Translations
One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, says to him,
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, saith unto him,
One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter's brother, saith to him,
one of his disciples — Andrew, the brother of Simon Peter — saith to him,
One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter's brother, says to him,
One from among his disciples, Andrew, the brother of Simon Peter, saith unto him—
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
One of His disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, said to Him,
One of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, said to him,
One of his disciples, Andrew, the brother of Simon Peter, said to Jesus,
Then saide vnto him one of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peters brother,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
One of his disciples, Andrew, the brother of Simon Peter, saith to him:
Pictures







Cross-references
- Mark 6:38-44
He saith unto them, How many loaves have ye? go and see. And when they knew, they say, Five, and two fishes.
Parallel account of Jesus feeding the multitude.
- Matthew 14:17-21
And they say unto him, We have here but five loaves, and two fishes.
Parallel account of Jesus feeding the multitude through the disciples.
- Luke 9:13-17
But he said unto them, Give ye them to eat. And they said, We have no more but five loaves and two fishes; except we should go and buy meat for all this people.
Parallel account of Jesus feeding the multitude and the remaining food.
- John 6:12-13
When they were filled, he said unto his disciples, Gather up the fragments that remain, that nothing be lost.
Jesus tells the disciples to gather the leftovers so nothing is wasted.
- Mark 6:41-43
And when he had taken the five loaves and the two fishes, he looked up to heaven, and blessed, and brake the loaves, and gave them to his disciples to set before them; and the two fishes divided he among them all.
The crowd eats the multiplied food, and the disciples gather twelve baskets of leftovers.
- Matthew 14:19-20
And he commanded the multitude to sit down on the grass, and took the five loaves, and the two fishes, and looking up to heaven, he blessed, and brake, and gave the loaves to his disciples, and the disciples to the multitude.
Jesus blesses and distributes the food, and the crowd gathers the fragments.
- 2 Kings 4:42-44
And there came a man from Baal-shalisha, and brought the man of God bread of the firstfruits, twenty loaves of barley, and full ears of corn in the husk thereof. And he said, Give unto the people, that they may eat.
Elisha feeds a hundred men with a small supply of bread.
- Mark 6:37
He answered and said unto them, Give ye them to eat. And they say unto him, Shall we go and buy two hundred pennyworth of bread, and give them to eat?
Jesus commands the disciples to feed the people.
- Luke 9:16-17
Then he took the five loaves and the two fishes, and looking up to heaven, he blessed them, and brake, and gave to the disciples to set before the multitude.
Parallel account describes the feeding and gathering the remaining fragments.
- John 6:32-35
Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Moses gave you not that bread from heaven; but my Father giveth you the true bread from heaven.
The loaves account is connected with Jesus’ teaching about the bread from heaven.
- John 6:60-66
Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is an hard saying; who can hear it?
Many disciples struggled with Jesus’ teaching and turned away.
- Matthew 16:9-10
Do ye not yet understand, neither remember the five loaves of the five thousand, and how many baskets ye took up?
recalls fragments gathered after feeding
- John 21:13
Jesus then cometh, and taketh bread, and giveth them, and fish likewise.
Jesus gives bread and fish, recalling the feeding.
- John 21:12
Jesus saith unto them, Come and dine. And none of the disciples durst ask him, Who art thou? knowing that it was the Lord.
The meal of bread and fish recalls Jesus’ feeding of the multitude.
- Matthew 14:16
But Jesus said unto them, They need not depart; give ye them to eat.
Jesus tells the disciples to feed the multitude.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
91 sources
Andrew, Simon Peter's brother, is the disciple who speaks to Jesus in the feeding of the multitude.DA 368.2–3ST Dec 15, 19092T 292.1 He reports that a boy in the company has been found carrying five barley loaves and two small fishes, which at Jesus' word are brought to Him for distribution.Lt 302, 1907, par. 3–6Ms 188, 1907, par. 10Ms 156, 1902, par. 1–5 He questions what such a small store is among so many, counting it as nothing for the great crowd with no more food to be obtained in the desert place.Lt 302, 1907, par. 3–6Ms 188, 1907, par. 10Ms 156, 1902, par. 1–5 A meager supply placed in Christ's hands is multiplied as it is imparted until it sustains the multitude, so limited visible resources are to be used faithfully and entrusted to God.6T 467.1Lt 121, 1904, par. 14–16Ms 66a, 1900, par. 30–31 Christ supplies what His workers need to give, for they can impart spiritual nourishment only as they receive it from Him and depend on Him when they feel helpless with nothing to give.DA 369.2–4ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 19, 1897
Setting and Occasion
Jesus had withdrawn with His disciples to a secluded place when the crowd gathered to meet Him, and the Passover was near.DA 364.1ST May 20, 1886 The company numbered five thousand men besides women and children, above ten thousand persons in all.DA 364.1ST May 20, 1886RH Jan 7, 1909Lt 121, 1904, par. 14–16DA 809.3 The multitude had been all day without food in that retirement.ST May 20, 1886
The place was a desert place and a deserted place where no more food could be obtained.ST May 20, 18863RED 54.2ST May 10, 1883 It was a grassy place away from the cities, a barren shore and beach beside the Sea of Galilee where much of His ministry was spent.21MR 138.2–3Ms 64, 1910, par. 10–11DA 809.3 That beach lay within sight of where the disciples later gathered and not far from Capernaum, the scene of many miracles.DA 809.3 Standing at times upon a hill, He sat as a teacher with authority, not at ease.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6
