Genesis 25:32
And Esau said, Behold, I am at the point to die: and what profit shall this birthright do to me?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And Esau said, Behold, I am at the point to die: and what profit shall this birthright do to me?
And Esau said, Behold, I am at the point to die: and what profit shall this birth-right bring to me?
And Esau said, Behold, I am at the point to die: and what profit shall the birthright do to me?
And Esau said, Behold, I am about to die: and what profit shall the birthright do to me?
And Esau saith, 'Lo, I am going to die, and what is this to me — birthright?'
And Esau said, Behold, I am going to die, and of what use can the birthright be to me?
And Esau said, Here am I, on the point of dying,—wherefore, then, should I, have, a birthright?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Look,” said Esau, “ I am about to die, so what good is a birthright to me?”
Esau said, “ Behold, I am about to die. What good is the birthright to me?”
And Esau said, Truly, I am at the point of death: what profit is the birthright to me?
And Esau sayd, Lo, I am almost dead, what is then this birthright to me?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
He answered: Lo I die, what will the first birthright avail me?
Pictures




Cross-references 20 of 21
- Hebrews 12:16-17
Lest there be any fornicator, or profane person, as Esau, who for one morsel of meat sold his birthright.
Esau sold his birthright for a meal and later could not regain the blessing.
- Genesis 27:1-40
And it came to pass, that when Isaac was old, and his eyes were dim, so that he could not see, he called Esau his eldest son, and said unto him, My son: and he said unto him, Behold, here am I.
Jacob’s deceit in obtaining Isaac’s blessing follows his purchase of Esau’s birthright.
- Matthew 16:26
For what is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?
Both weigh worldly gain against the loss of lasting spiritual value.
- Genesis 25:23
And the LORD said unto her, Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels; and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger.
The promise that the elder would serve the younger frames the birthright dispute.
- Hebrews 12:17
For ye know how that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
Esau’s later plea for the blessing was rejected after he sold his birthright.
- Romans 9:13
As it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated.
God’s love for Jacob and rejection of Esau explain the choice of the younger over the elder.
- Genesis 27:36
And he said, Is not he rightly named Jacob? for he hath supplanted me these two times: he took away my birthright; and, behold, now he hath taken away my blessing. And he said, Hast thou not reserved a blessing for me?
Esau recalls selling his birthright and grieves that Jacob has taken his blessing.
- Genesis 27:41
And Esau hated Jacob because of the blessing wherewith his father blessed him: and Esau said in his heart, The days of mourning for my father are at hand; then will I slay my brother Jacob.
Esau’s threat against Jacob drove Jacob to flee.
- Malachi 1:2-3
I have loved you, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? Was not Esau Jacob’s brother? saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob,
God’s words about Jacob and Esau reflect their choices and character.
- Genesis 27:27-29
And he came near, and kissed him: and he smelled the smell of his raiment, and blessed him, and said, See, the smell of my son is as the smell of a field which the LORD hath blessed:
The birthright purchase gave Jacob the right to the blessing.
- Joshua 24:4
And I gave unto Isaac Jacob and Esau: and I gave unto Esau mount Seir, to possess it; but Jacob and his children went down into Egypt.
Esau received Mount Seir after choosing present gain over his birthright.
- Genesis 36:1
Now these are the generations of Esau, who is Edom.
Identifies Esau as the ancestor of the Edomites.
- Genesis 27:19
And Jacob said unto his father, I am Esau thy firstborn; I have done according as thou badest me: arise, I pray thee, sit and eat of my venison, that thy soul may bless me.
Jacob continues the deception to obtain the elder’s blessing.
- Matthew 1:1-16
The book of the generation of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham.
The genealogy traces Jesus through Jacob, not Esau.
- 1 Chronicles 5:1-2
Now the sons of Reuben the firstborn of Israel, (for he was the firstborn; but, forasmuch as he defiled his father’s bed, his birthright was given unto the sons of Joseph the son of Israel: and the genealogy is not to be reckoned after the birthright.
Describes the transfer and division of the birthright.
- Mark 8:36-37
For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?
both warn against trading the soul for temporal gain
- Genesis 25:28
And Isaac loved Esau, because he did eat of his venison: but Rebekah loved Jacob.
Isaac favored Esau, while Rebekah favored Jacob.
- Genesis 36:6-7
And Esau took his wives, and his sons, and his daughters, and all the persons of his house, and his cattle, and all his beasts, and all his substance, which he had got in the land of Canaan; and went into the country from the face of his brother Jacob.
Esau’s wealth leads the brothers to part over their possessions.
- Genesis 25:5-6
And Abraham gave all that he had unto Isaac.
Ishmael gift contrasted with Isaac inheritance
- Genesis 32:6-7
And the messengers returned to Jacob, saying, We came to thy brother Esau, and also he cometh to meet thee, and four hundred men with him.
Esau’s birthright injury leads Jacob to fear his revenge.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
49 sources
Esau came in faint with intense hunger and believed he would suffer greatly or even die without the food he craved, so his question treated the birthright as worthless beside his immediate need because its value lay in the future and he valued present relief more.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6PP 179.1–2CH 110.2ST Apr 17, 1879SG3 113.2 What he surrendered was the peculiar honor, authority, consecration to God, priestly office, double portion, and blessing of possession belonging to the firstborn.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Dec 4, 1879 Indulged appetite overpowered his judgment until desire ruled him, revealing a profane indifference that lightly valued what was sacred and preferred momentary earthly indulgence to the future spiritual inheritance God had promised.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2Lt 5, 1877, par. 16CTBH 43.1–44.2PP 181.3–182.1 He recklessly gave up a lasting spiritual good for a meal to satisfy present appetite, imagining he could regain it later, but once despised and surrendered it could not be recovered even when sought earnestly with tears and bitter remorse, for his grief was over its consequences and not true repentance of a changed heart.CH 110.26MR 160.32SP 205.2–206.110MR 190.1–194.1Ms 56, 1900, par. 16–17 The birthright represents the heavenly inheritance, eternal life, and redemption purchased by Christ, and his course warns that multitudes repeat his bargain by trading heirship to heaven for appetite, selfish pleasure, money, position, or other present advantage and will awake too late to find no place for repentance.2T 37.3–38.21SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.14T 31.2–32.1
Setting and Words
Esau came in faint from the field with intense hunger and believed he would suffer great hardship or even die without the food he craved.CH 110.2ST Apr 17, 1879SG3 113.21SP 106.1CTBH 43.1–44.2 His cry that he was at the point to die was the claim of a man who thought his immediate need left him no future in which a distant privilege could help him.SG3 113.21SP 106.1Lt 98a, 1897, par. 1–6 His question about what profit the birthright would do him meant he treated it as worthless beside present relief, because its value lay in the future and he valued present satisfaction more.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6PP 179.1–2SG3 113.21SP 106.1Lt 5, 1877, par. 16 He passed over it as a matter worthy of scarcely a thought, valuing a morsel of meat to meet his present wants more than lasting privilege.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6Lt 5, 1877, par. 16SG3 114.1
