Daniel 8:13
Then I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said unto that certain saint which spake, How long shall be the vision concerning the daily sacrifice, and the transgression of desolation, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
Translations
Then I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said to that certain saint which spoke, How long shall be the vision concerning the daily sacrifice, and the transgression of desolation, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said unto that certain saint which spake, How long shall be the vision concerning the daily sacrifice, and the transgression of desolation, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
Then I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said to that certain saint who spoke, How long shall be the vision concerning the daily sacrifice, and the transgression of desolation, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
Then I heard a holy one speaking; and another holy one said unto that certain one which spake, How long shall be the vision concerning the continual burnt offering, and the transgression that maketh desolate, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
Then I heard a holy one speaking; and another holy one said unto that certain one who spake, How long shall be the vision concerning the continual burnt-offering, and the transgression that maketh desolate, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under foot?
'And I hear a certain holy one speaking, and a certain holy one saith to the wonderful numberer who is speaking: Till when [is] the vision of the continual [sacrifice], and of the transgression, an astonishment, to make both sanctuary and host a treading down?
And I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said unto that one who spoke, How long shall be the vision of the continual [ sacrifice] and of the transgression that maketh desolate, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden down under foot?
Then heard I a certain holy one, speaking,—and another holy one said to that certain holy one who was speaking—How long is the vision of the continual [ascending-sacrifice] as taken away, and the transgression which astoundeth, for both sanctuary and host to be given over to be trampled underfoot?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then I heard a holy one speaking, and another holy one said to him, “ How long until the fulfillment of the vision of the daily sacrifice, the rebellion that causes desolation, and the surrender of the sanctuary and of the host to be trampled?”
Then I heard a holy one speaking; and another holy one said to that certain one who spoke, “ How long will the vision about the continual burnt offering, and the disobedience that makes desolate, to give both the sanctuary and the army to be trodden under foot be?”
Then there came to my ears the voice of a holy one talking; and another holy one said to that certain one who was talking, How long will the vision be while the regular burned offering is taken away, and the unclean thing causing fear is put up, and the holy place crushed under foot?
Then I heard one of the Saints speaking, and one of the Saints spake vnto a certaine one, saying, Howe long shall endure the vision of the dayly sacrifice, and the iniquitie of the desolation to treade both the Sanctuarie and the armie vnder foote?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And I heard one of the saints speaking, and one saint said to another, I know not to whom that was speaking: How long shall be the vision, concerning the continual sacrifice, and the sin of the desolation that is made: and the sanctuary, and the strength be trodden under foot?
Cross-references 20 of 63
- Daniel 9:24-27
Seventy weeks are determined upon thy people and upon thy holy city, to finish the transgression, and to make an end of sins, and to make reconciliation for iniquity, and to bring in everlasting righteousness, and to seal up the vision and prophecy, and to anoint the most Holy.
Daniel 9 explains the time brought to view in Daniel 8.
- Hebrews 8:1-2
Now of the things which we have spoken this is the sum: We have such an high priest, who is set on the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens;
Christ serves as High Priest in the true heavenly sanctuary.
- Daniel 9:21-23
Yea, whiles I was speaking in prayer, even the man Gabriel, whom I had seen in the vision at the beginning, being caused to fly swiftly, touched me about the time of the evening oblation.
Gabriel comes to give Daniel understanding of the earlier vision.
- Daniel 8:20-22
The ram which thou sawest having two horns are the kings of Media and Persia.
Identifies Media and Persia, Greece, and the four successor kingdoms represented in the vision.
- Daniel 12:11
And from the time that the daily sacrifice shall be taken away, and the abomination that maketh desolate set up, there shall be a thousand two hundred and ninety days.
Names the daily’s removal and the abomination of desolation, then gives the 1,290 days.
- Daniel 8:26-27
And the vision of the evening and the morning which was told is true: wherefore shut thou up the vision; for it shall be for many days.
The vision concerns many days, and Daniel remains unable to understand it.
- Daniel 11:31
And arms shall stand on his part, and they shall pollute the sanctuary of strength, and shall take away the daily sacrifice, and they shall place the abomination that maketh desolate.
explains same taking away of daily
- Daniel 7:25
And he shall speak great words against the most High, and shall wear out the saints of the most High, and think to change times and laws: and they shall be given into his hand until a time and times and the dividing of time.
The little horn persecutes the saints and seeks to change God’s law.
- Daniel 8:17
So he came near where I stood: and when he came, I was afraid, and fell upon my face: but he said unto me, Understand, O son of man: for at the time of the end shall be the vision.
Gabriel says the vision concerns the time of the end.
- Daniel 9:17
Now therefore, O our God, hear the prayer of thy servant, and his supplications, and cause thy face to shine upon thy sanctuary that is desolate, for the Lord’s sake.
Daniel prays for God to look with favor on the desolate sanctuary.
- Daniel 9:27
And he shall confirm the covenant with many for one week: and in the midst of the week he shall cause the sacrifice and the oblation to cease, and for the overspreading of abominations he shall make it desolate, even until the consummation, and that determined shall be poured upon the desolate.
Both describe the sacrifice ceasing and the sanctuary becoming desolate.
- Daniel 8:25
And through his policy also he shall cause craft to prosper in his hand; and he shall magnify himself in his heart, and by peace shall destroy many: he shall also stand up against the Prince of princes; but he shall be broken without hand.
The little horn oppresses the holy people and is broken without human agency.
- Leviticus 16:15-22
Then shall he kill the goat of the sin offering, that is for the people, and bring his blood within the vail, and do with that blood as he did with the blood of the bullock, and sprinkle it upon the mercy seat, and before the mercy seat:
The Day of Atonement service portrays sanctuary cleansing through sacrificial blood and the removal of sin.
- Hebrews 9:23
It was therefore necessary that the patterns of things in the heavens should be purified with these; but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these.
heavenly things cleansed with better sacrifices
- Daniel 12:6-7
And one said to the man clothed in linen, which was upon the waters of the river, How long shall it be to the end of these wonders?
Both ask how long the vision’s troubles last; the answer ends with the scattering of the holy people.
