John 13:11
For he knew who should betray him; therefore said he, Ye are not all clean.
Translations
For he knew who should betray him; therefore said he, You are not all clean.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For he knew who should betray him; therefore said he, Ye are not all clean.
For he knew who would betray him; therefore said he, Ye are not all clean.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For he knew him that should betray him; therefore said he, Ye are not all clean.
for he knew him who is delivering him up; because of this he said, 'Ye are not all clean.'
For he knew him that delivered him up: on account of this he said, Ye are not all clean.
For he know the man that was delivering him up; therefore, said he—Not ye all, are pure.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For He knew who would betray Him. That is why He said, “ Not all of you are clean.”
For he knew him who would betray him; therefore he said, “ You are not all clean.”
( He had knowledge who was false to him; that is why he said, You are not all clean.)
For hee knewe who should betray him: therefore sayd he, Ye are not all cleane.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For he knew who he was that would betray him; therefore he said: You are not all clean.
Cross-references 20 of 26
- John 13:18-19
I speak not of you all: I know whom I have chosen: but that the scripture may be fulfilled, He that eateth bread with me hath lifted up his heel against me.
Jesus identifies Judas’s betrayal as Scripture’s fulfillment and foretells it so the disciples will believe.
- John 13:2
And supper being ended, the devil having now put into the heart of Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, to betray him;
Judas’s betrayal is present during the supper.
- John 13:21
When Jesus had thus said, he was troubled in spirit, and testified, and said, Verily, verily, I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me.
Jesus announces that one of the disciples will betray him.
- 1 Corinthians 11:23-26
For I have received of the Lord that which also I delivered unto you, That the Lord Jesus the same night in which he was betrayed took bread:
The supper commemorates Christ’s body and blood on the night he was betrayed.
- Matthew 26:21
And as they did eat, he said, Verily I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me.
Jesus announces that one of the disciples will betray him.
- John 15:3
Now ye are clean through the word which I have spoken unto you.
The disciples are clean through Christ’s word.
- Luke 22:21
But, behold, the hand of him that betrayeth me is with me on the table.
Jesus announces that his betrayer is at the table.
- John 13:30
He then having received the sop went immediately out: and it was night.
Judas leaves the supper to betray Jesus.
- Mark 14:18
And as they sat and did eat, Jesus said, Verily I say unto you, One of you which eateth with me shall betray me.
Jesus announces at supper that one of those eating with him will betray him.
- Matthew 26:15
And said unto them, What will ye give me, and I will deliver him unto you? And they covenanted with him for thirty pieces of silver.
Judas’s bargain identifies the betrayer Jesus knew was among them.
- Psalms 41:9
Yea, mine own familiar friend, in whom I trusted, which did eat of my bread, hath lifted up his heel against me.
A close companion who shared Jesus’ bread turns against Him.
- Matthew 26:26-28
And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and brake it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat; this is my body.
Jesus’ supper is for those made clean, and Judas was not clean.
- John 13:26
Jesus answered, He it is, to whom I shall give a sop, when I have dipped it. And when he had dipped the sop, he gave it to Judas Iscariot, the son of Simon.
Jesus identifies Judas as the betrayer by giving him the dipped sop.
- John 17:12
While I was with them in the world, I kept them in thy name: those that thou gavest me I have kept, and none of them is lost, but the son of perdition; that the scripture might be fulfilled.
Jesus identifies Judas as the son of perdition.
- John 6:64
But there are some of you that believe not. For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were that believed not, and who should betray him.
Both texts say Jesus knew from the beginning who would betray him.
- Luke 22:3-6
Then entered Satan into Judas surnamed Iscariot, being of the number of the twelve.
Judas agrees to betray Jesus before the supper.
- Matthew 26:23-24
And he answered and said, He that dippeth his hand with me in the dish, the same shall betray me.
Jesus identifies his betrayer and warns of the consequence.
- Luke 22:47-48
And while he yet spake, behold a multitude, and he that was called Judas, one of the twelve, went before them, and drew near unto Jesus to kiss him.
Judas uses a kiss to betray Jesus.
- John 6:70
Jesus answered them, Have not I chosen you twelve, and one of you is a devil?
Jesus had earlier said that one of the twelve was a devil.
- John 18:1-5
When Jesus had spoken these words, he went forth with his disciples over the brook Cedron, where was a garden, into the which he entered, and his disciples.
