Exodus 17:10
So Joshua did as Moses had said to him, and fought with Amalek: and Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
So Joshua did as Moses had said to him, and fought with Amalek: and Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
So Joshua did as Moses had said to him, and fought with Amalek: and Moses, Aaron, and Hur, went up to the top of the hill.
And Joshua doth as Moses hath said to him, to fight with Amalek, and Moses, Aaron, and Hur, have gone up [to] the top of the height;
And Joshua did as Moses had said to him, to fight with Amalek; and Moses, Aaron and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
So Joshua did as Moses had said to him, to fight with Amalek,—and Moses, Aaron and Hur, went up to the top of the hill.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Joshua did as Moses had instructed him and fought against the Amalekites, while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
So Joshua did as Moses had told him, and fought with Amalek; and Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
So Joshua did as Moses said to him, and went to war with Amalek: and Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
So Ioshua did as Moses bad him, and fought with Amalek: and Moses, Aaron, and Hur, went vp to the top of the hill.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Josue did as Moses had spoken, and he fought against Amalec; but Moses, and Aaron, and Hur went up upon the top of the hill.
Pictures




Cross-references
- Deuteronomy 25:17-19
Remember what Amalek did unto thee by the way, when ye were come forth out of Egypt;
Recalls Amalek’s attack on Israel’s weary stragglers and commands their judgment.
- Exodus 17:14
And the LORD said unto Moses, Write this for a memorial in a book, and rehearse it in the ears of Joshua: for I will utterly put out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven.
God commands a memorial and declares Amalek’s remembrance will be blotted out.
- 1 Samuel 15:2
Thus saith the LORD of hosts, I remember that which Amalek did to Israel, how he laid wait for him in the way, when he came up from Egypt.
Recalls Amalek’s attack on Israel as the reason for judgment.
- Numbers 24:20
And when he looked on Amalek, he took up his parable, and said, Amalek was the first of the nations; but his latter end shall be that he perish for ever.
Amalek is named in a pronouncement of destruction, fulfilled in their defeat.
- 1 Chronicles 4:43
And they smote the rest of the Amalekites that were escaped, and dwelt there unto this day.
Simeonites destroyed the surviving Amalekites.
- Numbers 13:16
These are the names of the men which Moses sent to spy out the land. And Moses called Oshea the son of Nun Jehoshua.
Records Moses changing Oshea’s name to Joshua.
- Esther 3:1
After these things did king Ahasuerus promote Haman the son of Hammedatha the Agagite, and advanced him, and set his seat above all the princes that were with him.
Haman is identified as an Agagite and presented as Amalek’s later representative.
- Deuteronomy 25:19
Therefore it shall be, when the LORD thy God hath given thee rest from all thine enemies round about, in the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee for an inheritance to possess it, that thou shalt blot out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven; thou shalt not forget it.
Commands Israel to blot out Amalek’s memory.
- Genesis 36:12
And Timna was concubine to Eliphaz Esau’s son; and she bare to Eliphaz Amalek: these were the sons of Adah Esau’s wife.
Amalek is identified as Esau’s descendant.
- Exodus 17:16
For he said, Because the LORD hath sworn that the LORD will have war with Amalek from generation to generation.
Amalek’s assault is described as opposition to the throne of Jehovah.
- 1 Samuel 15:3
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
Amalek’s destruction is presented as an act of love.
- 1 Samuel 15:8
And he took Agag the king of the Amalekites alive, and utterly destroyed all the people with the edge of the sword.
Agag is identified as king of the Amalekites.
- Numbers 14:45
Then the Amalekites came down, and the Canaanites which dwelt in that hill, and smote them, and discomfited them, even unto Hormah.
cited as Amalekite history continuing the conflict
- 1 Samuel 27:8
And David and his men went up, and invaded the Geshurites, and the Gezrites, and the Amalekites: for those nations were of old the inhabitants of the land, as thou goest to Shur, even unto the land of Egypt.
cited as David defeating surviving Amalekites
- 2 Samuel 8:12
Of Syria, and of Moab, and of the children of Ammon, and of the Philistines, and of Amalek, and of the spoil of Hadadezer, son of Rehob, king of Zobah.