- Daniel 8:19
And he said, Behold, I will make thee know what shall be in the last end of the indignation: for at the time appointed the end shall be.
Identifies the appointed end of the indignation and trampling.
- Daniel 8:3-8
Then I lifted up mine eyes, and saw, and, behold, there stood before the river a ram which had two horns: and the two horns were high; but one was higher than the other, and the higher came up last.
The ram and goat symbolize Medo-Persia and Greece, whose kingdoms shape the vision.
- Matthew 24:15
When ye therefore shall see the abomination of desolation, spoken of by Daniel the prophet, stand in the holy place, ( whoso readeth, let him understand:)
Jesus’ warning about the abomination is linked to Daniel’s desolating power.
- Daniel 9:21
Yea, whiles I was speaking in prayer, even the man Gabriel, whom I had seen in the vision at the beginning, being caused to fly swiftly, touched me about the time of the evening oblation.
Gabriel returns to Daniel to complete the explanation of the earlier vision.
- Daniel 8:26
And the vision of the evening and the morning which was told is true: wherefore shut thou up the vision; for it shall be for many days.
The vision is affirmed as true and concerns many days to come.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
13 sources
The question asks how long the vision about the daily and the transgression of desolation will last, while the sanctuary and God's people are left to be trampled underfoot.LS 44.2LS 61.1–210MR 49.3 Its answer is given in the next verse, that after two thousand and three hundred days the sanctuary would be cleansed.LS 44.2LS 61.1–2 Those days are twenty-three hundred years, which cannot be literal days because of the vast scope of the empires involved.LS 44.2PK 554.1 The word rendered daily stands alone, without the word sacrifice, which was supplied by human interpretation.ExVEGW 61.2 The identity of that daily was disputed, but the verse itself does not settle the dispute and its differing views are not to be made a test of faith.CWP 10.3–11.110MR 49.3CWP 5.2 Prophetic time ceased to be a test in 1844, and time has not been a test since then and never will be again.ExVEGW 61.2Ms 15, 1850, par. 12
Vision Question and Setting
The word employed is “daily” alone, without “sacrifice,” that added word being a human interpretation supplied to the text.ExVEGW 61.2 The question asked is how long the vision concerning the daily and the transgression of desolation shall continue, while both the sanctuary and the host, God’s people, are left to be trodden underfoot.LS 44.2LS 61.1–210MR 49.3
It comes at the close of a further vision of future events, asking how long that vision shall be.PK 554.1 It belongs with the revelations of Daniel 7-12 concerning the mysteries of ages to come, reaching to the closing period of this world’s history.PK 547.1
The vision at issue concerns the empires of Persia, Greece, and Rome.LS 44.2 Its little-horn symbols and specifications apply to historical Rome, not to Antiochus Epiphanes.LS 67.3–69.3 The light of this vision, associated with the Ulai, was given especially for the last days, is now being fulfilled, and its foretold events will soon come to pass.Ms 142, 1901, par. 6
Prophetic Time and Fulfillment
The question of how long the oppression of the vision would continue, with the sanctuary and the host trodden underfoot, introduces the answer given in the following verse of two thousand and three hundred days, after which the sanctuary would be cleansed.LS 44.2LS 61.1–2 Those two thousand and three hundred days mean twenty-three hundred years to elapse before the cleansing of God's sanctuary, and they cannot be literal days because the vision concerns the empires of Persia, Greece, and Rome.LS 44.2PK 554.1 The verse belongs to the prophetic time setting addressed by Daniel 8 and 9, whose prophetic periods are reckoned from 457 B.C.GC 687.4
The length of that period filled Daniel with perplexity because he could not understand its relation to the seventy years' captivity foretold through Jeremiah, and though the angel Gabriel gave him a partial interpretation, Daniel fainted and remained astonished when told the vision would be for many days.PK 554.1 Troubled by this unexplained time element, he mistakenly thought the 2,300 days ended with the seventy years of Israel's captivity, and his prayer for Jerusalem's desolate sanctuary reflects that misunderstanding.LS 45.2–3
Even Daniel himself did not fully understand all that was revealed to him, for it was not given him to understand it all, but it was to be shut up and sealed even to the time of the end, with the assurance that he would rest and stand in his lot and place at the end of the days.PK 547.1
Doctrinal Dispute and Counsel
The question in the verse belongs to a dispute over the meaning and identity of the daily, which the verse itself does not settle.CWP 10.3–11.110MR 49.3CWP 5.2 The correct view of the daily was given by God to those who proclaimed the first angel's message and the judgment-hour message.ExVEGW 61.2Ms 15, 1850, par. 12 Before 1844 nearly all of them were united on that view, while afterward competing views arose and brought confusion and darkness.ExVEGW 61.2Ms 15, 1850, par. 12
The verse is not to be made a test of faith or treated as a vital matter of great importance, nor are the differing views about it to be made a test.CWP 10.3–11.110MR 49.3CWP 5.2 Disputes over its interpretation have caused confusion and distracted believers from their work, so attention should instead be given to truths on which there is unity and clear understanding.CWP 10.3–11.1 Prophetic time ceased to be a test in 1844, time has not been a test since 1844, and it will never again be a test.ExVEGW 61.2Ms 15, 1850, par. 12
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
358 sources
One holy angel is heard asking another how long the vision about the continual and the desolating rebellion will last while sanctuary and worshippers are left to be trampled, and the answer given is unto twenty-three hundred evenings-mornings and then the sanctuary shall be cleansed.RH Dec 15, 1868ST Nov 13, 1879
The vision so measured is the whole of what was shown, the ram for Media and Persia, the goat for Greece with its great horn and fourfold division, and the exceeding great little horn for Rome in both its pagan and papal workings.RH Mar 10, 1874RH Feb 15, 1870RH Feb 15, 1870
The continual and the rebellion that makes desolate are two successive desolating powers, paganism followed by the papacy, the sanctuary is the true heavenly dwelling where Christ ministers and not the earth or the destroyed earthly house, and the host is His people joined to that sanctuary.RH Mar 17, 1853RH Mar 1, 1870RH Feb 15, 1870ST Aug 3, 1915ST Nov 19, 1885
