1 Samuel 8:5
And said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
Translations
And said to him, Behold, you are old, and your sons walk not in your ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
And said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
and said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
And said to him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
and they said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.
and say unto him, 'Lo, thou hast become aged, and thy sons have not walked in thy ways; now, appoint to us a king, to judge us, like all the nations.'
and said to him, Behold, thou art become old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now appoint us a king to judge us, like all the nations.
and said unto him—Lo! thou, art old, and, thy sons, walk not in thy ways: Now, appoint for us a king to judge us, like all the nations.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Look,” they said, “ you are old, and your sons do not walk in your ways. Now appoint a king to judge us like all the other nations.”
They said to him, “ Behold, you are old, and your sons don’t walk in your ways. Now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.”
And said to him, See now, you are old, and your sons do not go in your ways: give us a king now to be our judge, so that we may be like the other nations.
And said vnto him, Beholde, thou art olde, and thy sonnes walke not in thy wayes: make vs nowe a King to iudge vs like all nations.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And they said to him: Behold thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: make us a king, to judge us, as all nations have.
Pictures

Cross-references 20 of 28
- 1 Samuel 8:20
That we also may be like all the nations; and that our king may judge us, and go out before us, and fight our battles.
Israel wants a king to judge and lead them in battle, like other nations.
- Hosea 13:11
I gave thee a king in mine anger, and took him away in my wrath.
God gave Israel a king in anger after they demanded one.
- John 19:15
But they cried out, Away with him, away with him, crucify him. Pilate saith unto them, Shall I crucify your King? The chief priests answered, We have no king but Cæsar.
Israel’s demand for a human king culminates in rejecting Christ for Caesar.
- 1 Samuel 12:17-18
Is it not wheat harvest to day? I will call unto the LORD, and he shall send thunder and rain; that ye may perceive and see that your wickedness is great, which ye have done in the sight of the LORD, in asking you a king.
The thunder and rain showed God’s displeasure with Israel’s demand for a king.
- 1 Samuel 8:9
Now therefore hearken unto their voice: howbeit yet protest solemnly unto them, and shew them the manner of the king that shall reign over them.
God tells Samuel to protest and warn them about the king they request.
- Deuteronomy 17:14
When thou art come unto the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee, and shalt possess it, and shalt dwell therein, and shalt say, I will set a king over me, like as all the nations that are about me;
Foretells Israel’s request for a king like the surrounding nations.
- 1 Samuel 8:11-18
And he said, This will be the manner of the king that shall reign over you: He will take your sons, and appoint them for himself, for his chariots, and to be his horsemen; and some shall run before his chariots.
Samuel warns of the oppressive consequences of the people’s demand for a king.
- 1 Samuel 10:19
And ye have this day rejected your God, who himself saved you out of all your adversities and your tribulations; and ye have said unto him, Nay, but set a king over us. Now therefore present yourselves before the LORD by your tribes, and by your thousands.
Asking for a king was rejecting God as ruler.
- 1 Samuel 12:12-13
And when ye saw that Nahash the king of the children of Ammon came against you, ye said unto me, Nay; but a king shall reign over us: when the LORD your God was your king.
Samuel recalls Israel’s demand for a king and identifies Saul as the king they chose.
- 1 Samuel 8:22
And the LORD said to Samuel, Hearken unto their voice, and make them a king. And Samuel said unto the men of Israel, Go ye every man unto his city.
God directs Samuel to grant the people’s request for a king.
- 1 Samuel 9:2
And he had a son, whose name was Saul, a choice young man, and a goodly: and there was not among the children of Israel a goodlier person than he: from his shoulders and upward he was higher than any of the people.
Saul’s exceptional height fits the stature people favored in a king.
- Isaiah 9:6-7
For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace.
Promises an everlasting ruler on David’s throne who judges with justice.
- 1 Kings 12:1-20
And Rehoboam went to Shechem: for all Israel were come to Shechem to make him king.
Recounts Israel’s division after the people demand a king and reject Rehoboam’s rule.
- 1 Samuel 12:19
And all the people said unto Samuel, Pray for thy servants unto the LORD thy God, that we die not: for we have added unto all our sins this evil, to ask us a king.
Israel confesses that asking for a king added to their sins.
- 1 Samuel 10:24-27
And Samuel said to all the people, See ye him whom the LORD hath chosen, that there is none like him among all the people? And all the people shouted, and said, God save the king.
The people acclaim Saul, while some reject the king God appointed.
- 1 Samuel 8:18
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the LORD will not hear you in that day.
warns of unanswered crying under the chosen king
- Judges 21:25
In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes.
Both describe Israel’s disorder amid the absence of a king.
- Judges 17:6
In those days there was no king in Israel, but every man did that which was right in his own eyes.
Both describe Israel’s lack of a king.
- John 6:15
When Jesus therefore perceived that they would come and take him by force, to make him a king, he departed again into a mountain himself alone.
