John 5:18
Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that God was his Father, making himself equal with God.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that God was his Father, making himself equal with God.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For this cause therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only brake the sabbath, but also called God his own Father, making himself equal with God.
because of this, then, were the Jews seeking the more to kill him, because not only was he breaking the sabbath, but he also called God his own Father, making himself equal to God.
For this therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he had not only violated the sabbath, but also said that God was his own Father, making himself equal with God.
On this account, therefore, the rather, were the Jews seeking to slay him,—because, not only was he breaking the Sabbath, but was calling God, his own Father, making, himself, equal, with, God.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Because of this, the Jews tried all the harder to kill Him. Not only was He breaking the Sabbath, but He was even calling God His own Father, making Himself equal with God.
For this cause therefore the Jews sought all the more to kill him, because he not only broke the Sabbath, but also called God his own Father, making himself equal with God.
For this cause the Jews had an even greater desire to put Jesus to death, because not only did he not keep the Sabbath but he said God was his Father, so making himself equal with God.
Therefore the Iewes sought the more to kill him: not onely because he had broken the Sabbath: but said also that God was his Father, and made himselfe equall with God.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Hereupon therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he did not only break the sabbath, but also said God was his Father, making himself equal to God.
Cross-references 20 of 49
- John 5:8-10
Jesus saith unto him, Rise, take up thy bed, and walk.
Jesus healed the man on the Sabbath and commanded him to carry his bed, prompting the accusation.
- Mark 2:28
Therefore the Son of man is Lord also of the sabbath.
Jesus is Lord of the Sabbath, though accused of breaking it.
- Exodus 20:8-11
Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
The Sabbath command is the law at issue in the dispute.
- Matthew 12:1-13
At that time Jesus went on the sabbath day through the corn; and his disciples were an hungred, and began to pluck the ears of corn, and to eat.
Jesus defends lawful Sabbath acts and healing.
- John 7:22-23
Moses therefore gave unto you circumcision; ( not because it is of Moses, but of the fathers;) and ye on the sabbath day circumcise a man.
Jesus compares Sabbath healing with circumcision performed on the Sabbath.
- John 9:16
Therefore said some of the Pharisees, This man is not of God, because he keepeth not the sabbath day. Others said, How can a man that is a sinner do such miracles? And there was a division among them.
both record the false charge of Sabbath-breaking
- Genesis 2:2-3
And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.
God rested on the seventh day and blessed and sanctified it.
- Mark 3:1-6
And he entered again into the synagogue; and there was a man there which had a withered hand.
Jesus healed on the Sabbath, intensifying plans against him.
- Luke 13:14
And the ruler of the synagogue answered with indignation, because that Jesus had healed on the sabbath day, and said unto the people, There are six days in which men ought to work: in them therefore come and be healed, and not on the sabbath day.
A synagogue ruler objects to Jesus healing on the Sabbath.
- John 10:36
Say ye of him, whom the Father hath sanctified, and sent into the world, Thou blasphemest; because I said, I am the Son of God?
Jesus answers the charge of making himself God by affirming that he is the Son of God.
- John 5:26-27
For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself;
The Son has life in himself and authority to execute judgment.
- Luke 6:7
And the scribes and Pharisees watched him, whether he would heal on the sabbath day; that they might find an accusation against him.
Religious leaders watched Jesus heal on the Sabbath to find an accusation.
- Matthew 12:12
How much then is a man better than a sheep? Wherefore it is lawful to do well on the sabbath days.
Jesus teaches that doing good on the Sabbath is lawful.
- John 5:10
The Jews therefore said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath day: it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.
The Sabbath dispute preceded the effort to kill Jesus.
- John 8:58-59
Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Before Abraham was, I am.
Jesus declares His preexistence, and the Jews try to stone Him for it.
- Hebrews 1:3
Who being the brightness of his glory, and the express image of his person, and upholding all things by the word of his power, when he had by himself purged our sins, sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high;
The Son bears the Father’s express image and shares his divine glory.
- Mark 2:27
And he said unto them, The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath:
Jesus teaches that the Sabbath was made for humanity, not as a burden of rules.
- John 1:1
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.
The Word was God, affirming Christ’s equality with God.
- John 7:19
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you keepeth the law? Why go ye about to kill me?
Jesus charges the rulers with breaking the law while seeking to kill him.