The people had followed Him on foot from place to place and listened to His teaching until thousands were gathered, weary and hungry.Ms 130, 1909, par. 4–6Ms 124, 1909, par. 21ST May 20, 1886 He pitied them rather than sending them away hungering, and fed them bounteously.Ms 130, 1909, par. 4–6ST May 20, 18863RED 56.1 He had taught them words such as had never before fallen upon ears, words never heard before that laid hold of minds and sank into hearts, while His pure and simple doctrine and tender benevolence won hearts.ST May 20, 18863RED 56.1 He had healed their sick and comforted their sorrow.ST May 20, 18863RED 56.1 In this He considered their bodily needs as well as their spiritual benefit.RH May 30, 1871
He asked what food was at hand and what could be found among the company to feed the crowd.Ms 130, 1909, par. 4–6Lt 275, 1903, par. 14–19ST May 20, 1886 He already knew what He would do.Ms 124, 1909, par. 21 He took advantage of circumstances and of the opportunity to become a field preacher to the multitude that followed Him.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6 Supplying temporal food to the hungry opened the way to place Him in the chair of instruction to give the people the Word which is the bread of life, and the occasion would be long remembered.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6
Andrew's Report
The one who speaks is Andrew, Simon Peter's brother, one of the disciples addressing Jesus in the feeding of the five thousand.DA 368.2–3ST Dec 15, 19092T 292.13RED 63.2ST Apr 24, 1901 He stands among the disciples through whom the provision is afterward distributed, with the credit for the work remaining Christ's.ST Apr 24, 1901Ms 14, 1902, par. 4 His speaking identifies him in the account as the disciple who brings the scanty supply to notice while seeing how far too little it is for the crowd.DA 368.2–3Ms 14, 1902, par. 4
What Andrew reports is that a boy, a lad in the company, has been found carrying five barley loaves and two small fishes, only a few loaves and a few fishes.Lt 302, 1907, par. 3–6Ms 188, 1907, par. 10Ms 156, 1902, par. 1–5Ms 128, 1905, par. 9–13Lt 275, 1903, par. 14–19 He brings this small supply forward in answer to the inquiry what food could be found among the company.Ms 128, 1905, par. 9–13Lt 275, 1903, par. 14–19ST Mar 1, 1877 At Jesus' word the little store is brought to Him, who commands that it be brought for distribution and then uses it to feed the people until food is left over.Ms 188, 1907, par. 10Ms 156, 1902, par. 1–5ST Mar 1, 1877
With the report Andrew asks what such a small store is among so many, counting it as nothing for the great crowd of about five thousand men besides women and children who had followed on foot until weary and hungry.Lt 302, 1907, par. 3–6Ms 188, 1907, par. 10Ms 156, 1902, par. 1–5Lt 275, 1903, par. 14–19Ms 124, 1909, par. 21 No more food is to be obtained there in the deserted place, and the amount on hand cannot feed the multitude.Ms 124, 1909, par. 21ST Mar 1, 1877 His question shows how great need set against limited resources can make human means appear as nothing and weaken faith, making men hesitate to give what they have instead of depending on God and following Christ's direction.Lt 302, 1907, par. 3–6ST Mar 1, 1877DA 368.2–3
Miracle of Provision
Jesus blessed the small supply and had it brought for distribution, giving it to the disciples to pass to the people in an orderly way until all were satisfied.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–43RED 55.2Ms 71, 1911, par. 5–8 The bread multiplied in the distribution and the fish increased in the hands of those who distributed them, so that five thousand men besides women and children — above ten thousand persons — ate from five barley loaves and two small fishes.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–4RH Jan 21, 1909ST May 10, 18833RED 55.2Ms 64, 1910, par. 10–11 When all had eaten, the remaining fragments were gathered so that nothing would be lost, and twelve baskets remained.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–4RH Jan 21, 1909ST May 10, 18833RED 55.2Ms 64, 1910, par. 10–11
No human power could create so much food from so little, and no other one could do so mighty a miracle.ST May 20, 18863RED 56.1 The increase showed Jesus’ power and beneficence and care, revealed the Father’s works done through Christ, and showed His divinity and His connection with the Father.ST May 20, 1886ST May 10, 18833RED 56.1RH Jan 7, 1909ST Aug 12, 1897 It gave evidence heaped upon evidence, sufficient to convince any mind open to evidence, and led thoughtful and candid witnesses to take exalted views of His character and office.RH Jan 7, 1909Ms 57, 1898, par. 22–25 His pure and simple doctrine had laid hold of minds and His tender benevolence had won hearts, for He had taught words never before heard, healed the sick and comforted sorrow rather than send the multitude away hungering.ST May 20, 18863RED 56.1 While eating the food He bounteously provided, those served decided He was indeed the Messiah, for teaching and healing had nearly convinced them of His divinity and this miracle crowned their growing conviction with entire belief.ST May 20, 18863RED 56.12SP 262.3–263.1
The miracle reveals the same creative power God continually uses to provide the harvest and feed people, the same divine power at work in the multiplication of seed and the daily production of food.ED 107.3ST Aug 12, 1897DA 367.3 God gives life to the seed and provides food through the harvest, sustains living things by active power, and can in a moment create a supply sufficient for more than five thousand when need requires it.ED 107.3DA 367.33MR 352.4Ms 156, 1902, par. 6–7 Men are thus dependent on God for life, for food, for health, and even for the very air breathed, and the grace of God on a small portion makes it all-sufficient, able to spread a table in the wilderness and multiply scanty provision a hundredfold.Ms 114, 1899, par. 1–33MR 352.4Ms 156, 1902, par. 6–7 That provision is not to be squandered or used in an aimless, wasteful manner but is to be used with care, industry and frugality, with glory given to the Creator rather than to natural causes, human work, selfishness or unnatural appetite.ST Aug 12, 1897DA 367.3Ms 156, 1902, par. 6–7
The fame of the wonderful miracle on the barren shore spread far and near.ST Dec 29, 18873RED 63.2 The multitude left Jesus there knowing no boat remained by which He could depart, and on the following morning returned to the spot where they had last seen Him, arriving in large numbers by land and water to seek Him.ST Dec 29, 18873RED 63.2 Strengthened in conviction that He was the Messiah, they planned to take Him by force and make Him king, a project set on foot by Judas which Christ rebuked with greater and unusual authority and refused.2SP 262.3–263.1Ms 9, 1898, par. 31–32Ms 28, 1897, par. 10–12 Judas was not satisfied with how affairs turned out there, was provoked by the rebuke, and became more separated from Jesus in feeling and love.Ms 28, 1897, par. 10–12 The disciples remembered this feeding when Jesus later provided them with a miraculous catch of fish, which helped them recognize His power to provide and His care for them.ST Oct 3, 1878 That providing of bread for five thousand besides women and children was part of His mission and expressed His love for the children of men.Ms 18, 1898, par. 11