Israel seeks a human king, while the crowd would make Jesus king for food.
- Judges 8:23
And Gideon said unto them, I will not rule over you, neither shall my son rule over you: the LORD shall rule over you.
Gideon says the Lord, not a human ruler, will rule Israel.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
35 sources
The elders asked Samuel to appoint a king to govern them like the surrounding nations, giving as their reason that he was old and his sons did not follow his ways.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15PP 604.2 Their complaint about his sons was largely a pretext for a change long desired from pride and discontent, for they found no fault with Samuel's own rule and were seeking worldly display and standing among the nations rather than correction of wrongs.PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882 In demanding a visible human king to judge them, lead their armies and unite them under a strong central power, they were rejecting God Himself as their Ruler and Sovereign and not merely setting Samuel aside.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1 The request showed lack of faith in His wisdom, care and power to defend and guide them, choosing seen human strength above His invisible rule and trusting their own judgment instead of His counsel.1SP 353.2SG4 65.46T 249.4–250.2 God therefore let them have their own way after solemn warning, and their choice exchanged His mild and beneficent government for royal pomp, tyranny and distress.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1
Elders' Plea and Motives
The elders came to Samuel with stated grounds that he was old and his sons did not walk in his ways, and on that basis they asked him to appoint a king to govern them like all the nations.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15PP 604.21SP 353.2SG4 65.4 Their demand was to be judged and governed after the pattern of the surrounding nations rather than under the rule God had given them.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–151SP 353.2SG4 65.4ST Jul 13, 1882
His sons had been educated and trained and were well qualified to judge Israel if they had purposed in heart to be true to principle like Daniel in the courts of Babylon, with God to be with them and honor them if they had sought His counsel and honored Him.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Instead they turned aside after lucre and took bribes and perverted judgment, becoming unjust judges through love of money.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Samuel was not to blame for their wrongdoing though he carried a sore and disappointed heart, showing how children by their course can weaken and counteract the best efforts of their parents.Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15
That complaint about age and corrupt judges was a pretext for a change already desired from discontent and pride, not a sudden concern for justice or a sincere effort to correct abuses.PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882 They found no fault with Samuel's own administration, yet he felt the request as censure upon himself and an attempt to set him aside.PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882 Their sons' injustice caused dissatisfaction, but the people were more troubled by threats to their material interests than by the earlier religious corruption of Hophni and Phinehas, and complaints against the sons gave them a pretext for pressing a change they had long wanted.ST Jul 13, 1882 It illustrates how hearts estranged from God may use almost any pretext to disregard His authority to satisfy pride and self-love, even at the cost of His cause and by imitating the world's customs to satisfy ambition.ST Jul 13, 1882
Their real motive was to be like the surrounding nations and to be recognized and esteemed great in the eyes of the world.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31 They were weary of the rule of those who kept before them God's will, God's ways and God's honor, and wanted reformed religion and rule so they might make a great display of external prosperity before the world.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29 God had brought them out of slavery and idolatry in Egypt to keep His law including the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and to preserve a peculiar, holy character to represent Him under His own rule, but in this demand they set that distinction aside.ST Feb 17, 1898 They treated that distinct way of life as unwelcome instead of a privilege and blessing, exchanging the simplicity and self-restraint needed for their highest development and for God's plan of their education for the pomp and self-indulgence of heathen peoples.ED 49.1 As they adopted their neighbors' customs they lost reverence for God and pride in being His chosen people, despite His purpose that they remain a distinct people devoted to His service.PP 603.3RH Jul 23, 1901
They wanted divine rule made visible in a man, a human king they could see to judge them and to lead their armies, instead of being satisfied to have God for ruler ruling through wise men who waited upon Him for counsel.Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 They desired to unite under a strong central government and wrongly thought a king would restore harmony among tribes weakened by jealousy and tribal conflict and left exposed to enemies.ST Jul 13, 1882PP 603.3 The demand sought worldly power, plans and policy and blamed their government for troubles instead of relying on God's invisible power and unseen wisdom which had led them, guided and delivered them and given them victory.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11
Rejecting God's Rule Answered
In asking for a king who pleased them, Israel refused to be satisfied with God as Ruler governing through wise men who waited upon Him for counsel. Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24 The demand discarded Samuel before God had released him, and in doing so dishonored the Lord God of Israel, for they had rejected not Samuel but God that He should not reign over them as divine Ruler and Sovereign. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1
