Matthew 27:23
And the governor said, Why, what evil hath he done? But they cried out the more, saying, Let him be crucified.
Translations
And the governor said, Why, what evil has he done? But they cried out the more, saying, Let him be crucified.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And the governor said, Why, what evil hath he done? But they cried out the more, saying, Let him be crucified.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said, Why, what evil hath he done? But they cried out exceedingly, saying, Let him be crucified.
And the governor said, 'Why, what evil did he?' and they were crying out the more, saying, 'Let be crucified.'
And the governor said, What evil then has he done? But they cried more than ever, saying, Let him be crucified.
But, he, said—Indeed! what evil hath he done? But, they, vehemently, were crying aloud, saying—Let him be crucified!
“ Why?” asked Pilate. “ What evil has He done?”But they shouted all the louder, “ Crucify Him!”
“ Why?” asked the governor. “ What evil has He done?” But they shouted all the louder, “ Crucify Him!”
But the governor said, “ Why? What evil has he done?”But they cried out exceedingly, saying, “ Let him be crucified!”
And he said, Why, what evil has he done? But they gave loud cries, saying, To the cross with him!
Then saide the gouernour, But what euill hath he done? Then they cryed the more, saying, Let him be crucified.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
The governor said to them: Why, what evil hath he done? But they cried out the more, saying: Let him be crucified.
Pictures




Cross-references 20 of 34
- Luke 23:20-23
Pilate therefore, willing to release Jesus, spake again to them.
Pilate declares Jesus innocent, but the crowd insists on his crucifixion.
- Mark 15:14
Then Pilate said unto them, Why, what evil hath he done? And they cried out the more exceedingly, Crucify him.
Pilate asks what evil Jesus has done, and the crowd demands His crucifixion.
- John 19:6
When the chief priests therefore and officers saw him, they cried out, saying, Crucify him, crucify him. Pilate saith unto them, Take ye him, and crucify him: for I find no fault in him.
Pilate declares Jesus innocent as the crowd demands crucifixion.
- Acts 3:14-15
But ye denied the Holy One and the Just, and desired a murderer to be granted unto you;
The crowd rejected Jesus and chose a murderer, demanding Jesus’ crucifixion.
- John 18:39-40
But ye have a custom, that I should release unto you one at the passover: will ye therefore that I release unto you the King of the Jews?
Pilate offers to release Jesus, but the crowd chooses Barabbas.
- John 19:15
But they cried out, Away with him, away with him, crucify him. Pilate saith unto them, Shall I crucify your King? The chief priests answered, We have no king but Cæsar.
The crowd demands that Jesus be crucified despite Pilate’s reluctance.
- Matthew 27:19
When he was set down on the judgment seat, his wife sent unto him, saying, Have thou nothing to do with that just man: for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of him.
Pilate’s wife warns him not to condemn Jesus, the just man.
- Luke 23:34
Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots.
Jesus prayed for forgiveness for those crucifying him.
- Matthew 27:42
He saved others; himself he cannot save. If he be the King of Israel, let him now come down from the cross, and we will believe him.
The taunts at the cross continue the rejection begun at Jesus’ trial.
- Luke 23:21
But they cried, saying, Crucify him, crucify him.
The crowd repeatedly demanded that Jesus be crucified.
- Luke 23:16
I will therefore chastise him, and release him.
Pilate finds Jesus innocent yet offers to chastise and release him.
- Matthew 27:15-18
Now at that feast the governor was wont to release unto the people a prisoner, whom they would.
The crowd chooses Barabbas over Jesus during Pilate’s release decision.
- Luke 23:4
Then said Pilate to the chief priests and to the people, I find no fault in this man.
Pilate declares Jesus innocent before delivering Him.
- Matthew 27:12-14
And when he was accused of the chief priests and elders, he answered nothing.
Jesus remains silent before false accusations during his trial.