- Jeremiah 17:21-22
Thus saith the LORD; Take heed to yourselves, and bear no burden on the sabbath day, nor bring it in by the gates of Jerusalem;
Forbids carrying burdens on the Sabbath, the charge raised against Jesus.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
45 sources
After healing the disabled man at Bethesda on the Sabbath, the Jewish leaders sought all the more to kill Jesus for what they called Sabbath-breaking and for calling God His own Father in making Himself equal with God.DA 201.3–4Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15DA 207.4–208.17MR 278.1–3 The Sabbath charge was false, for relieving suffering and doing good honors the day rather than desecrates it.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–82SP 164.1–2ST May 13, 1886HSFM 234.3–235.2Ms 29a, 1885, par. 6–8 Their reading of His claim to equality was correct in the highest sense, not the shared sonship the nation claimed, and on that ground they accused Him of blasphemy.DA 207.4–208.1RH Mar 5, 1901DA 231.2PP 37.1–38.1 By that claim He asserted equal right with God to carry on His Father's sacred work that never ceases, including healing the sick in harmony with the Father.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–8DA 207.4–208.12SP 164.1–2ST May 13, 18862SP 165.1 Convicted yet enraged, the rulers grew more bitter and determined to take His life, and only fear of the people who recognized Him as Healer restrained them from slaying Him on the spot.Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15DA 207.4–208.1ST Feb 15, 18773RED 35.23RED 28.2–29.1
Bethesda Healing Setting
John 5:18 belongs to the healing of the crippled, paralytic, impotent and disabled man at the pool of Bethesda on the Sabbath during the second visit to Jerusalem.DA 201.3–47MR 278.1–3Lt 1, 1876, par. 6 It records the Jews accusing Him of Sabbath-breaking for that healing and introduces the discourse He gave in reply to the accusation.DA 201.3–47MR 278.1–3Lt 1, 1876, par. 6 Fear of the people kept the leaders, who wanted to take His life, from slaying Him on the spot.
He healed deliberately on that Sabbath, knowing the act would stir Jewish prejudice and cut short His work.DA 201.3–4 He did so, with the command to the man to carry his bed, to expose the burden of Jewish restrictions and open the way to declare their traditions void.DA 206.1–2 His act did not lessen the Sabbath law but honored it by freeing it from requirements that had made it a burden instead of a blessing.DA 206.1–2
The charge of breaking the Sabbath law was brought before the Sanhedrin and its tribunal, where Jesus, the Lord of the Sabbath, stood on trial for His life.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 32.1–2DA 204.4–205.12SP 169.1–2 The leaders hoped by it to condemn His teaching and weaken His influence with the people.DA 204.4–205.1 He refused to plead guilty to any wrong or to submit to their questioning and examination, because they had no authority from the Jewish system to interfere with His work and their claim rested only on pride and arrogance.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 32.1–22SP 169.1–2 His bold declaration of His mission and work, His claims and words, were unanswerable and left His judges, looking on with mingled astonishment and rage, unable to condemn Him.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 32.1–22SP 169.1–2 Part of the accusation fastened on His command to the healed man to carry his bed, which the rulers treated as sacrilege and a Sabbath violation while overlooking the healing itself, hoping to use it as grounds to condemn Him.2SP 159.1–2
Sabbath Charge Refuted
The charge was that He had broken the Sabbath because He healed and restored a suffering man, the paralytic, on that day, a judgment made according to a narrow understanding and interpretation of the law.Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–82SP 164.1–23RED 27.1–2ST Apr 7, 1881 That healing did not desecrate the Sabbath but honored it, for relieving human suffering and doing good is in harmony with God's law and the Father's plan.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–82SP 164.1–2ST May 13, 18863RED 27.1–2 The Sabbath law forbids toil for a livelihood and labor for worldly pleasure or profit, not doing good.2SP 164.1–2ST May 13, 1886
The rest day was sanctified and set apart by Jehovah for a special purpose after finishing the work of creation, and as God ceased His labor of creating and rested on that day and blessed it, so man is to leave the occupation of daily life.2SP 164.1–22SP 165.1 It was not intended as a period of useless inactivity, but for devoting those sacred hours to healthful rest, to worship, and to holy deeds.2SP 165.1ST Feb 15, 1877 The accusation that He broke the Sabbath was false and could not be sustained or proved.HSFM 234.3–235.2Ms 29a, 1885, par. 6–8Ms 28, 1899, par. 11–12Ms 48, 1893, par. 7 This is shown by the fact that His enemies afterward had to hire false witnesses to testify against Him, for if the charge had been true they would not have needed false testimony.HSFM 234.3–235.2Ms 29a, 1885, par. 6–8Ms 48, 1893, par. 7