What he surrendered in that exchange was the peculiar advantages and special privileges of the firstborn.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Dec 4, 1879 These were honor and authority in family and tribe next to the parents, consecration to God and selection to the priestly office, a double portion of the father's goods, and the blessing of possession.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Dec 4, 1879 Jacob used Esau's faintness and necessity to his own advantage, offering pottage on condition that Esau renounce all claim to the birthright.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Apr 24, 1879ST Feb 24, 1887 The reckless bargain was then bound with a solemn oath that Jacob should have the birthright.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Apr 24, 1879
Jacob had been taught from God's word by his mother that the elder should serve the younger, and reasoned in his youth that the promise could not be fulfilled while Esau kept those advantages.ST Apr 17, 1879 God's promise would have been fulfilled in its proper time if Jacob had been willing to wait in faith.ST Jul 31, 1884 Instead, lacking faith, he tried to secure for himself what God had promised and obtained his brother's birthright and blessing by fraud, and that obtaining by fraud was sin.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Nov 17, 1909PP 201.3–202.2 That wrongdoing brought hatred and lasting consequences, requiring true repentance afterward before God could hear his prayer for deliverance and mercifully preserve his life.ST Nov 17, 1909PP 201.3–202.2
After Jacob became wealthy he returned that material blessing of possession to Esau.ST Dec 4, 1879 At their father's deathbed the two brothers met in united grief, with Esau's former purpose to be revenged for the stolen blessing changed.ST Dec 4, 1879 They were no longer separated by enmity, jealousy and hatred, and parted only because their possessions were too great and their religious faith too unlike for them to live together.ST Dec 4, 1879
Heart Behind Bargain
Indulged appetite overpowered judgment and every other consideration, so that desire and inclination ruled and a morsel of meat seemed more important than lasting blessing.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2CTBH 43.1–44.2Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 Hunger made present relief feel like a matter of suffering greatly or even dying without the craved food, and beside that urgency the birthright was treated as worthless.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2CTBH 43.1–44.2 What was surrendered was sacred and eternal, yet it was made to appear less valuable than immediate comfort and present satisfaction.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2
The exchange was the crisis of life, passed without knowing it, and the act laid bare prevailing traits, choices, and the true estimate of what was sacred and should have been sacredly cherished.Lt 5, 1877, par. 16 Indifference to divine blessings and requirements made the seller profane, lightly valuing the birthright and trading it for momentary gratification of unrestrained appetite.PP 181.3–182.1Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 A small indulgence to meet present wants was valued more than the service of the Master.Lt 5, 1877, par. 16Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42
Momentary earthly indulgence and worldly pleasure were preferred to the future spiritual inheritance promised by God.PP 179.1–2ST Jun 20, 1900PP 181.3–182.1 Life was lived only for the present with no thought for the future, as if to eat and drink because tomorrow brings death, controlled by inclination and refusing self-denial.PP 181.3–182.1 That decision determined the aftercourse of life.Lt 5, 1877, par. 16
Irreversible Loss Foretold
Esau sold his birthright for a single meal to satisfy present hunger, treating a lasting spiritual good as worthless beside immediate appetite.6MR 160.310MR 190.1–194.1Ms 56, 1900, par. 16–17 His exchange was reckless, choosing personal desire and self-gratification over loyalty to God and surrendering something sacred for a cheap, temporary gain.6MR 160.310MR 190.1–194.1 It is the same folly as spending means on outward display instead of valuing inward Christian graces.Ms 56, 1900, par. 16–17
He believed he would suffer greatly or even die without the food he craved, so appetite overpowered judgment and every other consideration.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2CTBH 43.1–44.2 In that state he counted the birthright as having no value and bartered it away, imagining he might buy the blessing back later.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2CTBH 43.1–44.2 Once despised and surrendered it could not be regained even at great cost, even when sought earnestly with tears and bitter remorse over his rashness.CH 110.22T 37.3–38.2CTBH 43.1–44.2Lt 98a, 1897, par. 1–6Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 To gratify carnal desire for one morsel of meat is to sell the soul, sell peace, sacrifice integrity for selfish advantage, walk unguarded into snares, and become profane and failing of grace.Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 The same danger faces those who know present truth and whose names are registered on church books when inclination rules them and they gratify selfish desires, which calls for close inspection of motives, actions and daily influence and for departing from all iniquity.Lt 98a, 1897, par. 1–6Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42
His grief afterward came from the unexpected consequences of his sin and loss, not from true repentance.2SP 205.2–206.1ST Apr 19, 1877 Sorrow over guilt or loss is not godly sorrow when the heart remains unchanged.2SP 205.2–206.1
His reckless bargain, bound with a solemn oath that the birthright should pass for pottage, stands as a warning that people trade their inheritance of heaven for appetite, corrupt passions and other selfish pleasures.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1PP 181.3–182.1Lt 23, 1890, par. 6–7 He represents those who lightly value the redemption purchased for them and sacrifice heirship to heaven for perishable earthly things, living only for the present with no thought for the future.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 When gratification of depraved appetite must be yielded or the high heavenly blessings promised only to the self-denying and God-fearing be lost, the clamors of appetite generally prevail.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 Many controlled by inclination refuse to deny unhealthy appetite, sacrifice health, enfeeble mental faculties, benumb the finer sensibilities of the soul with tea, coffee, snuff, tobacco, spirits and other selfish gratifications and hurtful lusts, and virtually despise God and heaven.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 Even professed Christians told they cannot have heaven with these hurtful indulgences and must cleanse themselves from all filthiness of flesh and spirit are offended and abandon the straight way because they will not give them up.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 Multitudes thus sell their birthright for mere temporary pleasure that weakens and debases, and as Esau awoke too late to see the folly of his rash exchange when his loss could not be recovered and his great distress when the blessing passed could not remedy the matter, so in the day of God those who bartered away their heirship will awake too late and find no place for repentance although they seek it carefully and with tears.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1PP 181.3–182.1Lt 23, 1890, par. 6–7
What Birthright Signifies
