Matthew 19:18
He saith unto him, Which? Jesus said, Thou shalt do no murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness,
Translations
He says to him, Which? Jesus said, You shall do no murder, You shall not commit adultery, You shall not steal, You shall not bear false witness,
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
He saith unto him, Which? Jesus said, Thou shalt do no murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness,
He saith to him, Which? Jesus said, Thou shalt do no murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness,
Revised Version, American Standard Version
He saith unto him, Which? And Jesus said, Thou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness,
He saith to him, 'What kind?' And Jesus said, 'Thou shalt not kill, thou shalt not commit adultery, thou shalt not steal, thou shalt not bear false witness,
He says to him, Which? And Jesus said, Thou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness,
He saith unto him, Which? Jesus, said—These: Thou shalt not commit murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal,—Thou shalt not bear false witness;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Which ones?” the man asked.Jesus answered, “‘ Do not murder, do not commit adultery, do not steal, do not bear false witness,
He said to him, “ Which ones?”Jesus said, “‘ You shall not murder.’ ‘ You shall not commit adultery.’ ‘ You shall not steal.’ ‘ You shall not offer false testimony.’
He says to him, Which? And Jesus said, Do not put anyone to death, Do not be untrue in married life, Do not take what is not yours, Do not give false witness,
He sayd to him, Which? And Iesus sayde, These, Thou shalt not kill: Thou shalt not commit adulterie: Thou shalt not steale: Thou shalt not beare false witnesse.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
He said to him: Which? And Jesus said: Thou shalt do no murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness.
Pictures


Cross-references 20 of 51
- Exodus 20:13-16
Thou shalt not kill.
Jesus names four commandments also given in the Decalogue.
- Mark 10:19
Thou knowest the commandments, Do not commit adultery, Do not kill, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Defraud not, Honour thy father and mother.
Mark records Jesus’ parallel exchange and list of commandments.
- Matthew 22:37-40
Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
Jesus says love for God and neighbor underlies all the law and its commandments.
- Matthew 5:17-19
Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.
Jesus affirms the law’s enduring force and warns against breaking its commandments.
- Luke 18:18-23
And a certain ruler asked him, saying, Good Master, what shall I do to inherit eternal life?
parallel account of same incident
- James 2:10-11
For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.
Offending in one commandment makes a person guilty of the whole law.
- Romans 7:7
What shall we say then? Is the law sin? God forbid. Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law: for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.
The commandment against coveting reveals sin and identifies the law.
- Leviticus 19:18
Thou shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of thy people, but thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I am the LORD.
Jesus includes the command to love one’s neighbor in his answer.
- Ephesians 6:2
Honour thy father and mother; ( which is the first commandment with promise;)
It repeats the command to honor father and mother from Jesus’ list.
- Revelation 14:12
Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.
The saints keep God’s commandments and have faith in Jesus.
- Revelation 22:14
Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.
Doing God’s commandments is linked with entering the city and having right to the tree of life.
- Luke 10:27-28
And he answering said, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind; and thy neighbour as thyself.
Jesus affirms that loving God and neighbor as the law requires leads to life.
- Deuteronomy 4:13
And he declared unto you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments; and he wrote them upon two tables of stone.
Identifies the covenant’s commandments as the Ten Commandments written on stone.
- Exodus 20:8-11
Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
The fourth commandment establishes the Sabbath Jesus’ reply does not name.
- Matthew 19:22
But when the young man heard that saying, he went away sorrowful: for he had great possessions.
His attachment to possessions makes him leave sorrowful.
- Matthew 15:4
For God commanded, saying, Honour thy father and mother: and, He that curseth father or mother, let him die the death.
Both quote commandments, including the command to honor parents.
- Mark 10:21-22
Then Jesus beholding him loved him, and said unto him, One thing thou lackest: go thy way, sell whatsoever thou hast, and give to the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven: and come, take up the cross, and follow me.
Jesus tells the young man to give to the poor and follow him; the man departs sorrowful.
- 1 John 5:3
For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments: and his commandments are not grievous.
Keeping God’s commandments is identified with love for God.
- Matthew 5:19
Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.
Jesus warns against breaking commandments and commends those who keep and teach them.
- Romans 13:9
For this, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness, Thou shalt not covet; and if there be any other commandment, it is briefly comprehended in this saying, namely, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.