Judas comes with a mob to arrest Jesus.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
47 sources
At the supper before His crucifixion, while washing the disciples' feet, Jesus said they were not all clean because He knew Judas Iscariot would betray Him.Ms 102, 1904, par. 4–7Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10Ms 19, 1897, par. 3–5Lt 117, 1897, par. 8–10Ms 103, 1903, par. 19–21 To be not clean means to be inwardly defiled in heart and unconverted, which outward washing cannot remove, while the others were cleansed from pride and strife and made ready in humility, love and unity.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 649.1DA 646.3Ms 106, 1903, par. 54–5520MR 148.5–7 He washed even Judas's feet tenderly and let him share the supper as a final appeal of love to confess, believe and be cleansed, but Judas resisted the Holy Spirit, rejected the light and left under Satan's control to carry out his treachery.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 720.2DA 655.4Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57Ms 120, 1897, par. 9 By this act He established foot washing as a continuing ordinance of humility and loving service, to bring believers together in oneness and to prepare their hearts for communion.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–1021MR 346.1–3GW92 245.3–246.2DA 650.2–3 Since human beings cannot read the secrets of the soul, His foreknowledge does not bar anyone from foot washing and the Lord's Supper, yet at every observance He is present as unseen witness reading every heart and calling the unclean to confess and be cleansed.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17Ms 8, 1897, par. 1020MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20
Setting at Last Supper
The saying was spoken while Jesus was washing the disciples' feet at the supper before the Passover and His crucifixion.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10Ms 19, 1897, par. 3–5 He had risen from supper, laid aside His garments, girded Himself with a towel, poured water into a basin, and washed and wiped their feet.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10Ms 19, 1897, par. 3–5 In that washing He told Peter that without washing he had no part with Him, and that one already washed needs only to wash his feet, declaring them clean every whit but not all.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10 The foot-washing was a sacred act done to lead the disciples by remembrance of what Christ had done for them into humility where no one exalts himself above another, and to bring each brother to understand the feelings of his brother.Ms 19, 1897, par. 3–5
At that last gathering before the crucifixion the disciples came with hearts full of selfishness and tempers heated by disputing who should be greatest.GW92 245.3–246.26MR 24.2–3 That contention filled Christ with sorrow and would have shut them out from great blessing.6MR 24.2–3 Hearing their whisperings and seeing their flushed faces, He without a word laid aside His outer garment, girded Himself with a towel as a servant, and washed their feet to rebuke their pride and strife.GW92 245.3–246.26MR 24.2–3 The act humbled the disciples and exposed the pride in their hearts, opening their eyes, filling them with bitter shame and humiliation, and showing them themselves in a new light.6MR 24.2–3Ms 50, 1890, par. 12–13 It was His final lesson in humility and loving service from the pure and spotless Lamb who humbled Himself and gave Himself as a sacrifice, and it left an impression they remembered for life.GW92 245.3–246.26MR 24.2–3
He had taken His disciples away alone, separate from the wicked and unbelievers.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2 He first washed their feet and then gave them broken bread to represent His broken body and juice of the vine to represent His spilled blood.Ms 14, 1895, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2 Through those symbols He is remembered as the sin-bearer who became sin so that people might become God's righteousness in Him.Ms 14, 1895, par. 1–2 Even in that separated company Judas was present as the one not clean.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2
The betrayer was Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, after the devil had put betrayal into his heart.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10
Christ Knew the Betrayer
He knew who would betray Him, and for that reason He said they were not all clean.Ms 102, 1904, par. 4–7Lt 117, 1897, par. 8–10Ms 103, 1903, par. 19–21Lt 336, 1906, par. 5–9Ms 113a, 1897, par. 15 In so saying He distinguished Judas from those who were clean.Ms 102, 1904, par. 4–7Lt 117, 1897, par. 8–10Ms 103, 1903, par. 19–21Lt 336, 1906, par. 5–9Ms 113a, 1897, par. 15 Judas did not share the spiritual cleanness of the others, and His words reflected His knowledge that Judas was not spiritually clean.Ms 102, 1904, par. 4–7Ms 103, 1903, par. 19–21Lt 336, 1906, par. 5–9 Spiritual uncleanness is thus connected with betrayal of Christ.Lt 117, 1897, par. 8–10
He knew Judas's character and secret purpose and wicked schemes to betray Him.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9Ms 106, 1903, par. 29–30DA 653.4–5 He alone knew that secret purpose, while the disciples knew nothing of it and still looked upon Judas as a man of great capabilities and valuable qualifications.Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57 By saying that not all were clean He gave convincing proof that He had read his intentions and that He knew Judas was false.Ms 106, 1903, par. 29–30DA 653.4–5 He gave him no word of rebuke and did not expose him, but treated him with the same goodness, humility and love He showed all the disciples.Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57
