AdventAI

John 5:10

The Jews therefore said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath day: it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    The Jews therefore said to him that was cured, It is the sabbath day: it is not lawful for you to carry your bed.

  • King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    The Jews therefore said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath day: it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.

  • Webster Bible

    The Jews therefore said to him that was cured, it is the sabbath; it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.

  • Revised Version, American Standard Version

    So the Jews said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath, and it is not lawful for thee to take up thy bed.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    the Jews then said to him that hath been healed, 'It is a sabbath; it is not lawful to thee to take up the couch.'

  • Darby Translation

    The Jews therefore said to the healed [man], It is sabbath, it is not permitted thee to take up thy couch.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    The Jews, therefore, were saying, unto him who had been cured—It is, Sabbath; and it is not allowable for thee to take up thy couch:—

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    so the Jews said to the man who had been healed, “ This is the Sabbath! It is unlawful for you to carry your mat.”

  • World English Bible

    So the Jews said to him who was cured, “ It is the Sabbath. It is not lawful for you to carry the mat.”

  • Bible in Basic English

    So the Jews said to the man who had been made well, It is the Sabbath; and it is against the law for you to take up your bed.

  • Geneva Bible

    The Iewes therefore said to him that was made whole, It is the Sabbath day: it is not lawfull for thee to cary thy bed.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    The Jews therefore said to him that was healed: It is the sabbath; it is not lawful for thee to take up thy bed.

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

25 sources

The charge was spoken to the man healed at Bethesda after thirty-eight years of helplessness, when the Jewish leaders met him carrying his mat on the Sabbath and sternly accused him of doing what was unlawful.DA 201.3–4Ms 192, 1897, par. 1–2DA 203.2–3ST Mar 31, 18813RED 28.2–29.1 He had left in perfect soundness with joy, hurrying toward Jerusalem praising God and telling everyone of his cure, having forgotten in his joy that it was the Sabbath.ST Mar 31, 1881Ms 191, 1897, par. 9 Instead of rejoicing in his restoration, they overlooked the miracle and cared more about the burden he carried than about the healing itself.COS 77.2–78.5Ms 192, 1897, par. 1–23RED 21.1–2DA 203.2–32SP 159.1–2 Their accusation rested not on God's law but on prejudiced human customs and additions to the fourth commandment, which had hidden the Sabbath's merciful purpose and turned a blessing of rest and joy into a yoke of bondage.3RED 22.1–23RED 24.3–25.12SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886ST Jul 15, 1886 Jesus had deliberately commanded the act, knowing it would stir prejudice, in order to bring forward the question of what is lawful on the Sabbath, to free the day from burdensome requirements and show that relieving human suffering is proper Sabbath conduct.DA 201.3–4Ms 141, 1906, par. 54–553RED 24.3–25.12SP 161.3–162.1Ms 192, 1897, par. 9

Healing and Sabbath Charge

The charge belongs to the Sabbath healing at Bethesda in Judea during the early ministry, when the man who had been disabled and helpless for thirty-eight years and had to be carried to the pool was made whole.DA 201.3–43RED 28.2–29.13RED 36.17MR 278.1–3DA 231.2 The healing provoked the hostility of the leading Jews and set in motion their plot against His life, and the accusation over carrying the bed led to the discourse that followed in which His Sonship to the Eternal was proclaimed before the Sanhedrin.3RED 36.17MR 278.1–3DA 231.2 The man who had been carried there a helpless sufferer left in perfect soundness, rolling up his mat and blanket and going his way with joy and ease while Jesus quietly passed on.ST Mar 31, 1881Ms 191, 1897, par. 9 Filled with gratitude at being made whole, he hurried toward Jerusalem praising God in his new strength, unable to refrain from telling everyone he met of the wonderful work, having forgotten in his joy that it was the Sabbath.ST Mar 31, 1881Ms 191, 1897, par. 9

As he went on his way the Pharisees and Jewish leaders met and confronted him as he told them of his cure, listening with coolness and a frown instead of joy that the poor sufferer had been made whole.Ms 192, 1897, par. 1–2DA 203.2–32SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886 They declared it unlawful for him to carry his bed on the Sabbath and treated the act as unlawful burden-bearing, seeking grounds to condemn Jesus.DA 203.2–32SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886 They cared more about the mat, rug, blanket and bed he was carrying than about the glorious work done in his restoration, interrupted his story, overlooked the miracle, and sternly reproved and challenged him for bearing burdens on the Lord's day.COS 77.2–78.5Ms 192, 1897, par. 1–23RED 21.1–2ST Mar 31, 1881 Their objection reflected false ideas about Sabbath observance, for Jesus had told the man to carry the bed to draw attention and correct those errors.COS 77.2–78.5

The man felt no guilt or condemnation for obeying the command of the One who had healed him by God's power, because he had acted at the order of One who showed power from God to work so wonderful a miracle.DA 203.2–33RED 22.1–2ST Mar 31, 18812SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886