Both quote commandments from the Decalogue.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
62 sources
When asked which commands must be kept to enter into life, Jesus names the duties to other people, forbidding killing, marital unfaithfulness, theft and lying, and adding honor for parents and love for neighbor as self.1T 170.4–171.3SG2 239.1–240.1RH Sep 11, 1900Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3 A young ruler in Israel had asked what good he should do for eternal life, sincerely supposing he had kept all these from his youth yet feeling he still lacked something.SG2 239.1–240.1Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25 Entering into life requires keeping the commandments, not by outward compliance alone but with heart, soul, strength and mind in supreme love to God and love to neighbor.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25ST Oct 29, 1912 His supreme love of riches was his idol, shutting him from loving God with the whole heart and from loving his neighbor, so he failed both love to God and love to man.1T 170.4–171.33MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12 Christ's further call to sell, give to the poor and follow Him exposed that selfishness and showed that keeping the commands requires surrender, stewardship for the needy, and receiving Christ's righteousness and power within.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27RH May 20, 1862Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9
Commandments Jesus Named
To the question Which, the answer names four prohibitions: no murder, no adultery, no stealing, and no false witness.1T 170.4–171.3SG2 239.1–240.1RH Sep 11, 1900Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Lt 195, 1903, par. 8–10 The list is given to one asking what good thing to do to enter into life and inherit eternal life, as the commandments to keep for that end.SG2 239.1–240.1RH Sep 11, 1900Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Lt 195, 1903, par. 8–10 The experience pictures the condition of many Sabbath-keepers.SG2 239.1–240.13MR 66.2–67.2
The answer continues beyond those four by adding honor to father and mother and love for neighbor as self.1T 170.4–171.3Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27 The prohibitions against murder, adultery, theft, and false witness are thus joined with honoring parents and loving neighbor as oneself as what to keep in order to enter into life.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Ms 150, 1899, par. 22–27 These added duties toward the neighbor still do not by themselves resolve the lack, which the call to give possessions to the poor and follow exposes.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27
The commands listed are five of the last six commandments, with the second great commandment on which the last six hang added to them.1T 170.4–171.3Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12Lt 118, 1897, par. 21–25 They belong to the second table of the Decalogue given at Sinai, concerning duty to other people, and to the moral law rather than a ceremonial precept.Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27COL 390.2–391.1DA 518.6DA 518.5 Their principle is summed up as love for neighbor, entailing unselfish wholehearted love shown in caring for people in peril and need, warning and laboring for them, and not rejecting or discouraging those who err.Ms 150, 1899, par. 22–27Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12Lt 118, 1897, par. 21–25
The first four commandments, containing duty to God and requiring supreme love for God with all heart, soul, and mind, are not named in this verse.1T 170.4–171.3Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12SG2 240.2–241.1 By quoting the precepts of Jehovah the answer points to the ten holy commandments, exposing deficiency in fulfilling the law where self-love is supreme.13MR 21.1–3 The verse itself leaves the listed commands without further exposition, and their meaning is tested by the later call to sell possessions, lay up treasure in heaven, give to the poor, and follow.1T 170.4–171.313MR 21.1–3Lt 2, 1857, par. 6–8
Setting Of The Question
The question behind the verse comes from a young man who is a ruler in Israel asking what good thing to do to have eternal life and to enter into life, and which commandments must be kept.SG2 239.1–240.1Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Lt 195, 1903, par. 8–10Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3 Jesus answers by naming the prohibitions against killing, adultery, stealing, and lying or bearing false witness, joined with honoring father and mother and loving neighbor as self, as what must be kept in order to enter into life.SG2 239.1–240.1Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Lt 195, 1903, par. 8–10Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5 Strict obedience to the letter is set forth as the duty pointed out to him, and the experience pictures the condition of many Sabbath-keepers when duty is pointed out.SG2 239.1–240.13MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3 He supposes he has kept them from his youth up yet deceives himself, for Jesus knows where he fails and touches the plague spot of his life.3MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3 His great possessions stand in the way of loving God with the whole heart and of following his Master in self-denial, so he is not ready to follow and in this shows his weakness and that he is not a true lover of God.3MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5
He comes recognizing Christ as a teacher by whom he is willing to be taught, having observed His compassion for the poor and ignorant and having been touched by His meekness and lowliness of heart.Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5 He has high motives but is not perfect in understanding, thinks highly of his own righteousness yet feels he lacks something, and considers himself an honest applicant who understands the service owed to God.Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5Ms 123, 1908, par. 35–42DA 518.5 He sincerely believes he has kept the law from his youth and honestly believes himself perfect and blameless as far as the law is concerned, claiming to have kept all these from his youth up.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25Ms 123, 1908, par. 35–42DA 519.2Lt 202, 1899, par. 3–4 Outward obedience of that kind does not mean heart devotion and Christian goodness, and keeping the commandments in that limited way without surrendering wealth to serve others and follow Christ does not make him truly obedient.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25DA 519.2Lt 202, 1899, par. 3–4 When Christ's close teaching means too much to him he goes away sorrowful, and when further tested over worldly possessions as his idol he fails over what stands in the way of gaining eternal life.Ms 40, 1905, par. 3–5Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25Ms 123, 1908, par. 35–42