To say Christ broke the Sabbath is to stand with the Pharisees in their false accusation against Him, repeating the charge made against Him by those who sought to condemn and kill Him while He was guiltless and had presented evidence of His innocence.Ms 29a, 1885, par. 6–8Ms 48, 1893, par. 7 His works were in perfect harmony with God's law, for Christ obeyed the law perfectly in human nature, demonstrating that it can be kept.Ms 28, 1899, par. 11–12 The act of healing the disabled man should have been sufficient evidence that He was the world's Redeemer and the Son of God, but the prejudice, unbelief, and opposition of the scribes and Pharisees led them to reject Him and turn the evidence against Him.Ms 191, 1897, par. 8 His defense included that as the law allowed circumcision on the Sabbath when the eighth day fell then, making a man completely well on the Sabbath was also in harmony with the law, requiring them to judge righteously rather than by appearances.DA 456.2–4
As Lord of the Sabbath He was brought before the tribunal of the rulers to be tried for His life on the charge of breaking the Sabbath law, and stood arraigned before an earthly court.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 32.1–22SP 169.1–2 He refused to plead guilty to any wrong or admit wrongdoing, and refused to submit to be examined by them or submit to their questioning, for they had no authority from the Jewish system to interfere with His work and their claim to authority rested only on pride and arrogance.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 32.1–22SP 169.1–2 His judges looked on Him with mingled astonishment and rage, yet His words and mission were unanswerable and left them unable to condemn Him.ST Feb 15, 18772SP 169.1–2 He stood before His accusers clothed with divine grace and spoke words that pierced them like arrows of truth, offering no apology for the act complained of and giving no explanation of His purpose in doing it, but turning upon the rulers so that the accused became the accuser.2SP 170.2
Equality With God
The leaders understood correctly that by calling God His own Father He was claiming equality with God in the highest sense, not merely using the shared language by which the whole nation called God Father, and on that ground they charged Him with blasphemy.DA 207.4–208.1RH Mar 5, 1901 His oneness with the Father was oneness in nature, will, and purpose, and in sharing His work and counsel.RH Mar 5, 1901 By that claim He asserted equal rights with God to do a sacred work of the same character and kind as His Father's work that never ceases, including healing the sick.DA 207.4–208.12SP 164.1–2ST May 13, 18863RED 27.1–2ST Apr 7, 1881
That equality affirms the Father and the Son as distinct, and it does not mean He acts independently, for the Son does what He sees the Father doing and the Father shows Him all He does.Ms 111, 1903, par. 3–6 His answer that He worked as the Father worked explained His relation to the Father and the authority behind His actions.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–8 The verses that follow present the Son as doing the Father's works, giving life, and exercising judgment, and they call all people to honor the Son as they honor the Father.Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15 He is the only one with power to give life, which the leaders rejected in Satan's effort to separate the Father and the Son.Ms 69, 1912, par. 40–45
Before the Sanhedrin He took His true station and declared Himself the Son of the Eternal, thereby proclaiming His divinity and Sonship.2SP 165.1ST Feb 15, 1877DA 231.2 The Son has been equal with the Father from the beginning, without change of position or authority, a fact made necessary to state plainly by Lucifer's envy and claims to equality with Christ.PP 37.1–38.1 He defended His Sabbath work at Bethesda by affirming His Sonship and declaring that He worked in harmony with the Father as the Father worked, at the same time teaching the true meaning of the Sabbath.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–82SP 165.1ST Feb 15, 1877DA 284.2–285.3
Murderous Opposition Intensified
The Jews sought the more to kill Him because the two charges stood together, Sabbath-breaking for His work of healing on that day and making Himself equal with God by calling God His own Father, and their anger grew still stronger after His answer that His Father works hitherto and He works, which explained His relation to the Father and the authority behind His actions.Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–8Lt 20, 1899, par. 19–20 The verses that follow set forth the Son as doing the Father's works, giving life and exercising judgment, and call all to honor the Son as they honor the Father.Lt 248, 1906, par. 11–15 Relieving human suffering did not desecrate the Sabbath but was in harmony with God's law and the Father's plan.Lt 189, 1909, par. 5–8
Unable to answer His Sabbath arguments drawn from the work of God and the unceasing round of nature, having only custom and tradition against Him, the rulers evaded those points and turned their anger against Him for making Himself equal with God.ST Feb 15, 18773RED 28.2–29.12SP 165.2–166.1 They raged without bounds to seize Him and put Him to death, and were only prevented from doing so.ST Feb 15, 18772SP 165.2–166.1 They sought to stir up anger against Him and to turn the people against Him.3RED 28.2–29.12SP 165.2–166.1