His words pointed to Judas's hidden treachery.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 655.2–3 They were spoken so that Judas would understand He was not ignorant, and so that all would know He knew the betrayer.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9 The disciples did not understand them at the time, and only remembered afterward what they revealed.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 655.2–3 His foreknowledge was meant to strengthen the faith of the others.DA 655.2–3
Judas's presence restrained Him from expressing His feelings freely.RH Nov 4, 1902 After Judas left, that restraint was removed.RH Nov 4, 1902 He then spoke more openly and tenderly to those who remained.RH Nov 4, 1902
Meaning of Clean and Unclean
To be not clean means to be unclean inwardly in heart and spirit, and Judas alone was not included when Jesus declared the disciples clean.DA 649.1DA 646.3DA 720.2COS 110.7–9ST Feb 9, 1915 Although his feet were washed and he was tenderly served with the rest, he remained spiritually unclean.DA 649.1DA 720.2COS 110.7–9 Jesus knew he would betray Him, and the exception exposed that hidden treachery.DA 646.3DA 720.2COS 110.7–9ST Feb 9, 1915
Outward foot-washing does not wash away sin, so washing left Judas still defiled in soul.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 649.1Ms 106, 1903, par. 54–55COS 110.7–9 He had not yielded his heart to Christ, been purified, submitted himself to Him, turned from sin, or received cleansing, but brought a traitor's heart to the basin and kept its moral defilement.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 649.1Ms 106, 1903, par. 54–55 The cleansing of the heart is tested in humble service, and mere outward washing did not make him love Jesus.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9COS 110.7–9
He had never experienced the soul cleansing and change of character that constitute conversion, though he acted as a disciple and showed interest in Christ's work and had not received Him as personal Saviour.20MR 148.5–7 Outward discipleship is thus distinguished from inward conversion.20MR 148.5–7 The others had received cleansing from sin, yet temptation had brought pride, jealousy, and alienation into their hearts.DA 646.3 His washing of their feet represented His cleansing grace removing those faults and restoring humility, love, and unity, so that they were ready to receive His words and share in the supper and memorial service.DA 646.3
Patient Appeal to Judas
Though He knew the secret purpose and wicked scheme to betray Him, Jesus still washed Judas's feet, tenderly and even first, and welcomed him to the table to share in the sacrament.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 720.2DA 655.4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20 That washing and that place at the table were His last act for His betrayer, done with willingness to do anything to save even the most guilty sinner, and were a final appeal of love calling him to repent and be cleansed from sin.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 720.2DA 655.420MR 149.2–4Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20 Foreknowledge did not lead Him to exclude Judas, for no human can read the secrets of the soul or reliably tell the worthy from the unworthy and decide who shall take part.20MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20
The declaration that they were not all clean was spoken so Judas would understand that his treachery was known and that Jesus was not ignorant, and so all would afterward know He had known the betrayer.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9 It gave Judas a last opportunity to confess, to believe in Jesus as the Son of God and Redeemer of the world, to be converted, and to become a child of God, though the disciples did not grasp its meaning until afterward.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9
That love and goodness, shown without rebuke or exposure through all His association with him even to bathing his soiled feet with His own hands and wiping them with the towel, thrilled Judas's heart with an impulse then and there to confess his sin.DA 720.2Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57Ms 120, 1897, par. 9 Instead he turned the wrong way, braced his soul against light, fought away the deep impressions of the Holy Spirit, and rejected the final appeal.DA 720.2Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57Ms 120, 1897, par. 9 He let himself become a channel of darkness and a traitor and betrayer, his case was then decided, Satan took control of his heart and mind, and he left to carry out his plan, unafraid and unturned though he knew his purpose was exposed.DA 720.2Ms 19, 1897, par. 56–57Ms 120, 1897, par. 9COS 110.7–9
Such continued ministry to one spiritually unclean shows God's patience, mercy, forbearance, and longsuffering toward even the most grievously erring, and His long patience with perverse human nature.Ms 19, 1897, par. 6–9DA 655.2–3Ms 106, 1903, par. 54–55ST Feb 9, 1915 It teaches not to carelessly abandon one who is in error and leave that person exposed to temptation, but to bear patiently with those at fault and with false brethren who will remain in the church until the close of time.MH 493.3–4Ms 106, 1903, par. 54–55ST Feb 9, 1915 Outward faults do not make a person like Judas, for Peter often appeared worse yet through God's grace became a life of service.MH 493.3–4
Ordinance of Humility Established
The washing of the disciples' feet established foot-washing as a religious ordinance and service to be kept, rather than merely an act of ordinary hospitality.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10DA 650.2–3Ms 8, 1897, par. 10 Its example and command to wash one another's feet are to be brought to remembrance whenever believers come to the ordinance, for God is sacredly near on every such occasion.Ms 35, 1897, par. 9–10 It was given to test and prove loyalty, and it was practiced as a Christian ordinance alongside the Lord's Supper.Ms 8, 1897, par. 10Lt 164, 1897, par. 4–5Lt 189, 1897, par. 15 As a practice to be kept, it is to be observed with separation of the sexes, sisters washing sisters' feet and men not washing women's feet together.5MR 192.1–3