Bread of Life Taught
Supplying temporal food to the hungry opened the way to place Jesus in the chair of instruction to give the Word which is the bread of life.Lt 9, 1902, par. 1–721MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6 He took advantage of circumstances to become a field preacher to the multitude that followed Him, standing at times upon a hill and sitting as a teacher with authority to enlarge a small substance of temporal food by miracle.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6 The account belongs to the feeding of the five thousand and shows He cared for the people's physical need for food as well as their need to hear words of life.Lt 9, 1902, par. 1–717MR 252.1CH 283.1–2 Through the miracle He taught that the spiritual food He gives — Himself, the Bread of Life — is more important than perishable food, and the lessons of the chapter direct readers to Christ the living bread and to receive and obey His words, which are spirit and life leading to eternal life.Lt 9, 1902, par. 1–7Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28
Eating the Son of God's flesh and drinking His blood explains how eternal life is gained.Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15Lt 95, 1901, par. 18–19 As bread gives the body strength, faith in Christ and obedience to His teaching give the soul spiritual strength and everlasting life.2SP 282.1–283.24RED 95.1 This means trusting His words and the power of His sacrifice, not literally consuming His human body, for His teaching, example, life and death are the spiritual food that gives life.2SP 282.1–283.2 The living bread is received by taking the Word into the life, and the language about Christ's flesh and blood points to Him as the substitute for sin and the only hope of ancient Israel.21MR 44.1–2
The sixth chapter shows the Word of God is the bread of life representing the body and blood of the Son of God.Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15 The gospel does not address the understanding alone like mathematics for the intellect but aims at the heart, addresses the moral nature, and takes possession of the will, casting down imaginations and every high thing exalting itself against the knowledge of God and bringing every thought captive to the obedience of Christ.Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15 Learning this requires being a submissive student in the school of Christ, disciplined to habits of obedience, with the soul emptied of all proud possessions so Christ may imprint His image on the soul and the soul-temple may be the abiding place of the Most High.Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15
In this chapter Jesus spoke plain truths that many, including disciples, did not understand at the time though later events made them clearer.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 132SP 282.1–283.2 These truths brought people's real feelings to light and led them to decide for or against Him, testing those who claimed to follow Him.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–15 Many were offended because they resisted reproof and chose human praise over God's admonition, and many turned away when His words exposed their lives and when they heard the conditions of eternal life and entrance into God's kingdom, while the test established the faithfulness of those who remained.Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–159MR 242.1Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Lt 13, 1876, par. 1–39MR 32.3–5 The miracle of the loaves became the occasion for the teaching that He was the bread of life, and together with walking on the water it stands as the setting in which some disciples turned from Him.9MR 242.1Lt 13, 1876, par. 1–39MR 32.3–5
The people who later asked for a sign had witnessed the feeding and hoped He would repeat it, but He used the miracle to lead them to believe in Him as the Son of God and receive Him as the Bread of Life.Lt 73, 1901, par. 16–1813MR 219.4–220.1 Those who had followed Him for food and other temporal benefits rejected that lesson despite seeing His works, for they were not seeking evidence that would settle their faith.13MR 219.4–220.1Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Ms 50, 1898, par. 4–8 Those who sought Him for bread and resisted the cross turned away when they heard the conditions of eternal life.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Ms 50, 1898, par. 4–8
Disciples as Channels
In the feeding the disciples stand as channels and appointed means of communication between Christ and the people, receiving from Him and passing His provision on to others.DA 369.2–4ST Aug 19, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902MH 49.1 The food multiplied in His hands as they distributed it, for He is the source of strength and the Bread of Life, and His followers are to rely on Him for what they give.DA 369.2–4ST Aug 19, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902 All who are united to Him receive the bread of life from Him and impart it to others, and they can impart spiritual nourishment only as they receive it from Him.DA 369.2–4ST Jan 22, 1902MH 49.1 They served as instruments through whom He provided food to the crowd, and the credit for the work belonged to Him, not to them.ST Apr 24, 1901
He brings His disciples forward before large numbers to give them reputation, so that many will recognize in their workings that they work as He worked, and His deeds of mercy open a door for them.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6 Supplying temporal food to the hungry opens the way to place Him in the chair of instruction to give the Word which is the bread of life, and the distribution of grace in words with the free-will offering of enlarged food with His blessing on it prepares the way in many places.21MR 138.2–3Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6 The same blessing rests on disciples as they break the bread of life to hungry souls.Lt 252, 1906, par. 2–6