cited as David defeating surviving Amalekites
- 1 Samuel 30:1
And it came to pass, when David and his men were come to Ziklag on the third day, that the Amalekites had invaded the south, and Ziklag, and smitten Ziklag, and burned it with fire;
cited as David defeating surviving Amalekites
- Ezekiel 35:5
Because thou hast had a perpetual hatred, and hast shed the blood of the children of Israel by the force of the sword in the time of their calamity, in the time that their iniquity had an end:
The passage connects Amalek’s hostility with Esau’s enduring hatred.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
15 sources
Joshua obeyed Moses by leading chosen soldiers from the tribes to fight Amalek the next day, while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill overlooking the battle.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.1 On the hill Moses stood with God's rod and raised his hands toward heaven in prayer, so that fighting in the valley below was joined with intercession above.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.1 As long as his hands were stretched upward Israel prevailed and drove the enemy back, but when fatigue let them fall Amalek prevailed, showing that success came not from human power or the rod itself but from God fighting for His people and giving victory in answer to prayer.Ms 125, 1909, par. 6–10SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.1 Yet divine strength was joined with human effort, for Joshua and his men fought actively with the sword below while Aaron and Hur held up Moses' weary hands until sunset, until Amalek was defeated and put to flight.2T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 299.1–2 The uplifted hands declared openly that Israel's help and destiny were in God alone as their acknowledged Leader and Guide, calling His people to take no glory to themselves but to look to Him continually in faith and to hold up His workers today by prayer.Ms 125, 1909, par. 6–102T 107.1Ms 75, 1903, par. 17Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10
Battle Setting and Background
Joshua acted exactly as Moses had told him, taking command of soldiers chosen from the tribes to meet Amalek in battle on the next day, while Moses with Aaron and Hur went up to the top of the hill overlooking the field where the fighting could be watched.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 298.4 The arrangement divided the work between the valley and the height, with Joshua leading Israel's soldiers against the Amalekites below as Moses directed, and Moses, Aaron, and Hur taking their place on the hill above.2T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 298.4GW92 31.3–32.2 Action in the battle below was thus joined from the outset with intercession above, as Moses stood with God's rod and raised his hands toward heaven in prayer for Israel.SG3 257.1–258.24T 530.3–531.2GW92 31.3–32.2
This engagement was the first war between Israel and Amalek in the wilderness, in which the Amalekites were the first to attack Israel there.PP 627.3 The attack came after Israel murmured over its need for water, and God allowed their enemies to make war with them because of their unbelief.SG3 256.1 The purpose in permitting the war was to show Israel that its strength came from Him rather than from itself.SG3 256.1
Amalek's course was marked by cruelty, defiance of God, and idolatry, which led God to pronounce sentence against them through Moses.PP 627.3 They also boasted that Israel's God could not deliver His people, and for that defiant boast God appointed their destruction by the very people they had despised.1SP 361.3–362.1
Victory Through Trusting God
On the hill Moses stood with the rod of God and lifted his hands toward heaven in prayer, entreating God for help, so that the fighting in the valley below was joined with intercession above.2T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2GW92 31.3–32.2PP 299.1–2 While his hands were held up Israel prevailed and drove the enemy back, and only as long as they were stretched upward did that advantage continue.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.1Ms 75, 1903, par. 17Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10 When weariness let them fall, Amalek prevailed and gained the advantage.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 299.1–2
