AdventAI

1 Samuel 8:20

That we also may be like all the nations; and that our king may judge us, and go out before us, and fight our battles.

King James Version

Translations

Pictures

Samuel Hears the Elders Ask for a King (1 Samuel 8:20)
Samuel Hears the Elders Ask for a King AI-generated · by emmanuel_higgins

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

25 sources

Israel would not be turned from warning but fixedly insisted on a human king to be like all the nations, to judge them and go out before them and fight their battles.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21
The demand was not a rejection of Samuel the man but a rejection of God that He should not reign over them, throwing off His wise rule as King.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21EDFCP 23.1
They had grown weary of being ruled by pious rulers who kept God's will and honor before them, and in pride and loss of faith blamed their weakness on their form of government instead of on their sins, wanting royal splendor, centralized human leadership and military skill to bring prosperity and esteem among the nations.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11SG4 66.1
Though God had repeatedly gone before them, fought for them and raised up deliverers, they no longer trusted His invisible guidance and sufficiency to defend and give victory, and disregarded their distinct privilege as His specially chosen people under His theocracy to copy heathen nations that did not know Him.ST Jul 13, 1882SG4 65.41SP 353.26T 249.4–250.2
God therefore permitted them to have their own way and granted the desire of their unsanctified hearts, yet their prosperity still depended on obedience, and the same folly is repeated whenever His work is carried on by unsanctified human judgment and trust in men for outward show instead of humble dependence on His rule.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–156T 249.4–250.2EDFCP 23.1ST Jul 13, 1882

Demand and Its Motives

Israel would not obey warning but fixedly insisted on having a human king to be like all the nations, to judge them and go out before them and fight their battles.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15ST Jul 13, 1882 The demand was a deliberate decision by their own voice to discard Samuel before God had released him and to choose human rule instead of remaining under God's jurisdiction, management and control.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31PP 604.2 It came from leaving first love, from spiritual blindness, and from not knowing the blessing and safety of being led and controlled by the Lord in all ways.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21

The elders' stated complaint about Samuel's sons did not reflect their real motive but served as a pretext.PP 604.2 The demand was driven by discontent and pride in a deliberate effort to set Samuel aside.PP 604.2 They had grown tired and weary of being ruled by pious rulers who kept God's will, ways, purposes and honor before them.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21 They wanted a reformed religion and rule that would bring external prosperity, riches and splendor, royal appearance, personal courage and military skill, so they would be esteemed great and display outward greatness before the world and not be looked down on and despised by surrounding nations.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24 It was in their own mind and judgment the way that would bring the most glory to themselves as a nation, hankering after riches and splendor like other nations as they had once hankered after the leeks and onions of Egypt.Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Their wish to be like the nations meant disregarding the privilege and blessing of belonging to God as His specially chosen and distinct people in order to follow the example of heathen nations that did not know or acknowledge God.ST Jul 13, 1882Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11PP 607.1 Renouncing divine theocracy for likeness to others exchanged humble dependence on God and His Holy Spirit for outward show and worldly, fashionable influence.Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24

They wrongly blamed their troubles and weakness on their form of government and lack of kingly authority instead of on their sins that had led God to leave them vulnerable to enemies.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11SG4 66.1ST Jul 13, 1882 They thought a king and visible, centralized human leadership embodied in a man would end envy, jealousy and strife among the tribes, provide military defense and leadership of armies, and carry responsibility to provide funds, manage enterprises and solve problems for them.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11SG4 66.1ST Jul 13, 1882Ms 106, 1899 The demand showed lack of faith and confidence in God's providence, care and sufficiency to rule, provide rulers, defend and give victory through invisible guidance and power that had already led them and given success in battle.SG4 65.41SP 353.26T 249.4–250.2 He had repeatedly heard their cry when they cried to Him, gone before them, fought for them, raised up rulers and deliverers to deliver them, and worked in unseen ways giving wisdom, power, deliverance and success that enemies could not explain and that gave no glory to human wisdom or agency, as when deliverance came through Gideon.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11SG4 66.1 They chose instead a temporal ruler and misplaced confidence in a human ruler to judge, lead and fight for them rather than trusting God as their Divine Helper and special leader.SG4 65.41SP 353.2ST Jul 27, 1882

Rejection of Divine Rule

The demand was not against Samuel as a man but against God Himself, that He should not reign over them, throwing off His wise jurisdiction, management and control as King and dishonoring Him to His face.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21EDFCP 23.1Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 It was dissatisfaction not with the prophet but with divine authority, choosing a pleasing temporal ruler embodied in a man instead of remaining satisfied with God as Ruler who had governed through wise men waiting on Him for counsel.Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21EDFCP 23.1Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 That invisible guidance had already given wisdom, power, deliverance, victory and success in ways enemies could not explain, giving no glory to human wisdom or agency, as in the deliverance through Gideon.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11SC 38.1–2