The lesson is that He supplies what His workers need to give, for their own resources are not enough but what they receive from Him is sufficient, and giving does not leave them without supply.DA 369.2–4ST Aug 19, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902 He received from the Father and gave to the disciples to distribute to the people, and He relied on His heavenly Father for what was needed to feed the hungry multitude.ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 19, 1897MH 49.1 His representatives are shown to give the bread of life to the people and to depend on Him when they feel helpless with nothing to give, for their work was to give the people the bread of life and when they would often face hungry souls they had to seek spiritual food from God so they could serve others rather than turn anyone away unfed.DA 369.2–4MH 49.1RH Aug 11, 1910
The small supply increased as they gave it, and the gift increases in the giving.6T 263.1Ms 127, 1903, par. 10Lt 7, 1901, par. 1–3 His followers receive grace from Him to give to the needy, they too share in the food provided, and the miracle shows the value of working together with God to care for people.6T 263.1Lt 7, 1901, par. 1–3 His command to feed others carries the power to provide what is needed, and a small supply placed in His hands can sustain many when it is imparted, so that His servants relying on His power can give others the Bread of Life.DA 369.1ST Aug 19, 1897
The account is applied as an example of how those who dedicate themselves to God may receive the Holy Spirit and serve people in need, as He attended to the needs of the crowd and provided abundantly from a small amount of food.Ms 186, 1907, par. 8–9 It shows that God provides for His people and that people should not take God's place by restricting others.Lt 199, 1901, par. 18–20
His way of working in this event is an example for His followers to follow, for the event shows His power and that He is the source of all blessings.Lt 90, 1900, par. 6–7 He can also give tact, skill, and understanding to those who follow Him, as He provided abundantly from five loaves and two fish.Ms 14, 1902, par. 4
Trust and Faithful Use
After all were satisfied Jesus directed the disciples to gather the remaining fragments so that nothing would be lost, and twelve baskets were left over.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–4ST Dec 15, 19092T 292.1CH 283.1–2Ms 67, 1903, par. 36–37 God's gifts and food are a good and necessary provision that are not to be wasted but are to be used with care, industry, frugality and thrift, especially in times of difficulty and when resources must be used economically.ST Dec 15, 19092T 292.1CH 283.1–2Ms 3, 1912, par. 4–5 What is received is to benefit others rather than be lost.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–4ST Dec 15, 1909 The food had multiplied as it passed from Christ to those who received it, and His actions in giving and then gathering leave lasting impressions.Ms 197, 1907, par. 1–4Ms 67, 1903, par. 36–37
As the loaves and fishes increased as they were received and passed on, so truth multiplies as it is shared, and for that reason even small fragments of literature containing truth should be preserved rather than lost.Ms 127, 1903, par. 10 God can multiply what is given to meet the needs of a multitude, turning a meager supply into abundance.6T 467.1Lt 121, 1904, par. 14–16Ms 66a, 1900, par. 30–31Ms 66, 1900, par. 10 A small supply placed in Christ's hands can sustain many when it is imparted, for five loaves and two fishes fed five thousand men besides women and children with twelve baskets left over.Lt 121, 1904, par. 14–16ST Aug 19, 1897 Jesus blesses and multiplies scant resources until they meet great needs, working with those who give and serve with unselfish hearts so that the little offered can be made sufficient to carry forward His work, and He can make limited offerings sufficient for the needs of His work today.Ms 66a, 1900, par. 30–31Ms 66, 1900, par. 10Ms 66, 1900, par. 11–12 Therefore limited visible resources should be used faithfully and entrusted to God, and His servants relying on His power can give others the Bread of Life.6T 467.1ST Aug 19, 1897
To be connected with Christ means to do one's best though it is not much, then to cast the helpless soul upon Jesus as Saviour and Redeemer with a faith that works by love and purifies the soul.Ms 130, 1909, par. 4–6 Without fretting over what cannot be controlled, what seems insufficient can become enough for oneself and something to share with others.Lt 121, 1904, par. 14–16 People should share what they have and care for those who lack the truth.Ms 180, 1907, par. 27–28 Faith should lay hold upon God and expect success, and not stop work or measure advance in the work by the means at hand, for to do so shows very limited faith.Ms 38, 1895, par. 58–602MR 283.1–284.2 Small and scattered means placed in missionary work will be multiplied by God as they are imparted to others so that all eat and are filled.Ms 38, 1895, par. 58–602MR 283.1–284.2
As God's human agents given the great work of diffusing the gospel over the whole earth, people are to plan and work in faith, practice economy, bind about wants, save something from a meager store to sustain the work and cause of God, do what the hands find to do, and go forward in sincerity and faith while character is formed after the divine pattern.Ms 38, 1895, par. 58–602MR 283.1–284.2 That feeding is an example whose methods are to be studied in carrying forward food work, with simple, inexpensive preparations and without selfish private interests obstructing the work.Lt 302, 1906, par. 5 Gifts sent with thanksgiving and prayer to advance medical missionary soul-saving work will be multiplied and blessed in the same way the food given to the disciples to give to the people was multiplied and blessed.STB 148.2–3 Making the best use of the means available allows God to enable the feeding of multitudes who are starving for the bread of life.STB 148.2–3 Christ has power to supply food miraculously and will supply the needs of His children today in the same way, giving knowledge to find food and continuing His benevolence in providing for bodily needs.Lt 27, 1902, par. 17–1917MR 252.3
He promises wisdom and skill, talent and ingenuity to devise means to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, and teach the ignorant, and to manufacture necessary, wholesome, inexpensive foods to be sold to the poor at as low a rate as possible, a work more needed in the Southern states than in any other part of America.Lt 27, 1902, par. 17–19 Andrew's report of a boy's small supply set against the needs of a great crowd, followed by food for everyone with twelve baskets left over, shows that Christ can meet great needs and calls for faith and practical willingness to help.RH Jan 21, 1909 The miracle teaches His disciples to care for people seeking salvation by making practical efforts to provide for them when they are hungry or weary and removing obstacles that make coming to Christ difficult.ST Aug 12, 1897 The account of the disciples having only five loaves and a few small fish, far too little for the hungry crowd seated on a grassy place away from the cities, yet distributing until everyone had eaten and gathering what remained, shows Christ's provision and teaches that His works of help are to be valued.Ms 64, 1910, par. 10–11