Jesus names the commandments in a way that tests the ruler's sincerity and reveals how he regards Jesus.DA 518.4 The encounter opens the way for Him to teach right principles about God's free grace and the reward of the righteous.COL 390.1DA 518.4 In the encounter He presents the condition of discipleship.DA 719.3 Judas is displeased with that condition and thinks the ruler's wealth and influence could help Christ's cause.DA 719.3
Obedience Required For Life
To enter into life and gain eternal life requires keeping the commandments, with strict obedience to the letter bringing eternal life.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–153MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9 The law's full demand is perfect obedience and harmony with God as required in Eden and still required under the covenant of grace, a rule of conduct for everyone who would enter the kingdom and the terms by which Christian character is developed and the only hope of salvation.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25Ms 123, 1908, par. 35–42DA 523.2 The list of no murder, no adultery, no stealing, and no false witness, together with honoring father and mother and loving neighbor as self, sets obedience to God's commands as the way to a perfect character fitted to live eternally with God in the abodes of bliss.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Ms 123, 1908, par. 35–42 These commandments do not by themselves resolve the lack, for Jesus calls to give possessions to the poor and follow Him, showing that obedience also requires surrender and discipleship.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9
Obedience must involve the whole person with heart, soul, strength, and mind, not merely knowledge, profession, or outward legal compliance.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25DA 523.2Lt 118, 1897, par. 37–40 It must shape the life, enter the life, and appear in the character, and be kept in spirit and truth.ST Oct 29, 1912DA 523.2 Their claims are revealed in a person's life and example, for knowing or claiming to keep them does not prove understanding, and disobedience reveals ignorance of their meaning and of God's character which the law portrays.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Oct 22, 1894 Outward obedience did not mean heart devotion and Christian goodness, but required a humble, contrite heart that recognized the supreme love owed to God.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Oct 22, 1894DA 519.2
The law requires supreme love to God and love for neighbor as self.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12COL 392.113MR 21.1–3Ms 35, 1889, par. 3 The lover of self is a transgressor of the law.COL 392.1 Cherishing an idol in the soul, with the world as god, and living in love of self and worldly gain leaves a person destitute of that love, out of harmony with the principles of heaven, and lacking everything that qualifies for entrance into the kingdom of heaven.Lt 8, 1895, par. 22–25COL 392.113MR 21.1–3 Keeping these neighbor commands therefore entails unselfish, wholehearted love for others, shown by caring for people in peril and need, warning and laboring for them, and not rejecting or discouraging those who err.Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12
Keeping God's law requires accepting Christ as Saviour and receiving His righteousness, with Christ's divine power joined to human effort and Christ as the life within the soul.Ms 1, 1889, par. 35–40Lt 354, 1905, par. 27 Christ's life in humanity demonstrated that God's law can be kept, while attempts to produce righteousness apart from Him fail.Ms 1, 1889, par. 35–40 A humble, contrite heart must rely on His perfection to cover deficiency.DA 519.2 Obedience and self-surrender are required of all who would become His disciples, giving up whatever would corrupt the whole person, and nothing short of obedience is acceptable.Lt 354, 1905, par. 27DA 523.4
Love Exposing The Ruler
The ruler confidently answers that he has kept all these from his youth up, supposing and thinking himself obedient, yet outward integrity, confidence, and willingness to keep them do not prove fulfillment or completeness of character.1T 170.4–171.33MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Ms 150, 1899, par. 22–27 His claim is false, mistaken, and self-deceived, and does not mean he understands or truly keeps them.1T 170.4–171.33MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 1–3Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27Ms 1, 1889, par. 35–40 Willingness to obey is not readiness to surrender what stands between the soul and eternal life.RH May 20, 1862CET 166.2SG4 267.1
His supreme love of riches is his idol and the plague spot of his life, standing distinctly in the way of loving God with all heart, soul, and mind.1T 170.4–171.33MR 66.2–67.2SG2 240.2–241.1ST Oct 28, 1908STB 573.3–574.1 Because his heart is on his treasure and swallowed up in earthly possessions, which he loves better than God and better than heavenly treasure, he fails the first four commandments concerning duty to God.1T 170.4–171.3SG2 240.2–241.1ST Oct 28, 1908 That same love shuts his eyes to the wants of his fellow men and keeps him from sharing with the poor and blessing others, so he does not love his neighbor as himself and fails the last six.1T 170.4–171.3Ms 150, 1899, par. 22–27SG2 240.2–241.1 He holds the goods entrusted to him more dearly than the Giver and fails to use them for the good of others, loving his possessions above God, above God's service, and above the souls of fellow men, loving God's gifts more than the Giver.1T 170.4–171.3Ms 150, 1899, par. 22–27Lt 118, 1897, par. 21–25ST Oct 28, 1908
Jesus' further instruction to sell possessions, give to the poor, and follow Him touches that spot and exposes supreme selfishness and a fatal deficiency.3MR 66.2–67.2Ms 23, 1885, par. 25–27COL 392.1ST Feb 14, 1878ST Jul 21, 1898 It makes manifest the selfishness of the heart and the plague-spot in the character.3MR 66.2–67.2COL 392.1 In refusing self-denial and failing to receive and follow Christ, he shows his weakness, that he is not a true lover of God, and that he still lacks heart devotion, love for God, and Christian goodness.3MR 66.2–67.2COL 392.1ST Jul 21, 1898