It came from leaving first love and from not knowing the blessing and safety of being led and controlled by the Lord in all ways.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31 It came from spiritual blindness in which the people thought Samuel did not understand their circumstances, motives, designs and advantages and did not discern God's word speaking through him.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 It revealed lack of sacred reverent fear of God as Supreme Ruler, putting authority in human power to be controlled by it.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 It continued the rebellion that left their fathers' bodies in the wilderness after coming out of Egypt, in forsaking God to serve other gods.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21

They carried out their own purposes and judgment in the face of solemn protest from one they knew to be God's prophet, bewitched by Satan working on their hearts to follow his counsel.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21 Their minds were bent on following their own judgment and casting aside the wisdom of God for the way that in their own mind would bring most glory to themselves as a nation.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Pride kept them from retracting after plain warning of the sure results of a king's rule.EDFCP 23.1Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11

Israel's distinct status as God's specially chosen people under divine theocracy was disregarded in order to copy heathen nations that did not know or acknowledge God.ST Jul 13, 18821SP 353.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 Their government was meant to be distinct, with God choosing its leaders and guiding the people through His laws, prophets and counsel, and with Jehovah Himself going before them and fighting for them so that turning back to Him after sin brought deliverers and safety.1SP 353.2PP 614.4 By demanding likeness to others they renounced humble dependence on God and His Holy Spirit for outward show and worldly, fashionable influence, exchanging dependence on His invisible guidance and sufficiency for visible human leadership and strength from men.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24

God plainly told them through Samuel that the way was wrong and not the right and best way, having him protest solemnly and show them the manner of the king that would reign over them, yet they refused to be changed.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 The demand was persisted in after warning, so the Lord permitted them to have their own way and granted the desire of their unsanctified hearts, giving the demanded king in anger.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15EDFCP 23.1ST Jul 13, 1882 He showed His displeasure by thunder and lightning and hail, and royal pomp came with tyranny and exaction as a bitter exchange for His mild and beneficent rule.EDFCP 23.1ST Jul 13, 1882

The decision shows how little confidence can be placed in finite human beings whose hearts are not daily and hourly under the sanctifying, subduing influence of the Spirit of God and controlled by His love and fear.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21

Consequences and Present Warning

The king Israel received mirrored their own desires and lack of submission, for they valued royal appearance, personal courage and military skill above justice, character and reverence for God.SG4 65.4PP 636.1 Such a monarch might receive the honor due to God and lead the people away from Him, and unless he continually trusted God for wisdom his rule could exalt the unworthy and make the innocent suffer.SG4 65.4PP 636.1 Royal pomp came with tyranny and exaction, a bitter exchange for God's mild and beneficent rule.SG4 65.4ST Jul 13, 1882 Saul's example under that rule helped spread irreligion and godlessness, and after Samuel's death the people recognized that rejecting godly leadership had brought harmful consequences.PP 636.1PP 663.1–2

By rebelling against God's counsel they left His merciful guidance for the rule of men secure in their own way and judgment, bringing afterward distress that heeded counsel would have prevented.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29ST Jul 27, 1882PP 614.4 Although God granted the request, their prosperity still depended on obedience to Him.ST Jul 27, 1882PP 614.4 Asking for a king was an evil added to all their other sins, an ingratitude that oppressed their souls and severed them from God, and it had to be definitely confessed by name before they found peace.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29SC 38.1–2 They would learn their error and return to allegiance to God, a return recognized after Samuel's death.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29PP 636.1PP 663.1–2 That choice is connected with the later destruction of Jerusalem and dispersion of the nation, for seeking strength from visible human leadership instead of trusting God's invisible guidance, power and sufficiency dishonors God and weakens His people.6T 249.4–250.2Ms 169, 1899, par. 24

The same course is repeated whenever God's work is carried on by unsanctified human judgment and worldly plans and policy in order to be recognized by the world, laying plans God never purposed and separating the work from His rule.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 61, 1890, par. 184MR 69.2 It renounces divine theocracy for likeness to others, exchanging humble dependence on God and His Holy Spirit for outward show and worldly, fashionable influence in an attempt to raise self that instead lowers influence, dulls spiritual discernment and imperils the cause of God.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24Ms 61, 1890, par. 18 The same disposition appears when a man insists on independence and a self-sufficient mind to control churches and institutions, claiming prerogative through money and putting himself where God has not placed him, becoming a channel of darkness unless he becomes little in his own sight and walks humbly for guidance.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31EDFCP 23.1 It appears also when organizations and their members look to a president or central committee to provide funds, manage enterprises and solve their problems, as though wanting a king to fight for them.EDFCP 23.1Ms 106, 1899 That same folly will be repeated among God's people today unless there is greater humility, less confidence in self and more trust in God, for only as divine power is combined with human effort will the work abide the test, with less talking and much more praying, meekness of spirit, caution in plans and movements, revealed dependence on God and the mind of Christ.EDFCP 23.1Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24Ms 61, 1890, par. 18