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
85 sources
Andrew, Simon Peter's brother and one of the disciples, speaks to Jesus with information about food before the boy's lunch is used.ST May 20, 1886ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jul 26, 1905 He had found the boy because he was moving among the crowd doing personal work and searching, ready to begin with what could be found.RH May 29, 1900RH Feb 26, 1901RH May 29, 1900 He reports a boy with five barley loaves and two small fishes, yet counts it as nothing among so many, showing doubt and a sense of impossibility under Christ's test of faith.ST May 20, 1886ST Feb 1, 1899ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jun 6, 1900 His words answer Christ's inquiry about what food could be found and His command to bring it to Him, for Christ was not seeking advice but trying faith.ST May 20, 1886RH Mar 17, 1903RH Dec 23, 1902 The setting is the feeding of five thousand men besides women and children in a desert place, after a day of teaching and healing when the hungry multitude had followed Jesus across the sea from Capernaum.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Oct 12, 1904
Andrew and His Report
The one who speaks is Andrew, one of the disciples, Simon Peter's brother, volunteering information to Jesus about the food on hand before the lad's lunch is used.ST May 20, 1886ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jul 26, 1905ST Feb 15, 1905RH Apr 22, 1915 He is among those who bring the practical problem of the crowd's need to Jesus, explaining that what is available is far too little.ST Jul 26, 1905 He had come to know of the bread and fish because he had been out among the crowd doing personal work, helping people and praying with them, searching until he found the lad.RH May 29, 1900RH May 29, 1900 In recognizing the boy who carried the food and being willing to begin with what was available, he shows that missionary service need not wait until every need is calculated or supplied but starts by using what is had and is.RH Feb 26, 1901ST Aug 28, 1901
He reports a boy with five barley loaves and two small fishes, simple poor food, yet in the same breath asks what so little is among so many.ST Mar 1, 1877ST May 20, 1886ST Feb 1, 1899ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jun 6, 1900 The small store is counted as nothing, with no more to be obtained in that place, and the question carries doubt and a sense of impossibility.ST May 20, 1886ST May 10, 1883 Even while helping bring the limited resources to Christ he still sees the task as impossible, and so fails the test Christ puts to His followers.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Dec 23, 1902 Christ is not asking for advice but trying faith, and the right answer would have been to turn a sunny face to Him in trust that He has a plan, that the responsibility is His, and that He will tell what to do and make a satisfactory way.RH Dec 23, 1902RH Dec 23, 1902
The setting is the feeding of the five thousand, five thousand men besides unnumbered women and children, in a desert place away from towns where earthly support is absent.ST May 20, 1886ST Mar 8, 1899RH Jul 28, 1903ST Mar 22, 1899 Jesus and His disciples had gone from Capernaum across the sea to the northwest and east side for much-needed rest, and the multitude followed so eagerly that they neglected comfort and food.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899 After a day of teaching and healing He was moved with compassion at their eagerness and need, laying aside all consideration of self to feed them with the bread of life until evening and then relieve their physical necessities as a whole Saviour caring for every need.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Oct 12, 1904 The multitude knew no boat remained, and as news spread they returned the next morning, while those who heard Him in Capernaum had come from near where the miracle occurred.ST Mar 22, 1899
His report answers Jesus' inquiry how much food could be found for those who had been all day without food, and Jesus commands that it be brought to Him for distribution.ST May 20, 1886 Andrew brings forward all the disciples have, the two hundred pennyworth of bread and the five barley loaves and two small fishes, which means human absolute incompetence and nothingness, the poor resources all men can produce when set before an almost insuperable difficulty.RH Dec 23, 1902 God always brings people face to face with their own incompetence before showing what He will do, to teach fuller trust and reveal Christ and the Father with greater adoring conceptions.RH Dec 23, 1902 If Philip had brought the loaves and fishes to Jesus the multitude would have been fed and Philip would have been the honored instrument, for God's work is finished not by human might but as men work in harmony with His purposes and follow His directions.RH Mar 17, 1903 That gathering and act of care took place during a peaceful interval that allowed Jesus to teach and minister in Palestine, near Passover on the northern bank of the sea on a verdant hill, after which, as the crowd prepared to make Him king, He sent the disciples away and dismissed the people and went alone to pray.ST Aug 13, 1902ST Jan 13, 1914
Loaves and Fishes Described
The supply Andrew named was a boy's small lunch of five barley loaves and two small fishes brought by a lad.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Feb 1, 1899ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jun 6, 1900 It was simple, poor food, described as thin barley loaves and little fishes and coarse food taken in Christ's hands.ST Jun 6, 1900 That scant food was all that could be found for the multitude, yet taken, blessed, broken and distributed it multiplied as He broke it, as the disciples broke from what they held, and as the people received and ate until five thousand men besides unnumbered women and children were fed and filled in a place away from towns.ST Mar 1, 1877 The fragments gathered that nothing be lost filled twelve baskets, more than twelve times the original quantity, by a creative word that must be either denied or admitted as a miracle of creative power.