His words and works convicted them of guilt and affirmed His divine authority, yet conviction only made them more bitter and determined to take His life.3RED 35.2ST Feb 15, 18772SP 172.2 His mighty works had arrested the people's notice and aroused wonder, and His searching discourse deeply convicted many so they were ready to acknowledge His divine authority, while the same words pressed guilt home upon the rulers' consciences and thrilled their hearts with condemnation.ST Feb 15, 1877 Having failed to subvert His authority or turn the people's respect and attention from Him, they denounced Him as an impostor, sent messengers over the country to warn the people against Him, and sent spies to watch Him and report what He said and did.3RED 35.2ST Feb 15, 1877 He stood now most surely under the shadow of the cross.3RED 35.2ST Feb 15, 1877 The plot against His life began with the Sabbath healing at Bethesda, which made it unsafe to remain in Jerusalem, so He left Jerusalem for Galilee and made Capernaum the scene of His labors.DA 456.2–43RED 36.12SP 173.1–174.2
Only the people kept the authorities from slaying Him on the spot, for fear of the people restrained them.DA 207.4–208.12SP 164.1–2ST Apr 7, 1881 Many recognized Him as the healer and friend of the suffering, listened with candor and fairness, defended and justified His healing of the man afflicted for thirty-eight years, and put the rulers to shame.DA 207.4–208.1ST Feb 15, 18773RED 28.2–29.12SP 165.2–166.1 The priests and elders therefore had to restrain their hatred and wait for a more favorable time to carry out their design.ST Feb 15, 18772SP 165.2–166.1 His claim of equal rights with God to do a sacred work of the same character as His Father's work that never ceases made them still more incensed.DA 207.4–208.12SP 164.1–2ST Apr 7, 1881
Their claimed zeal for the sacredness of the day and for God concealed anger and fear that He was gaining influence and that His challenge to their traditions threatened their power.RH Mar 5, 1901 They treated His Sabbath miracles bringing relief to the afflicted as a pretext for hostility and as grounds to condemn Him as a Sabbath-breaker, seeking grounds to accuse Him in efforts to destroy Him and put an end to His life.2SP 367.3–368.1RH Mar 5, 1901Ms 191, 1897, par. 3–4 His teaching exposed their failure to live by the law they claimed to defend, and their murderous intent contradicted their claim to defend the law, as shown when He challenged them for seeking to kill Him and reasoned that as circumcision was allowed on the Sabbath when the eighth day fell then, making a man completely well on the Sabbath was also in harmony with the law, requiring righteous judgment rather than judgment by appearances.DA 456.2–42SP 340.1–2 They watched Him, hid their intent from the people, and planned to use accusations against Him.2SP 340.1–2RH Mar 5, 1901Ms 191, 1897, par. 3–4 His faithfulness to God's commandments provoked the accusations of Sabbath-breaking and blasphemy because human traditions and requirements had been placed above God's law, and the same pattern of reproach and persecution would be repeated against His faithful followers.COL 170.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
82 sources
On the weekly seventh-day Sabbath at the pool of Bethesda Jesus healed a man infirm thirty-eight years and told him to rise and carry his mat, for which the Jews sought the more to kill him as a supposed Sabbath-breaker who called God his Father.ST Feb 15, 1877ST Mar 8, 1899RH Jan 19, 1860ST Apr 11, 1900ST Mar 22, 1899
He had not broken the Sabbath, for healing the afflicted in mercy and commanding the carrying of the small rug as evidence of the cure are lawful doing of good in God's service, while the charge rested only on burdensome human tradition.ST Dec 4, 1884RH Sep 17, 1861RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Aug 27, 1885
Calling God his own proper Father meant he is the only begotten Son partaking of the substance and nature of God, which the Jews correctly understood as making himself equal with God.ST Jan 25, 1899ST Aug 20, 1896ST Nov 1, 1877RH Jul 20, 1916RH Nov 14, 1854
Those who held otherwise taught that he did not claim independent equality but acted only in dependence on what the Father showed him, and that he denied making himself equal with God.ST May 3, 1899ST Jan 25, 1899RH Nov 10, 1859
Their seeking to kill him for faithful keeping against tradition continued until they killed him with Rome's aid, yet his words and works uphold the Sabbath's sanctity and show that doing good and God's work is its true keeping.ST Nov 14, 1900STST Jan 21, 1903ST Nov 14, 1900
Context and Setting
The setting is the healing at the pool of Bethesda in Jerusalem on the Sabbath during a feast, when a man infirm for thirty-eight years was healed and told to rise, take up his mat and walk.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Dec 4, 1884ST Jun 20, 1911 The healing brought a false charge of Sabbath-breaking, and placed Jesus in Jerusalem where the Jews were seeking to kill him.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899 Their anger turned against him because he made himself equal with God, growing so furious that they nearly seized him, but the people listened candidly and defended his healing of the man afflicted for thirty-eight years, so hatred was restrained for a time.ST Feb 15, 1877 The charge arose from a narrow, mistaken view of the Sabbath commandment, since doing good, meeting need, and serving God on the Sabbath is lawful, and the commandment forbids one's own secular work, not work done in God's service for his glory.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Jun 20, 1911