- Matthew 26:59
Now the chief priests, and elders, and all the council, sought false witness against Jesus, to put him to death;
False witnesses were sought to condemn Jesus, though he was innocent.
- Matthew 21:9
And the multitudes that went before, and that followed, cried, saying, Hosanna to the Son of David: Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord; Hosanna in the highest.
The crowd hailed Jesus as king, then demanded his crucifixion.
- Luke 23:18
And they cried out all at once, saying, Away with this man, and release unto us Barabbas:
echoes crowd demand for Barabbas
- Luke 23:19
( Who for a certain sedition made in the city, and for murder, was cast into prison.)
Barabbas, chosen instead of Jesus, was imprisoned for insurrection and murder.
- Isaiah 53:8-9
He was taken from prison and from judgment: and who shall declare his generation? for he was cut off out of the land of the living: for the transgression of my people was he stricken.
Foretells the Messiah’s condemnation and death under the appearance of justice.
- Matthew 27:17
Therefore when they were gathered together, Pilate said unto them, Whom will ye that I release unto you? Barabbas, or Jesus which is called Christ?
quotes Pilate's choice question
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
51 sources
Pilate's question declared that no evil was proved against Jesus, for he repeatedly found no fault in Him and it was met with no answer because there was nothing to accuse Him of.RH Jan 23, 1900Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6COS 149.4–6 The crowd answered that appeal for justice with an even louder, more insistent demand that He be crucified, stirred by priests and rulers to choose Barabbas, a robber and murderer, over the pure and guiltless One.RH Jan 23, 1900COS 149.4–6DA 735.1–5DA 394.2–35RED 62.3 Though knowing Jesus was innocent, Pilate failed in his duty to do justice and yielded his judgment to a lawless, enraged mob, submitting the sentence to their will.Ms 29, 1909, par. 12–17COS 148.8–149.3ST Jun 3, 1889 The cry was prompted by Satan working through priests and people to reject Jesus and oppose the love revealing God's character, and this malicious rejection exposed his hatred and malice to the loyal universe without defeating the plan of salvation.4SP 321.1–2GC88 501.1–2EW 131.1ST Mar 12, 1885 That judgment-hall choice between Christ and Barabbas symbolizes the choice in earth's final crisis to accept Christ, the Truth, or Satan, the rebel and murderer, and that same choosing is still being made by every person in life today.16MR 259.3–260.1Lt 31, 1898, par. 33–35
Trial Scene Before Pilate
The question belongs to the hearing before Pilate, where Jesus stood bound as a prisoner while the Jewish officials sought to have their own sentence carried out.DA 723.1–724.1 His calm, dignified appearance bore no sign of guilt, and Pilate was reluctant to condemn Him without a substantiated charge.DA 723.1–724.1 The episode belongs to the history of professedly pious Jews, and its place in the account links the crowd's demand for His death to the procession from Pilate's hall to Calvary.Ms 150, 1906, par. 1–3DA 722.5
Pilate attempted to save Jesus by setting Him alongside Barabbas, hoping the contrast between Jesus' innocence and Barabbas' guilt would lead the people to choose Jesus.Ms 112, 1897, par. 33–34 He did so because he recognized Jesus as innocent and no ordinary man, yet the people rejected the choice and demanded crucifixion.Ms 112, 1897, par. 33–34 When Pilate asked whom to release they shouted for Barabbas, and when he asked what to do with Jesus they cried the more for crucifixion.ST May 17, 1899Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9 Pilate declared he found no fault in Him and washed his hands as innocent of His blood, yet delivered Christ into their hands, and they called for His blood to be on them and on their children.ST May 17, 1899Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9
The demand for Barabbas chose a robber and murderer rather than the Son of God, and those who made it crucified Him.ST May 17, 1899Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9 The voices that cried out against Jesus even after the governor asked what evil He had done were the same voices that later praised Herod as a god.3SP 343.2
