- Exodus 20:11
For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it.
The Sabbath command contrasts with the Sabbath-breaking episode.
- Deuteronomy 5:13
Six days thou shalt labour, and do all thy work:
It restates the six-days-work, seventh-day-rest command.
- Exodus 31:13
Speak thou also unto the children of Israel, saying, Verily my sabbaths ye shall keep: for it is a sign between me and you throughout your generations; that ye may know that I am the LORD that doth sanctify you.
The Sabbath is a sign that God sanctifies his people.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
The verse records a man found gathering sticks or wood on the Sabbath to make a fire, doing unnecessary work against the Lord's commandment, who was wilfully brought before Moses and Aaron and all the congregation and then taken outside the camp, cut off from the people and put to death by stoning.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8Ms 146, 1906, par. 16–28
The gathering was not done in ignorance but in knowing, wilful, high-handed and deliberate rebellion.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–81T 533.1Ms 8, 1866, par. 4Ms 146, 1906, par. 16–28
The Sabbath was made for man, for his benefit.1T 533.1Ms 8, 1866, par. 4
Knowingly working on the seventh day in transgression of the holy commandment is a crime of great magnitude in the sight of Heaven, the offender being deemed unworthy to live, which proves God is very particular regarding observance of His holy law.1T 533.1Ms 8, 1866, par. 4Ms 146, 1906, par. 16–28
Under the Mosaic law that magnitude required the death of the offender, and that death did not end the punishment, for God will not take a transgressor of His law to heaven; the offender must suffer temporal and eternal death, the second death, which is the full and final penalty for transgressing the law of God.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–81T 533.1Ms 8, 1866, par. 4
The same principle of knowing, high-handed breaking applies to violation of the seventh commandment.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8
The civil death penalty by stoning is not now required, but its abolition does not make the sin small.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8Ms 146, 1906, par. 16–28
The verse now requires a strict, thorough course that removes God's frown and curse from the camp by suspending the offender from fellowship and the privileges of the house of God.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8
To treat confession alone as enough and receive the offender lightly corrupts the young, disgraces the cause, and brings God's wrath so He will not dwell in the assemblies.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8
The sin is exceedingly sinful now because God is purifying unto Himself a peculiar people zealous of good works.Ms 3, 1854, par. 3–8
A time is coming when each must answer for every disregard of God's law, leaving a solemn duty to study how to observe the Sabbath of the Lord and to teach others its sacredness.Ms 146, 1906, par. 16–28
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
81 sources
Found gathering wood on the Sabbath in the wilderness, the man was brought to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation, kept in ward until the Lord declared what should be done, then stoned with stones outside the camp by the whole congregation at the Lord's command.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902RH Aug 20, 1857 His gathering was unnecessary common labor, probably for kindling a fire to cook or wash that belonged to the six working days, done openly and without need of health or necessity in deliberate defiance of the fourth commandment.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Jan 8, 1857ST Apr 14, 1898 It was presumptuous sin with a high hand, despising the word of the Lord and showing contempt for the Law-giver, not mere transgression or mistake.ST Sep 26, 1911RH Jan 7, 1862 Death by stoning outside the camp was the temporal civil penalty under the theocratic government, the same as for blasphemy, murder and idolatry, made a notable object lesson for an aggravated offense, yet it was never the full and final penalty, which is eternal death, and under the gospel mercy now pleads for the Sabbath-breaker to repent and live.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902RH May 2, 1854RH Nov 25, 1852ST Apr 30, 1894 The case proves the Sabbath binds a particular appointed seventh day and still forbids doing on the seventh what can be done on the sixth, while works of mercy and necessity and direct labor for God were never forbidden, and though sentence is not now immediately executed, presumptuous breaking will as surely be punished.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Aug 20, 1857RH Feb 14, 1907RH Mar 9, 1869
Setting and Procedure
