AdventAI

Genesis 44:19

My lord asked his servants, saying, Have ye a father, or a brother?

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

5 sources

The words are Judah's, spoken in his plea to Joseph for Benjamin, recalling Joseph's earlier question to his servants whether they had a father or a brother.1SP 148.2–149.1PP 224.3–225.1PP 229.6–230.2SG3 163.2–164.1 That original question was put to learn about their family, whether their father or a brother was still living, and whether Benjamin was still alive and with their father.PP 224.3–225.1PP 229.6–230.2 By repeating it Judah introduced the family circumstances behind Benjamin's journey to Egypt, together with his own concern for the lad and his pledge to protect him.1SP 148.2–149.1PP 229.6–230.2SG3 163.2–164.1

Judah went on to explain that their father had been reluctant to let Benjamin go down to Egypt.SG3 163.2–164.1 He declared that his father's life was bound up with the lad's, so that loss of the boy would bring grief upon the aged father.ST Mar 31, 1887PP 229.6–230.2SG3 163.2–164.1 This account prepared his final appeal to remain himself as a slave in Benjamin's place, that Benjamin might return to their father.ST Mar 31, 1887PP 229.6–230.2SG3 163.2–164.1

Sources

  1. 1SP 148.2–149.1 Spirit of Prophecy Volume One — CHAPTER XIV. Ellen G. White, 1870
  2. PP 224.3–225.1 Patriarchs and Prophets — JOSEPH AND HIS BROTHERS—21 Ellen G. White, 1890
  3. PP 229.6–230.2 Patriarchs and Prophets — JOSEPH AND HIS BROTHERS—21 Ellen G. White, 1890
  4. SG3 163.2–164.1 Spiritual Gifts Volume Three — CHAPTER XV. Ellen G. White, 1864
  5. ST Mar 31, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 13 — The Commentary Ellen G. White, March 31, 1887

Pioneers and periodicals

10 sources

Judah is repeating Joseph's earlier question about a father or a brother as part of his plea for Benjamin after the hidden cup was found in Benjamin's sack, recounting their family circumstances, explaining that their father's life is bound up with the lad, and offering himself as a slave in Benjamin's place so Benjamin may return.ST Nov 24, 1898ST Jan 28, 1913ST Oct 23, 1901 That question began the exchange that required the youngest brother to be brought to Egypt and compelled their father to send Benjamin.ST Nov 24, 1898ST Oct 23, 1901 It belonged to Joseph's testing of his brothers over Benjamin to see what they would do and whether they still held toward Benjamin the same envy and jealousy they had shown toward Joseph, while his own heart yearned for his loved ones in Canaan and he scarcely restrained his love, and years of affliction had softened the brothers to greater humility and love for one another.ST Apr 16, 1894 The setting is the great famine and Joseph's meeting and reunion with his father's family after his brothers' envy, his sale to the Ishmaelites, his sojourn in Egypt, and God's good dealings with him through it all, in providential care preserving his relatives and the progenitors of the Seed and turning their harmful intentions to good.ST Jan 28, 1913ST Jan 23, 1912 The plea containing it is a most eloquent passage showing passion, power, and beauty, and its rereading makes hearts grow tender with lessons on the surface as well as deeper ones.ST Dec 9, 1908ST Feb 5, 1885 The chapter also shows theft was deemed heinous and stealing and covetousness were known to be sinful before Sinai, and the history shows that whatever God has intended a person for, God can be safely trusted to bring that person to it by a roundabout yet right way.RH Aug 17, 1876RH Jan 19, 1860

Place in Joseph's Story

Genesis 44:19 is Judah recalling Joseph's earlier question about whether the brothers had a father or a brother, spoken in his plea for Benjamin in Genesis 44:18-34 after the hidden silver cup was found in Benjamin's sack.ST Mar 31, 1887ST Nov 24, 1898ST Jan 28, 1913ST Oct 23, 1901ST Apr 16, 1894 In that plea he recounts the family circumstances, explains that his father's life is bound up with the lad, and offers himself as a slave in Benjamin's place so that Benjamin can return to their father.ST Mar 31, 1887ST Nov 24, 1898ST Oct 23, 1901ST Apr 16, 1894 The question began the exchange that led Joseph to require the youngest brother's presence in Egypt, and Judah's answer set out the circumstances behind their father's deep attachment to him.ST Nov 24, 1898ST Jan 28, 1913ST Oct 23, 1901 As Judah recalls it, that demand compelled their father to send Benjamin, the son whose life was bound up with Jacob's.ST Nov 24, 1898ST Oct 23, 1901

The question belonged to Joseph's policy to hold his brethren and try them to see what they would do in regard to Benjamin and whether they still held the same envy and jealousy toward Benjamin that they had shown toward Joseph.ST Apr 16, 1894 During the years of separation Joseph's heart yearned for his loved ones in Canaan, and he scarcely restrained his love and emotion while testing them.ST Apr 16, 1894 The afflictions of years had softened the brothers' hearts to greater humility and love for each other.ST Apr 16, 1894