Human Traditions Versus True Sabbath

The charge that it was unlawful to carry the bed treated the act as forbidden burden-bearing, yet it rested not on God's law but on prejudiced human customs and traditions added to the fourth commandment and made binding by foolish wresting of Scripture.3RED 22.1–22SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886Ms 192, 1897, par. 9Ms 192, 1897, par. 6–7 The rebuke showed that the object and significance of the Sabbath requirement had been lost sight of and its original holy requirements hidden beneath lengthy human Thou shalts and Thou shalt nots.Ms 192, 1897, par. 9Ms 192, 1897, par. 6–7 The sacred ordinance God gave in love and mercy as a blessing for rest and peace and joy had thus been made a curse, a day of rigorous exactions made oppressive by burdensome customs and loaded with frivolous and senseless restrictions.3RED 24.3–25.1ST Jul 15, 18862SP 161.3–162.1DA 206.1–2Ms 192, 1897, par. 6–7 What had been given for blessing had become a burden and a yoke of bondage.3RED 24.3–25.1ST Jul 15, 18862SP 161.3–162.1DA 206.1–2Ms 192, 1897, par. 6–7

The verse establishes the true Sabbath principle that there are cases of necessity in which relieving human suffering after years of affliction is proper Sabbath conduct, while unnecessary work is to be avoided.Ms 141, 1906, par. 54–55 The leaders' objection served as a pretext for unbelief, for instead of rejoicing in the healing they fixed on the tradition they thought had been violated and refused to accept the miracle as evidence of divine power.ST Mar 31, 1881ST Jul 15, 1886 With bigotry they overlooked the miracle and showed no delight in the cure.3RED 22.1–2ST Mar 31, 18812SP 159.1–2ST May 13, 1886

They excused the restored man from blame while treating the One who took responsibility for ordering the act as guilty of breaking the law and of sacrilege.3RED 22.1–2ST Mar 31, 1881 They pressed for His identity because they already knew only Jesus could have done such a work, and they wanted direct proof from the man so they could condemn Jesus as a Sabbath-breaker both for healing on the Sabbath and for bidding the man carry his bed away.3RED 22.1–2ST Mar 31, 1881Ms 192, 1897, par. 5

Deliberate Challenge and Aftermath

Jesus knew that healing the man on the Sabbath would stir prejudice and cut short His work, yet He deliberately sought him out and volunteered to heal him without being asked, making no effort to avoid conflict.DA 201.3–4Ms 192, 1897, par. 9 He would not tell the man to remain where he was until sundown but commanded him to carry his bed, foreseeing that the command would secure attention and be violently resisted as Sabbath-breaking.Ms 192, 1897, par. 9 He refused to sanction the false, prejudiced and perverted standard that treated carrying the bed as breaking the Sabbath, or to leave it undisturbed, because He had to place before the people the true import of the Sabbath.Ms 192, 1897, par. 9

He gave the command so the healing would become public and draw attention, even though it would be violently resisted, and so the question of what is lawful on the Sabbath would be brought forward.3RED 24.3–25.12SP 161.3–162.1DA 206.1–2Ms 192, 1897, par. 9 His purpose in drawing attention was to correct false ideas about Sabbath observance, challenge narrow rules, and place the true import of the Sabbath before the people.COS 77.2–78.53RED 24.3–25.12SP 161.3–162.1DA 206.1–2Ms 192, 1897, par. 9 He acted to free the day from burdensome human requirements that had turned it from a blessing into a burden and a curse, and to uphold the Father's law and restore the Sabbath to its intended dignity and blessing without lessening the law.3RED 24.3–25.12SP 161.3–162.1DA 206.1–2

The rulers' customs and traditions could not answer His arguments about the Sabbath and God's work, while the people defended the healing as right and the rulers evaded the issue and sought grounds to condemn Him.3RED 28.2–29.1 The confrontation sparked a great uproar in the temple court and a sharp controversy over the true claims of the Sabbath law.ST Apr 7, 1881 In answer to the accusation Jesus declared that the Father works and He works, claiming equal right with God to do a work equally sacred and of the same character as the Father's work in heaven.ST Apr 7, 1881

The leaders were further incensed because, as they understood it, He had not only broken the law but added the heinous sin of declaring Himself equal with God.ST Apr 7, 1881 The healing and its aftermath gave them a pretext for hostility and persecution and led them to plot against His life and seek His death.ST Apr 7, 18813RED 36.12SP 340.1–2 Only the interference of the people kept the enraged authorities from slaying Him on the spot.ST Apr 7, 1881 The accusation led to the discourse that followed, in which the healing and the lessons given afterward proclaimed His Sonship to the Eternal, which He declared before the Sanhedrin.Lt 1, 1876, par. 67MR 278.1–3DA 231.2