The loaves had been made through ordinary, unnoticed household labor, a mother's work making barley cakes, yet brought to the Master they became part of a great work of blessing in which a small act has great results.ST May 29, 1884ST Jul 10, 1893 It was a plain meal providing no delicacies merely to please or to tempt the appetite, whose effect upon the people differed from its effect upon the rulers.ST Jan 24, 1878ST Sep 3, 1896 Jesus honored barley bread in working the miracle, but honoring it did not make eating it obligatory.ST Jan 24, 1878 He fed the multitude on bread and fish because it was their accustomed and longed-for food, merely taking what they had and multiplying it as the only food that would satisfy them; for forced reforms are of no benefit, reforms must grow out of conviction and education to be a blessing, and food must appeal to mind as well as digestion, so that inferior food with a satisfied mind is better than the best food with discontent.RH Dec 21, 1905
The scant store counted as nothing among so many, with no more to be obtained in that desert place where the people had been all day without food.ST May 20, 1886ST Dec 22, 1887 Brought forward as all the disciples had, with the two hundred pennyworth of bread, it means human absolute incompetence and nothingness, the poor resources that are all people can produce when set before an almost insuperable difficulty.RH Dec 23, 1902 Though He had power to provide abundantly without it and to provide food miraculously in another way, Christ chose to take the little that was offered and satisfy the hungry crowd, to teach hope and trust.RH Apr 10, 1900ST Aug 5, 1913
Miracle Feeds Thousands
Jesus had the disciples seat the people in groups of fifties on the grass to restore order, then took the coarse food in His hands, looked up to heaven, invoked God's favor upon it, broke it, and gave it to the disciples to distribute to the multitude.ST Dec 22, 1887ST Nov 21, 1911 The crowd could not count on the miracle that followed, for order was restored first by having the people sit down.ST Nov 21, 1911 The disciples arranged the people in groups and passed on what Jesus gave them, so that the small supply fed everyone.ST Dec 22, 1887
The food multiplied by the creative word as He broke it, as the disciples broke from the pieces they held, and as the people received and ate it. His word multiplied the scant supply of five barley loaves and two small fish on the east side of the Sea of Galilee until the multitude was satisfied. The precise way the multiplication was done is hidden, as all creative acts are.ST Mar 30, 1904 The miracle was astonishing, though the daily multiplication of seed into grain and the transformation of moisture in the vine into wine also involve marvels overlooked through familiarity.ST Aug 26, 1880
Five thousand men plus unnumbered women and children were fed and filled in a place away from towns. Five barley cakes and two little fish fed the multitude, including women and children, until all were satisfied.ST Oct 28, 1897 The blessing in Christ's hands increased to meet the need.ST Oct 28, 1897 The food was distributed in an orderly way, satisfied the people, and showed Jesus' power and care.ST May 10, 1883 The disciples saw the food multiply as it was passed from hand to hand, feeding more than five thousand men as well as women and children, and this showed the Father's works being done through Christ.RH Jan 7, 1909 No human power could create so much food from so little, so the increase was a mighty miracle that no other one could do.ST May 20, 1886
The fragments were gathered that nothing be lost, filling twelve baskets.RH Mar 16, 1905 The small supply fed everyone, and twelve baskets of fragments remained.ST Dec 22, 1887 Jesus then provides food for everyone by miraculous power, with twelve baskets left over.RH Jan 21, 1909 The gathered fragments were far greater and more than twelve times the original quantity. The boy's food would have filled only a corner of one of the twelve baskets of broken pieces, which were far greater than the original store.ST Mar 30, 1904 Jesus' command to gather the leftovers teaches that food should not be wasted, even plain food, urging restraint rather than spending extravagantly on luxuries and dainties.RH Mar 16, 1905
The account is true history that must be either denied or admitted as a miracle of creative power, the creative word multiplying the food. It was a literal bodily feeding, presented with details about its time, place, and circumstances, making it publicly checkable by the many people present.RH Feb 4, 1862
The same divine power appears in the annual supply of food for the world, which is likewise a continuing miracle of God's power in providing for His creatures.ST Dec 24, 1902 Every loaf of bread is a miraculous gift from God, even when its provision takes place gradually through ordinary processes.RH Apr 9, 1901 His power works both in extraordinary miracles and in the ordinary growth of harvests, supplying life's needs.ST Aug 12, 1897 This direct way of providing bread is distinct from the gradual growth and processing of grain, though both ways show the same divine power.ST Mar 31, 1898
The disciples later remembered this miracle when Jesus fed them beside the sea after His resurrection.ST Nov 4, 1886ST Nov 4, 1886 Remembering the feeding with loaves and fishes helped the disciples recognize His care when He later provided them with a miraculous catch of fish.ST Oct 3, 1878 The people who later heard Jesus speak in Capernaum had come from near the place by the Sea of Tiberias where that miracle occurred.ST Mar 14, 1911
Christ Revealed and Believed
Moved with compassion at their eagerness and need, laying aside all thought of self and rest after they had followed from Capernaum across to the shore, Jesus fed them with the bread of life until evening and then wrought a notable miracle to relieve their physical necessities, showing He is a whole Saviour who cares for every need.ST Mar 8, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899 Those who put self aside to be with Him where earthly support is absent can trust Him to care for them, for He provided both spiritual food by His teaching and physical food for hunger, considering bodily needs as well as spiritual benefit.RH May 30, 1871ST Mar 22, 1899RH May 29, 1900 His power and tender care met ordinary needs with simple food, without using luxury or worldly comforts to attract, pledging instead supply of needs and the better gift of His abiding presence, and the gathering of fragments teaches nothing should be wasted.STRH May 29, 1900