He values his riches, possessions, and standing more than heavenly treasure and eternal life.SG4 265.5RH May 20, 1862ST Oct 28, 19084T 219.3CET 164.3 He wants heavenly treasure but also wants the temporal advantages of his riches, yet to give up earthly treasure that is seen for heavenly treasure that is unseen seems too great a risk.ST Oct 28, 1908STB 573.3–574.1 His position and possessions draw his affections from God, and keeping anything back weakens moral strength because cherished worldly things take over the heart.ST Oct 28, 1908STB 573.3–574.1 So he chooses earthly treasure, lets the world receive his worship, and goes away sorrowful with chilled desire.SG4 265.54T 219.3CET 164.3STB 573.3–574.1 Earthly treasures cannot be loved and worshiped while having the true riches, and those who love riches cannot love Jesus.ST Oct 28, 1908STB 573.3–574.1
Knowing and keeping the commandments is therefore not enough when the heart is ruled by earthly riches.ST Mar 11, 1889ST Nov 5, 1894CET 166.2 The young man would not give up his wealth to help others and secure treasure in heaven, and so rejected the way pointed out rather than part with what stood between him and following Jesus.ST Mar 11, 1889ST Nov 5, 1894CET 166.2SG4 267.1
Call To Surrender And Follow
Jesus did not stop with naming murder, adultery, theft, and false witness, with honoring parents and loving neighbor, but went on to call the young man to sell what he had, give to the poor and suffering, and follow Him.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 58, 1896, par. 20 Keeping the commandments therefore includes surrender and discipleship, and love proved by self-sacrifice as the test of character.Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 58, 1896, par. 204T 49.3–50.1 The refusal to part with wealth showed unwillingness to make the sacrifice required to follow Christ, and the remaining failure of attachment to possessions had to be faced despite the claim to have kept the commandments from youth.4T 49.3–50.1ST Mar 30, 18761T 207.2 That call may require giving up earthly wealth, becoming rich in good works, and giving up whatever would corrupt the whole person.Lt 354, 1907, par. 13–15Lt 44, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 58, 1896, par. 20
The duties to fellow men named hang on loving neighbor as self, and they are kept in practice only when love to God and fellow men predominates over love of riches.SG2 242.1–31T 172.1–3 This is impossible while the heart is on earthly possessions, for supreme love of riches makes loving God with all heart, soul, and mind impossible and shuts the eyes to the wants of fellow men.SG2 242.1–31T 172.1–3 When truth set home by the Spirit crowds out the love of riches, love of Jesus replaces it, possessions are held as the Lord's and faithfully used as a steward to bless the needy and advance God's cause.SG2 242.1–31T 172.1–3 Then the first four commandments and the last six named by Jesus can be kept, wealth is treated as God's entrusted goods used to serve people and advance His work, and it becomes possible for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God through loving service.SG2 242.1–31T 172.1–3
Keeping these neighbor commands, which require loving neighbors as self alongside supreme love for God, entails unselfish wholehearted love shown by caring for people in peril and need, warning and laboring for them, and not rejecting or discouraging those who err.Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12ST Nov 5, 1894 Knowing the commandments is not enough when riches are loved more than God and neighbor, as seen when the young man turned away once the way to life required sacrificing his wealth.Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12ST Nov 5, 1894 Even a poor person must use what he has to bless others and cannot disregard their claims while obeying God.Ms 62, 1894, par. 11–12ST Nov 5, 1894
His experience pictures the condition of many Sabbath-keepers and represents a large class who, when duty in keeping the Sabbath and other duty is pointed out, see a cross to lift because earthly treasures hold them, which is why so few obey.SG2 239.1–240.13MR 66.2–67.2Ms 39, 1886, par. 9–103MR 69.1–3 Christ tested the ruler by the law by touching the plague spot of his life, his great possessions that stood in the way of loving God with the whole heart, and the same test comes to many now.3MR 66.2–67.2DA 523.2RH Sep 11, 1900 When tested, many like the ruler refuse to deny self, take up the cross, and follow Christ, proving the heart unregenerate whatever the outward propriety of conduct or belief claimed, and showing weakness and lack of true love to God by unwillingness to follow the Master in self-denial.3MR 66.2–67.2DA 523.2RH Sep 11, 1900 To be prepared for the Lord's coming God's law must be written in mind and heart and brought home to the conscience until sin is seen as exceedingly sinful, with death to self and crucifixion of self as necessary to know spiritual holiness, for obedience must shape the life and appear in the character rather than remain outward legal compliance.DA 523.2RH Sep 11, 1900
Keeping the commandments in this setting means searching the Scriptures to discharge duty aright, perfecting a Christian character like Christ the perfect Pattern, being channels of true light who seek others and set light on a candlestick rather than under a bushel, laying up treasure in heaven, and faithfully presenting entrusted sacred truths and talents until the Master comes to reckon, and in this way eternal life is secured.3MR 69.1–3 His sorrow when the cause of God called for his property warns professed believers who hold property instead of giving means to speed messengers to feed hungry sheep dying for want of saving truth and to carry the gospel to those in need.ST2 46.1ExVEGW 29.3–30.1STA 104.4–106.1EW 40.1–2 Professing to keep the commandments does not prevent choosing money and power over immortal life and treasure in heaven, and valuing earthly property above service to God is dangerous.STM2 30.1ExVEGW 29.3–30.14T 50.2 Earthly goods may soon be swept away by the overflowing scourge, leaving it too late to sacrifice them and lay up treasure in heaven, while sacrifice for God's work lays up treasure in heaven, in contrast to Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son.ST2 46.1STM2 30.1STA 104.4–106.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
102 sources
When the rich young ruler asked which commandments lead to eternal life, Jesus answered by naming the neighbor-directed precepts against murder, adultery, theft and false witness, with honor to parents and love to neighbor.RH Nov 26, 1857ST Nov 14, 1900ST Sep 26, 1906ST Feb 10, 1898RH Feb 23, 1905
Those named precepts identify the Ten Commandments, the moral law spoken at Sinai, and keeping them whole is the way to enter into life.RH May 3, 1860ST Jun 19, 1884ST Nov 14, 1900ST Aug 26, 1897RH Dec 28, 1869
Naming only some does not abolish the rest, and the omission of duties to God gives no proof that the Sabbath is void or changed.RH Oct 11, 1906RH Feb 26, 1901RH Aug 15, 1854RH Oct 26, 1911ST Aug 26, 1897
