Numbers 20:4
And why have ye brought up the congregation of the LORD into this wilderness, that we and our cattle should die there?
Translations
And why have you brought up the congregation of the LORD into this wilderness, that we and our cattle should die there?
And why have ye brought up the congregation of the LORD into this wilderness, that we and our cattle should die there?
And why have ye brought up the congregation of the Lord into this wilderness, that we and our cattle should die there?
And why have ye brought the congregation of the LORD into this wilderness, that we and our cattle should die there?
And why have ye brought the assembly of the LORD into this wilderness, that we should die there, we and our cattle?
And why have ye brought the assembly of Jehovah into this wilderness, that we should die there, we and our beasts?
and why have ye brought in the assembly of Jehovah unto this wilderness to die there, we and our beasts?
And why have ye brought the congregation of Jehovah into this wilderness, that we should die there, we and our beasts?
Wherefore then hast thou brought the convocation of Yahweh into this desert,—to die there, we, and our cattle?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Why have you brought the LORD’s assembly into this wilderness for us and our livestock to die here?
Why have you brought the LORD’s assembly into this wilderness, that we should die there, we and our animals?
Why have you taken the Lord's people into this waste, for death to come to us and to our cattle there?
Why haue ye thus brought the Congregation of the Lord vnto his wildernesse, that both we, and our cattell should die there?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Why have you brought out the church of the Lord into the wilderness, that both we and our cattle should die?
Cross-references
- Numbers 20:12
And the LORD spake unto Moses and Aaron, Because ye believed me not, to sanctify me in the eyes of the children of Israel, therefore ye shall not bring this congregation into the land which I have given them.
Moses and Aaron are judged for failing to honor God before Israel.
- Numbers 20:10-11
And Moses and Aaron gathered the congregation together before the rock, and he said unto them, Hear now, ye rebels; must we fetch you water out of this rock?
Moses answers the people’s water complaint in anger and strikes the rock.
- Numbers 20:8
Take the rod, and gather thou the assembly together, thou, and Aaron thy brother, and speak ye unto the rock before their eyes; and it shall give forth his water, and thou shalt bring forth to them water out of the rock: so thou shalt give the congregation and their beasts drink.
God answers the complaint by commanding Moses to bring water from the rock.
- Exodus 17:1-7
And all the congregation of the children of Israel journeyed from the wilderness of Sin, after their journeys, according to the commandment of the LORD, and pitched in Rephidim: and there was no water for the people to drink.
God had earlier provided water from a rock when Israel murmured in the wilderness.
- Numbers 20:11
And Moses lifted up his hand, and with his rod he smote the rock twice: and the water came out abundantly, and the congregation drank, and their beasts also.
Water came from the rock despite the congregation’s complaint.
- Psalms 106:33
Because they provoked his spirit, so that he spake unadvisedly with his lips.
Israel’s provocation led Moses to speak rashly.
- Numbers 21:5
And the people spake against God, and against Moses, Wherefore have ye brought us up out of Egypt to die in the wilderness? for there is no bread, neither is there any water; and our soul loatheth this light bread.
Israel again complains that God brought them into the wilderness to die.
- Numbers 14:2-3
And all the children of Israel murmured against Moses and against Aaron: and the whole congregation said unto them, Would God that we had died in the land of Egypt! or would God we had died in this wilderness!
The complaint repeats the earlier generation’s distrust and rebellion at Canaan’s borders.
- Deuteronomy 34:4-5
And the LORD said unto him, This is the land which I sware unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto Jacob, saying, I will give it unto thy seed: I have caused thee to see it with thine eyes, but thou shalt not go over thither.
Moses sees the promised land but dies without entering it.
- Numbers 14:29-30
Your carcases shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me,
Only Caleb and Joshua among the adults who left Egypt reached the promised land.
- Numbers 20:14-21
And Moses sent messengers from Kadesh unto the king of Edom, Thus saith thy brother Israel, Thou knowest all the travail that hath befallen us:
Edom refuses Israel passage through its land.