The wider setting is the great famine and Joseph's meeting and reunion with his father's family after his brothers' envy, his sale to the Ishmaelites, his sojourn in Egypt, and God's good dealings with him through it all, including the fulfilment of his dreams.ST Jan 28, 1913 The plea for Benjamin containing the verse is one of the most eloquent passages in the English language. It is eloquent oration and one of the best specimens of eloquence in the Hebrew Scriptures, showing the intrinsic literary value of its literature with passion, power, and beauty.ST Feb 5, 1885

Doctrine and Practical Lessons

The account to which the question about father and brother belongs shows that theft was regarded as a heinous offense in Joseph's time. The brothers' conduct over the silver cup shows that they knew stealing was wrong and that covetousness was sinful.RH Aug 17, 1876 This proves that the law forbidding theft was already in force before Moses and Sinai.

The question stands within the continuing story of Joseph and God's providential care in preserving his relatives.ST Jan 23, 1912 That care extended to the preservation of the progenitors of the Seed. The events surrounding it turned the brothers' harmful intentions toward Joseph to their good.ST Jan 23, 1912 The story of Joseph and his brethren is full of lessons on the surface as well as deeper ones.

The history of Joseph to which the question belongs shows that whatever God has intended a person for, God can be safely trusted to bring that person to it.RH Jan 19, 1860 His leading is by a roundabout way, but it guides right.RH Jan 19, 1860 Judah's plea for Benjamin, in which the question is recalled, is a thrilling and eloquent appeal whose rereading makes hearts grow tender.ST Dec 9, 1908

Sources

  1. ST Nov 24, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 47 — The Sabbath School International Series November 24, 1898
  2. ST Jan 28, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 4 — Our Bible Band January 28, 1913
  3. ST Oct 23, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 43 — THE “SURE WORD OF PROPHECY.” G., October 23, 1901
  4. ST Apr 16, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 24 — International S. S. Lessons Monday, April 16, 1894
  5. ST Jan 23, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 4 — Joseph and the Exodus January 23, 1912
  6. ST Dec 9, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 35, No. 19 — Our Bible Band Editor, December 9, 1908
  7. ST Feb 5, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 6 — An Appeal for the Study of the Hebrew Scriptures February 5, 1885
  8. RH Aug 17, 1876 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 48, No. 8 — THE COMMANDMENTS.—PART 1 A. C. Spicker, Fifth-day, August 17, 1876
  9. RH Jan 19, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 9 — Trust God’s Guidance January 19, 1860
  10. ST Mar 31, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 13 — The Commentary Ellen G. White, March 31, 1887

Cross-references

  1. Genesis 43:7

    And they said, The man asked us straitly of our state, and of our kindred, saying, Is your father yet alive? have ye another brother? and we told him according to the tenor of these words: could we certainly know that he would say, Bring your brother down?

    Judah recalls Joseph asking about their father and another brother.

  2. Genesis 44:30-31

    Now therefore when I come to thy servant my father, and the lad be not with us; seeing that his life is bound up in the lad’s life;

    Judah explains that Benjamin’s loss would bring Jacob grief and death.

  3. Genesis 42:20

    But bring your youngest brother unto me; so shall your words be verified, and ye shall not die. And they did so.

    Joseph required the brothers to bring Benjamin to Egypt.

  4. Genesis 43:8-9

    And Judah said unto Israel his father, Send the lad with me, and we will arise and go; that we may live, and not die, both we, and thou, and also our little ones.

    Judah pledged himself to bring Benjamin safely back to their father.

  5. Genesis 45:3

    And Joseph said unto his brethren, I am Joseph; doth my father yet live? And his brethren could not answer him; for they were troubled at his presence.

    Joseph’s earlier question about their father leads to his self-revelation.

  6. Genesis 44:33

    Now therefore, I pray thee, let thy servant abide instead of the lad a bondman to my lord; and let the lad go up with his brethren.

    Judah offers to become a slave in Benjamin’s place.

  7. Genesis 42:13

    And they said, Thy servants are twelve brethren, the sons of one man in the land of Canaan; and, behold, the youngest is this day with our father, and one is not.

    Joseph questions his brothers about their family and learns the youngest is with their father.

  8. Genesis 44:8-9

    Behold, the money, which we found in our sacks’ mouths, we brought again unto thee out of the land of Canaan: how then should we steal out of thy lord’s house silver or gold?

    The brothers deny stealing and propose punishment if the cup is found.

  9. Genesis 37:7-10

    For, behold, we were binding sheaves in the field, and, lo, my sheaf arose, and also stood upright; and, behold, your sheaves stood round about, and made obeisance to my sheaf.

    The brothers’ obeisance fulfills Joseph’s dream.

  10. Genesis 42:21

    And they said one to another, We are verily guilty concerning our brother, in that we saw the anguish of his soul, when he besought us, and we would not hear; therefore is this distress come upon us.

    The brothers recognize their guilt over what they did to Joseph.