The birthright stands for the heavenly inheritance, eternal life itself, and the redemption purchased by Christ, and to sell it is to sacrifice heirship to heaven for perishable earthly things and to lose the soul for a small temporal gain.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1Lt 25, 1873, par. 4–5Lt 7, 1864, par. 10–12 Esau's question treats it as worthless because he believes he is near death, reckoning its future value as nothing beside immediate hunger, and that reckoning is repeated whenever present appetite and corrupt passions are allowed to prevail over high and heavenly blessings promised only to the self-denying.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1 It is selling everlasting life and eternal riches for temporary worldly satisfaction, for worldly position or praise, for holding to earthly treasures instead of laying up treasure in heaven, and for withholding from God His own in tithes and offerings.5T 274.3Lt 25, 1873, par. 4–5Lt 7, 1864, par. 10–12 Those who make that exchange strengthen love of the world, hinder the preparing of a people to stand when the Son of man is revealed, bring a curse for failing to render to God His own, and keep worldly-mindedness, wrong words and uncontrolled temper instead of being refined, purified and hid in the day of trouble.5T 274.3Lt 7, 1864, par. 10–12 They may later grieve the bargain when it is too late to recover what was surrendered, finding no place for repentance though sought carefully and with tears when judgment comes.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1
The birthright is life that measures with the life of God, while the pottage is room for self instead of room for Jesus, light, love, meekness and lowliness of heart.Lt 17a, 1891, par. 25–26 To sell eternal interest for that cheap price is to depart from the living God for enthroned and worshiped self.Lt 17a, 1891, par. 25–26 The loss sets life and death before the seller and demands choosing that day whom to serve, with repentance, conversion, renewal of covenant at the cross of Calvary, cleansing of the soul-temple from moral defilement, and death to self by crucifying self.Lt 17a, 1891, par. 25–26 If self is not crucified, the life that measures with the life of God is lost.Lt 17a, 1891, par. 25–26
The birthright also stands for a God-given privilege, responsibility and sacred inheritance entrusted for the blessing of humanity, including knowledge of biblical truth and abilities to be used for good.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6Ms 14a, 1897, par. 13–14Lt 170, 1899, par. 28–30 To treat it as having no value beside immediate need and appetite is Esau's folly, and to neglect it and fail to use those abilities is to nearly sell it.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6Lt 170, 1899, par. 28–30 Selling it for food warns against wasting that inheritance through intemperate appetite or through greed for money and dishonest practices.Ms 14a, 1897, par. 13–14 Giving large sums to another to manage according to that person's judgment repeats the same neglect, because it surrenders the giver's own stewardship of entrusted means as Esau surrendered his birthright for a meal.Lt 170, 1899, par. 28–30
Selling the birthright means yielding to impulse and unconsecrated passion, trading loyalty to God for a desired object, selling peace and integrity for selfish advantage, and walking unguarded into snares.Lt 17, 1896, par. 8–9Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42Lt 63, 1896, par. 16 It is a selfish act to gratify carnal desire for one morsel of meat that sells the soul while gaining only a small temporal thing, making the seller profane and failing of the grace of God.Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42Lt 63, 1896, par. 16 The same cheap sale is made in choosing an unbelieving wife over God, yielding up His claims and promising to give up His Sabbath to obtain consent to marry, which sells God in a very cheap market, imperils the soul, brings the reproach of disloyalty, brings unhappiness into the family, and destroys the respect a wife ought to feel for her husband.Lt 17, 1896, par. 8–9 The loss reaches beyond the seller, for corrupt words, example and false principles draw others away from Christ into perplexity and destruction instead of healing and saving them, so motives, actions and daily influence must be closely inspected and all iniquity departed from.Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42Lt 63, 1896, par. 16
Present-Day Warnings
Esau's question treats a sacred eternal inheritance as worthless beside immediate satisfaction of appetite, imagining it might be bought back later, yet once despised and surrendered it could not be regained even with bitter remorse.2T 37.3–38.2ST Apr 24, 1879 His course warns that when gratification of depraved appetite must be yielded or the high heavenly blessings promised only to the self-denying and God-fearing be chosen, the clamors of appetite and corrupt passions generally prevail.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 Multitudes repeat it who are controlled by inclination and refuse to deny unhealthy appetite, sacrificing health, enfeebling mental faculties, benumbing the finer sensibilities of the soul with tea, coffee, snuff, tobacco, spirits and other selfish gratifications and hurtful lusts, and virtually despising God and heaven.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 Even professed Christians told they cannot have heaven with these hurtful indulgences and must cleanse themselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit and perfect holiness are offended and conclude they will no longer walk in the straight and strait way to eternal life.ST Apr 24, 1879PP 181.3–182.1 His example warns that uncontrolled appetite leads to yielding temptation and turning from truth, and warns the youth not to waste their God-given inheritance or betray sacred interests through intemperance and greed, for many repeat his trading of spiritual inheritance for indulgence through intemperate habits.4T 31.2–32.1Lt 83, 1897, par. 17–20Ms 34, 1902, par. 9–12
Students make the same exchange when they pursue education but neglect prayer, religious duties, and responsibility to others, for knowledge gained at that cost defeats its purpose.CE 246.1–2 Seeking education from selfish ambition and inclination while neglecting duties to parents, home burdens, faithfulness in little things, and the interest of the soul imitates Esau holding his birthright cheap and bartering it away for pottage to satisfy present appetite, valuing immediate inclination above lasting blessing at infinite loss and bartering away heaven just as cheaply.CE 246.1–2Ms 2, 1871, par. 13–15
The verse warns against trading spiritual privilege and hope of heaven and eternal life for money, worldly position, praise, influence or other present advantage and temporal interests.Lt 15, 1898, par. 17–19Lt 25, 1873, par. 4–5Lt 59, 1903, par. 7–11 It means holding to earthly treasures instead of laying up treasure in heaven, and withholding from God the proportion that belongs to Him in tithes and offerings, which strengthens love of the world, hinders the work of preparing a people to stand in the day when the Son of man shall be revealed, and brings the curse of the Lord for failing to render to Him His own.5T 274.3 Those who fail to cultivate strict integrity likewise sell their birthright by seeking gain through questionable dealings, and the birthright as sacred inheritance entrusted for blessing warns against wasting it through intemperate appetite or greed for money and dishonest practices.Lt 110, 1897, par. 36Ms 14a, 1897, par. 13–14 Eternal life is worth every sacrifice, and giving it up for human honor means losing it.Lt 25, 1873, par. 4–5
The same cheap sale occurs in yielding to impulse and unconsecrated passion and trading loyalty to God for a desired object by choosing an unbelieving wife over God, yielding up the claims of God and promising to give up the Sabbath to obtain her consent, which sells God in a very cheap market, imperils the soul, brings reproach of disloyalty, unhappiness into the family, and destroys the respect a wife ought to feel for her husband.Lt 17, 1896, par. 8–9 Selling the meal for immediate need also represents choosing friendship with the Lord's enemies over spiritual inheritance.Lt 1, 1880, par. 14 People, including ministers, may thus give up their sacred inheritance for a passing desire or gain, and the verse warns against trading soul and eternal welfare for financial relief or revenge and becoming a traitor to God for temporary gain.Lt 13, 1900, par. 7–8Lt 15, 1898, par. 1–5