The obedience required is perfect heart obedience through faith in Christ, for keeping alone cannot pardon past sin or justify, though disobedience brings death.RH Sep 4, 1900ST Jul 17, 1884ST Nov 14, 1900RH Aug 20, 1914ST Jan 31, 1906
The ruler claimed to have kept all these from his youth, yet the call to sell, give to the poor and follow exposed covetousness as his idol, showing he loved possessions more than God and neighbor and went away sorrowful.RH Nov 26, 1857ST Mar 5, 1902ST Nov 24, 1881ST Mar 22, 1883ST Nov 25, 1886
Encounter and Wording
The setting is a rich young ruler concerned about his salvation who eagerly comes to Jesus, kneels on the way, and asks what good thing he must do to have eternal life, then asks which commandments are meant.ST Sep 26, 1906ST Feb 10, 1898ST Oct 19, 1888 His use of the plural shows he knew Scripture contains more than one code of law and knew of two classes of commandments, including the moral code of the Ten Commandments spoken at Sinai and recorded in Exodus 20, and he asked as though wanting Jesus to identify a particular precept he had broken.RH Feb 23, 1905ST Oct 19, 1888ST Feb 14, 1878 His question and the answer reflect the teaching that eternal life comes through a coming Saviour.RH Feb 23, 1905
In reply Jesus names the prohibitions against murder, adultery, stealing and false witness, continued in the next verse by honoring father and mother and loving one's neighbor as oneself.RH Nov 26, 1857RH Sep 11, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900ST Dec 2, 1886 These are commandments from the Decalogue, commonly called the Ten Commandments, specifying the moral requirements involved in keeping the commandments as the way to enter into life.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Aug 20, 1912 They are not given in their written Decalogue order.ST Dec 2, 1886ST Aug 20, 1912 Unlike making knowledge of Christ's deity a condition of regeneration, here the requirement is stated by naming commandments.ST Nov 23, 1915
The precepts named are from the second table of the law, concerning a person's duties to other people and governing treatment of others.RH Nov 12, 1857RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 13, 1869RH May 16, 1854RH Feb 23, 1905 They grow out of love for one's neighbor, are included in the law that hangs on loving one's neighbor as oneself, and were deliberately chosen to set that principle before the inquirer and to test his duty to his neighbor.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Mar 23, 1852 The list is not every commandment required to be kept, since obedience to all had already been enjoined, but points to these because the young man claimed to be blameless toward his fellow men where he was specially deficient.RH Aug 15, 1854
The sixth commandment forbids murder, not every act causing death, so killing an ox for market or destroying insect or plant life is not murder.RH Mar 11, 1909 The same chapter places marriage back on the original order established in Eden, an order that should never have been abandoned.RH Mar 1, 1870 The encounter's recording three times, in Matthew 19, Mark 10 and Luke 18, shows its importance, giving example and precedent for counteracting last-day selfishness and keeping it out of the church. The answer is given in the very words of the Old Testament, on which Jesus rested his heart in the last six months before the cross as he entered its shadow, finding there the vital air of his soul, and on which he relied absolutely from the temptation at the beginning to the crowning sorrows at the close, proving that teaching came from his heart and deepest convictions.ST Feb 15, 1883
Law Jesus Meant
The commandments Jesus names are the Ten Commandments, the Decalogue, the moral law, the Father's law, the royal and spiritual law spoken at Sinai and written on stone.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Aug 26, 1897RH Dec 28, 1869RH May 24, 1870ST Aug 28, 1879 They are the commandments generally so called in the New Testament, distinct from the ceremonial ordinances and from the testimony of Jesus, and the quoted precepts against murder, adultery, theft, false witness, with honor to parents and love of neighbor, identify that whole code.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Aug 26, 1897RH Dec 28, 1869RH May 24, 1870RH Apr 17, 1855 Keeping them is essential to entering life, and they can be kept only by faith in Christ who forgives sin and writes the law on the heart.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Aug 26, 1897
He points to God's already existing, formerly given law, enforcing principles taught on God's authority and continued by the apostles, not issuing newly given, expanded, re-enacted or gospel commands.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Oct 10, 1865RH Aug 13, 1857RH Oct 10, 1854RH Nov 25, 1852 The references stand on their original authority and original basis, spoken before the crucifixion, and concern the moral law rather than the ceremonial law of ordinances or the law of Moses with its types and shadows.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Oct 10, 1865RH Aug 13, 1857RH Oct 10, 1854RH Aug 13, 1857 That moral law existed from Adam onward, and the apostles moved by the same Spirit in Christ continued in harmony with His teaching to urge these same commands as necessary for Gentile Christians and necessary to eternal life.ST Feb 22, 1883
Keeping the commandments means keeping every one of them as a whole, including duties to God and the command against coveting.RH Aug 15, 1854ST Mar 6, 1884ST Feb 22, 1883RH Feb 17, 1859 The list is not every commandment required, but points to the precepts of duty to other people because the inquirer claimed to be blameless there while being specially deficient in love of neighbor as himself.RH Aug 15, 1854RH Feb 17, 1859 Knowingly and willfully violating even one point makes a person guilty of breaking the law, so keeping the rest from youth does not excuse covetousness, which alone can forfeit heaven.RH Aug 15, 1854ST Feb 22, 1883RH Feb 17, 1859ST Jul 22, 1880
The commandments of God so identified are the Ten Commandments God gave in person, distinct from the faith of Jesus.RH Apr 17, 1855 Keeping those ten marks the saints in the time of patience beginning with disappointment, a day of affliction, trial and darkness while waiting for redemption at the coming of the Son of man.RH May 19, 1851 They also mark the remnant of the woman's seed after the twelve hundred and sixty years of papal rule, who to be commandment keepers must keep every one of them, even those trampled upon during that period, not God's law as amended by the papacy.RH May 7, 1872
Why Only Some Listed