That act continued the rebellion carried on since He brought them up out of Egypt, when they forsook Him and served other gods and left their fathers' bodies in the wilderness. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Their minds were bent on following their own judgment and casting aside God's judgment, revealing that they had left first love to follow worldly policy and human judgment in spiritual blindness that refuses His jurisdiction and separates from His rule and safety. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15
The demand showed lack of faith in His care, providence, wisdom and power to rule, defend, support them, settle their difficulties and raise up rulers for them. 1SP 353.2SG4 65.4Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16 They failed to appreciate His sufficiency and coveted the influence of men, sacrificing faith to be like the nations and choosing to be guided by seen human power rather than the invisible theocracy that had led them and given them victory. 6T 249.4–250.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11Ms 169, 1899, par. 24Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16 They failed to recognize God speaking through Samuel, and afterward neither the people nor their king thought it necessary to follow His commands implicitly but trusted their own wisdom. Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16
A human king could claim the honors due to God and, unless he continually trusted God and sought wisdom from Him, could become proud, lead the people away from God, and use authority unjustly to harm the innocent and favor the unworthy. 1SP 353.2SG4 65.4 They valued royal appearance, personal courage and military ability without seeking love and fear of God, and God gave them the kind of king they desired whose character reflected their own. PP 636.1
Samuel was distressed and displeased and prayed to the Lord, and the Lord directed him to listen to the people's voice and let it decide. Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15EDFCP 23.1 He permitted them to have their own way with all its consequences after faithfully telling them through Samuel all His words about the manner of the king and plainly warning that it was not the right and best way. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1RH Jul 23, 1901 They persisted in self-will from unsanctified hearts, imagining in their own mind and judgment that it would bring the most glory to themselves as a nation, and solemn protest and warning did not change their purpose. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1
God manifested displeasure by thunder, lightning and hail, yet pride kept them from retracting though they could have done so. Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8EDFCP 23.1 Royal pomp brought tyranny and heavy demands in place of His mild and beneficent rule, with distress from leaving His merciful guidance for the rule of men secure in their own way and judgment. Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29RH Jul 23, 1901ST Jul 13, 1882 Many who wanted a ruler meeting their own expectations rejected Saul when chosen without expected pomp, and envy, ambition and disappointment followed, while Saul himself was afraid and could not expect God to save through him. ST Jul 20, 1882 The people afterward recognized the choice as a mistake amid growing irreligion, had to confess the sin before finding peace, and learned their error to return to allegiance, while the final result of their own choice was seen in Jerusalem's destruction and the nation's dispersion. 6T 249.4–250.2Ms 169, 1899, par. 24PP 636.1
Call to Trust God
The request to be judged like all the nations exposes the folly of turning away from the Lord God of Israel as Ruler to lean on men and on human judgment.HL 283.2STBk 113.2LSEGW 323.1–2Ms 61, 1890, par. 18ST2 6.1 It revealed lack of humility, self-confidence, self-sufficiency and pride of heart without giving glory to God, for all human ability and wisdom is only derived from Him.STBk 113.2Ms 61, 1890, par. 18ST2 6.1Ms 40, 1890, par. 7–9 It was reliance on human judgment and on seen human power instead of trusting God, their Ruler, and wanting human rule like the surrounding nations.STBk 113.2ST2 6.1STA 113.1Ms 159, 1899, par. 13 That same folly will be repeated among the people of God today unless there is greater humility, less confidence in self, and more trust in the Lord at every step.HL 283.2LSEGW 323.1–2Ms 61, 1890, par. 18ST2 6.14MR 69.2
Depending on men and on one's own judgment is the great weakness of the church, and Israel made herself weak by dishonoring God, failing to appreciate His sufficiency and coveting the influence of men.6T 249.4–250.2Ms 159, 1899, par. 13Ms 40, 1890, par. 7–9 They chose a visible human king to guide them rather than the divine theocracy, the invisible power that had led them and given them victory, and the end of their own choice was seen in the destruction of Jerusalem and the dispersion of the nation.6T 249.4–250.2Ms 159, 1899, par. 13 The work will abide the test only as divine power is combined with human effort.Ms 61, 1890, par. 18ST2 6.14MR 69.2 That combination is shown when men no longer lean on men or on their own judgment but make God their trust, with meekness of spirit, less talking and much more praying, caution in plans and movements, dependence on God, teachable humble unselfish sanctified labor, and the mind of Christ.Ms 61, 1890, par. 18ST2 6.14MR 69.2Ms 40, 1890, par. 7–9 Unless Christ serves not only as Captain but as Pilot, and unless men inquire at every step if their way is the way of the Lord, the church will make shipwreck amid the perils of the last days.Ms 40, 1890, par. 7–9