The account stands in the Gospel of John, the beloved disciple, a very late New Testament writing made about fifty years after Matthew.ST Sep 10, 1912 It does not deal with the beginning of the earthly life of the Lord but plunges at once into doctrine, the spiritual meat of it, to impress the great fact that he who came and lived and died was the eternal Word.ST Sep 10, 1912 Its great lesson is the life which God offers and how that life may be received, uniting temple worship with helpful ministry on the Sabbath day.ST Sep 10, 1912 John 5 closes the readings in John for the week with closing verses in which the divine Lord gives endorsement to Moses and what Moses wrote.ST Sep 10, 1912
The passage confronts rejection of Christ, in that the Jews searched the Scriptures which testify of him yet refused to come to him for life.ST Sep 3, 1896 Their unbelief showed that they did not truly believe Moses, whose writings pointed to Christ.ST Sep 3, 1896 Even in the healing of the palsied man Christ the Life-giver and his mission were doubted, and unbelief plotted to kill him.ST Sep 26, 1895
The Sabbath named is the weekly seventh-day Sabbath of the Lord, the day God rested, rather than a ceremonial sabbath.RH Jan 19, 1860RH Mar 19, 1857 Its teaching applies to that day, not to Sunday.ST Apr 11, 1900 The day the Jews regarded as the Sabbath in their conflict with Jesus is still the Christian Sabbath, with no revision or repeal of the original command, and it remained binding during the gospel dispensation even after the crucifixion.RH Jan 19, 1860ST
The text must be examined by itself with the aid of the Spirit and given its own due weight and proper setting.ST Jan 29, 1902 Being grouped with other New Testament texts about keeping the Sabbath does not prove it teaches that it makes no difference what day is kept.ST Jan 29, 1902 The Sabbath charge arose from the healing and from the command that the healed man carry his bed, and the question to be asked is whether either act was forbidden by the Sabbath law and what, if anything, was transgressed.RH Apr 28, 1863
When Christ came the Jews were strict and particular about keeping the Sabbath, which shows the Sabbath had not been lost before his time. The controversy was not over which day was the Sabbath but over their interpretation of how it should be kept.ST Aug 20, 1896 Jewish regulations treated healing on the Sabbath as unlawful, and Christ's healing and his public declaration of equality with God brought increased hostility.ST Apr 5, 1899ST Aug 20, 1896 Their zeal to defend that interpretation led them to violate the commandment against killing, while the man unable to walk represents those who have no life apart from Christ.ST Aug 20, 1896
The Sabbath was set apart by Jehovah after creation, not for useless inactivity but for rest from daily work, worship and holy deeds.ST Feb 15, 1877 This bears on the Sabbath's origin and age.RH Apr 28, 1863 The response to the Sabbath healing joined the charge of breaking the Sabbath, as alleged, with the charge of calling God his Father, regarded as making himself equal with God.RH Apr 28, 1863 Jesus' defense that his Father works and that he works likewise appeals to the Father's continuing preserving and caring work.RH Apr 28, 1863
Sabbath Charge Is False
John 5:18 states the accusation that Jesus had broken the Sabbath, but the accusation itself does not prove that he actually did so, for the breaking was only supposed and not real.ST Dec 4, 1884RH Sep 17, 1861ST Aug 27, 1885ST Sep 2, 1897ST Jan 22, 1885 His testimony that he kept his Father's commandments shows he did not break the Sabbath, and his healing on that day violated no law of God.ST Dec 4, 1884RH Sep 17, 1861ST Aug 27, 1885 The Jews in their own minds counted his healing and his direction for the healed man to carry his bed as Sabbath-breaking, while holding a corrupted standard built on human commandments and tradition.RH Sep 17, 1861ST Sep 2, 1897 The small burden was not forbidden by Scripture and served as evidence of the cure.RH Sep 17, 1861
The charge was completely refuted, for he did only what was lawful and kept the Sabbath perfectly by honoring God and doing good to others.ST Feb 1, 1899ST Sep 12, 1911ST Feb 27, 1893 He kept his Father's commandments, did no sin, and did not relax the Sabbath.ST Aug 27, 1885RH Apr 7, 1851 As Lord of the Sabbath and its living expression, which is the sign of what he is to mankind, it was impossible for him to do anything on the Sabbath that was not Sabbath-keeping, because the very doing of it expressed the meaning of the Sabbath.ST Nov 14, 1900 What the Pharisees and doctors of the law called Sabbath-breaking was their name for his Sabbath-keeping because it did not suit their ideas and traditions.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Sep 12, 1911ST Feb 27, 1893
Healing the afflicted exactly accords with the design of the Sabbath, upholds the law's true letter and spirit, and was done to relieve suffering and honor God, not in a careless or irreverent manner.RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 11, 1894RH Dec 10, 1857 Such acts of mercy free the day from restrictive human traditions so it can be a time of rest, delight and holy joy.ST Jun 11, 1894 The commandment forbids one's own secular work for livelihood, pleasure or profit, not work done in God's service for his glory, including doing good, meeting need and serving God.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Jun 20, 1911 Restoring the crippled man was therefore an act of mercy permitted by the Sabbath commandment, kept in the true spirit of the commandment without contempt.RH Dec 10, 1857