Jesus names only some commandments, enough to identify the law he means and not a complete list of what must be kept.RH Oct 11, 1906RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 13, 1869RH Oct 26, 1911RH Jun 10, 1852 He makes no direct reference to the first, second, third, fourth, or tenth commandments, naming five or six neighbor-directed precepts and omitting duties to God.RH Oct 11, 1906RH Feb 26, 1901RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 13, 1869RH Jun 10, 1852 The commands named are from the second table of the Decalogue, concerning duty to other people, with the Sabbath and the first three absent because they do not belong to that neighbor-directed subset.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 13, 1869ST Aug 26, 1897ST Aug 18, 1909 Jesus had already enjoined obedience to all the commandments, and then pointed to these precepts to identify the whole code he meant.RH Aug 15, 1854ST Aug 26, 1897RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852RH May 2, 1854
The selection directs the young man to the part of the law concerning his duty to his neighbor, where he claimed to be blameless but was specially deficient and was transgressing.RH Aug 15, 1854RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 16, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852 It met the young man on the ground he knew and said he had kept, while drawing out the part relevant to those duties and to love of neighbor as himself.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Aug 15, 1854RH May 16, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852 His later response and Jesus' further instruction to sell possessions, give to the poor, and follow showed he had not fulfilled his obligations to his fellow human beings and had not been particular about all his duty.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Apr 13, 1869RH May 16, 1854ST Aug 18, 1909
Omission from this list does not abolish or repeal what is not quoted and gives no permission to break it.RH Jan 28, 1873RH May 2, 1854ST Jan 10, 1878ST Feb 27, 1912 By the same reasoning the omitted first, second, third, and tenth precepts would also be abolished, while the commandments are brought forward as a whole and eternal life is not gained by keeping only part.RH Aug 15, 1854RH Jan 28, 1873RH May 2, 1854 The second commandment is nowhere quoted in Christ's teachings and the third is not quoted either, yet blasphemy and idolatry remain wrong.RH Oct 11, 1906RH Oct 26, 1911ST Aug 18, 1909RH Jan 28, 1873ST Feb 27, 1912
In particular the omission of the fourth commandment is no argument against keeping the seventh-day Sabbath and no proof it is abolished, changed, nonbinding, void, or in need of re-enactment.RH Oct 11, 1906RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 16, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852RH May 2, 1854 The fact that the fourth commandment on the Sabbath is not directly quoted no more proves it is not obligatory than the fact that the first, second, and third are nowhere repeated proves they are not binding.ST Aug 18, 1909RH Jan 28, 1873ST Jan 10, 1878ST Feb 27, 1912 Keeping the commandments of God is the condition of entering eternal life, and the fourth commandment on the Sabbath is included alike with murder, theft, false witness, and adultery, so entering into life requires keeping it with the other nine.RH Aug 15, 1854ST Aug 26, 1897RH May 16, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852 The Sabbath remains as God's creation memorial, sign of His authority and Creator worship, the creation Sabbath continuing so no new Sabbath needed to be appointed, kept as terms of both covenants written on the heart under the new covenant and as evidence of love for God.RH Oct 11, 1906ST Aug 26, 1897RH May 16, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852RH Jun 10, 1852
Entering Life by Keeping
Keeping the commandments is the way and condition and duty for entering into life and eternal life.RH May 3, 1860ST Jun 19, 1884ST Nov 14, 1900ST Mar 6, 1884ST Dec 27, 1905 It is Christ's own direct instruction to everyone anxiously asking what good thing to do to be saved, and therefore is of all-absorbing interest.ST Jun 19, 1884ST Feb 10, 1898 It is eternal truth giving practical lessons for every age and land, with especial importance for days of peril.ST Feb 10, 1898 It is the rule for right living and the doorway into Christ's kingdom resting on honorable everyday life.ST Mar 6, 1884ST Dec 27, 1905 It is the duty Christ assigns the church and ministers to present throughout the Christian age until the end of the world and the resurrection of the just.RH May 3, 1860ST Dec 27, 1905
The obedience required is perfect, loving, heart obedience, not merely formal, outward, or negative avoidance.RH Sep 4, 1900RH Aug 20, 1914RH Apr 23, 1901 The commandments were ordained unto life, and perfect keeping would secure eternal life.RH Apr 23, 1901RH Apr 23, 1901 They must be written in mind and heart by the Spirit of God through faith in Christ who forgives sin.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Sep 27, 1910 So kept they prepare people to meet the judgment without fear and give right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city.ST Dec 27, 1905RH Aug 20, 1914ST Sep 27, 1910
Commandment-keeping by itself cannot buy eternal life or bring justification, pardon for past sin, or the full stature of moral character.ST Jul 17, 1884ST Oct 21, 1886RH Nov 6, 1900 These come only through accepting Christ, His blood, His perfect obedience, and God's righteousness by faith as a new creature.ST Jul 17, 1884ST Oct 21, 1886ST Mar 6, 1884RH Nov 6, 1900 Obedience is the way to life, while disobedience brings death as the consequence of sin, not a punishment arbitrarily imposed.ST Jan 31, 1906ST Oct 18, 1883ST Mar 6, 1884 The commandments were ordained to life and those who do them shall live, yet through sin the law becomes death to the sinner, whose wages is death, and believers are dead to its condemnation only as buried with Christ, dead to transgression.ST Jan 31, 1906ST Oct 18, 1883
Jesus thereby assigns the law its just place, magnifies it, and publicly announces new-covenant principles during His ministry.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Mar 19, 1872 His answer proves the moral law still binding, unchanged, unabolished and unamended under the gospel, and His teaching it before the cross challenges the claim it was abolished at the cross.RH May 3, 1860RH Mar 19, 1872RH Oct 31, 1854ST Mar 29, 1883 Because He enforced the commandments before the supposed abolition, they could not have been incorporated into a new constitution only afterward.RH May 3, 1860RH Mar 17, 1859 His words must not be isolated to make Him teach self-righteousness by works.ST Jul 17, 1884 Those who held the opposite taught that this instruction was given under the old covenant before the cross when Christ kept the Sabbath, and that the old covenant with the Sabbath was abolished at the cross and not commanded again by Christ and the apostles, so it is not now binding.RH Apr 9, 1872