It was Christ's final lesson in humility and loving service, given while the disciples disputed who should be greatest, teaching ministers and all disciples humility from His own example.GW92 245.3–246.2 He who did this was the pure and spotless Lamb who humbled Himself and gave Himself as a sacrifice for humanity.GW92 245.3–246.2 His disciples must follow His example and never consider themselves superior to the lowliest believer.4T 225.3–4 The ordinance was a sacred act done to lead the disciples by remembrance of what Christ had done for them into humility where no one exalts himself above another, and to bring each brother to understand the feelings of his brother.Ms 19, 1897, par. 3–5 It was given to teach a lesson of humility and to bring them together in unity, to assimilate their hearts in oneness with Him, and living this instruction overcomes dissension and strengthens unity with one another and with Christ.21MR 346.1–3Ms 75, 1898, par. 30–32
The ordinance is preparation for communion and precedes partaking of the emblems of the Lord's death.DA 650.2–3Ms 8, 1897, par. 10 Pride, conflict, and desire for supremacy keep the heart from fellowship with Christ and readiness to receive the communion.DA 650.2–3 It was observed together with the Lord's Supper, after humble confessions, as solemn acts humbling worshipers before God.Ms 6, 1859, par. 34Lt 73, 1888, par. 8Ms 28, 1892, par. 15–16 In that observance the sexes are separated, with sisters washing sisters' feet and men not washing women's feet.5MR 192.1–3
By this simple ordinance in connection with the last supper Christ discharged His disciples from the cares, burdens, rites, and ceremonies of the ancient Jewish obligations.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 This was because type was meeting antitype in Himself as the authority and foundation of those ordinances and the great and only efficacious offering for the sins of the world, so to continue them would be an insult to Jehovah.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 He gave this ordinance as a special season when He Himself is always present to lead each participant to feel the pulse of conscience, to awaken understanding of the lessons symbolized, to revive memory, to convict of sin, and to receive penitential offerings.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 It teaches that brother is not to exalt himself above brother and that the dangers of disunion and strife must be seen, because the health and holy activity of the soul are involved.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 It appeals not largely to intellectual capacity but to the heart and to the moral and spiritual nature, doing for the disciples what they needed and disentangling them from rites once held essential but made of no force by the reception of the Gospel.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 Eating His body and drinking His blood means not only the sacramental service but daily partaking of the bread of life that alone satisfies soul-hunger by receiving His Word and doing His will.Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19
Warning and Present Participation
Jesus knew who would betray Him, yet He still washed that disciple's feet and gave him a place at the table and a share in the sacramental service.20MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20 That foreknowledge does not bar anyone from foot washing and the Lord's Supper, and the statement that they were not all clean does not authorize exclusion.20MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20 Human beings cannot read the secrets of the soul and cannot reliably tell who is worthy and who is not, or distinguish the unfaithful from the faithful and the false from the true.20MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20 Therefore no one who wishes to join the ordinances is to be forbidden, no one is to decide who shall take part, the ordinance is not to be delayed because someone present is thought unworthy, and no one is to refuse to attend because another unworthy person is present.20MR 149.2–4Ms 35, 1897, par. 11–12Ms 47, 1897, par. 18–20
Not all who are present at foot washing are cleansed from sin, for the simple ordinance is a religious service rather than ordinary hospitality, given to test and prove loyalty.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17Ms 8, 1897, par. 10 It belongs to every observance as a test and heart-searcher, preceding the partaking of the emblems of the Lord's death.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17Ms 8, 1897, par. 10 At each season Christ Himself is present as the unseen witness, reading every heart with its concealed purposes, wrongdoing, and sin, leading each participant to feel the pulse of conscience, awakening understanding, reviving memory, and receiving penitential offerings.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19 At the same time the Holy Spirit is present to convince of sin and of every wrong and injustice done to a brother and to give gracious opportunity to confess it, appealing to the heart and moral and spiritual nature rather than largely to intellectual capacity.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17Ms 19, 1897, par. 18–19
The same words apply to those who neglect the communion service and leave these seasons of divine appointment, for by doing so they prove themselves unclean.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17DA 656.2–4 Yet they do not mean that people should be barred from the service because someone unworthy is present.Ms 19, 1897, par. 14–17DA 656.2–4 Christ is there to receive and cleanse the repentant.DA 656.2–4