Sources

  1. Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 53, 1890 Ellen G. White, written December 19–30, 1890
  2. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 40a, 1890 Ellen G. White, written November 3, 1890
  3. Ms 40, 1890, par. 16–21 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 40, 1890 Ellen G. White, written March 1891
  4. EDFCP 23.1 Elder Daniels and the Fresno Church - Pamphlet — Elder Daniels and the Fresno Church. Ellen G. White, 1890
  5. Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 40, 1890 Ellen G. White, written March 1891
  6. Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 5 (1887-1888) — Lt 12a, 1888 Ellen G. White, written March 1888
  7. SG4 66.1 Spiritual Gifts Volume Four — CHAPTER XXXIII. Ellen G. White, 1864
  8. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  9. SG4 65.4 Spiritual Gifts Volume Four — CHAPTER XXXIII. Ellen G. White, 1864
  10. 1SP 353.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume One — CHAPTER XXXIII. Ellen G. White, 1870
  11. 6T 249.4–250.2 Testimonies for the Church Volume Six — RESPONSIBILITIES OF MEDICAL WORKERS. Ellen G. White, 1901
  12. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  13. PP 604.2 Patriarchs and Prophets — THE FIRST KING OF ISRAEL—59 Ellen G. White, 1890
  14. Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Lt 9, 1901 Ellen G. White, written January 18, 1901
  15. PP 607.1 Patriarchs and Prophets — THE FIRST KING OF ISRAEL—59 Ellen G. White, 1890
  16. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  17. Ms 106, 1899 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 106, 1899 Ellen G. White Estate, written July 26, 1899
  18. ST Jul 27, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 28 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 27, 1882
  19. SC 38.1–2 Steps to Christ — Confession Ellen G. White, 1908
  20. PP 614.4 Patriarchs and Prophets — THE FIRST KING OF ISRAEL—59 Ellen G. White, 1890
  21. PP 636.1 Patriarchs and Prophets — SAUL REJECTED—61 Ellen G. White, 1890
  22. PP 663.1–2 Patriarchs and Prophets — THE MAGNANIMITY OF DAVID—65 Ellen G. White, 1890
  23. Ms 169, 1899, par. 24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 169, 1899 Ellen G. White, written December 22, 1899
  24. Ms 61, 1890, par. 18 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 61, 1890 Ellen G. White, written 1890
  25. 4MR 69.2 Manuscript Releases, vol. 4 [Nos. 210-259] — MR No. 214—Materials Relating to Seventh-day Adventists and Their Institutions and Confederacies and Labor Unions Ellen G. White, 1990

Pioneers and periodicals

53 sources

Israel firmly demanded a visible human king to rule over them, lead them out, and fight their battles for them just as the kings of the surrounding nations did.GSAM 46.1RH Jan 28, 1902 In asking for that king they did not merely reject Samuel, but rejected the Lord Himself that He should not reign over them.GSAM 46.1RH Jan 28, 1902RH Mar 25, 1875 They did so in order to be like all the nations and be reckoned among them, instead of remaining separate as His specially chosen people with God alone as King, Ruler, and Lawgiver.ST Jul 13, 1882RH Mar 16, 1916ST Aug 23, 1899 God granted their demand in anger after solemn warning, and the human kingship they received brought tyranny, exaction, and war in place of His mild and beneficent rule.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901 That choice to be formed into a State like the nations was itself a union of church and state, exchanging self-government under divine law for government of men by men under human law.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899RH May 26, 1904ST Apr 17, 1901

Words and Historical Setting

Israel settled on having a visible human king to be like the kings of surrounding nations, a king who would judge them and go out before them and fight their battles.GSAM 46.1RH Jan 28, 1902RH Apr 24, 1900ST Jun 30, 1909 Samuel had to yield his leadership to that popular insistence, though the request ran contrary to God's will.ST Jun 30, 1909 The demand was for a visible ruler to lead and to fight in place of unseen divine rule.RH Apr 24, 1900ST Jun 30, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895

To judge in this demand means more than deciding a case, for it denotes royal authority to rule and govern and protect, to uphold law and punish wrongdoing.RH Apr 25, 1871 The people wanted such a ruler because hostile peoples in Canaan were oppressing them and Samuel was not a warrior.ST Jul 22, 1889 They reasoned that a ruler using their enemies' tactics would help defeat those foes.ST Jul 22, 1889

They had grown dissatisfied with government by judges and wanted to be like all the nations.ST May 31, 1899 They blamed their troubles on that form of government despite God's repeated deliverances, grew weary of His rule, and refused His counsel.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882 They thought kingly rule would restrain disorder and end the envy and jealousy and strife among the tribes.ST Jul 13, 1882RH May 26, 1904

God had chosen to govern through judges appointed by Him whose authority came directly from Heaven.ST Sep 20, 1883 That course was taken partly because rulers with great power are in danger of pride and tyrannical treatment of others.ST Sep 20, 1883 The demand gave up that distinct rule by judges for a single great ruler like surrounding peoples, celebrated as national greatness after military victory abroad.