Other forms include giving large sums to another to manage according to that person's judgment instead of exercising one's own stewardship, which neglects the giver's own stewardship of entrusted means like Esau selling his birthright for a meal.Lt 170, 1899, par. 28–30 His choice foolishly surrendering lasting spiritual inheritance for temporary satisfaction is like spending money on outward display instead of valuing inward Christian graces.Ms 56, 1900, par. 16–17 Knowledge of biblical truth is also a birthright that can nearly be sold through neglect and failure to use one's abilities for good.Lt 111, 1899, par. 6 A selfish act to gratify carnal desire for one morsel sells the soul, sells peace, sacrifices integrity for selfish advantage, walks unguarded into snares, and makes a man profane and failing of grace, facing the same danger as those who know present truth and whose names are on church books yet gratify desires for selfish influences, calling for close inspection of motives, actions and daily influence and departing from all iniquity since Esau after gratification regretted it yet when he would have inherited the blessing was rejected and found no place of repentance though he sought it carefully with tears.Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 Gaining a small temporal thing while losing the soul reaches beyond oneself, for corrupt words, example and false principles draw others away from Christ into perplexity and destruction instead of healing and saving them.Lt 63, 1896, par. 16
In sum the verse illustrates selling eternal interests and everlasting life for a cheap, temporary price and worldly satisfaction, warning no one to sell the soul for what is temporary.Lt 7, 1864, par. 10–1218MR 245.3–247.2Lt 117, 1897, par. 8–10 It shows treating what is lasting and sacred as worthless beside immediate self-gratification and appetite, surrendering something sacred for cheap temporary gain, trading lasting spiritual good for temporary desire where repentance may come too late.18MR 245.3–247.210MR 190.1–194.1Lt 23, 1890, par. 6–7 To keep worldly mindedness, wrong and thoughtless words, and uncontrolled temper instead of reforming, being refined by grace, purified, made white and tried, and being prepared to be hid in the day of trouble and made fit for angels and Jesus is to make Esau's bargain now.Lt 7, 1864, par. 10–12
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
132 sources
Esau came in faint from the field to find Jacob with lentil pottage, and when Jacob demanded the birthright that day Esau answered that he was at the point to die and asked what profit it would do him, then swore to him and sold it for bread and pottage and went his way despising it.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Mar 30, 1888ST Mar 14, 1906 His plea of dying was an exaggeration, for he was only hungry and faint and not in real danger of death, and could have endured longer or found food otherwise.ST Oct 21, 1886ST Feb 19, 1894ST Feb 19, 1894 What he threw away was great, the firstborn's double share and honor and priesthood with headship of the family, and above all the covenant of Heaven's favor made with Abraham and Isaac and the chosen line through which blessing and the Messiah would come.ST Mar 25, 1880RH Jul 22, 1873RH Sep 21, 1911ST Mar 31, 1881ST Feb 19, 1894 He understood its worth yet counted it worthless beside present hunger, trading a lasting spiritual inheritance grasped by faith for a small immediate gratification.ST Feb 19, 1894ST Sep 22, 1898RH Jun 10, 1902ST Feb 14, 1884ST Mar 30, 1888 That brief indulgence brought irreversible loss, sought afterward with bitter tears to no avail, warning against selling the heavenly birthright for appetite, worldly gain, or present ease.ST Apr 24, 1879RH May 15, 1866RH May 15, 1866RH Jul 25, 1912
Words and Narrative Setting
Esau came in faint from the field while Jacob had cooked lentil pottage, and Jacob demanded the birthright that very day.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Mar 30, 1888 Esau answered that he was at the point to die and asked what profit the birthright would do him, then swore to Jacob and sold it for bread and pottage, ate and drank, rose up and went his way despising it.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Feb 26, 1894ST Feb 26, 1894 He is therefore identified as the one who sold his birthright for a mess of pottage, and his sale closes the account of Jacob and Esau.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Oct 4, 1905ST Feb 26, 1894
His plea of dying was exaggerated, for he was only hungry and faint and not in real danger of dying.ST Feb 19, 1894ST Feb 19, 1894ST Feb 19, 1894 He could have endured hunger longer or prepared food for himself, and his parents would have supplied his needs.ST Oct 21, 1886ST Feb 19, 1894ST Feb 19, 1894 He knew his father loved him and would provide for him, yet impatient and unreasoning he sold the inheritance for food.ST Oct 21, 1886ST Mar 7, 1906
He well understood the law of birthright and knew it conferred great privileges and blessings.ST Feb 14, 1884 He counted immediate food for his hunger, the law of pottage, as more important than that Heaven-given right.ST Feb 14, 1884 His words about dying and profit were an excuse by which he quieted his conscience for despising it to satisfy present bread-and-butter need.ST Feb 14, 1884
He spoke hastily without thought when faint and ruled by passionate desire for the red pottage.RH Aug 27, 1901 Determined to have what he wanted at any cost, he lost all reason so that he could see only the desire of the moment.RH Aug 27, 1901 He reasoned the birthright would profit him nothing if he died, and so sold it for one morsel of meat.RH Aug 27, 1901
His hunger was about to be relieved, yet he sold because he despised the right.RH Apr 14, 1859 He did not expect the sale to cost him the birthright, but intended to obtain the food and still inherit the blessing.RH Apr 14, 1859 His anguish came when he discovered that the careless choice had irreversibly cost him what was beyond price.RH Apr 14, 1859
The red pottage in the bargain is the red dahl still eaten extensively as a simple staple food with rice and wheat, plain to foreigners at first but liked after a time.ST Mar 14, 1906
The birthright and the blessing were distinct.ST He had already sold the former, which he foolishly failed to value, yet still coveted the latter and hoped to gain his father's blessing by pleasing him with food.ST
The chapter forecasts the contrasting characters of Esau and Jacob and shows God's providence at work in Isaac's family.ST Jan 9, 1912 It belongs to God's providential dealings with Abraham's family as the chosen family through which the Seed would come, carrying the promises from Abraham to Isaac to Jacob.STST Jan 14, 1913 It establishes that the Messiah descended from Jacob, not Esau.RH Nov 18, 1862
The aged father's overfond affection for Esau helped neither son and drew stronger sympathy from the mother for Jacob, bringing division.ST Jan 14, 1913 The mother knew God's promise would be manifest through Jacob and kept the Seed before him in a material way without fullest appreciation of the spiritual blessings, so Jacob's grasping was material overreaching that fits his name supplanter.ST Jan 14, 1913 That poor early experience, with Rebekah helping Jacob deceive Isaac from failure of faith, left Jacob with an unsatisfactory course that cost him much afterward, yet God in mercy brings a change.ST Jan 14, 1913ST Feb 17, 1914 His fraud to obtain what he coveted brought hatred and lasting consequences, leaving Esau wrathful with deadly threats and Jacob conscious of guilt and fearing bloody revenge, bringing separation, tears, heartache, guilt and sorrow to the old patriarch.ST Jun 12, 1884RH Jan 7, 1915 Coveting the birthright and blessing for temporal rather than spiritual ends drove him as an exile from his parents' home to become a wanderer, lonely and sad with conscience smitten, hurrying over four hundred miles from Beersheba toward Haran with Esau the fierce hunter possibly trailing close behind him.ST Oct 4, 1905 After Jacob became wealthy he returned the material blessing of possession to Esau, and at their father's deathbed the brothers met in united grief with enmity, jealousy and hatred changed, parting only because their possessions were too great and their faith too unlike to live together.ST Dec 4, 1879