Sources

  1. DA 201.3–4 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE. Ellen G. White, 1898
  2. Ms 192, 1897, par. 1–2 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 192, 1897 Ellen G. White, written February 1897
  3. DA 203.2–3 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE. Ellen G. White, 1898
  4. ST Mar 31, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 13 — LESSON FOR PACIFIC COAST—SABBATH, APRIL 9 Ellen G. White, March 31, 1881
  5. 3RED 28.2–29.1 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — JESUS AT BETHESDA. Ellen G. White, 1877
  6. Ms 191, 1897, par. 9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 191, 1897 Ellen G. White, written February 24, 1897
  7. COS 77.2–78.5 Christ Our Saviour — SABBATH-KEEPING. Ellen G. White, 1896
  8. 3RED 21.1–2 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — JESUS AT BETHESDA. Ellen G. White, 1877
  9. 2SP 159.1–2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  10. 3RED 22.1–2 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — JESUS AT BETHESDA. Ellen G. White, 1877
  11. 3RED 24.3–25.1 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — JESUS AT BETHESDA. Ellen G. White, 1877
  12. ST May 13, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 18 — The Commentary Ellen G. White, May 13, 1886
  13. ST Jul 15, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 27 — General Articles Ellen G. White, JULY 15, 1886
  14. Ms 141, 1906, par. 54–55 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 21 (1906) — Ms 141, 1906 Ellen G. White, written August 11, 1906
  15. 2SP 161.3–162.1 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  16. Ms 192, 1897, par. 9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 192, 1897 Ellen G. White, written February 1897
  17. 3RED 36.1 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — JESUS AT CAPERNAUM. Ellen G. White, 1877
  18. 7MR 278.1–3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 7 [Nos. 419-525] — MR No. 483—The Spirit of 1876 Ellen G. White, written 1876; published 1990
  19. DA 231.2 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE. Ellen G. White, 1898
  20. Ms 192, 1897, par. 6–7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 192, 1897 Ellen G. White, written February 1897
  21. DA 206.1–2 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE. Ellen G. White, 1898
  22. Ms 192, 1897, par. 5 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 192, 1897 Ellen G. White, written February 1897
  23. ST Apr 7, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 14 — The Sabbath School Ellen G. White, April 7, 1881
  24. 2SP 340.1–2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIX. Ellen G. White, 1877
  25. Lt 1, 1876, par. 6 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 3 (1876 - 1882) — Lt 1, 1876 Ellen G. White, written March 31, 1876

Pioneers and periodicals

55 sources

The healing was of a man helpless for thirty-eight years at the pool of Bethesda, whom Jesus restored on a festival Sabbath while the day was still in progress.ST Mar 15, 1905ST Nov 14, 1900RH Dec 5, 1907ST Mar 20, 1901 The bed he was told to take up was only a small mat or pallet on which he had lain, and the Jews met him with the charge that it was the Sabbath and not lawful to carry it.ST Mar 31, 1881RH Feb 11, 1862ST Mar 15, 1899RH May 5, 1874ST Aug 20, 1896 Their objection overlooked the miracle and pressed rule-breaking rather than rejoicing, excusing the man while seeking to condemn Jesus as a Sabbath-breaker for both healing and commanding the act.ST Mar 31, 1881ST Jun 8, 1882ST Oct 25, 1910 That charge rested on restrictive human traditions and added rules that had turned the Sabbath into a burden, not on a violation of God's law or the fourth commandment, which Jesus did not break, transgress or relax.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874RH Apr 7, 1851RH Oct 21, 1851 The healing and the command to carry the slight mat were works of necessity, mercy and honor to God, in harmony with the Sabbath's design as a day for doing good, while those who held otherwise taught that He intentionally violated the law against bearing burdens to change the Sabbath and that He did not regard Himself as bound by it.RH May 5, 1874RH Jun 18, 1861RH Feb 3, 1852 The Sabbath here remains the inspired name of the seventh day kept by the Jews and recognized in the Gospel era, not repealed or changed, and Jesus as its Lord settles its true keeping by showing that mercy is lawful upon it.ST Apr 13, 1915ST Jun 11, 1894ST Mar 16, 1882ST Jun 6, 1900RH Sep 3, 1908

Words and Setting

The scene is the healing at the pool of Bethesda of a man helpless for thirty-eight years with no one to help him reach the pool, whom Jesus helped when everything else had failed after asking, Wilt thou be made whole, and telling him to rise, take up his bed and walk.ST Mar 15, 1905ST Nov 14, 1900ST Mar 20, 1901 He had waited long among the withered and lame and halt and blind for the health-giving pool, and when the healing was given he took up his bed and walked.ST Mar 31, 1881ST Mar 20, 1901 The healing occurred at a festival, identified as the second Passover, and the Sabbath on which the cured man carried his bed belonged to that festival.ST Nov 14, 1900RH Dec 5, 1907 The response to the healing identifies the day as the Sabbath, and the sun had not yet set so the Sabbath was still in progress when he carried it.RH Dec 5, 1907