In the wilderness the man found gathering sticks on the Sabbath was brought to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation, put in ward until God declared what should be done to him, then by the Lord's command stoned with stones outside the camp by the whole congregation.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902RH Aug 20, 1857ST Sep 30, 1886RH Sep 14, 1916 The incident took place under God's rule of Israel and was the only recorded immediate execution for Sabbath-breaking, made a notable example for an aggravated offense so later generations would not hold God's law lightly.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902 His case became a public matter resulting in death as the consequence and penalty administered according to the law for Sabbath-breaking.ST Sep 30, 1886RH Sep 14, 1916
Moses did not decide the case himself, because the required judgment had not been declared, but referred it to the Lord who gave the sentence, showing God and not Moses as lawgiver who received God's words and conveyed them to the people.RH Dec 12, 1854RH May 17, 1864ST Jun 30, 1909 The man was held in custody while the Lord was consulted, and God Himself revealed the true situation and the penalty through His prophets or by Urim and Thummim in the high priest's breastplate.ST Jun 30, 1909 In a true theocracy God alone frames the laws, interprets them and pronounces the penalties while human rulers only enforce what God has given, giving infallible precision so no innocent person suffered and no unjust penalty was administered, a precision no earthly government today possesses.ST Jun 30, 1909 Moses did not take execution into his own hands, and after God ordered the execution the whole congregation was required to carry it out rather than punishment being inflicted immediately by an individual.ST Aug 13, 1902ST Aug 13, 1902
Being brought to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation guaranteed the man a fair trial with no disturbing element entering his judgment.ST Jan 2, 1907 Because his offense created no avenger animated by enmity, revenge, spite or private malice, sympathy toward him could prevail.ST Jan 2, 1907 What the murderer needed cities of refuge to obtain, protection from vengeance until he stood before the congregation in judgment, the Sabbath-breaker already had in being brought before the leaders and congregation for trial.ST Jan 2, 1907
The account does not tell for what purpose he gathered them, whether he intended to use the sticks for a fire or for a fence, and his act is described as carrying dry wood into the camp.RH Nov 25, 1852RH May 2, 1854 Gathering them for a fence would plainly violate the fourth commandment, though the fourth commandment itself does not mention gathering sticks or kindling fires.RH Nov 25, 1852RH May 2, 1854 The fifteenth chapter comes after the murmuring for flesh, the speaking against Moses, and the searching of the land and the reports of the spies, and before the lesson of Korah's rebellion in the sixteenth chapter and God's choice of the house of Aaron in the seventeenth.ST Feb 20, 1912 Even with this strict enforcement ending in stoning to death, the word Sabbath then disappears from the sacred record for about four hundred years afterward, in one reckoning for more than five hundred years.RH Nov 25, 1852RH May 2, 1854
What Gathering Sticks Meant
The sticks were probably gathered to kindle a fire for washing clothes or cooking manna, which was work belonging to the six laboring days because the manna to be eaten on the seventh was commanded to be cooked on the sixth.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857 The account itself does not state for what purpose he gathered them, whether for a fire or for a fence, and gathering them for a fence would plainly violate the fourth commandment.RH Nov 25, 1852RH May 2, 1854 In the wilderness such a fire was unnecessary, for the people were healthy, the climate was mild and warm and demanded no fire, food was rained from heaven, clothes were miraculously preserved, and there was not one feeble person among the tribes.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854ST May 10, 1905 To kindle a fire there was therefore an open violation of the Sabbath law in the fourth commandment, since Sabbath food had already been prepared on the day before.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857ST May 10, 1905
The gathering was not merely picking up fuel for a needed fire but presumptuously pursuing ordinary labor on the Sabbath, gathering timbers for mechanical industry. Stick-gathering in itself has no connection with kindling fires, except as objectors join them to excuse themselves from keeping the commandment. The ban on kindling fires in dwellings on the Sabbath belonged to the desert where fires were not needed for warmth and Sabbath food was cooked on the sixth day, so a fire there could only be for an unlawful purpose. Where fires are needed for warmth, as in Palestine in the cold season, it is right and in harmony with the Sabbath law to kindle them, because the Sabbath was made for man and requires nothing hard or unmerciful.