The bed the healed man was told to carry was a light object, only a blanket or rug on which he lay by the pool rather than a bed as now understood, carried to show that the man had truly been healed.RH Sep 17, 1861RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874 The Sabbath charge rested on burdensome human tradition that held every act of healing unlawful, not on God's law, and Christ disregarded those traditions while keeping the commandment.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Aug 27, 1885 His ideas of the Sabbath are God's ideas, while the opposing ideas were directly opposite and wrong, so the controversy is whether God's ideas or man's ideas should prevail.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Sep 2, 1897 He held the mind of God and the true idea of Sabbath-keeping, and deliberately healed on that day to restore its intended blessing and holy dignity without lessening the day's sanctity.ST Sep 2, 1897ST Jul 15, 1897
His appeal to his Father's continuing work of preserving and caring for humanity since creation showed his healing followed the Father's example and did not dishonor the Sabbath.RH Sep 17, 1861RH Feb 11, 1862 The Father's continuing merciful, life-preserving work did not mean the Father disregarded the Sabbath.RH Sep 17, 1861 His answer that the Son did only what he saw the Father do showed humility, acted in accordance with the Father's works, and answered the charge of self-exaltation.RH Sep 17, 1861RH Feb 11, 1862 Yet some have used the verse to represent him as actually violating or neglecting the Sabbath, even arguing that if the Sabbath commandment remained binding he should have been stoned as a sinner, while others have maintained he always observed it, leaving a disagreement over whether he violated the Sabbath.RH Oct 24, 1854ST Jul 27, 1882ST
Sonship Means Equality With God
The Jews added to the Sabbath accusation a second charge, that by calling God his own proper Father Jesus was making himself equal with God.ST Jan 25, 1899ST Aug 20, 1896ST Jan 21, 1903RH Nov 10, 1859 The claim was not sonship in the accommodated sense in which angels and holy men like Abraham, Moses and the prophets are called sons of God, which would make him only a good and righteous man.ST Nov 1, 1877 The Jews themselves claimed to be sons of God in that sense, yet they understood his claim to mean that God was his Father indeed and truly, his proper Father, thus making himself equal with God by actually partaking of the substance and nature of the eternal God.ST Nov 1, 1877 The verse therefore proves he is the Son of God in the natural and proper sense, in the same sense as a human son begotten of his own father's substance and person.ST Nov 1, 1877
Calling God his Father was claiming to be the only begotten Son of God, his highest title, making him equal with God by partaking of the divine nature.RH Nov 14, 1854 In this character as the Son of God he is the true Messiah and Saviour of the world, the object of faith, the author of eternal life, the object of worship by all the host of heaven, and the Creator of the worlds in his primeval nature.RH Nov 14, 1854 The Jews understood the claim in the highest sense, not merely as the nation's way of calling God their Father.RH Mar 5, 1901 Jesus claimed to be God's Son, one with the Father in nature, will and purpose, and to share in his work and counsel, claiming equal rights with God to do sacred work of the same kind as the Father's.ST May 13, 1886RH Mar 5, 1901 The Father had given him authority to execute judgment because he is the Son of man, and he was not merely a good man but God with us, whose words and works were the Father's, working with the Father in everything and always doing what pleased him.RH Jul 20, 1916RH Jul 24, 1913
The Jews correctly and logically reasoned that his declaring God to be his Father and himself to be the Son of God was claiming equality with God.ST Feb 20, 1901 His true humanity with his words and mighty works reveals he is more than a man, and the true claim is the very foundation of hope.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Feb 20, 1901 One position holds that they did not understand his claim to mean that he was the only Jehovah, or the same person as the Father.RH Nov 10, 1859 Another position holds that he did not claim equality with the Father independently, but as the Son acted in dependence on what the Father showed him and was equal with the Father in what the Father had given him.ST Jan 25, 1899 In that teaching the claim meant that he was God's Son and shared a united interest with the Father, not that he was the very and eternal God.RH Nov 10, 1859 Still another position holds that though he came working the works of God in healing the sick and raising the dead, he promptly met and denied the charge of making himself equal with God.ST May 3, 1899
The authorities regarded his action as a violation of the law and his claim as blasphemy, and their charge and rejection came from blindness and lack of knowledge of God and Christ, for with that knowledge they would not have rejected his Son.ST May 3, 1899ST Apr 7, 1881RH Nov 14, 1854 After the accusation of false witnesses failed to furnish ground for condemnation, this true claim became the final ground on which he was condemned, and the failure of his enemies to find fault confirmed the faultless perfection of his character.ST Feb 20, 1901 The belief that Christ, as the Son of God, is equal to the Father remains a point of disagreement.ST Nov 27, 1893