Pilate Declares Then Yields
The question what evil had been done affirms that no evil had been proved against Jesus, for the governor had repeatedly declared Him innocent and found no fault in Him.RH Jan 23, 1900Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6COS 149.4–6DA 735.1–5Ms 205, 1899, par. 6 The challenge to name His wrongdoing was met with no answer because there was nothing to accuse Him of.Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6DA 735.1–5Ms 205, 1899, par. 6 The crowd answered only by intensifying its demand that He be crucified, showing determination to have Him suffer death despite the lack of any proved fault and despite their own recognition of His innocence.RH Jan 23, 1900Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6COS 149.4–6DA 735.1–5 Their insistence displayed rejection of the sinless Christ and choice of violence and injustice, with religious bigotry and prejudice at work.RH Jan 23, 1900Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6 The priests had stirred the people to fury, and attempts to move them to pity failed.DA 735.1–5
Though knowing Jesus was innocent, the governor failed in his duty to do justice, even while wishing to avoid appearing guilty.Ms 29, 1909, par. 12–17ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jul 11, 18783SP 142.2–3ST Jul 11, 1878 He yielded his own judgment and lost control of the crowd, which now swayed him at its will.COS 148.8–149.3ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jul 11, 1878 He submitted the sentence and the question of life to a lawless, enraged and furious mob, revealing weakness and failure to uphold justice and to judge fairly.COS 148.8–149.3ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jul 11, 18783SP 142.2–3ST Jul 11, 1878 Priests and rulers thus forced the Roman governor to work their will.3SP 142.2–3 His earlier compromises of conscience had left him nearly helpless, and envy and malice were allowed to overwhelm justice so that the death of an innocent man was demanded.3SP 142.2–3
To appease the mob he protested that they were putting to death a man against whom they could prove nothing, yet he proposed to have Jesus beaten and released.ST Jul 11, 18785RED 62.3 His appeal for justice was answered with an even louder demand for crucifixion, though no proven charge stood against Him.ST Jul 11, 18785RED 62.3 That offer to punish instead of acquit exposed his weakness and disregard for duty.ST Jul 11, 1878
Crowd Demands Crucifixion Unjustly
Pilate's appeal for justice — asking what evil had been done — was answered with an even louder, more insistent demand that He be crucified, showing determination to have Him suffer death despite the lack of any proved fault.COS 149.4–6DA 735.1–55RED 62.3Ms 40, 1897, par. 51ST Jul 7, 1898 The insistence persisted although Pilate had repeatedly declared Him innocent and found no fault in Him, and although the crowd itself recognized His innocence, and Pilate's attempts to move them to pity failed.COS 149.4–6DA 735.1–5 Pilate protested that they were putting to death a man against whom they could prove nothing, yet proposed to have Jesus beaten and released to appease them.5RED 62.3
The demand for crucifixion followed the cry to release Barabbas, and it was stirred to fury by the priests and rulers, the chief priests and elders, and the rabbis urging the people on.DA 735.1–5ST Jun 3, 1889SG3 174.2–176.1ST Mar 26, 1894Ms 56, 1894, par. 3–4 Pilate yielded to the pressure of the mob despite the failure to substantiate the charges against Jesus.ST Jun 3, 1889
The rejection was driven by jealousy and fear that Jesus would gain authority, draw the people away, do greater works, become higher in authority and king, by hatred of His righteous, self-denying life that rebuked sin and corruption, by envy and malice overwhelming justice, by religious bigotry and prejudice, and by conviction from His pure life and holy teaching.Ms 40, 1897, par. 3–6ST Feb 5, 1880SG3 174.2–176.13SP 142.2–3STE 59.3 False testimony was arranged and privately hired to condemn Him to death, thinking that by taking His life they could prevent His becoming king, yet charges could not be substantiated.ST Feb 5, 1880SG3 174.2–176.1 Their rejection of Jesus illustrates why people also hate God's word, because it exposes sin and troubles the conscience.STE 59.3