What the Birthright Contained
The birthright Esau gave up for bread and lentil pottage, which he ate and drank before going his way, was a great hereditary possession in three parts: his father's chief blessing and special consecration to the Lord, a double share of his father's estate twice as large as his brother's, and the right to succeed to his father's official dignities and privileges.ST Mar 25, 1880RH Jul 22, 1873 To trade all this for a single meal that saved his life, only a morsel of pottage, was the height of folly and a poor bargain.ST Mar 25, 1880RH Jul 22, 1873 Those who now trade away standing in society, a once happy home, and hope of an inheritance with the redeemed for drink and for indulging the cravings of a perverted appetite receive far less in return than Esau did.ST Mar 25, 1880RH Jul 22, 1873
It included a double portion of the father's estate, the family priesthood, and the honor of becoming an ancestor of Christ, and Jacob received all of it except the double portion of the estate.RH Sep 21, 1911 The first-born's peculiar advantages were special privileges of honor and authority in family and tribe next to the parents, consecration to God and selection to the priest's office, and a double portion of the father's goods.ST Apr 17, 1879 It belonged to the first-born and carried a double portion of the inheritance, succession to whatever position his father held, and special spiritual blessings, since the first-born was regarded as especially devoted to God at a time when God's chosen people were the church of that time.ST Mar 30, 1888 It carried inheritance, family priesthood, and pre-eminence, with a double share of property and authority in the family.ST May 17, 1910
In Isaac's family it carried the family headship and the privilege of continuing the chosen line through which all families of the earth would be blessed, including the roles of prophet, priest, and king.ST Feb 19, 1894 In this family it was the line through which Christ would come and the race's salvation would be provided.ST May 17, 1910 The birthright he threw away was the covenant of Heaven's favor, which he understood and saw but despised in unbelief in his heart: God's covenant with Abraham and Isaac of the possession of the land of Canaan to them and their posterity, and the heavenly inheritance of which Canaan was the earnest and representation.ST Mar 31, 1881 He counted the fat valleys, Zion, Lebanon and the whole possession of Canaan a worthless toy beside a mess of pottage for an hour's gratification, and renounced his claim to God's kind care in this life and a heavenly paradise hereafter for what works the bitterness of death forever.ST Mar 31, 1881
Being called firstborn can refer to preeminence rather than birth order, since Jacob is called the firstborn despite Esau being older.ST Jan 11, 1905
Esau's Contempt and Unbelief
Esau counted his birthright as worthless beside his immediate hunger, reasoning that it could do him no good if he was about to die.ST Feb 19, 1894ST Sep 22, 1898ST Feb 19, 1894ST Jan 6, 1909ST Mar 24, 1898 Hungry and faint, he set present relief from food above lasting value, choosing a meal over his inheritance and letting appetite take priority over spiritual worth.RH Jun 10, 1902ST Feb 19, 1894ST Jan 6, 1909ST Mar 24, 1898 In this he exchanged a great future good and lasting spiritual privilege grasped by faith for a small present gratification, showing how sin leads people to discount what is grasped by faith in favor of what is immediately visible.RH Jun 10, 1902 His impulsive answer reveals disregard for a lasting inheritance in favor of present physical need.ST Feb 19, 1894ST Sep 22, 1898ST Jan 6, 1909
He came back faint and weary with enterprise dead in him and hope given over to peevish indolence and unsatisfied sensuality.ST Mar 31, 1881 As a slave of appetite he counted character, friends and prospects as nothing at that moment, and feigning himself ready to die of hunger he covenanted away all that was truly valuable to gratify gluttony for one meal, determined to have that dinner though it cost starving in perdition forever.ST Mar 31, 1881 The birthright he threw away was the covenant of Heaven's favor, which he understood and saw but despised in unbelief: God's covenant of the possession of the land of Canaan to Abraham and Isaac and their posterity, and the heavenly inheritance of which Canaan was the earnest and representation.ST Mar 31, 1881 He counted the fat valleys, Zion, Lebanon and the whole possession a worthless toy beside pottage, and renounced God's kind care in this life and a heavenly paradise hereafter for an hour's gratification that works the bitterness of death forever.ST Mar 31, 1881
His sale proved he had no trace of Abraham's faith and that he despised the promises of God.ST Mar 30, 1888 Counting the birthright as of no profit in the face of death and present want, he chose immediate gratification over future inheritance and revealed unbelief that the promises of God would profit one who should die for them.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Mar 30, 1888 With it he deliberately sold all claim to the promises made to Abraham and Isaac and afterwards to Jacob.ST Mar 30, 1888
His question means living by sight to satisfy sense, demanding pleasure and riches now and taking a portion in this life rather than waiting by faith for the inheritance reserved in heaven.RH Jun 3, 1858 It means taking a small present gift like Ishmael instead of waiting for the inheritance like Isaac, and selling a kingdom and oneself cheaply for momentary satisfaction.RH Jun 3, 1858 It is the opposite of leaving a possession to live upon a promise like the disciples, and of despising present treasures out of respect to future recompense like Moses, and it is the spirit of Dives enjoying good things here.RH Jun 3, 1858
He despised the promises and preferred whatever treasure could be had in hand, counting his birthright as an inheritance in the promises to be lived on by faith and not by sight as no profit beside present need, and trading it for hot pottage.ST Aug 21, 1884 Because of that choice he was the first to receive solid earthly possessions, Mount Seir to possess, while Jacob and the other patriarchs lived and died not having received the fulfilled promises and were not dissatisfied.ST Aug 21, 1884 Each share was what they preferred and what the Lord gave them, and the portion of immediate possession is in the long run less desirable than the portion in the promises, so God gives people the portion they choose and they must choose the promises over tempting immediate gain.ST Aug 21, 1884
He lightly esteemed the birthright, judging its spiritual blessing and future inheritance worthless beside immediate distress.ST Oct 6, 1914RH Dec 30, 1915 By contrast Jacob valued its spiritual blessings, including a place in God's kingdom and the call to obey God and seek His blessing.RH Dec 30, 1915 Jacob desired above everything else what Esau rejected, even though Jacob sought it through worldly means.ST Oct 6, 1914
Jacob longed for God and desired the better things while Esau was satisfied with the things of time and sense and rejected God.ST Jan 30, 1907 Esau's selfish character despised God's blessings and rejected God's character and identified itself with sin, in contrast to Jacob, who believed God and longed to become like Him.ST Jan 30, 1907ST Feb 27, 1901 God's choice of Jacob over Esau was not because his people were the greatest, wisest, most learned, most refined, or most cultured.ST Jan 30, 1907
Esau valued immediate self-indulgence and satisfying his appetite above the spiritual blessing, privilege, and heavenly birthright attached to the birthright.ST Jun 20, 1900ST Feb 28, 1906 Worldly pleasure seemed more desirable to him than the lasting spiritual inheritance, and by self-indulgence he surrendered his inheritance in God.ST Jun 20, 1900ST Feb 28, 1906 He counted his birthright as of no profit because he was hungry and thought he was at the point to die, despising a sacred inheritance for immediate gratification and selling what is divine and lasting for pottage.ST Sep 20, 1905 The verse therefore prompts the question of how highly one prizes the heavenly birthright.