- Exodus 20:1-2
And God spake all these words, saying,
shows God truly brought them out
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
22 sources
Thirsty and finding no water in a barren place with no seed or figs or vines or pomegranates, the people angrily accused Moses and Aaron of bringing the congregation of the Lord with their cattle and children into the wilderness to kill them, even wishing they had died with Korah, Dathan and Abiram.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14Lt 188, 1903, par. 36–40Ms 65, 1906, par. 25–30SG4 38.1–21SP 309.2–3 This happened at Kadesh near Edom on the borders of the promised land, when Israel was brought a second time to the same proving place after nearly forty years of wandering, and God had caused the long-flowing water from the rock to cease to prove whether they would trust His providence and walk by faith instead of by sight.Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–21SP 309.2–3RH Dec 31, 1903SG1 41.1–42.1 Their complaint showed forgetfulness of years of deliverance and provision, failure to keep God in view as their leader and turn to Him for help, and a repetition of the unbelief and murmuring of their fathers and the previous generation.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14Lt 188, 1903, par. 36–40Ms 65, 1906, par. 25–30Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–2 Though directed against Moses and Aaron, the murmuring was in truth against God and against Christ their invisible leader, whose work it was, so that accusing the leaders grieved and dishonored God and sinned against His providence.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873 God brings His people into strait places and then delivers them to exhibit His power and be glorified and to soften hearts to repentance, but Moses and Aaron sinned by taking the murmurings as personal dishonor, answering in wrath and taking to themselves the glory belonging to God, so the Lord was displeased and said they should not enter the promised land, and though God gave water the people's unbelief kept them from passing through Edom as intended.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1PP 424.2PP 428.1–2
Setting and Complaint
The complaint was made at Kadesh near Edom on the borders of the promised land, just before entering Canaan, when Israel had been brought a second time to the very place where they had first been proved soon after leaving Egypt, after nearly forty years of wandering.1SP 309.2–3FE 508.5–509.41SP 309.1 The water God had brought out of the rock had continued to flow for years until just before they came again to the rock, when the Lord caused that living stream to cease.1SP 309.2–31SP 309.1 God brought the people into this strait place of no water to prove them again, to see whether they would endure the trial of faith, trust His providence, believe His promise, and walk by faith instead of by sight.1SP 309.2–3RH Dec 31, 1903FE 508.5–509.41SP 309.1PP 413.3–4
Thirsty and finding no water, the people became impatient and did not remember God's power in giving water before.SG4 38.1–21SP 309.2–3 Instead of turning to God for help they angrily and impatiently accused Moses and Aaron, their appointed leaders, of bringing up the congregation of the LORD with their cattle and children into the wilderness to die there and to kill them.Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–2SG4 38.1–21SP 309.2–3SG1 41.1–42.1 Their charge that the leaders had brought them out to perish was directed against Moses and Aaron, while the work was God's and not Moses'.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14Lt 188, 1903, par. 36–40Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17
They called the place evil because it lacked food and water, with no seed or figs or vines or pomegranates and no water to drink.Ms 65, 1906, par. 25–301SP 309.2–3 In desperate murmuring they wished they had died with those destroyed in the rebellion of Korah, Dathan and Abiram.SG4 38.1–21SP 309.2–3
Unbelief and Its Results
The cry that Moses and Aaron had brought the congregation and their cattle into the wilderness to die showed that Israel had forgotten God's years of providing for them, of deliverance, and of power in giving water from the rock before.Lt 188, 1903, par. 36–40Ms 65, 1906, par. 25–30Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–2SG4 38.1–2 They failed to keep God in view as their leader, and instead of trusting Him and turning to Him for help when tested by the ceasing of the supply, they murmured against Him and treated lack of water as proof they would perish.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14Lt 188, 1903, par. 36–40Ms 65, 1906, par. 25–30Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–2 In this they repeated the unbelief and murmuring of their fathers and the previous generation, showing the same impatient, distrustful, unthankful and rebellious spirit instead of believing His promise.Ms 9, 1903, par. 10–17PP 414.1–2ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 31, 1903 God had permitted the lack just before entering Canaan to prove whether they would trust His providence and walk by faith, but they forgot the One who had supplied their wants for so many years.SG4 38.1–2ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 31, 1903