The outcome shows that Israel's success depended not on its own power but on God's direction and support, with God himself fighting for his people, subduing their enemies, and giving strength and victory in answer to prayer.Ms 125, 1909, par. 6–10SG3 257.1–258.21SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 299.1–2 The strength was not in the rod nor in human power, and letting go of hold on God to trust in self would leave his people weaker than those who did not know him.SG3 257.1–258.22T 107.1PP 299.1–2 The uplifted hands openly declared to Israel, to its enemies, and to all around that Israel's help was in God, that God alone held Israel's destiny and was its acknowledged leader.2T 107.1Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10 To him they were to look as their guide in the pillar of cloud and to trust the living God for help and victory.Ms 125, 1909, par. 6–102T 107.1
While the hands were up Israel had vitality, strength, and power, and the victory was given by the angels of God, the principalities and powers.Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10 Divine strength still had to be joined with human effort and preparation, for Joshua and his followers actively fought with the sword below while Moses prayed above.1SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 299.1–2PP 299.3–300.1 In that union of prayer and action Joshua defeated Amalek.1SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2
Support and Present Duty
Aaron and Hur stayed beside Moses on the hill and held up his weary hands, keeping them steady until sunset until Israel won completely and the enemy was put to flight.2T 107.11SP 229.14T 530.3–531.2PP 299.1–2Ms 75, 1903, par. 17 Aaron's part in holding up the leader's hands in the battle with Amalek is the same service remembered elsewhere.PP 425.4
Their support showed Israel its duty to sustain Moses in his arduous work of receiving God's word for them and leading them.2T 107.1PP 299.1–2 It teaches the value of faithful companions who sustain a weary servant through faith and prayer.4T 530.3–531.2 The verse means that when God's workers today go forth into the harvest field, those who remain at home must hold up their hands by prayer for them and must not neglect this duty.Ms 75, 1903, par. 17
The lesson is to take no glory to self but to reach up both hands of faith to God and look to Him and trust Him continually.Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10 That trust does not set aside effort, for the battle is still to be pressed to the gate as though having something to do.Ms 179, 1901, par. 9–10
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
35 sources
At Rephidim soon after the exodus Joshua obeyed Moses, taking chosen men to fight Amalek with the sword, while Moses, Aaron and Hur went up to the top of the hill with the rod of God in Moses' hand as the armies fought below.ST Feb 25, 1889ST Mar 25, 1889ST Jan 20, 1909 When Moses held up his hand Israel prevailed and when he let it down Amalek prevailed, until Aaron and Hur seated him on a stone and held his hands steady till sunset, so that Joshua defeated Amalek and Israel was delivered not by its own strength but by God's direct interposition.ST Apr 15, 1880RH May 29, 1913ST Feb 25, 1889 Prayer on the hill and faithful effort in the valley had to work together, for Moses' upraised hands in prayer were joined to Joshua's victory below and neither without the other is profitable.RH May 29, 1913RH Dec 7, 1911RH Nov 9, 1911RH Aug 1, 1871 Moses mediating on the hilltop while Joshua fought below is matched by Jesus interceding in heaven while His people engage in spiritual warfare, and Aaron and Hur upholding his hands are the example of faithful helpers whose unseen prayer and support bring victory and souls saved.RH Mar 30, 1911RH Nov 17, 1859RH Apr 12, 1860RH Feb 19, 1861 Amalek's attack was unprovoked, treacherous and cruel against weary stragglers by kinsmen who should have helped, challenging God's authority and beginning a war from generation to generation until their remembrance would be utterly put out from under heaven.ST Apr 23, 1902ST Jan 20, 1909RH Sep 15, 1874ST Apr 30, 1902ST Feb 25, 1889
Setting and Battle Course
So Joshua did as Moses had said to him, and fought with Amalek while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill, in Israel's successful encounter with the Amalekites at Rephidim during the wilderness journey after leaving Egypt.ST Aug 24, 1882ST Apr 23, 1902RH Nov 21, 1854 It stood between the Wilderness of Sin and Sinai, soon after the exodus.ST Aug 24, 1882ST Apr 23, 1902 It stands in the same series of divine care as the passage through the Red Sea, the giving of manna, the water from the smitten rock, the staying of Jordan, and the fall of Jericho, as one step in the journey of the elect from Egypt to the promised land in Canaan when the flying hosts of Amalek were put to flight before Israel.RH Nov 21, 1854 It is also placed as during the wilderness journey after leaving Sinai.