The same persistent self-will warns against putting self where God has not placed it, as in wanting one man's mind to control institutions and churches and thereby becoming a channel of darkness.Lt 38, 1890, par. 7–8 It warns against imitating the customs and practices of the world to satisfy pride, self-love and ambition, even at the cost of God's cause, and against adopting worldly plans and policy instead of trusting God as Ruler.ST Jul 13, 1882STA 113.1Ms 61, 1890, par. 19–20 Giving up even a little faith to meet the world and gain more converts separates souls from God.Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16 All whom God has placed in positions of responsibility who depart from God are left by Him, with the people that sustain them, to their own human wisdom.Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16 Therefore His people must not repeat Israel's sins of worldly policy but trust the Lord as their ruler rather than relying on people or their own judgment.LSEGW 323.1–2Ms 61, 1890, par. 19–20Lt 139, 1898, par. 12–16
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
71 sources
The elders asked the aged Samuel, whose sons as judges at Beersheba took bribes and perverted justice, to give them a king to govern them like the surrounding nations.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jan 28, 1902ST May 31, 1899ST Mar 31, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895 Their complaint about his age and his sons was a pretext for a long-settled desire born of discontent and pride, for they found no fault with Samuel himself yet sought to set him aside.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882 In asking for a visible human ruler to go before them and fight their battles, they rejected not Samuel but God, that He should not reign over them, breaking the covenant and taking the first formal step away from His direct rule.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jan 28, 1902RH Jun 29, 1916ST Oct 24, 1895 The cry to be like all the nations was only the outward sign of inward apostasy, for at heart they had already forsaken God, refused to govern themselves by His law, and blamed His government as a failure instead of confessing their own fault.ST Jul 22, 1889ST Apr 17, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901 As the church, by refusing to dwell alone and demanding to join the state and be governed like the states around them, they formed themselves into a state and made a union of church and state against His will.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 Kingship was not His chosen order or plan, but after warning of tyranny, oppression, and bloody wars He granted their persistent choice in anger as a concession, and seeking to imitate the nations brought decline, ruin, and captivity.ST Jul 22, 1889GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899ST Jan 2, 1912ST Sep 4, 1893
Setting and Wording
The elders asked Samuel, who was old and whose sons did not walk in his ways, to make them a king to judge them like all the nations, and Israel is the nation that asked to be like the other nations.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jan 28, 1902ST May 31, 1899ST Oct 10, 1895RH May 1, 1900 The demand to be ruled like the other nations marked apostasy and rejection of God's plan of government. Samuel's two sons assisted him in the work of judge at Beersheba, but they did not follow his ways and were corrupt and untrustworthy, taking bribes and perverting the proper use of their office.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Mar 31, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895 For this alleged reason and for other causes the people demanded a king, and asking for a king like other nations meant giving up the condition of relying in faith on God alone as their King.ST Mar 31, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895
The complaint about Samuel's age and his sons' corrupt conduct served as a pretext for pressing a change long wanted, coming not from sudden concern about justice but from long-standing discontent and pride and a settled desire for a king.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 13, 1882 The people said they could find no fault with Samuel's own rule, yet he felt their request was a censure of him and an attempt to set him aside.ST Jul 13, 1882 Their sons' injustice as judges caused dissatisfaction, but the people were more troubled by threats to their material interests than by the earlier religious corruption of Hophni and Phinehas.ST Jul 13, 1882 Hearts estranged from God may use almost any pretext to disregard His authority and satisfy pride and self-love even at the cost of His cause, driven by dissatisfaction and desire for worldly power and display.ST Jul 13, 1882
To judge in the request means to govern as a ruler or king, not merely to hear cases, as the judges of Israel had exercised royal authority by enforcing the law and protecting the people.RH Apr 25, 1871 What was asked was a visible human ruler like those of the surrounding nations, seen with the physical eye, to go before them, judge them, and fight their battles.RH Jun 29, 1916ST Oct 24, 1895 Though the people still acknowledged God as their invisible King, they wanted a visible ruler in place of Jehovah as King and governor ruling through ministers of His own appointment fitted by His Spirit.ST Oct 24, 1895 The request would never have been made if the people had been in right relation to God, and it proved their spiritual vision was failing through surrounding influence and apostasy from Him.ST Oct 24, 1895
The request came after Israel had been governed by judges for about 450 years, after centuries of contact with surrounding heathen nations and about four hundred and fifty years marked by relapses into abominable idolatry and gross sin followed by severe punishment through captivity by enemies.RH Mar 11, 1858RH Jun 11, 1901 It marks the transition from rule by judges appointed by the Lord to monarchy and the uniting of the twelve tribes under one king until Solomon's death, and the foundation of the monarchy.RH Sep 8, 1853ST Feb 13, 1901 It belongs to the great event of First and Second Samuel, in which Samuel had taken the place of the aged priest Eli as priest, judge, and leader of the people, and in answer to the request Saul was given as king.RH Mar 30, 1916 God let them have the desire of their heart, permitting three kings each ruling for forty years, and when Saul proved unworthy he was deposed and David took his place.RH Jun 11, 1901RH Mar 30, 1916