Murderous Opposition to Jesus
The healing on the Sabbath was the immediate cause of hostility, and the claim that God was his own Father added to the accusation, so persecution intensified into seeking the more to kill him.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Jan 21, 1903ST Nov 14, 1900 This marks the very first open steps ever taken to harm him in any way, taken because his keeping did not suit their ideas, and upon this Sabbath point everything else against him turned.ST Nov 14, 1900 By opposing his words and actions on the Sabbath they rejected him himself.ST Nov 14, 1900
He was arraigned before their tribunal on the charge of breaking the Sabbath law.ST Feb 15, 1877 He stood there as Lord of the Sabbath and refused to plead guilty or submit to their questioning, because they had no authority from the Jewish system to interfere with his work, their claim resting on pride and arrogance.ST Feb 15, 1877 His words and mission left them unable to condemn him.ST Feb 15, 1877
They evaded his arguments about the Sabbath and turned anger against him because he made himself equal with God.ST Feb 15, 1877ST Apr 7, 1881 Their fury was so great that they nearly seized him to kill him then.ST Feb 15, 1877ST Apr 7, 1881 The people listened candidly and defended his healing of the man afflicted for thirty-eight years, freeing the day from burdens imposed by Jewish rules, and the people's intervention alone kept the rulers from killing him and restrained their hatred for a time.ST Feb 15, 1877ST Apr 7, 1881 He had claimed the right to do a sacred work of the same character as his Father's work, which the authorities regarded as violation of the law and blasphemy.ST Apr 7, 1881
His mighty works had first arrested notice and aroused wonder, and his searching and impressive discourse disclosing his true character and divine authority powerfully affected and deeply convicted many so they were ready to acknowledge his divine authority.ST Feb 15, 1877 The same words thrilled the rulers' hearts with condemnation and pressed guilt home upon their consciences, yet this only made them more bitter and fixed them in determination to take his life.ST Feb 15, 1877 Having failed to subvert his authority or turn the people's respect and attention from him, they denounced him as an impostor, sent messengers all over the country to warn the people against him, and sent spies to watch him and report what he said and did, so that he was now most surely standing under the shadow of the cross.ST Feb 15, 1877
Opposition grew into a watched plan to use accusations against him, for his teaching correcting false ideas about observance and his merciful works on the Sabbath brought bitter opposition.RH Mar 5, 1901ST Sep 15, 1909 The authorities treated his Sabbath healings as a threat to the day's sacredness and his challenge to their traditions as a threat to their power.RH Mar 5, 1901 Their claimed zeal for God concealed anger and fear that he was gaining influence, so they watched him.RH Mar 5, 1901
The controversy was not over which day was the Sabbath, but over their interpretation of how it should be kept.ST Aug 20, 1896 Their zeal to defend that interpretation led them to violate the commandment against killing.ST Aug 20, 1896 In rejecting the divine idea of the Sabbath of the Lord they rejected the Lord of the Sabbath himself.ST Nov 21, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900 The man unable to walk represents those who have no life apart from Christ.ST Aug 20, 1896
The leaders treated the Bethesda healing as a violation deserving death, and their hostility was sharpened by the healing's influence among the people.ST Oct 25, 1910 They worried that Roman authority would not accept a Sabbath charge as grounds for action.ST Oct 25, 1910 Yet the growing case over his Sabbath teaching, which did not follow their traditional rules, eventually led to his death as a Sabbath-breaker, with majority prejudice helping turn the people against the innocent.ST Oct 25, 1910ST Jul 29, 1908ST Sep 4, 1901
That seeking to kill continued until they had killed him, ending in crucifixion.ST Nov 21, 1900ST Mar 12, 1894 They judged his actions by their own Sabbath rules, treated him as a Sabbath-breaker, and their religious complaints led to execution under Pilate with Rome's aid, making him a victim of religious legislation.ST May 19, 1914ST Mar 12, 1894 This was done to save the nation from the Romans, yet it only brought upon city and nation destruction by Roman power, the abomination of desolation, contrary to their claim that killing him would save them.ST Nov 21, 1900ST Mar 12, 1894
Sabbath Stands Unchanged
The Sabbath runs like a thread of gold through the whole Book, and what Jesus said and did about it in this verse belongs to that thread and shows his authority as teacher, interpreter and guide to settle questions about the Sabbath for those who follow him as Lord of the Sabbath and Head of the church.RH Sep 3, 1908 By healing on the Sabbath he challenged added restrictions and showed that doing good and doing God's work are proper Sabbath-keeping.ST Aug 20, 1896 The Sabbath was meant to be a blessing and not a burden, and Christ as Lord of the Sabbath upheld its holy purpose.ST Aug 20, 1896 In this he united temple worship with helpful ministry on the Sabbath day, in John's Gospel as a very late New Testament writing.