The unjust demand rejected the sinless Christ in favor of violence and injustice, choosing a robber and murderer over the pure and guiltless One.RH Jan 23, 1900DA 394.2–3Ms 56, 1894, par. 3–4 God's providential control turned the act to good without lessening guilt, for by murdering Him the leaders brought about the very outcome they sought to prevent, since through death Jesus became Redeemer and Saviour of the world, Redeemer of mankind, Saviour of the fallen race, and ruler over the whole world, yet their crime remained heinous.ST Feb 5, 1880SG3 174.2–176.1
The multitude that had hailed Jesus as king turned to hiss, revile, humiliate, and jeer at Him as a doomed man, a cruel jeering hooting rabble scorning Him who was doomed to the cross.DA 394.2–34RED 102.2–103.1 The contrast made His condemnation a severe test for the disciples, who saw their beloved Teacher in the hands of wicked men with their own nation clamoring for His blood and who mourned.DA 394.2–3ST Jul 7, 1898 Jesus foresaw this fickleness and inconstant favor and brought about an earlier crisis to sift unbelieving, weak, undecided, and faint-hearted professed followers, so their apostasy in the hour of horror would not sink the rest beneath fear and disappointment, overwhelm the twelve with surprise, carry them all away, or add unbearable grief and ruin of hope.4RED 102.2–103.12SP 289.2–290.1 The faithful few, having seen turning before for less reason, were comforted, strengthened, and prepared not to hang faith on others' opinions when professed lovers turned from Him in trouble.4RED 102.2–103.12SP 289.2–290.1
Satan Exposed, God Vindicated
The cry for crucifixion after the governor's question about what evil had been done was prompted by Satan working through priests and people to reject Jesus and to oppose the love and mercy that revealed God's character, the culmination of his effort to turn people against Christ and His love.4SP 321.1–2GC88 501.1–2ST Mar 12, 1885 Satan and his angels stirred Jesus' own nation to demand His blood and to heap cruelty and scorn upon Him, hoping the abuse would make Him abandon His humility and meekness.ST Mar 26, 1894SG1 39.1EW 131.1 His influence turned the stirred crowd into liars and murderers, and their act was witnessed by heaven and recorded for time and eternity.ST Mar 26, 1894Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9 Satan himself stood at the head of those reviling, crucifying, and abusing the Saviour and led the cruel mob in its abuse.Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9
This malicious rejection exposed Satan's hatred, revenge, and malice to the loyal universe and helped reveal his character to the universe.4SP 321.1–2GC88 501.1–2ST Mar 12, 1885 Yet the plot did not defeat the plan of salvation.EW 131.1 All rebellion against God is directly due to satanic influence, for those who set themselves against the government of God enter into alliance with Satan, who captivates the senses, misleads the understanding, and causes everything to appear in a false light.PP 635.2 The Jewish scribes and elders, professing great zeal for the honor of God while crying out for His Son to be crucified, deceived themselves with the belief that they were serving God, giving strong evidence of Satan's delusive power.PP 635.2
As with Korah, Dathan, and Abiram in rejecting Moses, in rejecting God's chosen instrument they rejected Christ and insulted the Spirit of God, and the same spirit still exists in those who follow their own will in opposition to the will of God.PP 635.2 The choice of Barabbas and the cry for crucifixion was a yoking with Satan and a bearing of the insults of Satan and his agencies, showing Satan linked with men.Ms 106, 1897, par. 5 Their triumphant shouting in blasphemy was directed against the Commander of all heaven, who came from heaven to save a perishing world and in whose heart zeal for right and justice and for the glory of God was the highest object.Ms 106, 1897, par. 5 Those shouting made an outward appearance of sanctity and deceived the people, though Christ had declared them whited sepulchers, and their choice gave evidence that profession of piety and of love for God and a claim to know the Scriptures neither made them sons of God nor led them to represent His character.Ms 106, 1897, par. 5