Samuel guided the matter, met with Saul and instructed him, and oversaw the public choosing.ST Oct 24, 1895 Those events took place in the same locality a few miles from Jerusalem, in the area of the tribe of Benjamin to which Saul belonged.ST Oct 24, 1895 Israel wanted a king to replace Samuel because he was old and his sons were not following his example, and Samuel eventually yielded the leadership to a king in response to the people's wish. Saul was made king because the people rejected Samuel's government and demanded a king, so that Saul was set up on the ruins of Samuel's rejected administration.ST Oct 31, 1895
Rejection of Divine Rule
The elders' demand for a human king to judge like surrounding nations rejected God's rule that He should not reign over them, not Samuel himself, choosing another than God to rule and refusing to remain distinct under God as only King, Ruler, and Lawgiver.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jan 28, 1902ST Jun 23, 1914GSAM 46.1RH May 27, 1909 It broke the covenant and was the first formal step and a long step toward ruin in rejecting the theocracy, marking the beginning of Israel's decline into apostasy interrupted only at times by efforts to restore true worship.GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899ST Nov 9, 1882ST Oct 10, 1895 Though the people still acknowledged God as invisible King, they wanted a visible ruler to govern them, and their demand persisted despite Samuel's warning about oppression, so God granted it in anger while the kingdom continued.RH Jan 28, 1902ST Jun 23, 1914GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899 The complaint named Samuel's old age and his sons' failure to follow his ways, but it sprang from dissatisfaction with rule by judges and from backsliding, blaming God's government instead of confessing failure to govern themselves and be true to conscience.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jan 28, 1902GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899ST Apr 17, 1901
God's preferred government was by judges with authority coming directly from Heaven, because a king with great power was in danger of pride and tyranny.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Apr 17, 1901 In that theocracy the Lord alone was sovereign, religious and civil life formed one community under God's laws, and Israel was not a state in which one person claimed sovereignty over another.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Apr 29, 1903 The work of Moses and the seventy elders was purely administrative with no legislative authority, for God was the actual legislator and real ruler speaking through Moses, Joshua, the elders that outlived Joshua, the judges, and Samuel the prophet.ST Apr 17, 1901RH Apr 3, 1913 Different people carried out different duties without ruling each other, with neither Levites nor civil officials ruling the other.ST Apr 29, 1903 Even a true theocracy could not keep the people loyal once they turned from God.ST Jun 23, 1914ST Apr 29, 1903
The demand marked a new era and ended the pure theocracy in which God directly governed a willing people through ministers of His own appointment fitted by His Spirit, a direct government possible only where the people willingly follow His guidance implicitly.ST Oct 10, 1895ST Oct 24, 1895ST Oct 24, 1895 In asking for a king seen with the physical eye to go before them and fight their battles, the people rejected not Samuel but God who sent him, proving their spiritual vision was failing through surrounding influence and apostasy, a request that would never have been made had they been in right relation to God.ST Oct 10, 1895ST Oct 24, 1895 Holding to the human-rulership idea wholly perverted the nation, meaning in effect away with God Himself and leading finally to having no king but Caesar.ST Oct 24, 1895 At the time national worship had been greatly restored and the people were in vastly better condition than for a long time before, yet they refused to let God rule longer by formally demanding a human king like other nations.ST Oct 24, 1895
The request did not then end God's care and government, for He retained the right to choose the king under Himself, a right tacitly acknowledged by all, and remained identified with the Hebrews under the kings.ST Nov 9, 1882RH Apr 3, 1913ST Jun 30, 1909ST Oct 24, 1895 God told Samuel to grant the request and to tell the people that if they would obey He would continue with their kings as He had been with their judges, continuing to regard Israel as His people and to work with and through them despite their departure.RH May 27, 1909RH Apr 3, 1913 He permitted the change without changing the principles on which the theocracy was founded, so Israel's Sabbath punishments and moral laws cannot be copied by the state.RH Apr 3, 1913ST Jun 30, 1909 The theocracy ended nationally only when they rejected Christ as rightful King and declared for Caesar, and from the destruction of that theocracy until Christ's return no true theocracy can be established on earth.RH May 27, 1909RH Apr 3, 1913
Saul was only a civil ruler who could not govern on moral grounds, while God remained the moral governor with another relation behind Saul's rule.RH Apr 15, 1873 Priests still ministered between God and the people, the ten commandments remained God's law and not Saul's law, and God's glory was still manifested over the ark of the testament and not Saul's glory.RH Apr 15, 1873 The verse does not mean God stood to Israel only as political ruler, lawgiver, and king just like the human king chosen in His place, for to judge the character of the one rejected by the one chosen would require concluding from the Jews rejecting Christ and choosing a murderer in His stead that Christ was like the murderer.RH Apr 15, 1873
Desire to Resemble Nations