The miracle revealed creative power without limit, for His word multiplied the scant supply until the multitude was satisfied with twelve baskets left over, calling for faith and practical willingness to help.RH Jan 21, 1909ST Mar 15, 1905 Placed in the Saviour's hands the little that could not meet need by itself became more than enough, and the precise manner is hidden as all creative acts are.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Sep 18, 1893ST Mar 30, 1904 He has inexhaustible supplies for a hungry world, opening His hand to satisfy the desire of everyone who brings hunger, the last fed as fully as the first like a fountain still brimming after millions have drunk.ST Mar 30, 1904 The boy's food would have filled only a corner of one basket, for the broken pieces were far greater than the original store, showing the bread of God is more than enough for present need, and the more He is scattered and eaten and carried to others the more He increases so that faithful giving enriches rather than impoverishes.ST Mar 30, 1904
When the people were hungry and He had no apparent means, He relied on His Father's provision, teaching dependence on God, so that those who after sound judgment face difficulties may seek God's wisdom and trust Him for deliverance.STST Aug 19, 1897 The food multiplied as it was passed from hand to hand to more than five thousand men besides women and children with twelve baskets of fragments left, showing the Father's works done through Christ.RH Jan 7, 1909 This was possible through the union of humanity and divinity in Him, and believers likewise need faith laying hold on Christ with self-denial and cross-bearing.RH May 20, 1909
He had spoken words such as never before fell on ears, healed the sick and comforted sorrow, and rather than send them away hungering fed them bounteously with an increase no human power could create from so little.ST May 20, 1886 His pure and simple doctrine laid hold on minds and His tender benevolence won hearts, and while eating the food He provided those so served decided He was indeed the Messiah.ST May 20, 1886 That teaching and healing had nearly convinced them of His divinity, and this mighty miracle which no other could do crowned their growing conviction with entire belief, leading the multitude to believe in Him as one who does good and helps others.ST May 20, 1886ST Dec 22, 1887
Convinced the promised King had come who could supply all needs in the desert and make them the first kingdom free from oppression and the Roman yoke, the people would take Him by force and proclaim Him king and rouse the Jews under His leadership when He did not offer Himself as king.ST Mar 5, 1896 Judas of Kerioth, who had worked hard that day distributing the food, afterward calculated in shekels what it would have brought if sold and led the crowd wanting to crown Jesus and take Him to Jerusalem, arguing one who could create food could feed an army against the Romans.ST Oct 25, 1910 The disciples, influenced by Judas, shared this mistaken hope for an earthly kingdom, wanting Him for what He provided rather than valuing His character, showing they were not ready to be subjects and the time for that kingdom had not come.ST Sep 5, 1895RH Jul 19, 1906 That movement was another form of the temptation shaped by Satan to avoid Gethsemane and Calvary, but Jesus sent the disciples away and dismissed the people near Passover and went alone to pray, continuing to serve others rather than accept the crown.ST Mar 5, 1896ST Aug 13, 1902
The chapter teaches that spiritual life comes by believing in Christ, distinct from natural life received from parents and sustained by food, air and sunshine; it is eternal life found in the Son and offered to those who believe and yield to God.ST Oct 6, 1909 He is the spiritual bread come down from heaven and the Bread of Life of which if a man eat he shall never hunger, to be kept daily and eaten fresh morning by morning as a daily living experience like daily bread, because the old manna turned to corruption.ST Nov 3, 1898 He supplies the food and His disciples joined to Him pass it on, receiving the bread of life from Him and sharing it with others, for they can impart only what they receive and giving does not leave them without supply.ST Jan 22, 1902 The broken and blessed loaves picture receiving spiritual nourishment from Christ the living Word with freedom and peace, and the miracle is repeated wherever the Word truly eaten day by day becomes part of the man, who becomes a living epistle, a new translation of God's Word, through whom as he gives to others they feed and live so the food multiplies through men and women regenerated by His word.RH Aug 6, 1908 The one who fed the crowd without waste is the same who supplied manna in the wilderness.
The feeding describes a literal, real event in which bodies were fed bounteously, not merely a symbolic or spiritual feeding of souls with the bread of life.ST Jul 25, 1911ST
Disciples Share the Work
Christ makes his disciples co-laborers in feeding the multitude, receiving the food from his hands and passing it on to the people.ST Aug 19, 1897ST Mar 15, 1905ST Apr 11, 1906RH Jul 28, 1903 They bring the crowd's need to him, he supplies what is lacking, and they distribute what he provides, while also gathering the remaining fragments.RH Jul 28, 1903RH Jul 23, 1901 Those joined to him thus receive the bread of life from him and share it with others, illustrating how his followers are to receive his blessings and impart them.ST Jan 22, 1902ST Apr 11, 1906 The food multiplied as it was distributed through them, showing they serve as channels through which he provides for others and must rely on him for what they give.ST Aug 19, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902
They can impart only what they receive from him, for their own resources are not enough but what comes from him is sufficient, and giving does not leave them without supply.ST Aug 19, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902 Merely carrying the vessels from which the bread is distributed is not enough to feed people, since the bread and the power to provide it come from Christ its source. The credit for the work belongs to Christ and not to the instruments through whom he works.ST Apr 24, 1901 With God's blessing what his people have can likewise help carry the bread of life to the whole world.RH Jul 11, 1912 Their work is to give the people that bread, seeking spiritual food from God when they face hungry souls and feel helpless and without anything to give, rather than turning anyone away unfed.RH Aug 11, 1910 They are to give just as good instruction to an audience of five thousand as to an audience of one, since a brief moment in a servant of God's life can lead to a great work and far-reaching blessing.ST Sep 10, 1896