Jacob's Craft and Election
Jacob acted as a supplanter whose mercenary character led him to take advantage of Esau's appetite and weakness to purchase the birthright, using his necessity and faint hunger over the pottage to gain renunciation of it.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Apr 1, 1897RH Jan 7, 1915 The taking shows disobedience and transgression even among God's chosen people, an act of trickery and fraud, duplicity and deception by Jacob and his mother.ST Feb 28, 1906ST Apr 1, 1897 This selfish, sinful dealing brought separation, tears, and heartache to the family.RH Jan 7, 1915
Jacob acted from what his mother had taught him of God's word that the elder would serve the younger, reasoning in his youth that the promise could not be fulfilled while Esau kept the first-born's peculiar advantages and special privileges of honor and authority in family and tribe next to the parents, consecration to God and selection to the priest's office, and a double portion of the father's goods.ST Apr 17, 1879 Though God had ordained that Jacob should have the prestige, Jacob was impatient to make the benefits sure and, encouraged by his mother, schemed to work it out himself, securing by craft for a paltry mess of pottage what God had already promised.ST Nov 21, 1906ST Oct 1, 1902 The transaction was a human work to supplement the Lord's promise.ST Oct 1, 1902
God's promise would have been fulfilled in its proper time if Jacob had been willing to wait; instead, lacking faith, he tried to secure it himself and obtained his brother's blessing by fraud.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Nov 21, 1906 Seeking by intrigue what would have come to him legitimately only brought trouble and long delay until at Peniel he put away all guile with deep penitence and trusted God to manage His own purpose.ST Nov 21, 1906 Jacob coveted the family birthright and blessing for temporal ends, not spiritual ends, and this overweening desire drove him as an exile from his parents' home to become a wanderer in a strange land after a lifetime as a home boy, leaving him lonely and sad with a conscience sorely smitten for the evil he had done, forced out, hated by his only brother, and truly alone while hurrying over four hundred miles from Beersheba toward Haran with Esau the fierce hunter, who had often trailed the hunted hart, possibly trailing close behind him.ST Oct 4, 1905 His fraud to obtain what he coveted brought hatred and lasting consequences, illustrating that wrongdoing reaps its harvest.ST Nov 17, 1909
Jacob was better than Esau in principle, yet in this act he was selfish and sinful, and that grasping sin is presented as cunning and wicked, with Esau belonging to a different realm from Jacob, who loved and honored God.ST Jul 27, 1904ST Dec 8, 1914 That grasping sin, with the later deception to steal the blessing, made Jacob guilty, separated him from Heaven as by a great gulf, and left him despairing and forsaken and fleeing from home.ST Jul 27, 1904 Jacob purchased Esau's birthright and thereby gained the true claim to Isaac's priestly blessing as heir of the sacred covenant, so that when Isaac set apart a day to consecrate his firstborn, God allowed Jacob to come in and receive the blessing on the ground of that long-since purchased claim, and God approved and sanctified Jacob's consecration.ST Mar 31, 1881
Jacob was chosen as the channel of the promise while Esau was passed by, but this special choice for a role in God's plan did not determine either brother's eternal salvation.ST Apr 10, 1907 God chose Jacob's line to carry His truth to the world because Jacob prized God's gift and blessing which Esau despised, treating the birthright as worthless and reasoning it could do him no good because he thought he was near death, yet that choice did not prevent Esau from being saved if he sought God in His appointed way.ST Apr 10, 1907ST Apr 11, 1906 Esau's choice was voluntary and did not mean God had shut him out from the blessings of salvation, and Jacob's later deception did not prevent Esau from seeking God's blessing.ST Sep 22, 1898ST Sep 22, 1898 God's grace through Christ is freely offered and available to all with responsibility resting on each person, and God's hatred of Esau means His hatred of sin.ST Sep 22, 1898ST Sep 22, 1898 In the passage Esau is identified as one who later persecuted Jacob, who avowed loyalty to God.RH Jun 8, 1916
Profanity, Law, and Irreversible Loss
Giving up the birthright made Esau a profane man in violation of the third commandment against swearing and profanity, and his guilt shows that law was already known and binding long before Sinai.ST May 9, 1906 The profanity was so grave that he lost the birthright permanently and could not get it back afterward though he sought it with bitter weeping, even to the loss of his life.ST May 9, 1906
Taking the birthright was theft in violation of the eighth commandment, showing the law against stealing was known before its proclamation at Sinai.ST Jun 6, 1906 The account of Esau's birthright, which Jacob coveted along with the blessing and took by an unrighteous course, also illustrates covetousness as sin included among violations of the first and second commandments.
Brief indulgence brought lasting loss and bitter regret that could not be undone, for he treated the birthright as worthless beside immediate relief from hunger on the plea it could do him no good if near death.RH May 15, 1866ST Mar 31, 1881 He earnestly sought to undo the act with tears but could not change its settled consequence, and a birthright so sold is never redeemed on earth.RH May 15, 1866RH May 15, 1866RH Oct 8, 1857 The choice made in an hour of passion and sensual appetite exchanged inheritance for food at the cost of the birthright, warning that choices made in sin can bring irrevocable loss.RH May 15, 1866ST Mar 31, 1881 In his strait the present outweighed the future, and he supposed he might get the future good in some other way than through the birthright, but there was no other way.RH Nov 19, 1857 That pictures neglecting the case in the court of heaven to amuse the soul with toys of earth, flattering the soul with hope of everlasting life while striving to enjoy the present life too and supposing God does not require giving up comforts or making great sacrifice.RH Nov 19, 1857 The end is loss of endless life in outer darkness forever separated from God, engulfed in ruin with weeping when too late and no more chance of repentance, so the lesson is to make a covenant with God by sacrifice now.RH Nov 19, 1857 His sorrow came from the unexpected consequences of his sin rather than true repentance, and in the day of God sinners who have bartered away their heirship will find no place for repentance although they seek it carefully and with tears (Hebrews 12:16-17). ST Apr 24, 1879
He bound his reckless bargain with a solemn oath that Jacob should have his birthright.ST Apr 24, 1879RH Aug 27, 1901 He spoke hastily without thought when faint and ruled by passionate desire, determined to have what he wanted at any cost until he lost all reason and could see only the desire of the moment.RH Aug 27, 1901 He represents those who let a root of bitterness remain in the heart, fall from the grace of God, speak hasty words, reach hasty conclusions, and become entirely separated from God (Hebrews 12:15). RH Aug 27, 1901 Those today who, like Esau, sell their birthright for gratification of appetite or some other passionate lust, determined to have what pleases the fancy irrespective of what the Lord says, commit the sin against the Holy Ghost and seal their doom.RH Aug 27, 1901
Selling the birthright for pottage leaves no place for repentance afterward though sought with tears.RH Nov 24, 1859 Awakening too late after treacherous silence and sanction of sin does not undo the sale but brings desolation.RH Nov 24, 1859
Types and Prophetic Parallels