Even when the disciples were taken away alone, separate from the wicked and unbelievers, to have their feet washed and then receive the broken bread to represent His broken body and the juice of the vine to represent His spilled blood, Judas was present among them as the one not clean.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2 So from time to time a Judas may appear to be with God's people and partake, eating and drinking to his own damnation.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2 But God will quickly make him manifest and purge him out from among Israel.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–612MR 247.1–2 Therefore shepherds must move understandingly and with care, following that example, and not hold foot washing and communion among unbelievers, lest reproach come on God's cause.Ms 14, 1850, par. 4–6
Cleanness is also required from the defilement of unkind talk, gossip, accusing brethren, and passing judgment.Lt 264, 1902, par. 11 Where self-assured conversation hurts souls and spoils the work of God, uncleanness remains.Lt 264, 1902, par. 11 Cleansing must come by the Holy Spirit purifying the lips as with a living coal.Lt 264, 1902, par. 11 To continue in such defiling talk is to handle strange fire and to leave His words about cleanness unheeded.Lt 264, 1902, par. 11
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
75 sources
He knew beforehand which one would hand him over, and for that reason he said they were not all clean, leaving Judas Iscariot out while counting the rest as clean.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878ST Feb 11, 1897RH Feb 24, 1859RH May 7, 1872 Not clean does not mean bodily dirt needing ordinary washing, but inward uncleanness of heart needing cleansing from sin.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878RH Feb 24, 1859 The saying belongs to his washing of the disciples' feet, which set foot-washing as a binding example and ordinance his followers must literally keep.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jul 15, 1886ST The service teaches that greatness in his kingdom is serving others in humility, with all believers equal as servants under one Master.ST Mar 30, 1904RH Feb 10, 1916ST Feb 20, 1901 Though he knew the betrayer, he lovingly washed even his feet, yet outward washing did not make him inwardly clean, so the service calls for self-examination, putting away differences, confession and forgiveness before sharing the Supper.ST Aug 28, 1879RH Jun 23, 1910RH Aug 19, 1902RH Jan 14, 1858
Context and Wording
For he knew who would betray him explains why he said they were not all clean, for his knowledge of the coming betrayal is the reason for the exception.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878CO 43.4–5RH Apr 2, 1908 The saying distinguishes spiritual condition rather than bodily dirt, for the washing was not for physical cleanliness or customary removal of dust and did not mean Peter must also have hands and head washed.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878RH Feb 24, 1859 Even one already clean from bathing still had to take part, so the act carried a deeper purpose taught through what was done.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878 The washing included all the disciples without distinction of class, even though one among them was unclean, because Judas was not spiritually clean.CO 43.4–5RH Dec 28, 1911
The one left out was Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, whom Jesus knew would betray him after the devil had put betrayal into his heart.ST Feb 11, 1897ST Jun 7, 1899 When saying they were clean he deliberately added that not all were clean in order to except Judas, while the rest were clean.ST Jul 30, 1885ST Feb 11, 1897ST Apr 19, 1905 The words point to Judas as the exception to the cleansing described and warn that not all outward disciples are spiritually clean.RH May 7, 1872ST Apr 19, 1905
The words were spoken in the upper chamber at the Passover supper on the night of the betrayal, in the course of washing feet at or near the beginning of the meal.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Nov 4, 1897ST Feb 4, 1903 The statement came after he had washed their feet and before he blessed and gave the bread and wine.CO 45.1–2ST Feb 4, 1903 It came before the open announcement that one would betray him, before the departure of Judas, and before the warning to Peter, while Judas still remained with Jesus and the others through supper, foot-washing, and Lord's Supper.ST Jul 12, 1905ST Feb 4, 1903 It belongs to the instruction on the night he was handed over to his enemies and to the instituting of the ordinance of humility and the identifying of the betrayer.ST Nov 4, 1897ST Feb 4, 1903ST May 26, 1909
He spoke with full foreknowledge from the beginning, reading the betrayer's secret character and purpose.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Nov 20, 1913RH Dec 28, 1911 He spoke after Judas had already covenanted with the chief priests for thirty pieces of silver to deliver him and was seeking opportunity to betray him, with revenge cherished in his heart and defilement upon him.RH Dec 28, 1911ST Apr 10, 1907 He spoke while knowing where the supper was held, which knowledge in Judas could have allowed him to alert enemies and disturb the supper and its instruction.ST May 18, 1904 Though knowing this he still washed the traitor's feet with the rest and gave him the bread and cup, showing he did not limit the Supper only to those clear from all sin, and showing that outward participation does not make one inwardly clean.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Nov 20, 1913RH Dec 28, 1911 The betrayal was no surprise to him, and his foresight confirmed his divine foreknowledge to strengthen true followers in his humiliation.RH Dec 28, 1911
Meaning of Not Clean