The miracle teaches his disciples to care for people seeking salvation, making practical efforts to provide for them when they are hungry or weary and removing obstacles that make coming difficult, with faith and practical willingness to help.RH Jan 21, 1909ST Aug 12, 1897 Judas of Kerioth worked hard that day distributing the food through the disciples from Jesus' hands to five thousand men besides women and children, yet afterward calculated how many shekels it would have brought if sold instead of given.ST Oct 25, 1910 God's work is finished not by human might or power but as men work in harmony with his purposes.RH Mar 17, 1903 When men follow his directions what he has said becomes fact and man becomes his honored instrument to accomplish it, and if Philip had brought the loaves and fishes the multitude would have been fed and he would have been the honored instrument.RH Mar 17, 1903
Trust Give and Apply
A humble gift placed in the Saviour's hands becomes more than enough to feed a hungry multitude, so even one or two loaves offered to Jesus are blessed to feed thousands who might otherwise go without.RH Dec 8, 1904RH May 29, 1900RH Jul 14, 1910 With God's blessing what His people have can carry the bread of life to the whole world, and resources given for mission work can be trusted to His blessing even while the task looks impossible.RH Feb 26, 1901RH Dec 8, 1904RH Jul 11, 1912 The lad's small lunch became more than enough through that blessing, though by itself it could not meet the need and no more could be obtained, and when it was placed in His hands the people were fed and food remained.RH Dec 8, 1904RH Apr 10, 1900RH May 29, 1900 Andrew himself shows helping bring limited resources to Christ while still seeing the task as impossible, for he found the boy and searched among the crowd yet questioned what so little was among so many.RH Feb 26, 1901RH May 29, 1900 There is now a famine for the word of God with souls appealing for the bread of life, and the call is not to hold goods for a rainy day while they plead but to give the Lord's cause the last dollar and trust Him, for Elijah's God is still God.RH Jun 24, 1902
God always brings people face to face with their own incompetence and nothingness before showing what He will do, setting poor resources that are all men can produce before an almost insuperable difficulty.RH Dec 23, 1902 He does this to teach fuller trust and hope in Christ and to reveal Christ and the Father, so that when He uses those poor resources the world gains greater and more adoring conceptions of what Jesus is.RH Apr 10, 1900RH Dec 23, 1902 Though He had power to provide abundantly without it, He chose to use what was available.RH Apr 10, 1900 Treasure is not meant to be selfishly hoarded, for it multiplies when shared and distributed, as the bread multiplied on the hillside of Galilee.ST May 13, 1880 Those united with Christ receive the bread of life and share it with others, for they can impart only what they receive from Him, and giving does not leave them without supply; passing on the light brings more from the Lord, for what is given away is kept.ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 13, 1880RH Jun 24, 1902 This calls for the faith and example of the widow of Zarephath rather than laying up this world's goods while hungry souls plead for bread.RH Jun 24, 1902
The command to gather the remaining fragments teaches that nothing should be wasted, even plain food, and that God's gifts and what is received should benefit others.ST Dec 15, 1909RH Mar 16, 1905RH May 29, 1900 The crowd was fed and twelve baskets of fragments remained, and the disciples were to take part in the work by gathering them after Christ had provided the loaves and fishes.RH Mar 16, 1905RH Jul 23, 1901 The miracle thus urges restraint rather than spending extravagantly on luxuries and dainties.RH Mar 16, 1905 It also shows Christ willing to provide both spiritual food through His teaching and physical food for the people, and His followers are to care for both body and soul.RH May 29, 1900 The miracle is repeated wherever the Word of God is truly eaten day by day and becomes part of the man. He who truly feeds upon Jesus Christ becomes a living epistle, a new translation of God's Word, and as he gives it to others they feed upon it and live, so the food multiplies through men and women regenerated by the power of His word.
The spiritual bread that came down from heaven keeps the soul so that if eaten there is no hunger, but the keeping must be daily and fresh morning by morning as a daily living experience like daily bread, because the old manna turned to corruption.ST Nov 3, 1898 Many followed Jesus afterward because the miracle seemed an easier way to gain daily bread.RH Jun 22, 1916 Yet the miracle does not replace God's plan that man earn his bread by the sweat of his brow, and earning bread by work remains the better way.RH Jun 22, 1916 Service need not wait until every need can be fully calculated or supplied, for Andrew recognized an opportunity when he knew a boy had food and was willing to begin with what was available.ST Aug 28, 1901 Missionary work begins by using what we have and are, since loaves made through ordinary, unnoticed work became part of a meal Christ used to feed the gathered people, proving a small act can have great results.ST May 29, 1884ST Aug 28, 1901
Christ fed the multitude on bread and fish because it was their accustomed food, merely taking what they had and multiplying it and giving them what they longed for as the only food that would satisfy them.RH Dec 21, 1905 In this God grants permission today, as to Israel anciently and to the multitude, to eat what is desired, while still desiring all to become intelligent on the food question and to eat that which is good.RH Dec 21, 1905 Forced reforms are of no benefit, because reforms must grow out of conviction and education to be a blessing, and food must appeal to the mind as well as to digestion, so inferior food with a satisfied mind is better than the best food with discontent.RH Dec 21, 1905 That public meal at which five thousand were fed with five loaves and two fishes stands contrasted with the Lord's supper, which was instituted privately and given only to disciples.RH May 27, 1873 He spread a table in the wilderness by His own hand because He pitied them as sheep having no shepherd on their way to the Passover.ST Nov 24, 1887
The same act proves the Saviour is present with His people when enemies are present and assaults nearly exhaust them.ST Nov 24, 1887 He remains to His own tempted and wearied servants what the good Samaritan was to the wounded traveler, healing their wounds, supplying their needs, and comforting their hearts.ST Nov 24, 1887
Sources