The twenty-three hundred are not literal days but symbolic years, the longest prophetic period, whose first four hundred ninety years are the seventy weeks cut off from them, beginning together with the decree to restore Jerusalem in 457 B.C. and ending in the autumn of 1844.RH Mar 17, 1853ST Nov 13, 1879RH Nov 21, 1854RH Mar 1851ST Jan 24, 1878
That cleansing is the heavenly counterpart of the yearly Day of Atonement in Leviticus 16, the investigative judgment begun at the end of the period with Christ's passing from the holy to the most holy place to blot out confessed sins and determine who shall stand when He comes.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Dec 30, 1915ST May 4, 1915ST Oct 28, 1913
Wording and Vision Setting
One holy one was speaking, and another holy one asked in Daniel's hearing how long the vision concerning the daily and the transgression of desolation would last while the sanctuary and the host were given to be trodden under foot.RH Dec 15, 1868ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jun 26, 1907 The answer in the next verse is unto 2,300 evenings-mornings, then the sanctuary shall be cleansed or justified, fixing the cleansing at the end of the 2,300 days with no interval afterward before that event.RH Dec 15, 1868ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jun 26, 1907ST Sep 7, 1915 The question concerns the prophetic vision of the Persian, Greek, and Roman powers and the oppression that is the work of the little horn, and it is the climax of the great vision, raising when the 2,300 days terminate, what sanctuary is to be purified, and what the purification means.ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jun 26, 1907ST Sep 7, 1915
The word vision means the whole vision recorded in Daniel 8 concerning Media and Persia, Greece, and Rome, including ram, goat, and little horn, not merely one symbol or one part alone within it.RH Feb 15, 1870RH Feb 15, 1870ST Dec 19, 1892RH Apr 30, 1901RH Feb 17, 1853 It spans the duration of the three great kingdoms as explained in the latter part of the chapter, and the 2,300 days answers the How long question for the entire vision reaching down to the time of the end.RH Feb 15, 1870ST Dec 19, 1892RH Apr 30, 1901RH Apr 14, 1853RH Feb 17, 1853
The words sacrifice or burnt-offering after daily, and shall be and concerning, were supplied by the translators and do not belong in the verse.ST Aug 3, 1915RH Jul 5, 1870RH Feb 17, 1853ST Aug 3, 1915RH Jan 6, 1853 The Hebrew has daily or tamid standing alone without addition, meaning continual or continuance.ST Aug 3, 1915RH Jul 5, 1870ST Aug 3, 1915RH Jan 6, 1853ST Dec 1, 1881 The expression evenings-mornings conveys days and is rendered as days.RH Jan 31, 1856
How long means literally Until when, asking for the end-point of the vision concerning the daily and the transgression of desolation giving both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden underfoot.RH Mar 28, 1912 The answer unto 2,300 days means in symbolic prophecy 2,300 years, reaching to the latter days at the time of the end, when God begins to cut short the reign of the lawless power and the just balances of the sanctuary pronounce judgment.RH Mar 28, 1912
Saint means holy one, and the saints speaking and answering are holy angels.ST May 3, 1910RH Feb 15, 1870ST Sep 27, 1883ST Apr 23, 1896RH Dec 31, 1861 The word can therefore mean angels as well as God's people on earth and saints in glory, and the holy myriads coming with the Lord are His holy angels distinct from His holy people whom He comes after.RH Feb 15, 1870ST Sep 27, 1883ST Apr 23, 1896ST Aug 29, 1878RH Dec 31, 1861
The conversation is between two heavenly beings speaking in Daniel's hearing for Daniel's information and for God's children, showing heaven's intense interest in the revelation.RH Mar 28, 1912RH Dec 30, 1915ST Aug 3, 1915ST Dec 24, 1894RH Jul 5, 1870 What the first speaking saint said is not recorded, but it made a deep impression on Daniel, who identifies him as that certain saint which spake.RH Jul 5, 1870 Both question and answer are placed on record so that the church should understand them, and the answer is addressed to Daniel as the one chiefly concerned rather than for the angels' information, so it can be revealed to God's people.ST Dec 24, 1894RH Jul 5, 1870
In one identification Michael, the Son of God and Archangel and Prince of the host whose voice raises the dead, is the first speaker, and Gabriel, appointed to instruct Daniel, asks the question.ST Dec 24, 1894 The question is asked on Daniel's behalf concerning Persia, Grecia, and Rome, voicing Daniel's cry to know whether the apostate persecuting power that exalts itself, oppresses the people of God, and casts down truth will prosper forever while appearing triumphant.RH Mar 28, 1912RH Dec 30, 1915ST Dec 24, 1894 In another identification the conversation is between Christ and Gabriel, with one asking how long the vision will last.RH Feb 15, 1870 In yet another form Daniel asks Gabriel how long shall be the vision, and Gabriel answers with the 2,300 days and the cleansing of the sanctuary.ST Jul 9, 1894
The question is asked of Palmoni, the wonderful numberer, in the vision given at Shushan in the third year of Belshazzar.RH Mar 28, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894RH Jul 5, 1870 The vision was given in the third year of Belshazzar in B.C. 553, fifty-three years after Jerusalem was taken and the seventy years captivity began and thirty-five years after the city and house of God were destroyed.ST Jan 24, 1878 Its last setting is in 538 B.C., Belshazzar's last year when Babylon fell in the first year of Darius the Median, near the fall of Babylon and near the close of the seventy years, standing in the history of Judah's captivity and Daniel's experiences in Babylon.RH Nov 21, 1854ST Jan 24, 1878ST Dec 24, 1894 It begins with Medo-Persia at its height and omits Babylon as passing away, concerning the empires of Persia, Greece, and Rome, though Daniel 8 alone does not give the period's precise starting date.RH Nov 21, 1854ST Jan 24, 1878RH Apr 30, 1857
Daniel only listened to the conversation of the two saints on the banks of the river of Elam on the Elam river bank, words shrouded in deepest mystery and not understood by listening alone.RH Jul 6, 1911 A voice from above the Ulai commanded Gabriel to make Daniel understand the vision, giving Gabriel the mission to make Daniel and succeeding generations understand what was meant by the mysterious conversation, a work Gabriel began at once and resumed later in answer to prayer after Daniel's consternation and illness.ST Apr 2, 1894RH Jul 6, 1911 This shows God's angels obey His commands at once, Christ sending Gabriel in response to command to explain the vision to Daniel.ST Apr 2, 1894RH Jul 6, 1911