What he carried was only a small mat, rug, blanket, pallet, couch or sleeping mat on which he had lain by the pool, not a bed as commonly understood today.ST Mar 31, 1881RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 31, 1881 Carrying it home demonstrated the reality of the cure, and its sudden removal as he walked away drew a crowd and broke the quiet of the porticoes.RH Feb 11, 1862ST Aug 2, 1910 In his joy and new strength he hurried toward Jerusalem praising God and forgot it was the Sabbath, yet he felt no condemnation for obeying one who had power from God to work so wonderful a miracle.ST Mar 31, 1881ST May 13, 1886 He did not yet know who his healer was, answering only that the one who had made him whole had told him to carry it, for the Stranger who healed him had disappeared in the stir, and he later confessed the Saviour.ST Mar 20, 1901ST Aug 2, 1910

The verse uses the singular Greek word sabbaton for the Sabbath day, distinguished from the plural form sabbata used for a week.RH Jan 29, 1867 It stands in John's Gospel, a very late New Testament writing, in an account that unites temple worship with helpful ministry on the Sabbath.RH Jan 29, 1867

Charge and Opposition

The Jews confronted the cured man with the identification that it was the Sabbath and that carrying his bed was not lawful, fastening their objection on his carrying the pallet even though he had just been cured.ST Jul 7, 1914ST Mar 15, 1899ST Aug 20, 1896ST Aug 20, 1896 Their devotion was to ceremonial rules, and the dispute was over their rules for observance rather than over which day was the Sabbath.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Aug 20, 1896 In defending their own interpretation they displayed the danger of violating one commandment while trying to uphold another.ST Aug 20, 1896 The objection belonged to the controversy over the Sabbath-day healing and the carrying of the bed afterward.ST Jul 7, 1914

They showed no delight in the cure but overlooked the miracle, seizing with bigotry on the carrying of the rug and blanket and mat as a violation of the Sabbath law.ST Mar 31, 1881ST Jun 8, 1882ST May 13, 1886 As he hurried toward Jerusalem praising God in his new strength they interrupted him to demand why he bore burdens on the Lord's day and sternly reminded him it was not lawful.ST Mar 31, 1881 In his joy he had forgotten it was the Sabbath, yet he felt no condemnation for obeying one who had power from God to work so wonderful a miracle.ST Mar 31, 1881ST May 13, 1886 Their focus on alleged rule-breaking and on restoration rather than rejoicing served as a pretext for unbelief and blinded them to the healing as evidence of divine power, which they refused to accept.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 15, 1886ST Oct 25, 1910 By making their customs and traditions the measure of lawful observance they had turned the Sabbath meant as sacred rest and blessing into a burden, and they treated the carrying as unlawful work and unlawful burden-bearing to use the healing as a charge.ST Jun 8, 1882ST May 13, 1886ST Jul 15, 1886ST Oct 25, 1910

They excused the restored man from blame while treating the one who took responsibility for ordering it as guilty of breaking the law and of sacrilege.ST Mar 31, 1881 They pressed for his identity because they knew only Jesus could have done it and hoped to get direct proof to condemn Jesus as a Sabbath-breaker both for healing on the Sabbath and for bidding the man carry his bed away.ST Mar 31, 1881

By branding the act unlawful and fixing Jesus as the one who had commanded it, this Sabbath charge clearly defined the Sabbath issue between Jesus and the Jews at His second Passover at the pool of Bethesda, where He healed a man with an infirmity of thirty-eight years by telling him to rise, take up his bed and walk.ST Nov 14, 1900 It began their persecution of Jesus and their seeking to slay Him, an opposition over His works and teaching and over Pharisaic ideas of keeping rather than God's that contributed to the hostility leading to His death and culminated in His crucifixion.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Sep 15, 1909 Their accusation over Sabbath keeping became part of the charge against Jesus who had healed the man.ST Jan 21, 1903 The refusal to endorse the human Sabbath traditions developed after the Babylonian captivity ended formal idolatry, when zeal for observance was turned into mere formality by adding man-made works until the Sabbath became an almost intolerable burden and the traditions of the elders were made the basis of doctrine, made the leaders more eager to put Him to death.ST Jun 5, 1901 The episode illustrates the correction of false ideas about what was lawful and the use of the day for merciful works, yet the controversy became a reason His opponents sought to put Him to death.ST Sep 15, 1909 The confrontation over the healed paralytic at Bethesda sparked a great uproar in the court of the temple and a sharp controversy over the true claims of the Sabbath law, and only the interference of the people kept the enraged authorities from slaying Him on the spot.ST Apr 7, 1881 Unbelief thus met the miracle with objection instead of faith and plotted to kill both the Life-giver and the one given life.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jun 5, 1901