The act was open, public, deliberate defiance, presumptuous sin of the kind described in Numbers 15:30-31, unlike conduct forced by immediate necessity.RH Jan 8, 1857ST Apr 14, 1898ST Jun 20, 1911ST Dec 3, 1896ST May 25, 1904 It was done without necessity for health or for the sick and feeble, without need of warmth, and not as a fire needed to save life or help the needy.ST Apr 14, 1898ST Jun 20, 1911ST Dec 3, 1896ST May 25, 1904ST May 14, 1896 It was unnecessary common labor, not a work of necessity, of worship, or of direct labor for God, which have ever been in harmony with the Sabbath law, but a work of presumption and defiant rebellion against God.ST Jun 20, 1911ST Dec 3, 1896ST May 25, 1904ST May 14, 1896 Allowing such a serious transgression incurring the death penalty to go unpunished would have undermined the authority of Israel's theocratic law.RH Jan 8, 1857
Gathering food or fuel on the Sabbath counts as forbidden work, on the same order as plucking ears as a kind of reaping and rubbing them with the hands as a kind of grinding or threshing, and preparing food on the Sabbath instead of having all food prepared on Friday before sunset.RH Jul 30, 1861ST Apr 14, 1881 Baking, boiling, frying, and stewing on the Sabbath are all equally forbidden as violations of the command to prepare Sabbath food on the sixth day and to kindle no fire on the Sabbath.RH Jul 30, 1861 To break the Sabbath rather than suffer hunger for a few hours was guilt worthy of stoning, proving how strict the Sabbath commands are.RH Jul 30, 1861ST Apr 14, 1881 The claim that the man was punished because the morning was frosty is rejected, for in the wilderness fire was needed only for tasks that could be done on other days.ST Sep 30, 1886
Presumptuous Defiant Sin
The gathering was presumptuous sin done with a high hand in defiance of the command that no fire be kindled on the Sabbath, despising the word of the Lord, reproaching the Lord, and showing contempt for the Law-giver in despite to the Spirit of grace.ST Sep 26, 1911RH Jan 7, 1862ST May 11, 1891 It was not mere transgression but open, daring, Heaven-defying sin against the fourth commandment.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Feb 21, 1911 The bringing of the stick-gatherer to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation was for judgment of that defiance.ST Sep 26, 1911RH Jan 7, 1862ST May 11, 1891
The putting of the man in ward until the mind of the Lord was declared proves his case did not come under the existing penalty for Sabbath work but required a new decision and special sentence from the Lord.ST Sep 26, 1911RH Jan 7, 1862RH Oct 26, 1911ST May 11, 1891 It was a special case of peculiar guilt and not a general law, directed against presumptuous open defiance done to show disregard for what God had said rather than mere violation of the Sabbath.ST Sep 26, 1911RH Oct 26, 1911ST May 11, 1891ST Dec 17, 1896 The prohibition on fire-building was applicable to the very warm climate through which Israel was then passing where fire was not needed and involved no practical need, but deliberate notorious defiance.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Dec 17, 1896 Israel often broke the Sabbath without this penalty, so the death sentence stands as God's attitude against presumption which wilful breakers of any command will meet in the day of God.RH Oct 26, 1911
The case cannot prove extraordinary strictness in Sabbath-keeping by the Hebrews, for the whole congregation that judged and stoned him were themselves guilty of violating the Sabbath.RH Jan 7, 1862 They had just been excluded from the promised land for that and other sins and continued greatly to pollute the Sabbath through the whole forty years in the wilderness.RH Jan 7, 1862 The man is an example of presumption as confidence without God's word to support it, assuming God would not punish what he considered a small Sabbath violation.ST Apr 19, 1883 He acted defiantly and presumptuously to show that he did not believe the requirements, and his defiant Sabbath-breaking brought death by stoning.ST Apr 19, 1883ST Dec 30, 1913 Standing in direct connection with the law that Israelite and stranger sojourning among them are under one law for sinning through ignorance and for doing ought presumptuously, the gathering illustrates the demerit of presumptuous sins and proves that in the service of the Lord there is no difference between Jews and Gentiles in Sabbath obligation.