The vision at Shushan concerning the future is deep, sublime, majestic, and seemingly inscrutable, given to unfold the mystery of God and holding precious jewels of truth, and none understood it at first.RH Dec 19, 1912 It therefore requires hard digging in the mine of truth, stretching the mind to the limit with taxing study, humility of heart, teachableness, prayer, dependence on God, and faith laying hold on divine aid for enlightenment to make its difficult and obscure things plain.RH Dec 19, 1912 Its meaning is to be studied first in the other parts of Daniel 8, then in related prophecies and in the history that fulfills them.RH Jan 23, 1913RH Dec 19, 1912
Empires and Little Horn
The two-horned ram is Media and Persia, the rough goat is Grecia, the notable horn between its eyes is Alexander the Great as the first king, and the four horns that stand up after it is broken are the fourfold division of his empire toward the four winds under his four generals as Macedon, Thrace, Syria and Egypt.RH Mar 21, 1854 The higher of the ram's two horns came up last because Media held the regal power first under Darius while Cyrus commanded the armies, then Persia rose to supremacy when Cyrus added Media to Persia.ST Jan 22, 1880RH Nov 26, 1857 That twofold character corresponds to the two arms of silver in Daniel 2 and is distinctly marked in the bear of Daniel 7 raised up on one side, while the ram and goat give a fuller account of what the bear and leopard show and the goat's division answers to the leopard's four heads.ST Aug 18, 1881ST May 3, 1877
The little horn which waxed exceeding great is Rome in the entirety of its career through pagan and papal phases. It is known by destroying God's people and the holy people, exalting itself against the Prince of the host and Prince of princes and putting Him to death, taking away the continual, casting down the sanctuary and truth to the ground, prospering through transgression, and being broken without human hand at Christ's second coming.RH Mar 10, 1874ST Aug 8, 1878 Rome is shown as one undivided power with no division into Eastern and Western empires, the king of fierce countenance arising in the latter time of the four kingdoms that succeeded Alexander.RH Mar 16, 1869 It is the same power as the fourth beast with the ten horns and the little horn in Daniel 7, with pagan Rome as a picture of papal Rome as temporal and spiritual power.ST May 20, 1897
The little horn is shown coming out of the Macedonian horn because Rome conquered Macedonia in 168 B.C., and that conquest gave Rome great power and prestige as the only exceedingly great power following Grecia.ST Mar 11, 1903 The vision reviews Medo-Persia and Greece and then describes Rome pagan and papal whose power is brought down in 1798, portrays Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece and Rome and Rome's division with the rise and period of the Papacy from 538 to 1798, and covers Rome from beginning to end in ancient and modern phases with emphasis on papal Rome.RH Nov 24, 1910RH Mar 29, 1864RH Apr 10, 1900 Its succession to Rome in later phases is clear and reliable, given after the first of the four world monarchies had passed and continued through chapters 8 to 11 to the last apostate power.ST Jun 30, 1914ST Apr 30, 1912
Horns are symbols of rulers civil or ecclesiastical and of kingdoms or nations, with the two horns of the ram denoting the kings of Media and Persia, the great horn denoting the first king of Grecia, and the four horns representing the divided kingdom.RH Mar 21, 1854ST Jan 6, 1887 Beasts represent a kingdom continuing through successive rulers and changes, and the pictured form is given because truth received through the eye gives more information and deeper and more lasting impressions of what will come in the last days.ST Jan 17, 1884ST Oct 25, 1883 The chapter uses symbolic images as an object lesson inviting comparison of its prophecies to understand their relationships, and its meaning is further explained in plain language in Daniel 11 rather than in symbols.ST May 27, 1908ST Jan 10, 1878
The expanded prophecies in Daniel 7-12 add details and distinctive features to the broad outline in Daniel 2, which is the alphabet of all symbolic prophecy reaching to the everlasting reign of Christ, and Revelation is given as its complement especially in Revelation 12, 13, 17 and 18.ST Oct 8, 1896ST Apr 29, 1903 The vision repeats events shown in Daniel 2, follows Daniel 7 with its four monarchies and ten kingdoms never to be reunited, and its general outline matches Daniel 2, 7 and 9 in tracing world empires shaping religion and civilization as cruel destructive beasts.ST Nov 28, 1895 Daniel 8 contains its own distinct set of prophetic symbols separate from Daniel 2 and Daniel 7, yet describes the same sequence of universal kingdoms and adds features to the earlier prophecies, with interpretation given within the Bible making its meaning definite rather than speculative.ST Oct 29, 1885ST Jun 30, 1914RH Oct 30, 1866RH Apr 15, 1909
In a differing view held by fewer, the little horn of Daniel 8 is a different power from the little horn of Daniel 7 and cannot be made identical with it.RH Jan 10, 1871 In another differing view the sanctuary cleansing concerns earthly events and the destruction of Mahometanism, and the little horn in Daniel 8 is identified with Mahometanism.RH Apr 15, 1873 None of the symbols of ram, he-goat and exceeding great horn means the United States. Antiochus Epiphanes was only one of many kings in the Syrian horn and is not brought into view, and the desolating work beyond him applies to Rome's destruction of Jerusalem associated in Daniel 9:26 as Jesus' reference to the abomination of desolation shows.ST May 27, 1875RH Dec 23, 1852
The chapter shows the three last powers, the persecution of God's people, and Christ's work as prophet and sacrifice and priest, asking how long the vision will last and giving 2,300 days meaning years reaching to 1844 with His coronation as King as the last and next event.ST Jul 8, 1897
Daily and Transgression Powers