Ruler's Claim Exposed
The young man confidently answered that he had kept the named commandments from his youth up, presenting himself as outwardly upright, moral, respectable and blameless with no open transgression charged against him.ST Mar 5, 1902RH Jul 10, 1856ST Apr 15, 1880RH Feb 19, 1867 He was just in the sense of rendering to every person his due with strict integrity, yet he was not good in the sense of being magnanimous, generous and benevolent toward the needy and suffering.ST Mar 22, 1883ST Nov 25, 1886 Keeping those neighbor-directed commandments alone did not meet the further demand Jesus then made of him to sell his possessions, give to the poor and follow him.ST Mar 5, 1902RH Feb 19, 1867
That claim was false, self-deceived and merely outward, for his observance was only negative and did not prove the spirit of the law, true keeping, heart devotion, love for God, Christian goodness, or understanding of the commandments' depth and of God's character.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Oct 22, 1894ST Nov 24, 1881ST Aug 18, 1909RH Oct 19, 1916 His great wealth, retained while needy people lacked life's necessities, revealed his failure to live by their principle of love for neighbor, and by that principle and its application he had not kept them at all.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Aug 18, 1909 His belief that an outwardly upright life meant he had kept them left him lacking what was needed for eternal life, because the commandments have depth beyond outward compliance and their claims are revealed in a person's life and example.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Oct 22, 1894RH Oct 19, 1916 Outward moral attainment was not enough, for the commandments must be lived out in daily life with practical, wholehearted obedience, not merely accepted as correct theory.RH Jul 10, 1856
Jesus' further call to sell possessions, give to the poor and follow him tested the claim and exposed what he still lacked.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Nov 12, 1857RH Sep 4, 1900ST Sep 17, 1912 The test revealed covetousness and selfishness, with riches as his idol holding his affections, and showed that he had not fulfilled his obligations to his fellow human beings.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Nov 12, 1857RH Sep 4, 1900 He loved his possessions, gifts, standing and treasure better than God, heavenly treasure, Christ and eternal life, valuing earthly wealth above treasure in heaven.RH Nov 26, 1857RH Nov 12, 1857 He withheld from the needy what he owed while retaining abundance amid want, keeping his wealth instead of loving his neighbor as himself.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Nov 12, 1857ST Sep 17, 1912 His love of wealth kept him from loving God above all and his neighbor as himself, and his possessions were the obstacle to following Jesus and inheriting eternal life.RH Nov 26, 1857
By loving himself and property more than God and neighbors he failed to love God with all heart, soul, mind and strength and to love his neighbor as himself.RH Nov 26, 1857RH Nov 26, 1857RH Nov 12, 1857ST Jul 17, 1884RH Oct 21, 1873 Thereby he broke the two great precepts on which all hang and became a violator of them all, keeping neither table though he thought he kept the last six.RH Nov 26, 1857ST Jul 17, 1884 His supreme love of riches made it impossible for him to love God with all his heart and soul and mind, shut his eyes to the wants of his fellow men, and left his heart on his treasure and swallowed up with earthly possessions.RH Nov 26, 1857 His deafness to the poor's cry proved profession without that love is empty show.ST Jul 17, 1884
Outward commandment-keeping and past religious experience therefore did not make his calling sure or remove the need to confront one cherished sin.RH Jul 10, 1856ST Oct 21, 1886 Outwardly knowing or keeping commandments is not enough to prove love for one's neighbor, which requires practical care and generosity, and living a moral life outwardly yet failing in that love fails to obtain eternal life.ST Jun 14, 1899 His own estimate did not meet God's standard, for perfection comes through following Christ, and commandment-keeping by itself cannot bring justification or the full stature of moral character.ST Oct 21, 1886 That requires dying to self, receiving Christ, and as a new creature attaining God's righteousness by faith, which alone enables a person truly to keep the commandments in generosity and benevolence rather than mere justice.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Jul 17, 1884ST Oct 21, 1886
He went away sorrowful, grieved and spiritually poor, rejecting the way pointed out and forfeiting treasure in heaven and fellowship with Christ because his love for earthly treasure was too strong.RH Nov 26, 1857RH May 20, 1862ST Mar 11, 1889RH Jul 29, 1909 He loved his possessions more than eternal life and would not give up his wealth to help others and secure treasure in heaven.RH May 20, 1862ST Mar 11, 1889 His sorrow did him no good because it was not godly sorrow leading to obedience, and his unwillingness to give up his possessions shows the cost of clinging to earthly goods when called to sacrifice for God's work.RH Nov 19, 1908 His case warns that riches can be a snare hindering entrance to the kingdom, for love of riches can lead a person to give up Christ and the reward of eternal life.RH Oct 30, 1856RH Jul 29, 1909
Wealth Generosity and Following
Having wealth is not itself wrong, but trusting in riches and letting love of money rule the heart instead of God is dangerous, for love of money is the root of all evil and covetousness is idolatry, and an idolater cannot enter God's kingdom.ST Sep 22, 1914RH Oct 25, 1906 The rich are the most handicapped spiritually while poverty is no hindrance to spiritual growth, because great possessions can hinder following Jesus and gaining eternal life, and riches can be a snare to entering the kingdom.ST Sep 22, 1914RH Oct 30, 1856RH Dec 17, 1872 Jesus rebukes the possession of riches only when riches hinder the growth of noble character, and He told the ruler to sell and give to the poor not from hatred but from love to save him from that love.ST Sep 22, 1914 Knowing and keeping the commandments is not enough if the heart is ruled by earthly riches and controlled by possessions, so that one forgets the needs of neighbors and will not give up wealth to help others and secure treasure in heaven, and clinging then brings sorrow and the cost of refusing sacrifice.ST Mar 11, 1889RH Oct 25, 1906RH Nov 19, 1908