Penalty Under Theocracy
Under Israel's theocratic government death by stoning outside the camp was the punishment for Sabbath-breaking.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902ST Apr 30, 1894RH Mar 15, 1864RH Aug 27, 1908 The man found gathering sticks on the Sabbath was brought to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation and put in ward until God declared what should be done, and then by the Lord's command the whole congregation stoned him with stones outside the camp.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902 Moses did not decide the case himself or take execution into his own hands, but God ordered the congregation to participate.ST Aug 13, 1902 This was the only recorded immediate execution for Sabbath-breaking, made an object lesson and notable example for an aggravated, presumptuous offense, so that the congregation then and all later generations would not hold God's law and Sabbath lightly.RH Dec 16, 1915ST Aug 13, 1902RH Sep 2, 1851 Gathering sticks in defiance of what God had said was as much a violation as going out and working all day openly before the congregation.RH Dec 16, 1915
Sabbath-breaking was punished with stoning to death, the same temporal death inflicted for blaspheming the name of the Lord, for murder and for idolatry.RH May 2, 1854RH Nov 25, 1852RH Aug 13, 1857RH Jan 2, 1900 The next recorded stoning after the blasphemy case was inflicted for Sabbath-breaking, proving the Sabbath law stands with moral laws and not with merely positive or ceremonial laws.RH Aug 13, 1857RH Jan 2, 1900 The stoning itself is not commanded in the fourth commandment, for no text changes that penalty from stoning, since the penalty is a detail of enforcement not specified in the Decalogue while the time of the Sabbath and the general manner of its observance specified there remain unchangeable.RH May 2, 1854ST Sep 13, 1905
That putting to death lawfully executes the penalty and does not break the command not to kill.RH Aug 27, 1857RH Aug 27, 1857 The prohibition of killing is the duty of the individual soul, while God as ruler commanded capital punishment to protect the lives and property of the nation, to restrain evil-doers, and to make an example to the young that they might turn from such demoralizing practices. To count such execution as wrong like the transgression itself would leave no law maintainable except through wrong and would make God unrighteous in taking vengeance, so the stoning neither relaxes the Sabbath law nor proves the prohibition of killing to be non-moral, but both laws remain fully binding and moral.RH Aug 27, 1857RH Aug 27, 1857 Contempt for the Sabbath was punished with death because treating God's Sabbath as of no account leads on to idolatry, and idolatry means eternal destruction of many, so in God's wisdom it is better that the one who subverts the whole nation should perish than that the nation should be destroyed. The execution typified the execution of the penalty for sin to be effected by Christ afterward, and the fact that priestly Sabbath labor was instituted before this stoning proves the Sabbath remained in fullest unrelaxed force and no less sacred, with priestly offerings foreshadowing the necessary consequence of transgression rather than relaxing its claims.RH Aug 27, 1857RH Aug 27, 1857
Temporal death was never the full and final penalty for breaking the law of God, which is eternal death, for sin is transgression of the law and the wages of sin is death.RH May 2, 1854RH Oct 28, 1858 The stoning did not pay the moral penalty due his sin or settle his personal account under the ethical code, and his responsibility as a moral agent remained wholly unaffected as with all others stoned for breaking the commandments.RH Oct 28, 1858 If temporal death satisfied the law the sin could not appear against him in the judgment.RH May 2, 1854 His gathering was both gross impiety against God as supreme moral Governor and daring rebellion against God as theocratic King, a public open violation of social and civil law, with a righteous temporal punishment annexed to disobedience under the Mosaic economy no more to pass with impunity than transgression of the law of the land in any well-ordered state today.RH Oct 28, 1858