The demand sprang from pride and a desire to follow the ways of the surrounding nations, and in making it Israel rejected God's rule and committed apostasy rather than fulfilling His plan.ST Jul 22, 1889ST Jan 2, 1912 It violated God's purpose that Israel remain separate from the heathen nations, for He had separated them to Himself as His own peculiar treasure, a people devoted to Him and distinct from all others, and they disregarded that high honor and privilege in eagerly desiring to imitate idolaters.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 They sought a worldly, temporal kingdom rather than God's spiritual rule, and their imitation of the nations led to idolatry, deep moral corruption, and doing worse than the heathen, until they were carried captive to Babylon.ST Jan 2, 1912 The same longing to conform to worldly customs continues among professed believers, who as they depart from the Lord become ambitious for worldly gains, honors, power and display, constantly seeking to imitate those who worship the god of this world on the plea of exerting stronger influence over the ungodly.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Aug 23, 1899 Seeking worldly honor and adopting the world's customs instead of remaining distinct brings weakness and corruption, proves that the prevailing spirit of the times endangers God's people, and is more culpable where there is greater light and privilege.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Jul 22, 1889
Asking for a king like all the nations was only the outward sign of an inward apostasy, for the people had already become like the nations at heart through backsliding.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901 Having forsaken God for Baal and Ashtaroth and departed from His peace, wisdom and righteousness to adopt heathen ways, they would not govern themselves by the law of God and therefore had to have a human authority and an earthly law by which they could be governed.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Jan 27, 1904 The demand was a complete rejection of God and His law for an earthly king and earthly law, open rebellion in rejecting God that He should not reign over them.ST Apr 17, 1901 It marks a stage of apostasy after faithfulness, paralleling the later Christian era when the church backslid, divided, followed heathen customs and let Constantine usurp Christ's place, while Israel's peaceful empire under Solomon showed what God could have accomplished through a loyal people and was willing to do among all nations if their kings recognized and served Him.ST Jan 30, 1896ST Jan 27, 1904
Their troubles came from their own failure to govern themselves and to be true to conscience, but instead of confessing their own fault they blamed God's government as a failure.ST Apr 17, 1901 Oppressed as the result of that apostasy and idolatry, they thought they needed a warrior ruler and a strong central government to unite the tribes, maintain standing among the nations and restore harmony, and concluded they must be freed from their divine Sovereign and govern themselves like other nations.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 22, 1889RH Mar 30, 1916 The experience and condition of the people under the later judges made such union appear necessary for deliverance, for they had proved unworthy, disregarded God's commands, fallen into evil ways and were fast losing their national and religious life.RH Mar 30, 1916RH May 26, 1904 The trouble was not God's system of rule by judges, in which the Lord alone was sovereign and the work of Moses and the seventy elders was purely administrative with no legislative authority and no person claiming sovereignty over another; the people needed to change themselves and learn self-government.ST Apr 17, 1901RH May 26, 1904 God intended eventually to give a king with His sanction, not an absolute tyrant like the kings of other nations, a king who would likely represent Christ's Messianic office, and though Samuel was at first reluctant God ordered him to accede to the people's wishes and he yielded and anointed Saul.ST Jul 22, 1889RH Mar 30, 1916
God had brought Israel out of slavery and idolatry in Egypt so they could keep the Sabbath and preserve a peculiar, holy character to represent Him, with Himself ruling over them, and He had said they should dwell alone and not be reckoned among the nations.ST Feb 17, 1898ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 In demanding to be reckoned among and like all the nations they acted contrary to His expressed will and solemn protest.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 After being safely established in Canaan under the continued fellowship, protection, love and pity of the divinely chosen Messenger of God's presence, they grew weary of heavenly direction and demanded to be led by an earthly king instead, cutting short a fellowship that would otherwise have been indefinitely extended.RH Jun 29, 1916 They grew tired of God's company and chose the kind of leader human sight favored, with Saul standing head and shoulders above the people, but loss of communion with God left them afraid to face Goliath though earlier generations had defeated giants while following God.ST Oct 13, 1881 Their cry was the rejoicing cry of a free people ruled by judges giving up that order to make their victorious military leader their supreme ruler, saying in effect, Now have we a king like all the nations, after a foreign war and the conquest and annexation of a distant land across the sea, in imitation of surrounding nations and eastern princes to rival them in might, wisdom and empire. By wrongfully and pridefully insisting on something God was not ready to give, they rejected blessings God could provide through Samuel and shut themselves off from influences that could have brought deeper benefits to their souls.ST Jul 22, 1889
Union of Church and State
Israel was the church while all the nations were states, and God had purposed that Israel should dwell alone with Himself as only King, Ruler and Lawgiver as a holy people not reckoned among the nations.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 By refusing to dwell alone and demanding to be reckoned among the nations and to be like all the nations, Israel asked to set up a kingdom and establish a state, joining itself to the State, becoming part of the State, and making religion a matter of State and government.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 In becoming like the nations Israel formed itself into a state, and in that very act formed a union of church and state and of religion and the State, contrary to God's expressed will and plain Word and against His solemn protest in rejecting God that He should not reign over them.ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 23, 1899 That union kept God from revealing Himself to the world as He really is, and the account belongs to the origin of the State and to the separation of religion and the State.ST Aug 23, 1899RH Apr 24, 1900