The lack of cleanness was not bodily dirt or dust on the feet calling for ordinary washing, but inward, spiritual uncleanness of heart needing cleansing from sin.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878RH Feb 24, 1859ST Jul 26, 1883 The washing was therefore not performed for physical cleanliness, but used an act to teach, distinguishing the spiritual condition of the disciples rather than showing that Peter needed his hands and head washed as well.ST Feb 7, 1884ST Oct 24, 1878 Even one already clean from bathing still had to take part, proving the service was not merely customary washing to remove dirt, nor hospitality, but an example to be followed in all coming time.ST Oct 24, 1878RH Feb 24, 1859ST Jul 26, 1883 Those cleansed through the word still need the foot-washing as a token of humility and brotherly love, for cleansing is not merely washing away bodily dust, and the disciples had already bathed though Peter did not understand the service.ST Jul 26, 1883ST Apr 19, 1905 The washing of bodies and feet illustrated the condition of the little church, which was not all clean because one disciple would betray him.ST Apr 19, 1905
A person who has bathed and needs only to wash his feet illustrates this cleansing, with being clean signifying spiritual cleansing applied to the disciples while Judas remains unclean.ST Apr 19, 1905ST May 1, 1901 In the foot-washing physical cleansing illustrated the moral cleansing needed to share in Christ's work, for those who serve the Master must be cleansed.ST May 1, 1901ST May 1, 1901 Humble service of this kind helps prevent strife and division among workers.ST May 1, 1901
The disciples were also not clean of heart because they had just been disputing which should have the highest place in the kingdom.RH Jun 23, 1910 They were full of alienation and dissension instead of true communion, and were not fit to receive the bread and the wine as emblems of true communion.RH Jun 23, 1910 This uncleanness was pointed out because it was desired to wash it away and prepare them for the communion service, establishing foot-washing as a lasting ordinance for the church that would always take away such feelings and conditions.RH Jun 23, 1910
Those who accepted Jesus were once fully cleansed in baptism but afterward become defiled again by sins and find themselves unclean in heart and life, needing cleansing again before taking the emblems that typify perfect unity with his holy, sinless life.RH Jun 23, 1910RH Jun 23, 1910 This later defilement does not entirely separate them from God nor cast them off forever from being his children, and foot-washing coming before the communion service gives time and opportunity for that cleansing, melting hearts and uniting lives and interests when rightly used.RH Jun 23, 1910 The other disciples could be clean while still facing temptation and the possibility of falling into sin, and yielding to temptation would require repentance and cleansing but would not prove they had never been cleansed.RH Jul 31, 1860 By contrast Judas, whose heart was unsanctified, would not yield his pride and self-will to Jesus to be cleansed, and the washing of feet as surrender of pride and self-will left him staying unclean.RH Jul 31, 1860RH Jun 23, 1910
Footwashing as Ordinance
The verse belongs to the washing of the disciples' feet in John 13:4-17, and also to the fuller account in John 13:1-17, which institutes foot-washing as a plainly taught, binding ordinance and example.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jul 15, 1886STRH Jan 20, 1853 As Lord and Master Christ washed His followers' feet when He was about to depart out of this world from love for them, said they ought to wash one another's feet, gave them an example to do as He had done to them, and closed with command to wash one another's feet, so that the record though stated only once is fully true and fully binding as a required Christian duty as valid as if repeated fifty times.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jul 15, 1886ST Jul 8, 1880RH Jan 20, 1853 Followers must literally keep and do what is commanded, men washing the feet of brethren and women washing the feet of sisters, as obedient children do what is said to be ought without caviling over words because He knew what He wanted and what was best, however humiliating, and to disregard His plain Word is to mock God while doing what He commands is what makes one His from a Bible standpoint.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jul 15, 1886ST Jul 8, 1880 It is most explicitly and strictly enjoined under warning that without His washing there is no part with Him, and it gives basis for practicing foot-washing in connection with communion immediately before the Lord's Supper.RH Jan 20, 1853
The act was more than hospitality and more than customary washing to remove dirt, for the lack of cleanness spoken of had no connection with physical uncleanness and the washing did not rest on the hospitable customs of those times.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Apr 22, 1862RH Feb 24, 1859ST Feb 7, 1884 There was no inhospitableness in the disciples and no physical need or need of hospitality calling it forth, so to read it as hospitality leaves it with no occasion and makes it a strange digression from the events then transpiring.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Apr 22, 1862ST Mar 9, 1888 He used an act to enforce a great moral lesson when surrounding circumstances called for it, as when He set a little child among them and taught conversion and becoming as little children to teach humility and equality when they had disputed who would be greatest, and the foot-washing taught that Christian fellowship calls for serving one another and for the service the act represents.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Feb 24, 1859ST Mar 9, 1888 The washing carried instruction to be understood later, and refusing it meant having no part with Him, so with hospitality and physical uncleanness ruled out His act and teaching can only mean He set an example He designed His disciples to follow in all coming time.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Feb 24, 1859ST Feb 7, 1884