Though spoken against Moses and Aaron, their appointed leaders, the murmuring was in truth against God and against Christ, their invisible leader.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.110MR 151.3PP 418.3 The work was God's, not Moses', and God alone deserved the glory, so in accusing the leaders the people grieved, dishonored and insulted God, insulting their best Friend and sinning against His providence.Ms 8, 1886, par. 11–14SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1 It was transgression against Christ, and Christ was the one offended who suffered most intensely as the one who would bear their iniquities.10MR 151.3PP 418.3 God often brings His people into strait places and then delivers them in their necessity to exhibit His power, that it may live in their memory and He may be glorified by them.SG1 41.1–42.1EW 132.3–133.1 He does so that they may realize His love and care and be led to serve and honor Him, and the lack of water was a merciful opportunity to sanctify the Lord before the people and show His long-suffering and tender pity to soften hearts and lead to repentance.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1
Moses and Aaron sinned in connection with the complaint by taking the murmurings personally as a trial and dishonor to themselves.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1 Made keenly sorrowful by continual waywardness, Moses for a little forgot how much God had borne with the people, thought only of self and personal wrong and ingratitude for his deep love, answered in wrath and claimed the power of opening the rock.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1 Thereby he took to himself the glory belonging to God and failed to honor and magnify Him before Israel that they might glorify God.SG1 41.1–42.1RH Jul 29, 1873EW 132.3–133.1 Satan stirred up the worst passions of Israel to murmur and rebel until Moses lost command of himself, and Moses was surprised into sin without premeditation.SG1 41.1–42.110MR 159.3–6 By appropriating God's glory he transgressed God's law and placed himself on Satan's side and under Satan's power, and the LORD was displeased and said he should not enter the promised land.SG1 41.1–42.1EW 132.3–133.110MR 159.3–6Lt 39, 1880, par. 1–2
Moses was wearied by the forty years wandering, and for a moment his faith let go its hold upon infinite power and failed just upon the borders of the promised land.10MR 151.3Ms 15, 1908, par. 6 This shows that Satan assails in the time of greatest weakness to prevail, gaining the victory when strength fails and will power weakens and faith ceases to repose in God, so that even those who have stood long and valiantly for the right can be overcome.Ms 15, 1908, par. 610MR 159.3–6 Israel's murmuring sin was their own and not caused by Moses, though their murmuring led him to deviate from the right and commit that excluding sin, and though Moses felt he had caused them to sin and mourned his own sin that kept him out.10MR 151.310MR 159.3–6 God gave water in answer to their clamors, but their unbelief and discontent kept them from passing through Edom as He had intended.PP 424.2PP 428.1–2 They therefore had to cross the desert again and drink from the miraculous spring when trust would have made it unnecessary, for their own murmuring brought the hardship of the journey around Edom instead of gratitude for His care.PP 424.2PP 428.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
18 sources
The verse records Israel's complaint at Kadesh, near the borders of Canaan, when finding no water they feared that they and their cattle would die in the wilderness.STST May 27, 1889ST Mar 4, 1913 They charged Moses and Aaron with bringing the congregation up out of Egypt into the wilderness to die there.ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889ST May 27, 1889 That accusation against their appointed leaders was in truth against God Himself, murmuring at His providence and denying His deliverance.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889 The complaint showed unbelief, distrust and impatience, forgetting His long provision and past deliverances and failing to trust Him to supply their need.ST Sep 30, 1880STRH Dec 9, 1909 Moses and Aaron sinned in connection with it by taking the murmuring as dishonor to themselves and failing to sanctify the Lord before the people, so Moses was not permitted to enter the promised land, showing that God judges impartially without favorites.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jan 12, 1869ST Jun 17, 1889ST Sep 17, 1902
Wilderness Complaint at Kadesh
The complaint was made at Kadesh, when the congregation found no water in the wilderness and feared that they and their cattle would die there.ST Sep 30, 1880STST May 27, 1889ST Mar 4, 1913RH Dec 9, 1909 They stood then near the borders of Canaan, yet their murmuring showed unbelief.ST Their angry charge, impatience, distrust, murmuring and faultfinding showed lack of trust in God, forgetting His long provision of water and His past deliverances and repeating the unbelief and murmuring of the earlier generation.ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 9, 1909
The people charged Moses and Aaron with bringing up the congregation of the LORD into the wilderness to die with their cattle, accusing Moses of leading them there.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889ST May 27, 1889ST Oct 1, 1902 They blamed Moses and Aaron for bringing them out of Egypt, when God Himself had brought them out of the land of Egypt out of the house of bondage.ST May 27, 1889 That murmuring was equivalent to a denial that God had anything to do with their wonderful deliverance, for the accusation against Moses and through him was against God despite His care for them.ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889 When the water supply failed they quickly forgot God's past deliverance and provision and turned from trust in Him to blame and unbelief.ST Apr 7, 1898 In accusing their appointed leaders they were grieving God, sinning against Him and dishonoring Him, insulting their best Friend and murmuring at His providence.RH Jul 29, 1873