Saul fulfilled the outward ideal of the desired leader as a strong and capable man impressive in appearance.ST Oct 13, 1881ST Jul 29, 1889 He was a man of the people's own choice rather than God's choice, pointed out to be their king.RH Mar 31, 1874 He reigned over them forty years.RH Mar 31, 1874 He proved to be a hard master as warned, and reliance on him did not give courage when Goliath challenged Saul and his army, for they were afraid.ST Oct 13, 1881ST Jul 29, 1889

The demand marks the foundation of the monarchy, organized under Saul and established under David.ST Feb 13, 1901RH Mar 25, 1875 It ended the pure theocracy in which God ruled directly, a rule possible only where the people follow Him implicitly.ST Oct 24, 1895 The request would never have been made if the people had been in right relation to God, and it proved their spiritual vision was failing because they had lost sight of God as they should have seen Him.ST Oct 24, 1895 God had foreseen that surrounding influence would lead them to apostatize and make this call, and Samuel declared this decline and its result as the Lord directed at a time when national worship had been greatly restored.ST Oct 24, 1895

Though God consented to the change, He remained supreme ruler over king and people and kept the right to choose the king Himself, a right all tacitly acknowledged.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895 He did not change the principles of the theocracy in this respect, and He even directed His prophets to anoint kings, some of whom were very bad.ST Nov 29, 1883ST Jun 30, 1909 The verse also fits the possibility of a king eventually being given with God's sanction, not as a tyrant but as a representative of the Messianic office.ST Jul 22, 1889

Rejection of Divine Rule

By demanding a human king to judge, lead, and fight for them so they could be like other nations, Israel rejected the Lord as its ruler and refused His voice spoken through Samuel.GSAM 46.1RH Jan 28, 1902ST May 31, 1899ST Nov 9, 1882RH Aug 14, 1856 They had not rejected Samuel but had rejected God that He should not reign over them, breaking His covenant to be His people and obey His voice.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 God told Samuel to hearken to the people's voice after solemnly protesting and showing them the manner of the king who would reign, and He gave them a king in anger and took him away in wrath.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 God retained the right to choose Israel's king Himself even in granting the request.ST Nov 9, 1882

This was Israel's first formal rejection of God as King in seeking to imitate other nations, falling short of the high calling to be distinct and exalted under His rule.RH Jan 28, 1902 Their demand rejected Samuel's offer to lead them and rejected the government of God as administered by Samuel.ST Jul 27, 1882ST Jun 13, 1906 The people exchanged a pious prophet whose prayers brought blessings for a king whose blind zeal brought a curse upon them.ST Aug 17, 1882 God did not reject His people in giving the king they desired, but continued to work toward His purpose for them on condition that they obeyed Him and kept His commandments, so that their prosperity still depended on obedience to Him.ST Jul 27, 1882RH Jan 28, 1902

The demand was only the outward sign of inward apostasy, because the people had already become inwardly like surrounding peoples and would not govern themselves by God's law.ST Apr 17, 1901 It was therefore natural and even necessary in their condition to have a human government suited to them, with recognized human authority to give human law by which they could be governed when they would not govern themselves.ST Apr 17, 1901 The insistence was complete rejection of God and His law for an earthly king and earthly law, open rebellion against God.ST Apr 17, 1901 That apostasy followed easy, natural steps from doubt and questioning to positive unbelief, to failure in self-government under the divine law, to utter rejection of that law as the rule of life, to open idolatry in some form, to monarchy.ST Apr 17, 1901 It was rooted in the rise of a generation that did not know the Lord nor His works for Israel and forsook Him and served Baal and Ashtaroth.ST Apr 17, 1901

Having failed in faith and loyalty to God as their only King, Ruler, and Lawgiver and fallen into apostasy and idolatry, Israel blamed the resulting oppression and raids on the government of God as a failure. In unbelief they concluded they needed a strong central government to maintain standing among the nations and to be freed from the rule of their divine Sovereign, with hearts fully set on being like the nations even after solemn warning. This repeated the fall of Babylon, Assyria, and Egypt, where the deceiver led from forgetting God into idolatry and from idolatry into monarchy to gain supremacy over them and turn them from the service of God. The demand grew out of idolatry and the evil ways of the heathen, and entering national politics and departing from the order God had established led to worship of false gods and ruin, until God forsook Israel as both church and nation.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Jan 27, 1904

Choosing a human king meant losing the conditions that called for faith in God alone as King.ST Mar 31, 1909 It lost sight of God's purpose for them to live by faith, receive God's life within, and be different from the nations so God's light could shine through them, dimming their witness and bringing defeat.ST Apr 2, 1902 Dissatisfied with dependence on Him, they forsook God as their king and looked to a human king for protection and guidance, patterning themselves after nations that had long forgotten God.ST Feb 27, 1901 They wanted a visible human ruler to lead and fight for them instead of trusting God as their Divine Helper and remaining in communion with Him, and misplaced confidence in outward appearance brought only fear before Goliath's challenge and, with the king, oppression and long and bloody wars.ST Jul 27, 1882ST Feb 27, 1901ST Oct 13, 1881