Perfect commandment-keeping includes surrendering all to God for the good of others, for the further instruction to sell possessions, give to the poor and follow reveals what is still lacking in one who claims to have kept murder, adultery, theft and false witness from youth.RH Sep 4, 1900RH Apr 23, 1901RH Apr 23, 1901 Giving all one has to advance God's cause is the supreme test and perfection of commandment-keeping, and attachment to riches shows obedience and love for neighbor to be incomplete.RH Apr 23, 1901 Genuine love for neighbor as self would lead to sharing wealth with those in need, recognizing it as a trust to use as God directs, investing means in His cause and using hearts, tongues, pens, influence and money to carry saving truth, which is the only way to save the soul; even a poor person must use what he has to bless others.RH Sep 4, 1900RH Apr 23, 1901 Keeping the commandments does not excuse anyone from surrendering wealth to relieve distressed brethren rather than using it for vain indulgence and worldly pleasure.RH Jul 31, 1856
The command to sell everything was specific to him, not a universal requirement that everyone sell all, for as the Great Physician discerning that property stood between him and eternal life He gave exactly the counsel needed, no more severe than necessary; if giving only part would have cured him only part would have been required, but thorough overcoming demanded all.RH Dec 8, 1874 Each person must nevertheless give up whatever competes with following Jesus, since discipleship cannot be offered on terms of wanting to become a disciple while keeping money.RH Dec 8, 1874ST Mar 24, 1881 That temper of renunciation and devotion to heavenly treasure is necessary for Christianity, not a special condition imposed only on him, and the difficulty of the rich entering God's kingdom applies across ages, though God's grace can change the heart.RH Jul 3, 1856 Keeping the commandments does not excuse enjoying and accumulating an estate or leaving the work to others, and becoming a laborer with Jesus means a clear line of separation between His service and the world so that riches and business cannot be taken along; the answer differs from improving society by political action and voting.RH Dec 8, 1874RH Jul 31, 1856RH Sep 16, 1902
Following Christ therefore requires renunciation of the world and all worldly tempers, devotion to heavenly treasure, willingness to deny self, take up the cross and sacrifice property to God's cause, and clear separation between His service and the world.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Sep 16, 1902 The same test comes to many now to prove whether profession is true discipleship and to bring the law home to conscience, exposing selfishness and covetousness which is idolatry, whose remedy and safeguard is sacrifice of property, all in extreme cases, to the cause of God.RH Aug 25, 1904ST Aug 21, 1884 Everyone must make sure to be truly dead to the world and alive to God, rather than deceived in thinking to be in the strait and narrow way while keeping an idol, and must receive present refining and purifying work to be made ready to abide His coming, to live with Him, and to enter through the gates of the city.RH Dec 10, 1857 Stifling conviction and deferring obedience when convinced of duty turns truth into a savor of death, for sorrow without godly obedience does no good, the Spirit will not always strive, and every opportunity and mercy must be accounted for; those who profess devotion while clinging to possessions are therefore called to act and bear fruits meet for repentance.RH Oct 15, 1857ST Aug 21, 1884
Scripture Connections Applied
The moral duties named here, including honorable and truthful conduct in everyday life, are a doorway into the kingdom, so that regeneration and justification rest on affectionate, dutiful uprightness toward others.ST Feb 22, 1883ST Jun 3, 1875 They were taught on the authority of the law of God rather than the law of Moses, and were continued in harmony by the apostles moved by the same Spirit in Christ.ST Feb 22, 1883 They belong to the one royal spiritual law that also says not to covet and to remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy, so that to offend in one point is to be guilty and every point of the ten must be kept.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 13, 1852 They remain necessary things for Gentile Christians and necessary to eternal life, even though the Jerusalem council did not repeat them among its four prohibitions.ST Feb 22, 1883 Ministers must therefore teach them, for as Lord of the Sabbath Christ did not make the Sabbath void or break the law, since He came not to destroy the law but to fulfill it, and whoever breaks one of the least commandments and teaches so shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 13, 1852
The answer was given to a kneeling inquirer on the way who asked what good thing to do for eternal life and then asked which commandments, by naming duties toward fellow people against murder, adultery, stealing and false witness, together with honoring father and mother and loving neighbor as self as the way to enter into life.ST Feb 10, 1898 Its recording three times in Matthew 19, Mark 10 and Luke 18 shows its importance. It supplies the example and precedent for counteracting the love of self that marks the last days and for keeping selfishness out of the church. The commandments were ordained unto life, so that perfect keeping would secure eternal life, and the young man's question about what he still lacked concerns the completeness of his obedience, with the call to sell possessions and give to the poor showing that giving all to advance God's cause is the supreme test and perfection of keeping.RH Apr 23, 1901 His words warn those professing devotion to God while clinging to worldly possessions, calling them to act and bear fruits meet for repentance, and to heed the warning against covetousness which is idolatry.RH Apr 23, 1901RH Oct 15, 1857
The questioner is representative of the respectable wealth-loving of every age and land, and the teaching is eternal truth giving practical lessons for every age and land with especial importance for days of peril.ST Feb 10, 1898 His youth speaks to the youth of all generations, to whom kind advice and warning direct attention to God's commandments. His outwardly blameless moral character and usefulness did not make him a Christian, for he still lacked the one thing needful and remained lost.RH May 18, 1876 Commendable conduct and the belief that one has done all that is required do not excuse failure in obedience, for Christ loved the man yet sent him away sorrowing because he lacked one thing, underscoring that obedience to God's commands matters more than outward religious acts.RH May 18, 1876RH Aug 15, 1871
Sources