Esau despising his spiritual birthright for immediate gratification is the type of worldliness still alive today. He is the hunter with his eye only on game, never looking upward to God, absorbed in business, money, pleasure, riches, honors, luxury, financial success and applause, generous and good-natured in a worldly way but unwilling to bend the knee in prayer and consecration. Though he has heard of a glorious heritage to come, he counts the birthright as a thing to be had any day for a mess of pottage, saying give the pottage and let another have the birthright. The verse means sacrificing the future for the present, putting the present world first to be secured by all means and seeking what is to come only afterward in odd moments and by side efforts, a folly in which hundreds and thousands are still selling their birthright. His sale for food represents those who have no faith and value temporary, worldly things over spiritual blessings.ST Nov 18, 1897ST Sep 1, 1909 He stands for those without faith, marked by unbelief and disobedience, who trade what is spiritual for what perishes, and his willingness to trade for a meal makes him the type of the worldly person who values temporary indulgence above spiritual privilege, though that birthright included a double share of property, authority in the family, the priesthood, and in this family the line through which Christ would come and the race's salvation would be provided.ST Nov 18, 1897ST Sep 1, 1909ST May 17, 1910
Despising the birthright and selling heaven for momentary gratification represents the course of the unrighteous who count the redemption purchased by Christ as of little value and sacrifice their heirship to heaven for perishable treasures.ST Apr 24, 1879 His selling for immediate satisfaction is a parallel to Adam's disobedience, through which Adam and his descendants entered bondage.ST Sep 24, 1894 Adam likewise sold his birthright, his heritage, and had nothing of that inheritance left to pass to his children.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 13, 1898 Putting present appetite and worldly gain ahead of lasting blessing means making the wrong choice between temporal profit and salvation, the same choice made by Judas betraying his Lord for thirty pieces of silver and by Gadara turning the Redeemer out of the land for a few thousand swine.RH Jan 8, 1875 It teaches never to turn Christ away from town or home for fear of what it will cost to bless and save.RH Jan 8, 1875
Giving up the birthright to satisfy hunger is a foolish bargain, trading what is permanently valuable for piping-hot momentary gratification.RH Jul 24, 1855 At Vanity Fair innumerable messes of pottage are offered to buyers who choose them at the cost of their birthrights, selling what is valuable for a song, like selling happiness for a whim and exchanging land and golden mansions in the Celestial City for a few years' lease of small dismal tenements in Vanity.RH Jul 24, 1855 The birthright was a squandered birthright, something he foolishly gave up.RH Jul 24, 1855ST Jun 30, 1898 Humanity's inheritance in the earth and right to life were forfeited like Esau's birthright sold for pottage, leaving people lost and without hope in themselves, but God made a way of escape through Christ and invites them to return, for God was not estranged from humanity but people had turned themselves away from Him.RH Aug 17, 1911 Esau and his descendants are identified as Edomites, and descent from Abraham through Isaac and Esau does not by itself entitle them to Israel's promises, for ancestry alone does not determine who belongs to God's true Israel.RH Jan 16, 1872 The birthright Jacob longed for raises what became of it and what Jacob and Esau each received, distinguishing Isaac's earthly possessions from the enduring substance.ST Oct 27, 1898
Present Warnings and Applications
Esau treated his birthright as worthless beside an immediate meal, though he was not so near death that he could not have endured hunger longer or prepared food for himself, and his choice illustrates despising a valuable inheritance for a brief, uncertain earthly benefit.ST Oct 21, 1886 Choosing worldly security over keeping the Sabbath likewise trades the hope of heavenly inheritance for temporary gain.ST Oct 21, 1886 That same reasoning is repeated by those convinced the seventh day is the Sabbath yet refusing to keep it, holding the law of bread and butter higher than the fourth commandment and excusing disobedience when obedience would cost them a living.ST Feb 14, 1884
When gratification of depraved appetite must be yielded or the high heavenly blessings promised only to the self-denying and God-fearing, the clamors of appetite generally prevail.ST Apr 24, 1879 Many controlled by inclination refuse to deny unhealthy appetite, sacrifice health, enfeeble mental faculties, and benumb sensibilities with tea, coffee, snuff, tobacco, spirits and other selfish gratifications, and virtually despise God and Heaven.ST Apr 24, 1879 Even professed Christians told they cannot have Heaven with these indulgences are offended and will no longer walk in the straight way.ST Apr 24, 1879 Health reform prepares people to remain faithful through the time of trouble rather than give up that inheritance for a morsel of meat. Rejecting simple habits to pamper taste acts even more foolishly than Esau, and selling the birthright for a glass of liquor leaves wretched bondage and a blighted life in contrast to the blessing of being a Christian helped by grace.ST May 2, 1878
People trade the hope of eternal life for far less, including indulgence in tobacco or whisky or refusal to give tithe.ST Feb 10, 1881 Spending money for tobacco and persisting in its injurious use sells interest in the kingdom even more cheaply than Esau, and those who do so can hardly expect to enter the kingdom.RH Aug 25, 1859 Valuing filthy habits, superfluities of dress, vain ornaments and other things that dishonor God and grieve the Holy Spirit above the blessed hope, the company of saints, the commandments of God and eternal life is the same exchange, which God permits but afterward leaves no space for repentance.RH Dec 2, 1862 Selling oneself to alcohol for temporary gratification is likened to selling a birthright for pottage, and those who worship alcohol cannot expect to inherit the kingdom.ST Feb 20, 1912
The verse means selling the eternal birthright for pottage, selling the soul for gold.RH Nov 23, 1911 It applies to bending every faculty toward amassing wealth for selfish gratification and perverting the faculty for acquiring knowledge into unsanctified channels for selfish gain, which perverts their purpose toward final ruin until the sale is complete and all desire for God's work is crushed out.RH Nov 23, 1911 The same bargain is repeated when insatiable cupidity makes men surrender what is far more valuable for present gain and millions sell liberty, manhood and souls for gold, for a mess of Mammon.ST May 24, 1905 The birthright is compared with the crown and eternal life forfeited by rejecting Christ's offer, and giving up the eternal reward to have one's own way or withholding a chance to give to God sells a blessing cheaply.RH Jan 10, 1871RH Sep 15, 1874
Esau parting with his birthright for naught was the first wanton disposal of God's gift of natural capital through lack of appreciation, selling to covetous men so the half-equipped seller becomes servant to the doubly-equipped buyer, degenerating into slavery bereft of independent occupation.ST Capital so gathered draws wage-earners into companies, colonies, villages and at last large cities with one class in luxury and others down to penury.ST The verse illustrates how a person may give up an inherited possession for what appears a present advantage.ST