Likeness to the Nations

Israel asked for a human king in order to resemble the nations around them and to be reckoned among those nations.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Dec 24, 1903RH Apr 2, 1908RH Jan 28, 1902 That was a refusal to accept their distinct and exalted place as God's specially chosen people and peculiar treasure, separated from every other people to dwell alone with God as their only King and Ruler and Lawgiver and government.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899RH Jan 28, 1902 Instead of remaining unreckoned among the nations, they chose to be like all the nations and to be counted with them by joining themselves to the State and making religion a matter of State and government in union with the State.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 God's purpose was that by obedience they should teach the nations His goodness and reveal Him to the world as He really is, but that choice kept Him from doing so.ST Apr 2, 1902ST Aug 23, 1899 It was Israel's first formal rejection of God as King, yet He did not reject His people but gave them the king they desired and continued to work toward His purpose for them on condition that they obeyed Him and kept His commandments.RH Jan 28, 1902

To be unlike other nations in having God as King was itself the blessing, a high honor and special privilege.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Aug 23, 1899 They disregarded that privilege and blessing and eagerly sought to follow the example of the heathen and to imitate their practices.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Aug 23, 1899 The same longing to conform to worldly customs and practices still exists among the professed people of God, springing from departing from the Lord and becoming ambitious for the gains and honors of the world.ST Aug 23, 1899 It constantly seeks to imitate those who worship the god of this world, even urging that by uniting with worldlings and conforming to their customs a stronger influence might be exerted over the ungodly.ST Aug 23, 1899 The same willingness to be joined to the State and to be like the nations continues in His professed people and the church in all the world today, and the same course is followed directly by the professed churches, the young people's societies and leagues of Christian Endeavor, and all the combined church elements.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899

By seeking to imitate those nations they sank below them and became despised among the nations.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Dec 24, 1903 In losing sight of God's purpose for them to live by faith, to receive His life within, and to be different so that His light could shine through them, their witness was dimmed and they suffered defeat and could no longer serve as a light and example to other peoples.RH Mar 16, 1916ST Apr 2, 1902 They not only became like the nations around them but later did worse than the heathen. Having obtained the king they demanded, they became like those nations, and their kings copied heathen customs, for the demand was not part of God's plan.RH Apr 2, 1908 Their later insistence on Caesar is a continued rejection of the Lord as king.ST May 14, 1902

Results of Human Kingship

God commanded Samuel to listen to the people's voice, but only after solemnly protesting and setting before them the manner of the king who would reign over them.RH Mar 25, 1875 Samuel's warning of the consequences was intended to turn them from their error to reliance on the Lord's freely given grace, yet they refused to heed it.RH Mar 25, 1875RH Jul 20, 1911 God would not permit the earthly king He allowed them to have to lead His chosen people in the way of other nations.RH Jul 20, 1911

He let the people have their way and gave them a king, but He gave in anger and took away in wrath.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 Royal pomp arrived together with tyranny and exaction, a bitter exchange for God's mild and beneficent rule.ST Jul 13, 1882 With that king came oppression and long and bloody wars, showing that disloyalty brings suffering and death to all who follow Satan's way.ST Feb 27, 1901 They had forsaken God as king to look to a human king for protection and guidance, patterning themselves after nations that had long forgotten God instead of remaining a peculiar people set as His example to the world.ST Feb 27, 1901

Having a king was a permitted departure from the Creator's design rather than what God originally wanted.ST Nov 29, 1883 It was granted as a concession in the same way permission was given to eat flesh, and both permissions were followed by punishment, with the shortening of human life after flesh-eating began matching the evil results that followed the granting of a king.RH Oct 28, 1873 Even so, God directed His prophets to anoint kings, some of whom were very bad.ST Nov 29, 1883

The demand stands as the voice of the people set against the voice of God.ST May 31, 1899 It shows that the majority can oppose God and be wrong on a moral question.ST Sep 9, 1889 The demand itself was wrong, driven by pride and willfulness, and it cost greater blessings they could have received from God.ST Jul 22, 1889 Insisting on things God is not ready to give can shut people off from influences that would bring greater spiritual benefit, and persisting in demanding what God had not granted brought disaster.ST Jul 22, 1889RH Jan 29, 1914 The people afterward saw that wanting a king in order to be like the surrounding nations and have a ruler lead and fight for them had been a mistake.ST Oct 19, 1888

Confidence in the human king proved worthless for defense.ST Aug 3, 1882 Although Saul looked like the kind of leader people choose by outward appearance, reliance on him did not give Israel courage, so they were afraid when Goliath challenged Saul and his army.ST Oct 13, 1881 Their later fear and flight before the Philistines likewise exposed how worthless that confidence was.ST Aug 3, 1882 The king expected to defend them could bring only weakness, failure, and loss.RH Jun 29, 1916 Israel prospered only while its king obeyed the Lord, but when king and people followed their own ways the nation was led into trouble.ST Oct 17, 1916 That path, begun by rejecting God as the true King despite His warning, ended in Jerusalem's destruction and captivity.RH Jun 29, 1916