In the Jewish dispensation there was no atonement that could reach his case, so he was stoned to death and removed from Israel.RH May 2, 1854 Under the gospel the atoning blood of Christ can reach his case, so mercy now pleads that the Sabbath-breaker be spared to turn from his sin, repent, find pardon and live.RH May 2, 1854RH Nov 25, 1852RH Nov 25, 1852 That temporal penalty does not remain in force under the gospel, where mercy allows the transgressor to repent and receive pardon, while the ultimate penalty for sin remains eternal death, showing the gospel covenant as the better covenant far excelling the ministration of condemnation and death.RH May 2, 1854RH Nov 25, 1852RH Nov 25, 1852
The ministration of death by men that fell on breakers of the Sabbath or any other commandment of the Decalogue was done away as part of the handwriting of ordinances nailed to the cross and ended at Christ's death.ST Nov 16, 1876 It belonged to the sanitary or police regulations and civil penalty annexed under the Mosaic economy, adapted to Israel for that people, that time and their wilderness environment, with certain additions, specifications and penalties forming part of the Mosaic civil law now not in force, distinguishable from the Decalogue as the eternal constitution of God's government, while the fourth commandment itself remains as binding as the third and fifth as part of the permanent and universal moral law.ST Nov 18, 1889RH Apr 16, 1872ST Feb 1, 1905RH Mar 17, 1863 Yet profaning the Sabbath still brings death, because the wages of sin is death and sin is transgression of the law of ten commandments, with the only difference now that God will do the work himself instead of entrusting it to sinners, for he that is without sin must first cast the stone.ST Nov 16, 1876 The episode belongs to the law of the theocracy and does not authorize civil governments that are not theocracies to enforce God's law with the death penalty or to enforce Sunday laws.ST Nov 18, 1889RH Mar 17, 1863ST Oct 22, 1894
Sabbath Law Affirmed
The bringing and stoning of the stick-gatherer shows the Sabbath meant a particular appointed seventh day, not merely one seventh portion of time or any day chosen at will.RH Aug 20, 1857RH Feb 14, 1907RH Mar 9, 1869RH Jul 30, 1867 Israel understood the command to require the definite seventh day, and every public enforcement from that first case to the Christian era proceeded on the ground that only keeping the seventh day as holy would answer the demands of the law, which overthrows the one-seventh-part and no-day-in-particular theory.RH Aug 20, 1857RH Mar 9, 1869RH Jul 30, 1867 God gave many evidences of His intention regarding the designated day, and the penalty imposed for disregarding it proves His particularity about the exact day He appointed.RH Feb 14, 1907RH Feb 13, 1913 To set aside His designation is contempt of His court, involving obedience or disobedience to the command of God.RH Feb 14, 1907ST Jul 12, 1905
Treating the particular day as unimportant and thinking it makes no difference had grave consequences, for the man who gathered with that thought paid for his thoughtlessness with his life.RH Feb 14, 1907RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jul 12, 1905 It is a fearful responsibility to attempt to change the commandments and ordinances of God, and to tamper with His law and requirements now is just as unholy when thousands of souls are deciding for eternity.RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jul 12, 1905 Carelessly disregarding His commandments and treating one day as interchangeable with another remains dangerous.RH Feb 14, 1907RH Feb 13, 1913
The Sabbath was binding on God's people in the wilderness during the forty years before Palestine, and the bringing of the worker to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation because his work broke that law proves it was not confined to Jews inside Palestine nor excused by place.ST Sep 29, 1881RH Mar 3, 1863 It was recognized and enforced by the penalty of death from Moses to David, with rigid outward observance then required.RH Nov 4, 1858RH Mar 3, 1863 To call the day of the wilderness incident Sunday would imply the ancient Jews kept Sunday, and changing the Sabbath to the following day would make Monday the Christian Sabbath.ST Sep 27, 1883ST Sep 29, 1881