Traditions Against True Sabbath

The charge that carrying the bed was unlawful rested on restrictive human tradition, Pharisaic ideas and burdensome added rules about Sabbath keeping, not on any violation of God's law or of the Decalogue itself.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Aug 25, 1909 The object carried was only a small mat, blanket, rug or pallet on which the man had lain by the pool, not a bed as commonly understood today, and carrying it demonstrated the reality of the cure and honored the Lord of the Sabbath while serving the relief of suffering.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 11, 1894 The healing and the command belonged to mercy and goodness proper to a day meant for rest, delight and holy joy, exposing the difference between those petty traditions and the Sabbath's true purpose.RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 11, 1894ST Jun 5, 1901 Refusal to endorse those Sabbath traditions made the leaders more eager to put Him to death, and the controversy over His works and teaching contributed to the hostility that led to His death.ST Jun 5, 1901

After the return from Babylonian captivity ended formal idolatry among the Jews, the rabbis loaded God's law with a mass of fanciful opinions and oppressive ceremonial restrictions, and zeal for Sabbath observance was turned into mere formality by adding man-made works until the traditions of the elders were made the basis of religious doctrine.STST Jun 5, 1901 The Jews went from Sabbath-breaking to the opposite extreme of fanatical over-observance, loading the Sabbath law until it became a burden and an almost intolerable burden.STST Jun 5, 1901ST Mar 4, 1889 Their prohibitions became as senseless as forbidding catching a flea or eating an egg laid on the Sabbath, and they would not heal the sick or relieve the needy and oppressed on that day, treating healing the sick as unlawful labor and rubbing out wheat in the hands as a kind of threshing.STST Mar 4, 1889

Those added rules buried Sabbath observance beneath formalism and unscriptural rules, so that opposition to proper care for the sick extended even to seeking to kill Jesus for healing on the Sabbath.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 15, 1886ST Apr 26, 1905 What had been given as blessing, sacred rest, rest and delight was turned into a burden, displaying devotion to ceremonial rules.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 15, 1886ST Aug 25, 1909 In defending their own interpretation of Sabbath observance the objectors showed the danger of violating one commandment while trying to uphold another, and the first house of Israel thus stumbled by keeping the right Sabbath in the wrong way.ST Mar 4, 1903ST Aug 20, 1896

Their strict attention to human rules obscured the Sabbath's true purpose, spiritual meaning and holy dignity, leading them to condemn an act connected with healing and mercy.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Jul 15, 1897RH Jul 18, 1854 Their traditions classified carrying a couch or burden as forbidden work, and their customs were treated as the measure of lawful Sabbath observance, which blinded them to the healing as evidence of divine power.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 15, 1886RH Jul 18, 1854 That same strictness could yet allow comparable acts to rescue or care for animals while condemning mercy to a healed man, in conflict with God's law.RH Jul 18, 1854

Jesus deliberately healed the man and told him to carry the bed on that day, purposely choosing the Sabbath to expose how added requirements had obscured its purpose and turned its intended blessing into a burden.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jul 15, 1897 His purpose was to rid the day of burdensome restrictions heaped upon it, to correct false ideas of what is lawful, and to teach that doing good and works of necessity and mercy matter more than human traditions and are proper Sabbath-keeping.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Apr 7, 1881ST Sep 15, 1909 That correction left the seventh day's sanctity and holy dignity unchanged and retained, while God's work of blessing and caring for people does not cease on the Sabbath.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Jul 15, 1897 The resulting sharp controversy over the true claims of the Sabbath law sparked a great uproar in the court of the temple, and the Sabbath controversy became a reason His opponents sought to put Him to death.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Sep 15, 1909

Lawful Mercy on Sabbath

Jesus did not break, transgress or relax God's Sabbath law, the fourth commandment, or His own precepts and teachings.RH May 5, 1874RH Apr 7, 1851RH Oct 21, 1851RH Sep 2, 1851RH Apr 11, 1854 The accusation by the Jews and Pharisees does not establish a violation, and the charge of Sabbath-breaking against Him in this chapter is completely refuted.RH Oct 21, 1851ST Feb 1, 1899RH Sep 2, 1851RH Nov 25, 1852RH Mar 1, 1864 The item carried was only a blanket, rug or mat on which he had lain by the pool, not a bed as commonly understood today.RH May 5, 1874 The healing and the command to carry it served the relief of suffering and the honor of God, in keeping with the Sabbath's design, while the objection reflected burdensome traditions that wrongly treated healing and other merciful acts as unlawful.RH May 5, 1874RH Apr 7, 1851RH Sep 2, 1851

Works of necessity and mercy matter more than human traditions, while leaving the seventh day's sanctity unchanged.RH May 5, 1874 The Sabbath exceptions shown here are limited to necessity and mercy and direct service to God, which are in harmony with the Sabbath law, but the account does not authorize ordinary labor on the Sabbath.RH Jun 18, 1861RH Dec 10, 1857ST Jun 20, 1911 Doing good and showing mercy were lawful on the Sabbath, for the commandment forbade labor but did not forbid the work of mercy He performed, and the additional restrictions were rabbinic rules, not part of the fourth commandment.RH Dec 10, 1857ST Feb 24, 1914 Jesus kept the Sabbath in its true spirit and did not violate its proper limits, healing and directing the man to carry his bed as part of doing good on the Sabbath.RH Dec 10, 1857ST Feb 24, 1914