His works of necessity and mercy rejected narrow human traditions but did not lessen the sanctity of the seventh day or abolish the law. The day the Jews regarded as the Sabbath in their conflict with him is still the Christian Sabbath, with no revision or repeal of the original Sabbath command.ST He publicly and conspicuously ignored extraneous human authority in Sabbath observance, disregarding the added Sabbath laws and traditions that were stressed above all other traditions, not breaking God's Sabbath law.ST Sep 26, 1906 That disregard more than once caused the priests and scribes to determine to have him put to death, yet he never taught or implied that the day of the Sabbath ought to be or would be changed.ST Sep 26, 1906
The charge that he broke the Sabbath was false, for he kept his Father's commandments and did not violate an existing law. Since breaking the law is sin and he was without sin, he could not have broken the Sabbath while its law was in force. His followers kept the Sabbath according to the commandment after his crucifixion, so the Sabbath law had not ceased before then. If it had ceased during his ministry, it was not among the ordinances later nailed to the cross, and God's moral law including the Sabbath remains binding.RH Jun 18, 1872
Restoring the crippled man was an act of mercy permitted by the Sabbath commandment.RH Dec 10, 1857 He did not violate the Sabbath or treat it with contempt, but kept it in the true spirit of the commandment.RH Dec 10, 1857 The accusation therefore cannot prove the Sabbath abolished.ST Apr 11, 1900RH Dec 10, 1857 Its Sabbath teaching applies to the seventh-day Sabbath, not to Sunday, and his healing and relief of suffering as acts of beneficence give no reason to treat another day as the Sabbath, even though he faced persecution from the Jews over his Sabbath practice.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Aug 3, 1904
Lessons for Faithfulness
The teachers who sought death for Jesus judged his keeping by their own conception of what observance required rather than by God's law.ST Jun 4, 1912ST Jul 4, 1899ST Jun 30, 1898ST Aug 3, 1904 Their condemnation rested on human rules about Sabbath observance, not on enforcement of God's law.ST Jun 30, 1898ST Aug 3, 1904 He publicly and conspicuously ignored their extraneous authority, disregarding the added Sabbath laws and traditions they stressed above all others, yet he never taught that the day of the Sabbath ought to be or would be changed.ST Sep 26, 1906 The verse illustrates how human authorities can mistake their own conception of God's requirements for the law itself.ST Aug 3, 1904ST Jan 16, 1907
Though professing obedience to the law, the rulers made it void by their customs, impugned his motives, and attacked his lawful Sabbath observance.ST Jan 15, 1885 He kept the day according to the commandment while not observing it according to their traditions.ST Mar 1, 1905 Unable to establish that he had sinned or committed a crime, they resorted to persecution.ST Mar 1, 1905 Persecution is always wrong, so the persecutor is in the wrong.ST Sep 2, 1897
He was persecuted and put to death for faithfully keeping the Sabbath according to God's standard against their traditional rules.ST Sep 2, 1897ST Jun 11, 1894ST Oct 7, 1897 The hostility arose from his refusal to honor their man-made religious institutions and from his love extending beyond their nation to people they despised. The Sabbath-breaking was only supposed, not real, for healing on the Sabbath is lawful, so he was keeping the Sabbath perfectly even while persecuted as a Sabbath-breaker.ST Sep 2, 1897 Those who now observe the seventh day while others rest on the first day may expect the same persecution from those with a false standard.ST Sep 2, 1897
To treat him as a Sabbath-breaker dishonors Christ, who is Lord of the Sabbath.RH Nov 15, 1906 A parallel charge echoes against the pope's claim to authority above human law, including power to release others from obedience to government, as placing himself on a level with God.ST Sep 16, 1875
The man unable to walk represents those who have no life apart from Christ.ST Aug 20, 1896 Even in healing the palsied man, Christ the Life-giver and his mission were doubted, and unbelief plotted to kill him.ST Sep 26, 1895 Their zeal to defend their interpretation of how the day should be kept led them to violate the commandment against killing.ST Aug 20, 1896
Sources