The law still forbids doing on the seventh what can be done on the sixth and is not really mercy and necessity, and neglect of sixth-day preparation violates it.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857 The sticks were probably for kindling a fire to wash clothes or cook manna, work belonging to the six laboring days because manna for the seventh was commanded to be cooked on the sixth, so gathering for it openly violated the fourth commandment.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857 In the wilderness no Sabbath fire was needed, with mild and warm climate, food rained from heaven, clothes miraculously preserved, and not one feeble person among the tribes.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857 Yet the law did not oblige Jews to suffer cold or hunger and does not so oblige now, for the law is holy, just and good.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Apr 23, 1857
Kindling a fire for warmth in cold weather or preparing proper food in sickness, and building a fire needed for comfort, health, possibly life or to save life and help the needy, is lawful mercy like watering an ox or horse or lifting a sheep from a pit, while refusing it would be mere sacrifice.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Jul 30, 1861ST May 14, 1896 Kindling expressly to cook to keep food warm and indulge appetite remains the same sin as cooking manna, so baking, boiling, frying and stewing on the Sabbath are equally forbidden and plain food cooked on the sixth day is sufficient for all in health.RH Jan 12, 1860RH May 2, 1854RH Jul 30, 1861 Building a fire when unnecessary and in defiance of God was forbidden, but a fire needed to save life or help the needy was not.RH Jul 30, 1861ST May 14, 1896 Priestly Sabbath labor instituted before the stoning proves the law remained in fullest unrelaxed force and no less binding, for priestly offerings did not relax its claims but foreshadowed the necessary consequence of transgression, and the putting to death typified the execution of the penalty to be effected by Christ afterward.RH Aug 27, 1857RH May 12, 1868 Likewise Joshua marching around Jericho by God's appointment, and traveling to the synagogue for holy convocation as obedience and the Lord's work, did not relax the law because they were God's work and only what was lawful, not one's own work or breach of the law.RH Aug 27, 1857RH May 12, 1868
Sabbath-breaking was both gross impiety against God as supreme moral Governor and daring rebellion against God as theocratic King, a public open violation of social and civil law brought for civil judgment under the theocracy.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Nov 4, 1858 Neglecting the Sabbath profanely violated the covenant and rejected God's sovereign authority as Creator and Governor, like idolatry, and stands with slander and unbelief as abhorrent to God.RH Nov 4, 1858RH Feb 24, 1916RH May 23, 1854 The death penalty attached showed how seriously the Lawgiver regards violation and how vital the appointed rest and worship are, for refusing them rejects God in practice.RH Nov 4, 1858RH Feb 24, 1916RH May 23, 1854 The civil penalty was temporary and righteous under the Mosaic economy, no more to pass with impunity than transgression of the law of the land in a well-ordered state today, and its temporariness does not make breaking permissible.RH Oct 28, 1858RH May 23, 1854
Definite observance was possible, so God's requirement is not physically impossible.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Sep 10, 1902 To do any common labor on the seventh required death, while work for God and works of mercy and necessity were never forbidden.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Sep 10, 1902 The death penalty proves how strict the commands are and shows the requirements are not less stringent now, with preparation day still to be kept.RH Jul 30, 1861ST Sep 13, 1905ST Mar 31, 1898 God is long-suffering, not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance, having already given many object lessons, but when sentence is passed judgment will be uniform and parallel with precedent so that violating His holy law is an awful risk.RH Jul 30, 1908ST Mar 31, 1898 Absence of immediate striking dead now no more proves the fourth commandment done away than liars surviving proves lying no sin, as with Ananias and Sapphira.RH Jul 30, 1908ST Feb 7, 1878ST Mar 31, 1898 The objection that renewed seventh-day observance must renew stoning was met and answered, for stoning is a detail of enforcement not specified in Exodus 20:8-11 while the time and general manner of observance specified there remain unchangeable, and no text changes that penalty from stoning.ST Sep 13, 1905RH Oct 3, 1871ST Feb 7, 1878