The immediate setting was lack of water at Rephidim, which led Israel to murmur against Moses and wish they were back in Egypt.ST Nov 7, 1895 Their failure was unbelief, for although they remembered God's past deliverance and did not deny His power to help, they focused on human leaders and blamed them instead of looking to God.ST Nov 7, 1895 Continued unbelief and blame of this kind warns against perishing in the wilderness.ST Nov 7, 1895
The verse falls in the record of Exodus 16-19 between the first giving of the manna in the Wilderness of Sin on the fifteenth day of the second month and the coming to Mount Sinai thirty days later.ST May 17, 1883 The manna shows Israel already understood the obligations of the Sabbath, gathering a double portion on the sixth day for the sixth day and the Sabbath, resting on the seventh day when none was found in the field.ST May 17, 1883 Those who went out to gather on the seventh day found none and were reproved by Jehovah for refusing to keep His commandments and laws.ST May 17, 1883 The Sabbath was therefore understood, binding, and enforced before Sinai, having been instituted at creation and made for man, with its blessings needed by all men as much as by the Jews.ST May 17, 1883 It was known one month before Sinai, so that its making known at Sinai was its special proclamation with the other commandments, not its first existence or knowledge.RH Jan 12, 1860
Amalek's attack was unprovoked, treacherous, cowardly and cruel, an ambush upon Israel in which they struck the weak, weary, vulnerable people and stragglers who had fallen behind at the rear.ST Aug 24, 1882ST Apr 23, 1902ST Apr 30, 1902 Amalek were the descendants of Esau and thus kinsmen of Israel who should have helped their Israelite relatives rather than attack them.ST Feb 25, 1889 Their cruelty to relatives is linked to God's judgment against them.ST Feb 25, 1889
Joshua obeyed Moses' direction, taking chosen men and leading Israel's fighters with the sword against Amalek.ST Feb 25, 1889ST Jan 20, 1909 This is his first appearance as Moses' minister or servant, already a capable military commander and not inexperienced, Moses' close friend and principal assistant for forty years who remained faithful.ST Feb 25, 1889 His obedience in carrying out Moses' command exemplifies responding to a leader's request for help.RH Mar 30, 1911ST Jan 22, 1894
Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill with the rod of God in Moses' hand while the armies fought on the plain below.ST Feb 25, 1889ST Jun 18, 1885 Aaron and Hur took their place on a nearby hill as his chief assistants, later acting as his deputies while he was absent on the mountain.ST Apr 15, 1880ST Mar 25, 1889 Aaron was of Levi, the tribe entrusted with the priesthood, and Hur was probably a leading prince of Judah.ST Mar 25, 1889
When Moses held up his hand Israel prevailed and when he let it down Amalek prevailed, his upheld arms accompanying Israel's success while weariness and lowered arms allowed Amalek to prevail.ST Feb 25, 1889RH Dec 7, 1911 When his hands grew heavy Aaron and Hur seated him on a stone and held his hands steady on both sides until sunset and the end of the day, and this aid helped bring victory.RH May 29, 1913ST Feb 25, 1889RH Nov 17, 1859 So Joshua defeated Amalek with the sword, the battle continuing alongside Moses' prayer until day's end, and the Amalekites were beaten and fled.RH May 29, 1913ST Feb 25, 1889ST Jun 18, 1885
The conflict was with Amalek as a bitter foe against God and His work, one of the wars Israel met on the way in which the Lord was with them, overthrowing enemies and delivering His people.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Aug 31, 1888 Amalek's host was among the enemies subject to God's sovereign power.ST Nov 4, 1880 It belongs to about sixteen months of leading toward the promised inheritance after deliverance from bondage, when God's power was signally manifested every day for preservation in feeding three million people with manna, providing abundant water by miracle, sending quails for flesh, and defeating attackers, proving His ability and willingness to do all He promised.ST Aug 31, 1888
Judgment Against Amalek Revealed
The victory belongs to the Lord, who approved the faithful service of both Joshua in the valley and Moses on the hill, for Israel prevailed while Moses sought God's help with upheld hands and Joshua led chosen men with the sword, and when his hands grew heavy Aaron and Hur seated him on a stone and held them steady until sunset.ST Apr 15, 1880ST Feb 25, 1889 Israel was delivered not by its own strength but by God's direct interposition, as the Lord overthrew enemies coming against them in the wilderness and delivered His people.ST Apr 15, 1880ST Feb 25, 1889ST Aug 31, 1888 That daily manifestation of power in feeding three million with manna, providing water by miracle, sending quails for flesh, and defeating attackers proved His ability and willingness to do all He promised on the way toward the promised inheritance after bondage.ST Aug 31, 1888 The battle is a further sign that God was faithful to His promises, for as Jacob was saved from Esau through prevailing prayer, his descendants were saved from Esau's people, the Amalekites who should have helped their Israelite kinsmen rather than attack them, and their cruelty to relatives is linked to God's judgment against them.ST Feb 25, 1889