The daily or continual desolation and the transgression of desolation are two distinct desolating powers joined by and in a long two-act campaign to trample the sanctuary and the host.RH Feb 15, 1870ST Aug 3, 1915ST Nov 19, 1885RH Jul 5, 1870RH Jan 6, 1853 The word sacrifice is not in the original but was supplied by translators, for the Hebrew means daily or continual, and the verse does not refer to the Jewish sacrifices or their removal.RH Jul 5, 1870RH Jan 6, 1853RH Apr 3, 1866ST Sep 9, 1880 The daily denotes continual desolation by paganism, encompassing Medo-Persia, Greece, and pagan Rome, and the transgression or abomination of desolation denotes the papacy or papal Rome succeeding it in time.RH Feb 15, 1870ST Aug 3, 1915RH Jul 5, 1870RH Jan 6, 1853RH Apr 3, 1866 The vision's concern is the oppression of God's people and their worship, not the glory of earthly kingdoms, and the change from one form to the other occurred under Roman power.RH Jul 5, 1870ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jan 6, 1853 The little horn represents Rome through both its pagan and papal periods, spanning the same ground as Daniel 7's fourth beast and its horns.ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 9, 1880
There are two sanctuaries in view, for the sanctuary trodden in the verse is the sanctuary of Jehovah of hosts, the habitation of the living true God and the same sanctuary to be cleansed, distinct from the sanctuary of the daily desolation which is the sanctuary of Satan exemplified by the Pantheon at Rome.RH Feb 15, 1870RH Jan 6, 1853 The word sanctuary can rightly belong to heathen idolatrous worship as well as to truth, so paganism and error have their own sanctuaries, temples and asylums consecrated to their service.RH Jan 6, 1853 These desolations oppose the heavenly sanctuary by setting up rival places of worship and turning people from God's sanctuary to counterfeit worship, also dishonoring Christ its heavenly minister by replacing His headship and ministry with human religious authority.RH Feb 15, 1870ST Aug 3, 1915RH Feb 3, 1853 Pagan worship forms were adapted into a counterfeit Christian worship that opposed God's cause and displaced the true sanctuary and Christ's ministry.ST Aug 3, 1915ST Sep 9, 1880
The daily is the spirit of paganism which began under Nebuchadnezzar and continued through the Medes and Persians, Greeks and imperial Romans.RH Apr 3, 1866 In that sense it is organized paganism, which was taken away in A.D. 508 to make room for the abomination that maketh desolate.RH Apr 3, 1866ST Sep 21, 1915 Rome appears under the double title of daily then transgression, first as pagan Rome when civil authority dominated the church before A.D. 538 and later as papal Rome when the church dominated civil authority after A.D. 538.ST Jun 18, 1896ST Jun 20, 1900 The phrase means daily desolation, and the reference covers the two phases of Roman power.ST Jun 18, 1896ST Jun 20, 1900
Paganism had to be taken away to prepare the way for the papacy, and was removed as the papacy rose.RH Jul 18, 1871ST Jul 27, 1882RH Sep 24, 1901 The first power is removed so that the second can take its place, with daily idol worship put down and Roman Catholic worship set up.RH Aug 29, 1854 The first power was already working while the church was in order, and the second, headed by the man of sin the Pope, would continue its abominable worship until destroyed by the brightness of Christ's coming.RH Aug 29, 1854 The daily is not the daily sacrifice of the Jews but the daily or continual abomination, that is paganism, an event accomplished in 508, and both systems oppressed the church though hostile to God and to each other.RH Jul 18, 1871RH Sep 24, 1901
The transgression takes the place of the daily only after the daily has stood against the Prince of princes and the power has cast down some of the church and the apostles.ST Jun 20, 1900 Its rise is placed after the rise of the ten kingdoms, while the man of sin had not yet succeeded the one who restrained him in the apostles' time.ST Jun 20, 1900 It is identified with the little horn of Daniel 7 and the man of sin in 2 Thessalonians 2, and asks how long the vision lasts while the sanctuary and God's people are trampled.ST Jun 20, 1900
The daily's sanctuary was its place of pagan worship, identified especially with Rome's Pantheon where idols from conquered nations were kept.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jan 28, 1858ST Sep 9, 1880 Its location in Rome was cast down when Constantine shifted the imperial capital to Constantinople, and the removal of the daily is applied to Constantine's government promoting Christianity by edict.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jan 28, 1858ST Sep 9, 1880 Pagan temples, altars and images were turned to papal use, for Rome's change from paganism to papacy was a change in the form of opposition.ST Sep 9, 1880
The daily removed by putting man in the place of God in the church through papal headship established in Western Rome in 508 and acknowledged in 533 is restored after the papal power as a persecutor is taken away in 1793-8.ST May 7, 1912 Then gospel work revives and sowing begins in preparation for restoring the daily in a fuller clearer sense in the light of the study of the sanctuary to be cleansed.ST May 7, 1912 The host given against the daily was the barbarian tribes that overran the provinces of the empire, who nominally accepted the Christianity Rome then offered as better than their native paganism.RH Mar 4, 1873 While they gained temporal dominion over Rome, Rome gained spiritual dominion over them, and the popes too weak to resist by arms used fraud and cunning, specious presumption and forged titles to bring them to acknowledge the pope as spiritual ruler and head, by which accessions the old paganism was finally rooted out as the religion of the empire.RH Mar 4, 1873
The daily sacrifice means the pagan Roman governments and its sacrifices, which were first restrained and taken away, and afterward the transgression of desolation was placed or set up in the holy place.RH Dec 9, 1852 The holy place at that time could not be the temple at Jerusalem, because that temple had been destroyed more than four hundred years before this desolating power was set up.RH Dec 9, 1852 The abomination of desolation is not the Roman armies or their idolatrous standards at the destruction of Jerusalem, and it is not the pagan Roman governments or its sacrifices.RH Dec 9, 1852RH Dec 9, 1852 Its only reasonable application is the setting up and establishing of the jurisdiction of the papal governments in the church, with the Pope of Rome as supreme executive.RH Dec 9, 1852
The verse does not refer to the daily Jewish sacrifices after the Jews' restoration to Jerusalem, nor does it make Jerusalem's temple and the unbelieving Jews the sanctuary and people of God at the city's destruction in A.D. 70.RH Apr 5, 1864 The daily was taken away no more than thirty years before the papacy was established, and identifying it with the sacrifices stopped at Jerusalem's destruction conflicts with the 1,290-day period which would then end in 1360.RH Apr 5, 1864 Dating the prophetic periods from the removal of Jewish worship, whether literally or figuratively, leads to no notable event.ST Sep 9, 1880 The transgression of desolation is distinguished from the pagan Roman governments and sacrifices called the daily sacrifice and from the Roman armies and standards at Jerusalem's destruction.RH Dec 9, 1852 It is a particular desolating power, singular unlike the plural abominations in Daniel 9:27, and its setting up in the church is the jurisdiction of the papal governments and the Pope of Rome.RH Dec 9, 1852