The request marked a turn into politics, for the people sought to take part in governing the nation rather than simply obeying and carrying out God's direction.ST Jul 29, 1897 This departure led them from worship of the true God to false gods, after which God forsook them as both church and nation.ST Jul 29, 1897 It warns against the church seeking civil government's help in religious matters, since doing so asks an inferior power to perform work it was not ordained to do and shows loss of connection with the supreme power.ST Jul 30, 1894
The demand came from backsliding and failure to govern themselves and to be true to conscience, yet instead of confessing their own fault the people blamed God's government as a failure.ST Apr 17, 1901 It rejected a theocracy in which the Lord alone was sovereign, Israel was not a state, no person claimed sovereignty over another, and the work of Moses and the seventy elders was purely administrative with no legislative authority.ST Apr 17, 1901 The demand belongs to a progression from rejecting God's law as the rule of life to human government under human law, for once people no longer govern themselves under divine law they are governed by other people, and the demand for a king leads naturally to the use of force to compel conduct that rulers regard as duty.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901
Until the demand God had continued as the real ruler and actual legislator, speaking through Moses and continuing through Joshua, the elders that outlived Joshua, and the judges until Samuel the prophet.RH Apr 3, 1913 The people's demand for a king to be like the nations around them displeased Samuel and was a rejection of God's rule over them and not merely of Samuel.RH Apr 3, 1913 God told Samuel to grant the request and to tell the people that if they would obey God He would continue with their kings as He had been with their judges, so God remained identified with the Hebrews under the kings.RH Apr 3, 1913 The verse therefore proves that until that demand God had continued as the real ruler in Israel, and it shows that Israel's Sabbath punishments and moral laws cannot be copied by the state, since from the later destruction of that theocracy until Christ's return no true theocracy can be established on earth.RH Apr 3, 1913
Permission and Consequences
Kingship was not God's chosen order, will, or plan for Israel, but a worldly temporal kingdom sought in place of His spiritual rule.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Sep 4, 1893RH Jul 20, 1911 God warned of the dangers and harm that would follow, seeking to turn the people from their error to rely on His freely given grace, yet they persisted in their choice and He granted it in anger.ST May 31, 1899ST Sep 4, 1893ST Sep 5, 1895RH Oct 28, 1873RH Jul 20, 1911 Even then He dealt mercifully, giving instruction to protect them under unrighteous rule and not allowing Israel's king to lead His chosen people in the way of other nations.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Sep 5, 1895RH Jul 20, 1911 His permission was a concession departing from His original ideal, like permission to eat flesh, and punishment followed as men's days gradually shortened after flesh was allowed.RH Oct 28, 1873 The relation is reciprocal, for God does not desire unwilling service or to reign over an unwilling people, but requires willing loving service, so that all just powers derive from consent of the governed and His kingdom will be those who have willingly chosen Jesus as King in heart and life.ST Sep 5, 1895
Despite Samuel's warning about the oppression a king would bring, the people refused his counsel.RH Jul 23, 1901GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899 God let them follow their own choice, dissatisfied with dependence on God and desiring to look to a king for protection and guidance against oppressing surrounding nations, thinking they needed a warrior ruler.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jul 22, 1889ST Feb 27, 1901 He allowed them a king in His anger who would bring royal pomp, tyranny, heavy demands, trouble, distress, oppression and bloody wars in place of His mild and beneficent rule.RH Jul 23, 1901ST Jul 13, 1882GSAM 46.1ST May 31, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901
Granting the request, though the people still acknowledged God as invisible King while wanting a visible ruler, marked the beginning of Israel's decline into apostasy, interrupted only at times by efforts to restore true worship and the reality of the sanctuary.ST Oct 19, 1888ST Jan 27, 1904 Seeking to imitate other nations and refusing to remain distinct brought ruin, for becoming like the nations led them to do worse than the heathen.RH Jul 22, 1902 The king who was to go before them, judge them and fight their battles could only lead them to utter ruin, proving human defense is weakness, failure and loss.RH Jun 29, 1916 His example helped turn society toward irreligion and godlessness, and the road then chosen ended in the destruction of Jerusalem and captivity in Babylon.ST Oct 19, 1888RH Jun 29, 1916
God had intended eventually to give them a king with His sanction, not an absolute tyrant like the other nations' kings, who would likely represent Christ's Messianic office.ST Jul 22, 1889 Israel's peaceful empire under Solomon showed what God could have accomplished through a loyal people, and what He was willing to do among all nations if their kings recognized and served Him.ST Jan 27, 1904