The same spirit is repeated whenever people face to face with duty refuse obedience because it would interfere with worldly interests and livelihood, and whenever those who have accepted truth put self and selfish pleasures such as tobacco, whisky, pleasure parties and card tables above God's service.ST Mar 30, 1888 Knowing the truth but refusing to obey because obedience requires sacrifice is like selling a heavenly birthright for temporary gain.RH Jul 13, 1905 Satan works the same way, not tempting at first to great sins but starting with small indulgence of appetite and adding larger compromises little by little until destruction.ST Apr 8, 1875 Giving up faith when trial cuts to the quick, murmuring and longing for the flesh-pots of Egypt, brings no profit but grief, and eternal life must be given a higher estimate than Esau's and not sold cheaply for temptations and trials.RH Nov 19, 1857RH Apr 18, 1912
Ministers repeat Esau's bargain when they leave worship of God, preaching Christ, prayer and care of souls and turn the church into a social center, lectureship, school, amusement, charity and political caucus, running after schemes to save the world by vote or organization, quoting poets instead of Christ.ST Sep 20, 1905 The church's embrace of fashionable ideas is likened to selling itself for pottage. People trade liberties for money or political advantage, a worse act because it harms others as well as themselves.ST Sep 9, 1886 The verse is applied to bartering freedom and liberty for imperial conquest and to trampling God's laws to gain worldly inheritance by injustice, oppression and denial of equity and liberty for all made in God's image, which when secured is lost and reaps bankruptcy, war and mourning, while doing right pays a hundredfold now and secures eternal inheritance.ST Oct 25, 1899RH Sep 2, 1862
To give up a meeting where Jesus was to be met and the joy of church in order to do paid work to gain a new hat is to be just as bad as Esau, who felt at the point to die and asked what profit the birthright could do him.ST Jul 4, 1878 Lettie compares herself to Esau because she gives up the spiritual good expected from meeting and church for worldly work, then regrets it.RH Apr 18, 1871 Mothers show the same danger when they undervalue their spiritual heritage by giving worldly tasks and appearances more attention than teaching children the Bible, studying the Sabbath-school lesson, preparing wholesome food and keeping daily devotion, though Esau knew his father loved him and would provide.ST Mar 7, 1906
Giving up lasting principle and inheritance for present safety and comfort is selling the birthright.ST Oct 19, 1904 Daniel, at not less than ninety after remaining true from youth in faith and temperance, refused that trade at that late day to save his life and instead kept praying openly toward Jerusalem three times a day though the writing was signed and the den of lions awaited.ST Oct 19, 1904 Christians do the same as Esau when, though promised all needed help from on high, they give way to discouragement and say they might as well give up the struggle and cease running the race.ST Oct 18, 1883
The exchange of inheritance for one meal is applied to people who surrender purity, fellowship with God and hope of eternal inheritance for passing pleasures.RH May 15, 1866 The pleasure soon fades but the lost birthright and consequences remain.RH May 15, 1866 Surrendering youthful purity, principle and hope of immortality for indulgence leaves degradation, regret and condemnation.RH Jun 5, 1866 It warns against knowingly choosing present loss over eternal life despite light to guide, and illustrates how easily eternal glory can be surrendered.RH Mar 20, 1879
Those who profess to follow Christ while wrapped in self-righteousness expecting to merit eternal life by good deeds do the same when tested, hugging idols instead of laying every idol on the altar.RH Jan 12, 1864 The Christian's whole life is self-denial and cross-bearing, renouncing even what is as dear as a right hand or eye, and whoever expects heaven by any other path throws away eternal life for temporary gratification.RH Jan 12, 1864 The verse means choosing unsanctified appetite over eternal life and the rich blessings connected with it, laboring for meat that perishes rather than meat that endures.RH Aug 23, 1864
Selling the birthright means trading eternal inheritance for fashions and pleasures of this life, made without meaning to by grieving the Holy Spirit and bartering conscience little by little until the world has too strong a hold to break away.ST Mar 25, 1880 God gives as a birthright a spirit of power and love, so to sell it for a worthless temporary thing desecrates the divine gift and sins against the Giver.RH Nov 16, 1911 The same trade is made when men and women sell their glorious birthright as children of God for worthless passions loved more than salvation, such as holding to hope of the stage rather than coming to Jesus.ST Dec 9, 1880
Esau's choice makes him an example of those who give up lasting spiritual good for passing pleasure, as people may surrender the kingdom for wine, food, passion, pride or money.ST Dec 24, 1894 It warns not to trade the promised inheritance of the New Jerusalem for temporary pleasures of sin or wealth and honors.ST Jul 8, 1930 Nor is lasting inheritance to be sacrificed for worldly goods, reputation or safety by keeping silent about truth for fear of loss.RH Sep 30, 1852 Believers should not surrender their share in the eternal home for present things, for the birthright of eternity is infinitely more valuable than temporary selfish aims, and surrendering it for selfish gain leaves no share in eternal life.RH Jul 25, 1912RH Sep 2, 1915ST Jan 11, 1916
Trading eternal life for temporary riches and honors, or for indulgences that diminish life rather than preserve it, is folly.RH Nov 3, 1874 Esau's bargain illustrates bartering lust, pleasure, power, wealth or fame for God's promises, surrendering fame for worldly rewards, and selling for temporary gain though free to choose.ST Oct 4, 1905ST Aug 26, 1889ST Feb 18, 1913 The birthright stands for a valuable inheritance that should not be traded for short-term gain, warning against sacrificing a sacred calling for present advantage, making merchandise of God's people, neglecting God's work, giving up honor and principle to win favor even more cheaply than Esau, and squandering it through reckless living.RH Dec 6, 1870ST Nov 21, 1911 The pearl of great price is within everyone's reach.ST Nov 21, 1911
Esau's choice illustrates neglecting the case in the court of heaven to amuse the soul with toys of earth, flattering the soul with hope of everlasting life while striving to enjoy the present life too and supposing God does not require giving up comforts.RH Nov 19, 1857 The end is loss of endless life in outer darkness forever separated from God, engulfed in ruin with weeping when too late, so the lesson is to make a covenant with God by sacrifice now.RH Nov 19, 1857 It does not pay to sell one's birthright for food, for the birthright is as priceless as truthfulness and its reputation.ST May 27, 1913 Trading it for money or temporary satisfaction brings self-contempt, isolation under condemnation, exile from self-respect, and a burned-out shell no money can make happy.ST May 27, 1913
Esau's birthright shows how a person can trade an eternal inheritance for brief selfish satisfaction, the worthless transient fruit of unions ruled by self rather than life in union with God.ST Dec 16, 1903RH Oct 7, 1909 People can trade their eternal birthright for passing worldly pleasures and die with the world rather than accept God and live. The trade is a bargain with Satan where man pays all he promised while Satan never fulfills his pledges, delivering goods so mean no one would take them as a gift, so it is far better to yield wholly to the Lord.RH Jun 18, 1872 Those who sacrifice obedience for livelihood or return faint and desperate enough to give up any right for food illustrate the same low valuation.ST Jul 5, 1910
Esau selling out very cheaply warns against selling out even cheaper than he did.ST Aug 22, 1878 His choice is an example of exchanging God's blessing and the Christian hope for carnal desire or earthly advantage, with warning of everlasting destruction.ST Oct 13, 1898
Sources