The transgression is the same power as Daniel 7's little horn, the man of sin, and Revelation 13's beast.ST Jun 20, 1900ST Jun 20, 1900 This power is blasphemous and desolating, makes war on the saints and opposes God and true worship, fulfilled in the papacy's persecution of God's people and its history of desolating many of the holy people.ST Aug 17, 1915ST Jun 20, 1900 Its period of wasting power is the time, times and half a time, and though shorn of power by a deadly wound it continues until Christ appears when it is destroyed.ST Jun 20, 1900 As papal Roman power it is distinct from the pagan Roman power that overthrew Jerusalem.RH Dec 10, 1867 The desolating power trampling sanctuary and host is distinct from the Roman army described as the abominable desolation in Matthew 24:15, and the verse is not the prophecy Jesus refers to there.RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 10, 1867 The phrase in the verse is identified as papal Rome, while Matthew's phrase refers to pagan Rome that destroyed Jerusalem, similar in English but not describing the same power.RH Dec 10, 1867 The desolation here is identified with the desolation in Daniel 9, so the power responsible for the final desolation is Rome, not Mohammedism.RH May 1, 1856
The continual comprehends the entire service of the earthly sanctuary as ordained of God, offered every day and never omitted.ST Oct 13, 1909 It includes the morning and evening sacrifices about sixteen times called the continual burnt offering in Numbers 28 and 29, the continual showbread, the lamps to burn continually, the perpetual incense which is the same as continual, and the high priest bearing judgment continually.ST Oct 13, 1909 There are two sanctuaries, earthly and heavenly, the earthly with all its services a type or figure of the heavenly and the heavenly the pattern of the earthly, and before the first advent every question of sin and cleansing met its solution in and through the sanctuary.ST Oct 13, 1909 That earthly service being in all its appointments a figure of the heavenly sanctuary, the term continual applies with equal force to the sanctuary above, and indeed the entire force of the prophecy applies there because the earthly sanctuary with its priesthood had ended its operations before this power began its operations.ST Oct 13, 1909 The cleansing after 2,300 evenings and mornings is linked to the judgment and Day of Atonement when each case was decided, representing Christ's work in the heavenly sanctuary.
The continual burnt-offering means the true living service of God carried on by Christ as High Priest and Prince of the host in the heavenly sanctuary.RH Nov 18, 1909 Salvation is continuance, eternal life ministered through the Son in the sanctuary service, brought to the flesh in Jesus Christ ministering His own presence in the Holy Spirit, and daily refers to God's continual acknowledged service with Christ present and reigning in the church.RH Oct 29, 1903 The daily stands for the continual living connecting service between God and His people, applied to various parts of God's service.ST The question asks how long that true service will be obscured and the truth hidden, and for the limit set in the divine plan to this blasphemous work.STRH Nov 18, 1909 That limit is the end of the 2,300 days or years expiring in A.D. 1844 reckoned from B.C. 457, which marks the end of that treading down of sanctuary and host.RH Nov 18, 1909
That obscuring is done by the hostile little-horn power that casts down His sanctuary place and truth to the ground and eclipses His ministry.ST Sep 20, 1910RH Nov 18, 1909 Attention is turned aside from Christ the strength of heaven ministering as High Priest to an earthly service, earthly priests and the earthly sacrifice of the mass. To take away the continual is to pervert sanctuary truth by leaving out that vital principle of eternal life, putting leader, temple and priest on earth instead of heaven and cutting off connection with heaven, keeping the form while destroying salvation.RH Oct 29, 1903 It leaves a temple, priesthood, sacrifice and church without Christ and substitutes paganism for Christianity under Christian names, eclipsing the heavenly sanctuary and Christ's priestly service for centuries until the end of the prophetic period when sanctuary and host are delivered from oppression.ST Sep 20, 1910 This taking away has been done, and the threefold message restores what was taken away by giving Christ His own place and God in Christ His true place in the gospel, restoring the true sanctuary idea to church and world.RH Oct 29, 1903
That apostasy exalting itself against the Prince of the host is fulfilled in an earthly priestly system that makes earthly priests and altars appear the only way to approach the heavenly, including a vast communion centered in Rome under the Holy See.RH Jun 6, 1912 Christ's place in the church was taken away in 508 when human authority assumed His place, and this continued for 1,290 years until 1798. The Jewish apostasy and desolation foreshadowed the papal apostasy of the Dark Ages. The vision, given in the third and last year of Belshazzar at the beginning of Darius the Median, shows a power rising to take away the continual service so that for a time it ceases, the Shekinah departs and the house is left desolate.RH Nov 25, 1902 It prepares God's people not to let the word or decree of man interrupt continual worship and service.RH Nov 25, 1902
The taking away of the continual is the papacy taking away the real presence of Christ in the living temple.ST Dec 10, 1902 It strikes at justification by faith, changing the law of faith into works and substituting the mystery of iniquity for the mystery of godliness, the little-horn counterfeit of the mystery of godliness seeking universal spiritual rule as professed vicar of Christ.RH Sep 13, 1915ST Dec 10, 1902 The sixteenth-century Reformation was an attempt to restore this fundamental doctrine of the one Mediator and His one sacrifice, whose restoration causes all other mediators, sacrifices, saints, works, penances, masses and indulgences to vanish.ST Dec 10, 1902 The continual taken away is restored through Christ's death, mediation and atonement, after which the sanctuary is cleansed and God's truth revealed in simplicity and power.ST Apr 2, 1912 The final stage of restoration began at the close of the 2,300 days in 1844.ST Apr 2, 1912 The claim that their ending in 1822 marked the taking away of the daily sacrifice is unscriptural.RH Aug 7, 1860