Government Church and State

The cry to be like all the nations with a king to lead and fight completes the change from theocracy to monarchy, where theocracy is self-government by aid of the divine law and monarchy is government of men by their fellow men under human law.ST Apr 17, 1901 The people supposed kingly rule would restrain disorder, but the change that was needed was in their own self-government, not in the system of rule by judges.RH May 26, 1904 That change came by easy and natural steps, from doubt and questioning to positive unbelief, to failure in self-government under the divine law, to utter rejection of that law as the rule of life, to open idolatry in some form, to monarchy.ST Apr 17, 1901 The demand carries in itself the natural and even necessary use of force to compel performance of what the governor conceives to be duty, which is why even the most conscientious rulers become persecutors while enforcing what seems to them plain moral duty.ST Apr 17, 1901 Israel's demand and the later perversion of the true idea of government display the consequences of rejecting His plan of self-government, or the reign of conscience.ST Apr 17, 1901

Wanting to be like all the nations and to be reckoned among the nations meant wanting a human king and making religion a matter of State and government in union with the State.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 Since Israel was the church and all the nations were States, becoming like them required forming itself into a State, and forming the church into a State was in itself forming a union of church and state.ST Aug 23, 1899 Because this was done contrary to plain declaration and solemn protest, any such union is against plain declaration and solemn protest.ST Aug 23, 1899 Refusing to dwell alone and to remain unreckoned among the nations by joining to the State in a union of religion and the State is rejecting God that He should not reign.ST Aug 23, 1899 That same course is followed by the professed churches, the young people's societies and leagues of Christian Endeavor, and all the combined church elements.ST Aug 23, 1899 Seeking civil government to do work for which it was not ordained, to lead and fight battles like the kings of other nations, is asking for another king and shows loss of connection with the supreme power.ST Jul 30, 1894

Prophecy Fulfilment and Present Warning

The cry to be like all the nations is evidence that rule was transferred from God's direct heavenly rule to an earthly king.RH Jan 26, 1860 The kingdom given in answer to that demand was organized under Saul and established under David, and in some respects it was made a type of the kingdom of God soon to be established under the seed of David, the Lord Jesus Christ.RH Mar 25, 1875 God later used the universal empire under Solomon, established altogether by peace and ruled only by the peace, wisdom, and righteousness of God, to demonstrate what He would have done for the world through Israel if they had stayed loyal to Him in peace, wisdom, and righteousness instead of taking that course.ST Jan 27, 1904 Even in the apostasy that brought kingships He made it a witness to all nations of what He was still ready, willing, and anxious to do if those kings would recognize Him and serve Him in holiness of heart.ST Jan 27, 1904

Forsaking God to be like the surrounding nations brings affliction, and the present hopeless, persecuted, scapegoat condition of the Jews in Europe and America is a very literal fulfilment of the Lord's word concerning that choice.ST Oct 31, 1900 Therefore the Zionist movement must fail in its national aim of restoring Jewish nationality.ST Oct 31, 1900 The hope of the Jews is not return to Palestine but return to the God of hosts, belief in the prophecies relating to Christ, and recognition of His work as their only means of salvation.ST Oct 31, 1900

The same desire to become like the nations in America breaks her bonds of peace, brings her down from splendid providential isolation and elevation of strength as the wonder of the world and the cynosure of liberty to the oppressed, and launches her upon the great troublous sea of international strife. It works the undoing of the Republic, so that the Republic still exists in name but empire is here. That same desire appears when a people drifts uncontrollably away from the principles on which its future was staked, losing republican simplicity while keeping only the outward forms of the republic. The military spirit gains ground, fame goes to unauthorized acts of war rather than to adherence to principle, and the whole trend is toward intermingling in the complications of the powers and involvement in the great battles of the last days.

The demand is repeated when the people of the West make John Ambitus, the commander who drove out the governors of Prince Diabolus and subdued the Land of the Sunrising, ruler over them all, ending the time when judges ruled the land. They rejoice that they now have a king like all the nations, giving up distinct government by judges for a single great ruler like surrounding peoples, celebrated as national greatness after military victory abroad. The same course is followed directly by the professed churches of God, the young people's societies and leagues of Christian Endeavor, and all the combined church elements of the land, in wanting to be reckoned among the nations by joining to the State in a union of religion and the State.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 That same willingness to be joined to the State and be like the nations continues in His professed people and the church in all the world today, refusing God's purpose for them to dwell alone with God as their only King, Ruler, Lawgiver and government and to teach the nations His goodness by obedience.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899

That choice kept God from revealing Himself to the world as He really is.ST Aug 23, 1899 The same longing to conform to worldly customs and practices still exists among the professed people of God.ST Aug 23, 1899 It comes from departing from the Lord, becoming ambitious for the gains and honors of the world, and constantly seeking to imitate the practices of those who worship the god of this world.ST Aug 23, 1899 It even urges that by uniting with worldlings and conforming to their customs they might exert a stronger influence over the ungodly.ST Aug 23, 1899