As a burden the carried item was too slight to be the kind of load God forbade, carried not for selfish pleasure or profit but for God's glory and fitting use that night, and calling it a burden did not make it one.RH Sep 2, 1851RH Feb 3, 1852RH Nov 25, 1852 The fourth commandment itself says nothing about bearing burdens.RH Nov 25, 1852RH Mar 1, 1864 The Sabbath permits deeds of mercy and goodness and is meant to be a day of rest, delight and holy joy, not a burden imposed by petty restrictions.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Jun 11, 1894 God's work of blessing and caring for people does not cease on the Sabbath, and Jesus chose the Sabbath for the healing to expose narrow rules and teach that doing good is proper Sabbath-keeping.ST Aug 20, 1896 His work of doing the Father's will pressed upon Him even on the Sabbath, devoted to that work rather than to political affairs.ST Apr 25, 1900

His answer, My Father worketh hitherto, and I work, claims equal rights with God to do a work equally sacred and of the same character as the Father's work in heaven.ST Apr 7, 1881 The Pharisees were further incensed because in their understanding He had not only broken the law but added the heinous sin of declaring Himself equal with God.ST Apr 7, 1881 Those who held that He actually broke the Sabbath taught that He told the man at Bethesda on the Sabbath to carry his worn couch through the streets of Jerusalem as an open violator of the law against bearing burdens, voluntarily and intentionally without request or necessity when any other day would have done as well, thereby making real the charge of Sabbath-breaking and pointing to a change of the Sabbath now being made. Others who held a like view taught that this command and the Sabbath healing show He did not regard Himself or His disciples as bound by the Sabbath law, justifying His conduct by His Father's continuing work.RH Feb 3, 1852 The verse is also cited as an alleged instance of teaching a man to break the Sabbath by carrying his bed when there was no need to move it until the next day, presented as an argument that the Jews could not keep the law rather than as an accepted conclusion about His teaching.RH Apr 11, 1854RH Apr 3, 1855

Sabbath Identity and Discipleship

The Sabbath named here is the inspired name of the seventh day continued into the Christian dispensation, the same day kept by the Jews and instituted at creation, still recognized in the Gospel era and not repealed or changed.ST Apr 13, 1915ST Mar 16, 1882ST Jun 6, 1900RH Jun 5, 1860 Together with John 9:14, 16 it identifies the Sabbath of the Gospel with the seventh day.ST Jun 6, 1900 The strict objection to carrying the bed confirms that the correct day was recognized, with no indication that track of it had been lost.ST Mar 16, 1882

What was said and done here belongs to what Jesus said and did about the Sabbath, like a thread of gold running through the Book.RH Sep 3, 1908 His authority as teacher, interpreter and guide, as Lord of the Sabbath and Head of the church, settles Sabbath questions for His followers.RH Sep 3, 1908 The passage in John 5:8-18 has a bearing on the Sabbath question alongside Matthew 12:1-13, Mark 2:23-28, Mark 3:1-5, Luke 6:1-10, Luke 14:1-5, Romans 14:5,6, Galatians 4:10 and Colossians 2:16, with accusations over plucking wheat and eating it and over healing the sick.ST Jan 29, 1902ST Mar 4, 1889 Being placed under a heading of Sabbath observance does not prove that it teaches that any day will do so long as one day is kept.ST Jan 29, 1902 Marginal references and subject indexes are wholly human work for convenience and suggestion, never authority in interpretation, and each text must be examined by the Spirit and given its due weight in its proper setting only as the Scriptures themselves warrant.ST Jan 29, 1902

The healing in this chapter shows willingness to heal still today.RH Jan 24, 1907 The sick and burdened are called to come in faith and leave sin and sickness behind.RH Jan 24, 1907 The delivered man joyfully bore his cot away from the scene of his suffering at the word of faith, love, healing and command, his whole being responding with the only reply that the One who made him whole had told him to carry it.ST Jun 18, 1912 That obedience was blessed individual help, healing, hope and obedience, and he could do no less and no more than obey his Deliverer.ST Jun 18, 1912 It is the divine right and divine duty to obey whether fellow churchmen or kin approve or not, so when the mighty work of grace has begun in a willing heart no one should attempt to modify or limit it.ST Jun 18, 1912

Taking up the bed and walking means rising on the promise of God today to be made whole in both body and soul, after waiting long among the withered and lame and halt and blind, with sin-bred disease departing as Jesus writes His law in the heart and with later confession of the Saviour.ST Mar 20, 1901 The recorded command to rise and carry the bed, followed by the warning to sin no more, shows that faith requires absolute obedience to God's word and law.ST Mar 15, 1899 The healing also illustrates Christ's authority to govern bodily life and its daily practices.ST Mar 15, 1899