Sanctuary Host and Treading
The sanctuary to be cleansed is not the earth or any part of it to be purified by fire at Christ's coming, not the church, not Canaan or Palestine, and not the long-destroyed earthly sanctuary, but God's sacred dwelling place, the true tabernacle in heaven of the new dispensation where Christ ministers by His own blood, of which the earthly tabernacle and temples were patterns.RH Mar 17, 1853ST Jun 26, 1907RH Mar 1, 1870RH Oct 30, 1855RH Jan 9, 1855 The earth is never called God's sanctuary in Scripture, being cursed and only His footstool, while the sanctuary is the definite holy dwelling God owns as His sanctuary, now the greater and more perfect tabernacle in heaven under the new covenant.RH Mar 1, 1870RH Jan 9, 1855 The cleansing promised in answer to the question is dependent on and the result of a ministration performed by means of blood, after the pattern of the earthly Day of Atonement in Leviticus 16 in which confessed sins borne into the sanctuary by blood were removed by blood and placed on the scapegoat, prefiguring the last great work of blotting out forever the sins of God's true Israel.RH Oct 30, 1855RH Jan 9, 1855 The church has not had either sanctuary or priesthood in old Jerusalem for the past 1800 years, but has had both sanctuary and priesthood elsewhere, in heaven.RH Nov 10, 1863
Only the first 400 to 490 years of the 2,300 belong to the first covenant, earthly sanctuary and Jewish church; the seventy weeks were allotted to the earthly sanctuary, and at their close the true sanctuary, its anointing, sacrifice, and minister were introduced.RH Jan 20, 1853RH Mar 2, 1852RH Oct 2, 1856ST May 27, 1880 At the end of those 400 years the Saviour accomplishes His ministry on earth and confirms the new covenant, and this transition came at the cross, when Christ's sacrifice replaced animal offerings, His priesthood replaced the Levitical priesthood, and the earthly sanctuary's shadow gave way to the true holy places in heaven.RH Jan 20, 1853RH Oct 2, 1856 Since the sanctuary still to be cleansed comes after earthly services ended, with 1810 years remaining after the seventy weeks, the prophecy applies to the new-covenant sanctuary connected with the New Jerusalem, the heavenly reality represented by the earthly type and pattern.RH Mar 2, 1852RH Oct 2, 1856ST May 27, 1880 Of the 2300 days only 490 days pertain to the earthly sanctuary and Jerusalem, while the rest extend into the ministry of the new-covenant sanctuary.ST Oct 22, 1874RH Mar 10, 1874
The word sanctuary ordinarily means the tabernacle or temple or, after they ceased to stand, what they represented, as in more than a hundred other texts; it is a habitation built for God to dwell in, erected inside its border or place, and the land of Canaan was only that border and dwelling-place of the people, not the sanctuary itself.RH Jan 6, 1853RH May 5, 1851 The use of sanctuary in this verse is disputed and is not included in one count of passages whose meaning is treated as established.RH May 5, 1851 Those who held a differing view argued the sanctuary in the vision must be capable of being trodden underfoot and cleansed and therefore identified it with the promised land, with its cleansing taking place at Christ's coming and the resurrection of the righteous dead. In that line the sanctuary trodden down was understood as the typical sanctuary, the temple desecrated and desolated by Israel's adversaries.RH Jan 1851 In another differing view the sanctuary was identified as the place of worship wherever God's people offer sincere praise, rather than a place confined to Jerusalem or Samaria, to be cleansed at the end of the 2300 days of the cruel powers that oppressed it.RH Jan 24, 1856
The verse must be studied with two desolations, two sanctuaries, and two hosts before it can be applied correctly, belonging to the same subject as the passages where the same words continual and desolation are used.ST Aug 3, 1915 There are two opposing sanctuaries in Daniel 8: the sanctuary in verse 13 is the sanctuary of Jehovah of hosts, the habitation of the only living and true God, distinct from the sanctuary of the daily desolation in verse 11, which is the sanctuary of Satan, the dwelling place of all the gods, exemplified by the Pantheon at Rome.RH Jan 6, 1853 The sanctuary of verse 13 is the one that the daily desolation, paganism, and the transgression of desolation, popery, were both to tread under foot, the same sanctuary of verse 14, and the word sanctuary can rightly belong to heathen and idolatrous worship as well as to truth, so paganism and error have their own sanctuaries, temples, and asylums consecrated to their service.RH Jan 6, 1853 The verse thus distinguishes their sanctuary, associated with counterfeit worship, from the sanctuary of the living God that they oppress.ST Aug 3, 1915
There are also two hosts: Satan's forces, given to the little horn and associated with the rival sanctuary and the daily desolation, and the host of heaven, the church of God, associated with Jehovah's sanctuary, represented as a host under attack with Michael, identified with Christ, as its Prince.RH Jan 6, 1853 The host given to the little horn against the daily is the forces of Satan, associated with the sanctuary of the daily desolation; the other host is the host of heaven, whose Prince is Michael, and in historical application the Roman Empire's forces, guided by the popes, suppressed paganism and helped transfer its sanctuary and services to the abomination of desolation.ST Aug 3, 1915 The host given to Rome in that history was the barbarian peoples who overran the empire and adopted the papal faith, while the question about the vision's duration leads to the 2,300 days and the sanctuary's cleansing.ST May 10, 1877
The host joined with the sanctuary is the church, God's people or worshipers related to the sanctuary, distinct and separate from the sanctuary itself, so the church cannot be the sanctuary; the host meant the Jews when given and Christians in the Christian era.ST Nov 13, 1879RH Mar 1, 1870RH Nov 10, 1863RH Mar 11, 1858 The host is the worshipers connected with the sanctuary, and the church has had neither sanctuary nor priesthood in earthly Jerusalem for about 1,800 years, but has had both in heaven under Christ's priesthood.RH Mar 11, 1858RH Jan 20, 1853RH Mar 1, 1870 Worshipers are never admitted inside the sanctuary but worship outside while the Priest alone goes inside on their behalf, as in the past dispensation.