Sources

  1. GSAM 46.1 The Great Second Advent Movement — *CHAPTER II* John N. Loughborough, 1905
  2. RH Jan 28, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 4 — ELDER A. T. ROBINSON A. T. Robinson, Tuesday, January 28, 1902
  3. RH Mar 25, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 13 — Thy Kingdom Come Roby Tuttle, March 25, 1875
  4. RH Mar 16, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 14 — A. T. ROBINSON A. T. ROBINSON, March 16, 1916
  5. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  6. ST Aug 23, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 34 — LIKE ALL THE NATIONS Alonzo T. Jones, August 23, 1899
  7. ST May 31, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 22 — VOX POPULI VOX DEI W. N. Glenn, May 31, 1899
  8. ST Feb 27, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 9 — THE GUERDON OF DISLOYALTY C. M. Snow, February 27, 1901
  9. ST Aug 23, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 34 — LIKE ALL THE NATIONS Alonzo T. Jones, August 23, 1899
  10. RH May 26, 1904 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 81, No. 21 — Not the Wrong System F. D. Starr, May 26, 1904
  11. ST Apr 17, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 16 — WE WILL HAVE A KING OVER US C. P. Bollman, April 17, 1901
  12. RH Apr 24, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 17 — READ AND LOAN Alonzo T. Jones, April 24, 1900
  13. ST Jun 30, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 25 — The Theocracy of Israel George E. Langdon, June 30, 1909
  14. ST Oct 24, 1895 Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 42 — International Sunday School Lessons October 24, 1895
  15. RH Apr 25, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 37, No. 19 — The Judgment Dr. Cumming, April 25, 1871
  16. ST Jul 22, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 28 — Notes on the International Lesson J. W. Scoles, July 22, 1889
  17. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  18. ST Jul 13, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 26 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 13, 1882
  19. ST Sep 20, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 35 — Saul and David John Nevins Andrews, September 20, 1883
  20. ST Oct 13, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 39 — CONSISTENT CHRISTIANS Dwight Lyman Moody, October 13, 1881
  21. ST Jul 29, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 29 — Notes on the International Lesson J. W. Scoles, July 29, 1889
  22. RH Mar 31, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 43, No. 16 — BRIEF HISTORIC VIEW OF THE KINGDOM Joseph H. Waggoner, March 31, 1874
  23. ST Feb 13, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 7 — BOOK NOTICES February 13, 1901
  24. RH Mar 25, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 13 — Thy Kingdom Come Roby Tuttle, March 25, 1875
  25. ST Nov 29, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 45 — Temperance W. N. Glenn, November 29, 1883
  26. ST Nov 9, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 42 — The Kingdom of God Editor, November 9, 1882
  27. RH Aug 14, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 15 — THE KINGDOM OF GOD.—No. 2. James White, August 14, 1856
  28. RH Jan 28, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 4 — ELDER A. T. ROBINSON A. T. Robinson, Tuesday, January 28, 1902
  29. ST Jul 27, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 28 — General Articles Ellen G. White, July 27, 1882
  30. ST Jun 13, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 23 — TO OBEY IS BETTER THAN SACRIFICE G., June 13, 1906
  31. ST Aug 17, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 31 — General Articles Ellen G. White, August 17, 1882
  32. ST Apr 17, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 16 — WE WILL HAVE A KING OVER US C. P. Bollman, April 17, 1901
  33. ST Jul 29, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 29 — THE CHURCH AND POLITICS.[^1] E. W. Whitney, July 29, 1897
  34. ST Jan 27, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 4 — History of Government Alonzo Trevier Jones, January 27, 1904
  35. ST Mar 31, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 13 — OUR BIBLE BAND March 31, 1909
  36. ST Apr 2, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 14 — A LIGHT-FILLED RELIGION Edison Driver, April 2, 1902
  37. RH Dec 24, 1903 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 80, No. 51 — Synopsis of Sabbath-School Lessons for Quarter Ending December 31 A. T. Robinson, Thursday, December 24, 1903
  38. RH Apr 2, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 14 — ***Contrasts and Counterfeits — No. 4*** C. M. S., April 2, 1908
  39. ST Aug 23, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 34 — LIKE ALL THE NATIONS Alonzo T. Jones, August 23, 1899
  40. ST Aug 23, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 34 — LIKE ALL THE NATIONS Alonzo T. Jones, August 23, 1899
  41. ST May 14, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 20 — ARCH OF TITUS F. C. Gilbert, May 14, 1902
  42. RH Jul 20, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 29 — Its Intervening Support John O. Corliss, July 20, 1911
  43. RH Oct 28, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 20 — Twenty-four Reasons for Being a Vegetarian, October 28, 1873
  44. ST Sep 9, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 35 — MINORITIES E. P. Marvin, September 9, 1889
  45. ST Jul 22, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 28 — Notes on the International Lesson J. W. Scoles, July 22, 1889
  46. RH Jan 29, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 5 — Power From the Wrong Source C. M. S., January 29, 1914
  47. ST Oct 19, 1888 Signs of the Times, Vol. 14, No. 40 — THE DEATH OF SAMUEL Ellen G. White, October 19, 1888
  48. ST Aug 3, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 29 — General Articles Ellen G. White, August 3, 1882
  49. RH Jun 29, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 32 — No King but Jesus J. S. Washburn, June 29, 1916
  50. ST Oct 17, 1916 Signs of the Times, Vol. 43, No. 41 — An Acknowledgment of Weakness Taylor G. Bunch, October 17, 1916
  51. ST Jul 30, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 38 — The Domain of Religion and That of Civil Governments H. F. Phelps, Monday, July 30, 1894
  52. RH Jan 26, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 10 — THE SETTING UP OF GOD'S EVERLASTING KINGDOM Fifth-Day, January 26, 1860
  53. ST Oct 31, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 44 — THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT L. A. P., October 31, 1900