The ordinance is a distinct command and example of humble service signifying and memorializing the humility and condescension of the Lord and Master, the Prince of glory, in taking a servant's place, commemorating not only the act of washing their feet but His whole humble life and humiliation, just as the bread and wine is a memorial of His death and baptism is a memorial of His resurrection.ST Jun 14, 1905RH Jun 16, 1868ST Feb 7, 1884RH Jan 8, 1867 It was practiced in the earlier and purer ages of this dispensation and in the early Christian church, until Rome laid polluting hands on the ordinances of the church and abolished or perverted them and its meaning was forgotten or burdened with superstition and outward forms.RH Jun 16, 1868ST Feb 7, 1884 At the close of this age it must be restored with as pure a gospel as at the beginning to occupy its appropriate place in the golden chain as part of the church's ordinances, celebrated instead of the Passover which has served its time and instead of Easter as a heathen institution.RH Jun 16, 1868ST Feb 7, 1884ST Mar 3, 1909 It was observed as a time of humility before partaking of the emblems of His death, and acceptable celebration requires living in obedience to God and being at peace with the brethren.RH Dec 18, 1860ST Mar 3, 1909
Its blessing comes through doing it, not merely knowing about it, for those who know and do these things are happy.ST Oct 31, 1878ST Aug 20, 1902RH Aug 22, 1871 Repeating the act keeps His humility before believers and teaches them to serve one another.ST Oct 31, 1878 Doing this brings Christians to a more common level with more union, communion, manifest love to each other, humility, and happiness, and doing all His will brings His Holy Spirit with power.ST Jul 8, 1880ST Aug 20, 1902RH Aug 22, 1871
Humility and Equal Service
In Christ's kingdom greatness means serving others, and every believer may be called to the lowliest service, for his followers are equal as siblings under one Father and servants under one Master.ST Mar 30, 1904ST Feb 20, 1901RH Oct 8, 1861 The washing followed strife over which was greatest and gave the striking lesson of humility the disciples needed to learn.RH Feb 10, 1916ST May 21, 1896ST Nov 15, 1883ST Nov 15, 1883 Following that example fosters holy, equal fellowship in one body with mutual care, rather than divisions into classes or ranks, and affirms the dignity and equality of all people against seeking supremacy.ST Feb 20, 1901ST Feb 20, 1901RH Oct 8, 1861 True greatness is humble service, and love like his prepares followers to share the gospel.ST Apr 11, 1906
Jesus was greater than they and by right of position Lord of all whom all creatures should serve and obey, yet he served them.ST May 21, 1896 He emptied himself of his rights and his power, did not seek a high estate, and took the form of a servant.ST May 21, 1896 This self-emptying service is Christianity and the mind he wanted the disciples to have and wants all his followers to have.ST May 21, 1896 This course overcomes the world, and for those who continue with him in it a kingdom and a table therein are prepared.ST May 21, 1896
The example makes ordinary, menial duties the test of humble, loving service, and the service expresses love and true fellowship in Christ.ST Feb 20, 1901RH May 30, 1912 Serving willingly out of love for Christ and others expresses humility, while doing the same work only from compulsion or duty is humiliation.RH May 30, 1912 Gladly taking the lowest duties belongs to serving him, and willingness to serve in small ways prepares a person for greater responsibilities.RH May 30, 1912ST Oct 25, 1883
The rebuke exposed the struggle for honor and supremacy, jealousy, criticism, and unholy ambition after three and one-half years of teaching, in sharp contrast at their last gathering before the crucifixion to the dispute over who was greatest.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Nov 15, 1883 At the beginning of the meal the washing answered their struggle over precedence and taught by example that humility is the ground of preferment in his kingdom.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Nov 15, 1883 It led all except Judas to see themselves in a new light, repent, and learn humility and loving service, and though erring and faulty they were brought to renewed love for their Master and one another.ST Apr 11, 1906RH Nov 20, 1913 Judas alone remained the exception, experiencing the servant's task as humiliation because of pride, realizing his secret purpose was known yet staying unclean.ST Apr 11, 1906RH May 30, 1912RH Nov 20, 1913
Jesus and the Betrayer
Though he knew from the beginning who would betray him and read the traitor's secret purpose and character, Jesus made no distinction of class but included all the disciples in the washing and the supper.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Nov 6, 1900 His knowledge that one among them was unclean and would betray him did not keep him from serving them with calm and tender love, and he humbly and lovingly washed even the traitor's feet.ST Aug 28, 1879RH Nov 6, 1900 He did this at the foot-washing on the last night before his crucifixion, after Judas had already covenanted with the chief priests for thirty pieces of silver and was seeking opportunity to deliver him, while the other disciples were striving over who should be greatest.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Jan 4, 1906 Though Judas had followed through three and one-half years of earthly toil with no higher motive than earthly honor and temporal gain, the glorious Son of God clothed with humanity stooped in a servant's act to wash his feet with the rest and gave him the bread and cup.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Jan 4, 1906