Trodden under foot is figurative, not literal stamping, meaning to oppress or act against another's interests and honor; both sanctuary and worshipers can be so trodden, as in the little horn's casting down of the truth and the stars and destroying the mighty and holy people in Daniel 8:24, and as in Hebrews 10:29 treating the Son of God with contempt by rejecting Him and regarding the covenant blood as unholy.RH Mar 11, 1858RH Sep 1, 1863 Being trodden does not mean wicked men or angels entering heaven and ruling there or trampling a heavenly building in dust; heavenly things are trodden under foot by earthly dishonor and rejection, just as Christ is crucified afresh and trodden under foot after His ascension and entrance into the heavenly sanctuary.RH Mar 28, 1854RH Apr 6, 1869 As apostates tread Christ its minister under foot by rejecting His blood and showing contempt for the Spirit of grace, they tread the sanctuary He ministers in, which is no more difficult to understand than Christ Himself being trodden underfoot.RH Apr 6, 1869ST Oct 22, 1874
The heavenly sanctuary is trodden when people reject Jesus, its minister, and look instead to human powers for forgiveness and life, and the true church that looks to Jesus in the heavenly sanctuary is likewise trodden down when rejected and persecuted.ST Jul 1, 1880RH Feb 3, 1853RH Jan 1851 The daily and the transgression of desolation represent paganism and papacy, which oppose God's worship by setting up rival sanctuaries and turning people from the heavenly sanctuary and Christ's ministry there, wearing out the saints and blaspheming God and those in heaven.ST Jul 1, 1880RH Feb 3, 1853 This applies to Rome's claims and practices, to Protestant spiritualizing that denies the personal Father and Son and the literal heavenly city and sanctuary, and to teaching that identifies the sanctuary to be cleansed at the end of the 2300 days as the promised land.RH Jan 1851
The pope has trodden the heavenly sanctuary by calling his own sanctuary at Rome the temple of God and the Holy or Eternal City to displace the heavenly city, turning the worship of men away from the temple of God in heaven to his own sanctuary, exalting himself above all that is called God and assuming to be head of the church in place of Jesus Christ.RH Mar 28, 1854RH Mar 24, 1910 The treading under foot is the papacy substituting a sanctuary of its own, a priesthood of its own, and forms of its own for the heavenly sanctuary where Christ ministers as great High Priest for the repentant and believing sinner, shutting away knowledge of the true service for many centuries.RH Nov 18, 1909RH Nov 18, 1909 Instead of pointing sinners to the heavenly sanctuary, the man of sin for many centuries held the place in the temple that belongs to Christ, putting forms and ceremonies in place of heart religion.RH Nov 18, 1909RH Nov 18, 1909
The papacy treads sanctuary and host by continuing the pagan Pontifex Maximus as head of the Roman priesthood, taking away the mediation of Christ and substituting a system of human mediation in its place, displacing Christ's sacrifice and drawing people away from direct reliance on God to human priests, the pope, Mary, and dead saints.RH Jun 11, 1901RH Apr 10, 1916 The papal power treads the host under foot by making war upon the saints and treads the sanctuary under foot by making war upon the tabernacle of God in heaven, blaspheming God, His heavenly tabernacle, and those who dwell in heaven, claiming divine powers and turning the worship of them that dwell on the earth from the temple of God in heaven to its own sanctuary at Rome.RH Mar 11, 1858 It treads under foot the Son of God by making the pope vicegerent of the Son of God and head of the church instead of Christ, leading men to worship this son of perdition as able like God to forgive past sins and to go beyond God in forgiving sins before their commission. That earthly priesthood claiming by right to succeed the Levitical order, begun in the mystery of iniquity and grown into the apostate church, so completely eclipsed and shut away the sanctuary and service of Christ in heaven that even the most enlightened Christians knew nothing of that sanctuary or its services after three centuries of Protestant gospel light.ST Oct 13, 1909 The ministry of Christ was thus set aside in favor of a service invented by man, with a Roman priesthood substituted and the people's understanding of Christ's mediation taken away as far as possible, permitted because of transgression, continuing until the time announced to Daniel arrived.RH Sep 1, 1863RH Oct 11, 1915RH May 28, 1908
Satan treads the sanctuary by erecting rival sanctuaries turning mankind to false worship in every age: in the Philistine temple holding the taken ark in the days of the Judges and Samuel, in Jeroboam's Bethel with calves against Solomon's temple on Mount Moriah drawing ten tribes away, in Belus in Babylon holding God's vessels in Nebuchadnezzar's day, and after the type gave place to the true, in the baptized Pantheon, temple of all the gods, and a temple at Rome with its own contents, service, and papal abomination.RH Nov 10, 1863 The treading under foot is the work of Satan through paganism and papacy as two agents acting as the little horn, Rome through both its pagan and papal phases, with the daily as pagan Rome giving place to papal Rome as the transgression of desolation.RH Nov 10, 1863RH Jun 28, 1870RH Nov 10, 1863RH Jul 30, 1867 The papal martyrdom of the saints is that same treading, indignation, and scattering of the holy people's power, whose wonders end with the three and a half times marking completion of the indignation.RH Mar 11, 1858RH Jul 30, 1867
The verse points to removal of the earthly sanctuary service when Jerusalem was taken by ancient Babylon, foreshadowing modern Babylon's removal of Christ's mediation in the heavenly sanctuary and replacing it with another ecclesiastical system corrupting the gospel, exposing the papacy's work and setting a limit on its permitted power.RH Oct 11, 1915 The sanctuary and the host are connected with Jerusalem and the Lord's people, and the sanctuary's cleansing means their iniquity is pardoned and removed before Christ appears and before His people are delivered and enter the New Jerusalem; the completion of this work is a message of comfort to them.RH Oct 14, 1852
Sources