The verse belongs to the narrative of Numbers 20 and 21, which records Miriam's death and Israel's journeying around Edom and the enemies they met on the way.ST Feb 20, 1912 The same chapter recounts Edom's refusal to let Israel pass through its land, linked to the lasting hostility between the descendants of Jacob and Esau.ST Oct 1, 1902 The lack of water came when the stream that had supplied them for years ceased to flow just before they entered Canaan.RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906 God permitted the lack on the borders of the promised land to prove whether they would trust His providence and believe His promise or imitate the unbelief of their fathers, as a test for them to show belief and to walk by faith instead of by sight.RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906 Instead of turning to God for help they forgot the One who had supplied their wants for so many years and murmured against Him, directing their cry against Moses and Aaron as if the leaders had brought the congregation and their cattle into the wilderness to die.RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906ST Apr 7, 1898
Unbelief Against God Himself
The complaint that Moses had brought the congregation and their cattle into the wilderness to die was in truth an accusation against God through His appointed leaders despite all His care.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889 In charging Moses and Aaron the people grieved God and sinned against Him, dishonoring Him, insulting their best Friend, and murmuring at His providence.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889 To blame Moses and Aaron for bringing them out of Egypt was to deny that God Himself had brought them out of the land of Egypt out of the house of bondage and had anything to do with their wonderful deliverance.ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 27, 1889
The outcry at Kadesh when no water was found showed impatience and distrust of God, unbelief and murmuring and faultfinding, though Israel stood near the borders of Canaan.ST Sep 30, 1880STRH Dec 9, 1909 They forgot the One who had supplied their wants for so many years, forgetting His long provision of water and His past deliverances and provision.ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906ST Apr 7, 1898RH Dec 9, 1909 Instead of turning to God for help they directed their cry against Moses and Aaron, failing the test God permitted when the stream that had supplied them for years ceased to flow just before they entered Canaan to prove whether they would trust His providence and believe His promise.ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906 That failure was a walking by sight instead of by faith, repeating and imitating the unbelief and murmuring of their fathers, the earlier generation.ST Sep 30, 1880RH Dec 31, 1903RH Aug 23, 1906
The murmuring arose from restrictions and fears about what they would eat and drink, with appetite overruling reason and leading to rebellion.ST Jun 10, 1875 Its consequence after repeated failures was forty years of wandering, of which only two of the adults who left Egypt reached the promised land.ST Jun 10, 1875 The speech accusing Moses of bringing up the congregation of the LORD to die there with their cattle was rebellious, foolish speech. Such speech must not be answered in a foolish manner lest the answerer become like the fool, yet it provoked Moses to do so when he spoke unadvisedly with his lips and called them rebels, and by that answer became too much like those he opposed.
Judgment Warning and Provision
The murmuring over lack of water became the occasion of sin for Moses and Aaron themselves, for they took the complaints as personal trial and dishonor to themselves rather than as sin against God.RH Jul 29, 1873 Instead of using the need as a merciful opportunity to sanctify the Lord before the people, they claimed in effect the power of opening the rock themselves.RH Jul 29, 1873 By this failure to show His long-suffering and tender pity in a way that would soften hearts and lead to repentance, they did not give God glory as the provider of the water.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Sep 17, 1902 For that failure Moses was not permitted to enter the promised land, showing that even he depended on God and that the welfare of the people required them to recognize their dependence on Him.ST Sep 17, 1902
The judgment on him teaches that God's commands are holy and that He judges impartially and strictly.RH Jan 12, 1869ST Jun 17, 1889 He shows no favorites, so that even one especially near to God is not excused when acting wrongly in His presence.RH Jan 12, 1869 The greater the nearness to God, the greater the responsibility to act reverently.RH Jan 12, 1869 Outward provocation does not excuse sin, whose root is in the human heart.ST Jun 17, 1889
The water that then sprang forth in copious streams to quench perishing thirst pictures the water of life obtained by searching the Scriptures.RH Dec 7, 1916 It springs forth responsive to the touch of faith.RH Dec 7, 1916 It need not be drawn to the surface by a bucket bound with creeds and traditions.RH Dec 7, 1916
Sources