Sources

  1. ST Mar 15, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 11 — Lessons from the Gospel of John March 15, 1905
  2. ST Nov 14, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 46 — LESSONS FROM MATTHEW 24 Alonzo T. Jones, NOVEMBER 14, 1900
  3. RH Dec 5, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 49 — Aids for Bible Readers December 5, 1907
  4. ST Mar 20, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 12 — WILT THOU BE MADE WHOLE? E. F. Johnston, March 20, 1901
  5. RH Feb 11, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 11 — History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, February 11, 1862
  6. ST Mar 15, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 11 — LESSON I.—SABBATH, APRIL 1, 1899 March 15, 1899
  7. RH May 5, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 21 — THE SABBATH AND THE LAW IN THE NEW TESTAMENT John Nevins Andrews, May 5, 1874
  8. ST Aug 20, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 33 — LESSON X.—SABBATH, SEPTEMBER 5, 1896 August 20, 1896
  9. ST Mar 31, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 13 — LESSON FOR PACIFIC COAST—SABBATH, APRIL 9 Ellen G. White, March 31, 1881
  10. ST Jun 8, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 22 — General Articles Ellen G. White, June 8, 1882
  11. ST Oct 25, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 42 — Shiloh: the Man of Sorrows October 25, 1910
  12. RH Apr 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 8 — THE HOLY SABBATH Joseph Bates, Monday, April 7, 1851
  13. RH Oct 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 6 — THE TWO LAWS October 21, 1851
  14. RH Jun 18, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 4 — THE SABBATH LAW Andrew J. Bois, June 18, 1861
  15. RH Feb 3, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 11 — Remarks of O. R. L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the Sabbath February 3, 1852
  16. ST Apr 13, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 15 — CHRIST AND THE SABBATH QUESTION R. C. P., April 13, 1915
  17. ST Jun 11, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 31 — THE SABBATH WILL BE A TEST IN THE LAST GREAT REFORMATION Matthew Larsen, Monday, June 11, 1894
  18. ST Mar 16, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 11 — The Sanctification of the First Day of the Week John Nevins Andrews, March 16, 1882
  19. ST Jun 6, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 23 — DID CHRIST CHANGE THE SABBATH? H. C. Giles, June 6, 1900
  20. RH Sep 3, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 36 — The Sabbath in the Bible A. H. Lewis, D. D., Thursday, September 3, 1908
  21. ST Mar 31, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 13 — RABBINICAL PRECEPTS CONCERNING THE SABBATH March 31, 1881
  22. ST Aug 2, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 30 — At the Pool of Bethesda Daniel March, D.D., August 2, 1910
  23. ST May 13, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 18 — The Commentary Ellen G. White, May 13, 1886
  24. RH Jan 29, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 8 — The Week and the Days of the Week Third-day, January 29, 1867
  25. ST Aug 20, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 33 — LESSON X.—SABBATH, SEPTEMBER 5, 1896 August 20, 1896
  26. ST Jul 7, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 26 — Wilt Thou Be Made Whole? Ellen G. White, July 7, 1914
  27. ST Jul 15, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 27 — General Articles Ellen G. White, JULY 15, 1886
  28. ST Sep 15, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 36 — The Sabbath Through the Ages Charles L. Taylor, September 15, 1909
  29. ST Jan 21, 1903 Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 3 — THE ACCUSATION A Little One of the Great Company, January 21, 1903
  30. ST Jun 5, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 23 — TWO OBJECTS OF SATANIC MALICE G., June 5, 1901
  31. ST Apr 7, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 14 — The Sabbath School Ellen G. White, April 7, 1881
  32. ST Aug 25, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 33 — Question Corner F. J. S., August 25, 1909
  33. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 45 — The Sabbath for All J. A. L. Derby
  34. ST Mar 4, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 9 — THE SABBATH OF THE LORD M. C. W., March 4, 1889
  35. ST Apr 26, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 17 — ABRAHAM AND THE SABBATH T. B. Snow, April 26, 1905
  36. ST Mar 4, 1903 Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 9 — PROPHECY AND THE SABBATH March 4, 1903
  37. ST Jul 15, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 27 — JEWISH CUSTOMS AND TRADITIONS Hilchoth Shabbath, July 15, 1897
  38. ST Aug 20, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 33 — LESSON X.—SABBATH, SEPTEMBER 5, 1896 Ellen G. White, August 20, 1896
  39. RH Jul 18, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 24 — THE SABBATH July 18, 1854
  40. RH Sep 2, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 3 — THE ROYAL LAW CONTENDED FOR Edward Stennet, September 2, 1851
  41. RH Apr 11, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 12 — COMMUNICATIONS John Norton Loughborough, April 11, 1854
  42. ST Feb 1, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 5 — LESSON VIII.—SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 1899 February 1, 1899
  43. RH Nov 25, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 14 — CONVERSATION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Unbeliever, Thursday, November 25, 1852
  44. RH Mar 1, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 14 — Sabbath Discussion Elder Miles Grant, Third-Day, March 1, 1864
  45. RH Dec 10, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 5 — The Cincinnati Daily Commercial, Editor, December 10, 1857
  46. ST Jun 20, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 24 — How Shall the Sabbath Be Kept? June 20, 1911
  47. ST Feb 24, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 7 — Sunday Laws and Sabbath Observance Daniel H. Kress, M.D., February 24, 1914
  48. RH Feb 3, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 11 — Remarks of O. R. L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the Sabbath February 3, 1852
  49. ST Apr 25, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 17 — THE TIME IS AT HAND Alonzo Trévier Jones, APRIL 25, 1900
  50. RH Apr 3, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 26 — SABBATH DISCUSSION M. E. Cornell, April 3, 1855
  51. RH Jun 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 3 — PREACH THE WORD James White, Third-Day, June 5, 1860
  52. ST Jan 29, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 5 — Question Corner January 29, 1902
  53. RH Jan 24, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 4 — Mr. Hubbell’s Conversion Lephia Bryant Larson, Thursday, January 24, 1907
  54. ST Jun 18, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 24 — The Individual C. L. Taylor, June 18, 1912
  55. ST Mar 15, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 11 — DIVINE HEALING Mrs. S. M. I. Henry, March 15, 1899