Warning and Application
The man found gathering sticks on the Sabbath was brought to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation and put in ward until God declared what should be done to him, and by the Lord's command he was surely put to death by stoning with stones outside the camp, which the congregation did.RH Dec 16, 1915 Under the theocratic government of Israel death by stoning was the punishment for Sabbath-breaking, and God made this man an object lesson so that the congregation then and all later generations would not hold God's law and Sabbath in light regard.RH Dec 16, 1915 Gathering sticks in defiance of what God had said was as much a violation of the Sabbath as going out and working all day openly before the congregation.RH Dec 16, 1915 His work was not a work of necessity, of worship, or of direct labor for God, which have ever been in harmony with the Sabbath law, but a work of presumption and defiant rebellion against God.ST Jun 20, 1911ST May 25, 1904 Such presumptuous Sabbath-breaking will as surely be punished now as it was punished in the wilderness.ST Jun 20, 1911ST May 25, 1904
The execution illustrates what will come to all the disobedient by and by when final rewards and penalties are executed, for sin is sin in whatever age committed and will meet its certain end.ST Sep 8, 1909 Because sentence is not now immediately executed it is no less certain.ST Sep 8, 1909 The death penalty is not now executed because God has already given many object lessons and is long-suffering, not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance and obedience.ST Mar 31, 1898 When sentence is passed and judgment is executed His decisions will be uniform and parallel with the precedent already established, so to violate God's holy law is an awful risk.ST Mar 31, 1898
Though gathering only a few sticks looked like a very little sin, in God's sight it was serious, and God said he should surely be put to death.RH Sep 4, 1860 No sin is small because every sin is against an infinite God and displeases the best Friend who sent His Son to die that sinners might have life, and the wages of every sin is death.RH Sep 4, 1860 Boldness in little sins encourages greater sins, as the Devil tempts from one degree of sin to another, which warns against committing little sins such as vain and idle words and worldly conversation, especially on the holy Sabbath.RH Sep 4, 1860 God required literal observance of the Sabbath and treated gathering sticks on that day as disobedience, requiring obedience and treating disregard for His command as serious.ST Mar 19, 1885RH Feb 26, 1914 The death penalty attached to this deliberate breaking showed how seriously the Lawgiver regarded Sabbath-breaking and proves how vital the Sabbath is to God's work.ST Sep 8, 1909RH May 23, 1854
The civil penalty was temporary and does not make Sabbath-breaking permissible, for the Sabbath command remains binding, and refusing its appointed rest and worship rejects God in practice.RH May 23, 1854 People being put to death for refusing to regard the Sabbath shows the same seriousness.ST May 15, 1884 His case occurred after violating a law already in force before the ministration associated with Moses had begun, showing the law was not null without that ministration.RH Mar 29, 1864 His guilt as Sabbath-breaking sin under God's law could not be erased by later abolition of that ministration.RH Aug 22, 1865 Israel's exclusion from the promised land resulted from unbelief, in contrast with God's commanded punishment for breaking the Sabbath.
The incident does not itself state the Sabbath law, which is given in Exodus 20:8-11.ST Nov 18, 1889 It records a willful Sabbath violation punished by death under the Jewish theocracy, where the Mosaic law prescribed death for that offense.ST Nov 18, 1889ST Oct 26, 1904 That death penalty was a legal consequence under that theocracy, not a requirement for keeping the moral precept today.ST Nov 18, 1889 The case is thus used to contrast that Mosaic Sabbath penalty with the claimed observance of the first day as a day of rest and worship.RH Jan 8, 1867
Further points
The verse stands within the law given for sin committed in ignorance.ST Apr 26, 1883 Ignorance does not make sin cease to be sin.ST Apr 26, 1883 When the sin becomes known, the person is guilty and must make the required offering to be forgiven.ST Apr 26, 1883
Sources