Cross-references 20 of 27

  1. 1 Samuel 8:7

    And the LORD said unto Samuel, Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee: for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.

    God identifies Israel’s demand for a king as rejection of his rule.

  2. 1 Samuel 8:5

    And said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.

    Israel asks for a king to judge them like the other nations.

  3. Hosea 13:11

    I gave thee a king in mine anger, and took him away in my wrath.

    God gave Israel a king in anger after they demanded one.

  4. 1 Samuel 12:12

    And when ye saw that Nahash the king of the children of Ammon came against you, ye said unto me, Nay; but a king shall reign over us: when the LORD your God was your king.

    Israel demanded a king when threatened, despite the Lord being their king.

  5. Numbers 23:9

    For from the top of the rocks I see him, and from the hills I behold him: lo, the people shall dwell alone, and shall not be reckoned among the nations.

    Israel’s calling to dwell apart contrasts with its desire to be like the nations.

  6. John 19:15

    But they cried out, Away with him, away with him, crucify him. Pilate saith unto them, Shall I crucify your King? The chief priests answered, We have no king but Cæsar.

    Israel rejects its King, declaring allegiance to Caesar instead.

  7. 1 Samuel 10:19

    And ye have this day rejected your God, who himself saved you out of all your adversities and your tribulations; and ye have said unto him, Nay, but set a king over us. Now therefore present yourselves before the LORD by your tribes, and by your thousands.

    Demanding a king meant rejecting God as King.

  8. 1 Samuel 8:9

    Now therefore hearken unto their voice: howbeit yet protest solemnly unto them, and shew them the manner of the king that shall reign over them.

    God commands a solemn protest showing the manner of king they will have.

  9. Deuteronomy 17:14

    When thou art come unto the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee, and shalt possess it, and shalt dwell therein, and shalt say, I will set a king over me, like as all the nations that are about me;

    foretold request to be like nations

  10. 1 Samuel 12:13

    Now therefore behold the king whom ye have chosen, and whom ye have desired! and, behold, the LORD hath set a king over you.

    Samuel identifies Saul as the king Israel chose and desired.

  11. 1 Samuel 12:19

    And all the people said unto Samuel, Pray for thy servants unto the LORD thy God, that we die not: for we have added unto all our sins this evil, to ask us a king.

    confession that named asking for a king

  12. 1 Samuel 9:17

    And when Samuel saw Saul, the LORD said unto him, Behold the man whom I spake to thee of! this same shall reign over my people.

    God identifies Saul as the man who will rule Israel.

  13. 1 Samuel 12:17-18

    Is it not wheat harvest to day? I will call unto the LORD, and he shall send thunder and rain; that ye may perceive and see that your wickedness is great, which ye have done in the sight of the LORD, in asking you a king.

    Thunder and rain showed the LORD’s displeasure at Israel’s demand for a king.

  14. Judges 21:25

    In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes.

    Israel’s desire for a king contrasts with the disorder when there was no king.

  15. 1 Samuel 10:24

    And Samuel said to all the people, See ye him whom the LORD hath chosen, that there is none like him among all the people? And all the people shouted, and said, God save the king.

    Saul is chosen and acclaimed as Israel’s king.

  16. 1 Samuel 13:14

    But now thy kingdom shall not continue: the LORD hath sought him a man after his own heart, and the LORD hath commanded him to be captain over his people, because thou hast not kept that which the LORD commanded thee.

    Saul fails to obey God, contrasting with a king guided by him.

  17. Jeremiah 23:5

    Behold, the days come, saith the LORD, that I will raise unto David a righteous Branch, and a King shall reign and prosper, and shall execute judgment and justice in the earth.

    The promised king reigns and executes judgment and justice.

  18. 1 Samuel 9:2

    And he had a son, whose name was Saul, a choice young man, and a goodly: and there was not among the children of Israel a goodlier person than he: from his shoulders and upward he was higher than any of the people.

    Saul is chosen as the king the people desired.

  19. Judges 17:6

    In those days there was no king in Israel, but every man did that which was right in his own eyes.

    Both describe Israel’s desire for a king amid the absence of centralized rule.

  20. 1 Samuel 8:3

    And his sons walked not in his ways, but turned aside after lucre, and took bribes, and perverted judgment.

    Corrupt judges gave occasion for the demand for a king.