That outward washing did not make Judas inwardly clean, for cleanness is inward cleansing from sin and not physical washing.RH Aug 19, 1902RH Apr 2, 1908 Having a part with him depended on more than taking part in a hypocritical formal ceremony, since communion with the Lord is restored through the blood of the Lamb.RH Apr 2, 1908 The washing represented a deeper spiritual cleansing in surrender of pride and self-will, and Judas would not yield his heart to be cleansed and stayed unclean.RH Jun 23, 1910RH Jan 4, 1906RH Nov 20, 1913 His outward participation therefore left him inwardly defiled, with his cherished betrayal still unforgiven and his sins unconfessed.RH Jan 4, 1906RH Nov 20, 1913
The words that not all were clean were convincing proof that he understood the betrayer’s dark, sullen, revengeful character and cherished purpose.RH Nov 20, 1913RH Nov 20, 1913RH Dec 28, 1911 Judas realized he was known and his secret purpose was read, yet he misread the menial act as proof that Jesus would never become a king who could bring honor, exaltation, or personal gain.RH Nov 20, 1913RH Jan 4, 1906RH Dec 28, 1911 There he reached the final decision to follow no further, and by that rejection he stayed unforgiven, leaving the Redeemer’s presence with sins unconfessed to go out into the gloom of eternal night as a lost soul forever.RH Jan 4, 1906 His covetousness and theft showed an unclean heart, his betrayal made him a son of perdition, and while he was present he restrained Jesus from speaking freely until after he left, when the restraint was removed and Jesus spoke more openly and tenderly to those who remained.RH Nov 4, 1902
The betrayal was no surprise to him, and his words at the Passover confirmed his divine foresight to strengthen the faith of true followers in his humiliation.ST Feb 9, 1915 His long patience in continuing to bear with Judas shows his patience with perverse human nature and teaches followers to bear patiently with false brethren who will remain in the church until the close of time.ST Feb 9, 1915RH Jul 23, 1901 For that reason believers are not to separate from those they consider mistaken or sinful, nor to judge who may take part in the Supper and keep others away, since open sin alone excludes the guilty and partaking is otherwise left to self-examination before God.RH Jul 23, 1901RH Dec 28, 1911 All the disciples had serious faults and were erring and faulty, but the washing brought all except one to repentance with renewed love for their Master and one another, even changing pride and ambition into teachableness.RH Nov 20, 1913RH Jul 23, 1901RH Dec 28, 1911
Preparation for Communion
Foot-washing coming immediately before the Lord's Supper gives time and opportunity for renewed cleansing to perfect unity, melting hearts and uniting lives and interests when rightly used.RH Jun 23, 1910RH Jun 23, 1910 Those who accepted Jesus were once fully cleansed in baptism but afterward become defiled again and need cleansing again in heart and life before taking the emblems that typify perfect unity with his holy, sinless life.RH Jun 23, 1910 The disciples were not clean of heart because they had just been disputing about which should have the highest place, full of alienation and dissension instead of true communion, and were not fit to receive the bread and the wine.RH Jun 23, 1910 Jesus pointed to this uncleanness because He desired to wash it away and to prepare them for the communion service, establishing foot-washing as a lasting ordinance that would always take away such feelings.RH Jun 23, 1910 It is a season of self-examination where pride, selfishness and hatred are exposed, where his people learn the true feelings of their hearts toward God and one another, resulting in mutual confessions and increased forbearance, forgiveness of one another's errors and true love preparatory to commemorating his sufferings and death.ST Mar 25, 1880 Following that example leads to heartfelt confession and heavenly blessing, humbling believers and cleansing hearts of pride and other foreign leaven so that pure love can flow in.RH Jan 14, 1858ST May 13, 1875
Rightly used, the service humbles and unites believers to a more common level with more union, communion, manifest love and humility, and helps prevent strife and division.ST Jul 8, 1880ST May 1, 1901 It removes alienation and restores fellowship, calling believers to settle difficulties before sharing the Lord's table.RH Jul 7, 1863 Physical cleansing there illustrated the moral cleansing needed to share in Christ's work, for those who serve the Master must be cleansed.ST May 1, 1901 Its keeping brings reconciliation and spiritual advancement shown in embracing brother with brother, tears, and counting a new beginning of time from that service.RH May 8, 1913
Open sin excludes the guilty, but otherwise no one should pass judgment or keep others from the table, leaving who shall partake to self-examination before God rather than to human judgment.RH Jul 23, 1901RH Dec 28, 1911 Jesus did not limit the Supper only to those clear from all sin, but washed erring, faulty disciples and brought all but one to repentance.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Jul 23, 1901 Though knowing from the beginning that Judas had already covenanted for thirty pieces of silver and had revenge in his heart and was defiled, He washed his feet with the rest and gave him the bread and cup, even letting him unite in partaking of the emblems of broken body and spilled blood while cherishing betrayal.RH Dec 28, 1911RH Dec 28, 1911 A long-suffering Saviour thus held out every inducement for the sinner to repent and be cleansed, and forbids exclusiveness at the Lord's Supper.RH Dec 28, 1911
Acceptable celebration of this ordinance requires living in obedience to God and being at peace with the brethren.ST Mar 3, 1909 The true service joins humble serving with washing feet, and observing the washing even imperfectly is better than neglecting it altogether.ST Apr 10, 1907 Turning it into a mere formal ceremony where participants are given thirty pieces of silver as a price for unfaithfulness perverts it, and the presence of a betrayer who was not spiritually clean shows its danger.ST Apr 10, 1907
Sources