Cross-references 20 of 39

  1. Matthew 12:12

    How much then is a man better than a sheep? Wherefore it is lawful to do well on the sabbath days.

    Christ teaches that doing good on the Sabbath is lawful.

  2. Exodus 20:9-10

    Six days shalt thou labour, and do all thy work:

    The leaders invoke the commandment’s prohibition of work on the Sabbath.

  3. John 5:16-18

    And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.

    The Sabbath healing provokes hostility, and Jesus explains his work by the Father’s ongoing work.

  4. Mark 2:27-28

    And he said unto them, The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath:

    Jesus explains the Sabbath’s purpose for humanity and declares himself its Lord.

  5. Luke 13:14-16

    And the ruler of the synagogue answered with indignation, because that Jesus had healed on the sabbath day, and said unto the people, There are six days in which men ought to work: in them therefore come and be healed, and not on the sabbath day.

    Jesus defends Sabbath healing by contrasting it with customary care for animals.

  6. Jeremiah 17:21-27

    Thus saith the LORD; Take heed to yourselves, and bear no burden on the sabbath day, nor bring it in by the gates of Jerusalem;

    Defines the burdens forbidden on the Sabbath.

  7. Mark 3:4

    And he saith unto them, Is it lawful to do good on the sabbath days, or to do evil? to save life, or to kill? But they held their peace.

    Jesus asks whether doing good on the Sabbath is lawful.

  8. Matthew 12:8

    For the Son of man is Lord even of the sabbath day.

    Jesus’ lordship over the Sabbath challenges restrictive Sabbath customs.

  9. John 9:14

    And it was the sabbath day when Jesus made the clay, and opened his eyes.

    A parallel Gospel account notes a healing on the Sabbath.

  10. John 5:16

    And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.

    Jesus is persecuted because he healed on the Sabbath.

  11. John 5:18

    Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that God was his Father, making himself equal with God.

    Sabbath-breaking and Jesus’ claim to equality with God prompt his opponents to seek his death.

  12. Genesis 2:2-3

    And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.

    The Sabbath was instituted and sanctified at creation.

  13. John 7:21-23

    Jesus answered and said unto them, I have done one work, and ye all marvel.

    Jesus defends his Sabbath healing by comparing it with Sabbath circumcision.

  14. Nehemiah 13:15-19

    In those days saw I in Judah some treading wine presses on the sabbath, and bringing in sheaves, and lading asses; as also wine, grapes, and figs, and all manner of burdens, which they brought into Jerusalem on the sabbath day: and I testified against them in the day wherein they sold victuals.

    Both texts address carrying burdens on the Sabbath.

  15. Luke 6:1-11

    And it came to pass on the second sabbath after the first, that he went through the corn fields; and his disciples plucked the ears of corn, and did eat, rubbing them in their hands.

    Both texts record disputes over Sabbath observance and accusations against Christ.

  16. John 9:16

    Therefore said some of the Pharisees, This man is not of God, because he keepeth not the sabbath day. Others said, How can a man that is a sinner do such miracles? And there was a division among them.

    Pharisees accuse Jesus of violating the Sabbath after a healing.

  17. Luke 14:1-5

    And it came to pass, as he went into the house of one of the chief Pharisees to eat bread on the sabbath day, that they watched him.

    Jesus heals on the Sabbath and answers objections to Sabbath labor.

  18. Luke 23:56

    And they returned, and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the sabbath day according to the commandment.

    Cited as New Testament recognition of the Sabbath law.

  19. Luke 6:7

    And the scribes and Pharisees watched him, whether he would heal on the sabbath day; that they might find an accusation against him.

    Religious leaders watched Jesus heal on the Sabbath to find an accusation.

  20. John 5:14

    Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple, and said unto him, Behold, thou art made whole: sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee.

    Jesus warns the healed man to sin no more.