Bible memorials begin with the events commemorated by them, and God commanded that this event and His promise be recorded and repeated to Joshua.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Apr 30, 1902 Moses' altar named The Lord my banner memorialized God as His people's banner in the conflict with Amalek after their treacherous attack on the weak, weary and stragglers ended in defeat for Amalek.ST Apr 30, 1902 The chapter gives the setting for and contains the prophecy that the remembrance of Amalek would be utterly put out from under heaven, with war with Amalek from generation to generation until the last of the nation ceased from the earth.ST Jan 20, 1909RH Sep 15, 1874 That attack at Rephidim is described as a fanatical assault whose remembrance was later to be blotted out from under heaven.ST Apr 30, 1902ST May 23, 1911
Amalek's opposition indicates Amalek would remain against God's throne, since by attacking Israel they challenged God's authority established among His people.ST Aug 24, 1882 That treacherous hostility began at Rephidim with an unprovoked, cowardly and cruel ambush striking those weakened by exhaustion who had fallen behind, and it was the reason given for Saul's later destruction of the Amalekites.ST Aug 24, 1882ST Apr 23, 1902 This hostility later appears in Haman, a descendant of King Agag, whose plot against the Jews continued that opposition to God's people, but God overruled his plans to save them.ST Apr 23, 1902 That unprovoked attack began four hundred years of mercy in which the Amalekites could seek God and make matters right.ST Feb 9, 1915
At the end of that time their iniquity was full, they had become a curse to themselves and a menace to surrounding nations, and letting them live would have caused the eternal destruction of many souls through wicked influence.ST Feb 9, 1915 So the later command to destroy them utterly was an act of love in which God slew hundreds to save thousands.ST Feb 9, 1915 Amalek stands as an alien outside God's people, so that to be an Amalekite is to be an outsider who is not in the message of present truth.RH Dec 9, 1858
Prayer and Spiritual Warfare
The fighting in the valley and the intercession on the hill must go together, for divine strength is joined to human effort and either without the other is weak and unprofitable, and the prayer continued alongside the battle until the end of the day when victory came.RH May 29, 1913 The upheld arms accompanied Israel's success while weariness and lowered arms let Amalek prevail, showing the importance of prayer in the struggle.RH Dec 7, 1911RH Nov 9, 1911RH Aug 1, 1871 The prayerful uplifted hands were connected with victory in the valley, and the prayer accompanied the defeat of Amalek.RH Dec 7, 1911RH Nov 9, 1911RH Aug 1, 1871
Going up to the hilltop while the fighting went on below was mediation for the people, matched by Jesus interceding in heaven while His people are engaged in spiritual warfare.RH Feb 19, 1861 Aaron and Hur are examples of faithful men and women who pray in secret and uphold God's cause.RH Apr 12, 1860 Their unseen prayers affect individuals, families, churches, and the world, bringing hundreds to salvation in answer to prayer offered when no eye but God could see.RH Apr 12, 1860 God will openly reward them at the day of judgment and in the world of retribution when the secrets of all hearts are revealed, the souls won through them shining like gems in the crown of rejoicing forever, while these faithful helpers themselves shine like stars forever in the kingdom of God, elevated in heavenly glory before the whole universe and all holy beings.RH Apr 12, 1860
Workers need others to uphold them as Moses' hands were held up in the conflict, and such aid helped bring the victory.RH Mar 30, 1911RH Nov 17, 1859 Carrying out the command to fight is an example of responding to a leader's request for help and thus helping the pastor.RH Mar 30, 1911ST Jan 22, 1894 The battle stands as an obstacle on the way forward that faith and works can overcome.ST Jul 8, 1880
The battle with Amalek pictures the Christian's continual struggle against temptation, with assaults from without and sinful passions within threatening to overrun the soul and destroy spiritual possessions.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jul 20, 1904 That struggle should drive the Christian to Jesus Christ for victory rather than to discouragement.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jul 20, 1904 The hands held up in battle are a picture of keeping watch over the heart, for as Amalek prevailed as soon as the hands grew heavy and sank, so corruption prevails as soon as watchfulness stops.RH Oct 2, 1856 Keeping the heart is therefore a work never done till life ends, allowing not even a few minutes of intermission, and brief neglect costs many sad days and nights as with David and Peter.RH Oct 2, 1856
The hand wielding the sword in the valley did not grow weary, but the hand holding the rod on the hilltop grew weary.ST Jul 19, 1883 Holding the rod was the more spiritual duty, and the more spiritual the duty the more apt people are to tire of it.ST Jul 19, 1883
Sources