The request came after about four hundred and fifty years marked by relapses into idolatry and gross sin followed by severe punishment through captivity by enemies, whose cruel and despotic rulers displayed the consequences of living without God's favor without Israel learning the warning.RH Jun 11, 1901 It brings the establishment of the monarchy, the great event of First and Second Samuel in which Samuel had taken Eli's place as priest, judge and leader, and in answer Saul was given as king.RH Mar 30, 1916 The first king given was Saul, a Benjaminite specially prepared, who within a short time sorely displeased God by two acts of rebellion, after the second of which He rejected him from being king, and he soon perished in battle.ST Apr 28, 1914 His rule brought bitter consequences, including the danger that his decree would cost Jonathan his life, and when he proved unworthy he was deposed and David took his place.ST Aug 17, 1882RH Mar 30, 1916 God thus permitted three kings, each ruling for forty years.RH Jun 11, 1901
They got the king they asked for, and Israel's kings copied the customs of surrounding nations.RH Apr 2, 1908 Their example does not justify polygamy, because that was not part of God's plan from the beginning.RH Apr 2, 1908
Warning to Later Peoples
The same willingness to be like all the nations continues in the church in all the world today.ST Aug 23, 1899 The professed churches of God, the young people's societies and leagues of Christian Endeavor, all the combined church elements follow the same course of joining to the State and refusing to dwell alone unreckoned among the nations.ST Aug 23, 1899 As they depart from the Lord they become ambitious for the gains and honors of the world, for power and display, constantly seeking to imitate the practices of those who worship the god of this world, many urging that by uniting with worldlings and conforming to their customs they might exert a stronger influence over the ungodly.ST Aug 23, 1899 That desire sprang from pride and brought idolatry and deep moral corruption, for seeking worldly honor and adopting the world's customs rather than remaining distinct brings weakness and corruption.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Jul 22, 1889 Acting against expressed will in this way is more culpable when there is greater light and privilege.ST Aug 4, 1881
Seeking to imitate other nations brought Israel to ruin, and the same warning applies to a republic providentially separated from other nations when it follows Israel's example.RH Jul 22, 1902 America in splendid providential isolation had been the wonder of the world and the cynosure of liberty to the oppressed, admired and loved, a means in providence for influencing the nations to higher thought and broader liberties, but in desiring to become like the nations she has broken her bonds of peace, descended from her elevation of strength, and launched herself upon the great troublous sea of international strife to her own undoing. This is an uncontrollable drifting away from the principles on which the nation had staked its future, keeping the outward forms of government while the spirit of it runs out, gaining a military spirit and losing simple republican life, and moving toward intermingling in the complications of other powers. Heeding this desire to be like the nations points to involvement in the great battles of the last days, and keeps from being taken unawares.
The demand marks a stage of apostasy after faithfulness, joined with persecution and only partial reforms, and it parallels the Christian era when the church backslid, divided, followed heathen customs, and departed by consenting to let Constantine usurp the place of Christ.ST Jan 30, 1896 This desire for a human king later gave way to the choice of Caesar over Christ.ST May 14, 1902 Though God still cared and worked for and through the people afterward, holding to the human-rulership idea wholly perverted the nation, so that holding to that demand meant in effect away with God Himself and led finally to having no king but Caesar. The theocracy ended nationally only when they rejected Christ as rightful King and declared for Caesar.RH May 27, 1909 The demand belongs to earthly Jerusalem and stands as a monumental failure of earthly, fleshly hope, the same fleshly principle as Abraham's effort to supplement the promise and as man's side of the covenant at Sinai, and as the later rejection of Christ and God for Barabbas and Caesar, standing for the utter hopelessness of all salvation by human works and for the baselessness of hoping for Christ's kingdom to be set up on earth by human means.ST Apr 11, 1900
Cursed is the man who trusts in man and makes flesh his arm while his heart departs from the Lord, for Christians fight and conquer only by submission, suffering, and love through the cross, by giving life not taking it.RH Jun 29, 1916 The king who was to fight for them could only lead them to utter ruin ending in destruction of Jerusalem and captivity in Babylon, proving human defense is only weakness, failure, and loss.RH Jun 29, 1916 The request marked a choice to rely on human rule and warfare rather than fully trust God to fight battles.RH Oct 2, 1900 God does not desire unwilling service or to reign over an unwilling people, but requires willing, loving service, and all just powers derive from the consent of the governed, and the kingdom will be those who have willingly chosen Jesus as King in heart and life and chosen His reign of love.ST Sep 5, 1895 The disorder behind the demand showed not a wrong system of rule by judges but the people's need to change themselves and learn self-government, and peace comes when the heart submits to God rather than insisting on its own choice.ST Jul 20, 1882RH May 26, 1904
The majority decision demanding a king and rejecting God's will shows that being in the majority does not mean being right.ST Sep 9, 1889 An unthinking, dissatisfied people looking to political change for deliverance may reject self-government and choose a king, though change of rulers cannot change corrupt hearts and only God's grace can do that.ST Nov 22, 1910 The request marked a turn into politics in seeking to take part in governing rather than simply obeying and carrying out divine direction, and this departure led from worship of the true God to false gods, so that God forsook them as both a church and a nation.ST Jul 29, 1897 In choosing a king to be like other nations the nation forsook God, after which only a few remained loyal to Him.RH Oct 8, 1908
Sources