Though utterly helpless when priests and rulers forced even the Roman governor to work their will, Jesus trusted the word of God and withstood the power of the whole world, giving an example of living faith by which the soul becomes a conquering power and righteousness triumphs.RH Nov 11, 1915Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9 From the manger to the cross He lived a sinless life without swerving from allegiance to His Father, thus proving false Satan's assertion that God's law could not be kept.Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9 By suffering on Calvary a cruel death of shame He proved false Satan's charges against God and vindicated God in the sight of the angels in heaven as One willing to make in man's behalf the greatest sacrifice that could be made.Lt 132, 1910, par. 4–9
Retribution and Final Reckoning
The sentence they demanded for Christ later fell upon the demanders themselves, for during Jerusalem's destruction many Jews were crucified with crosses planted around the city in great numbers.DA 840.5Lt 98, 1900, par. 31–33 Having refused mercy and persisted in rebellion, God permitted them to follow their own purposes and withdrew the protection of heavenly intelligences, so Jerusalem was humiliated and brought low, illustrating the result of an unrighteous, disobedient course.Lt 98, 1900, par. 31–33 By calling for His blood to be upon themselves and their children they brought consequences upon themselves, those words continued to trouble them and God's curse rested on them, while their hands were not cleansed from shedding the Redeemer's blood.ST May 17, 189912MR 411.3–4 The swelling cry had Jesus executed as a criminal, but many who joined it later realized the calamity when Jesus was missing from the feast and they learned He was dead.ST Aug 8, 1878 They would have as eagerly cried for Jesus had He still been alive, and their mourning over the sick and dying left without His healing showed that a great light had gone out leaving a blank that could not be supplied.ST Aug 8, 1878
Those who later listened at Pentecost had taken an active part in His death with their voices mingling with the rabble throng, yet they trembled with conviction and anguish when the disciples declared by the Holy Spirit that the humiliated, spit-upon, smitten, thorn-crowned, crucified Man is the Prince of Life now at God's right hand.ST May 17, 1899 Those who rejected and crucified Him will see Him in glory as King of kings and Lord of lords.ST Mar 26, 1894 At the final judgment sinners compelled to look upon Him still wearing humanity will remember with indescribable confusion how His love was slighted and His compassion abused.21MR 349.6–350.3
Finite man rejected the Prince of Life and cast Christ out while heaven received Him, choosing Barabbas, crowning Christ with thorns, and calling for His death.Lt 31, 1898, par. 33–35 His death brings upon the rejector of mercy God's wrath and judgments unmixed with mercy, the wrath of the Lamb, but to all who receive and believe Him it is hope and eternal life, for God exalted Him and crowned Him with royal majesty.Lt 31, 1898, par. 33–35 The demand was disloyalty and denial dishonoring God by traitors in disguise whom Christ fully knows.MWISDAP 15.3–4 For the unrepentant punishment hereafter is measured by light and position, so the higher the position and the greater the light of one becoming disloyal, the greater the punishment.MWISDAP 15.3–4
Choosing Barabbas Still Today
The choice in the judgment hall between Christ and Barabbas stands for the choice in earth's final crisis to accept Christ, the Truth, or Satan, the rebel, liar, robber, and murderer.16MR 259.3–260.1 Jesus is the Son of God who made the world and all things in it, while Barabbas stands for Satan personified.16MR 259.3–260.1 The roaring demand for Barabbas and for Christ to be crucified chose Satan before the Son of God and exalted Satan above Him.16MR 259.3–260.1
That same choosing is still being made in the world today, with each person individually demonstrating by life whether he chooses Barabbas or Christ.16MR 259.3–260.1 The issue still stands whether to have Christ Jesus to rule or to have Barabbas.Lt 31, 1898, par. 33–35 Rejecting the message of mercy concerning God's commandments and the faith of Jesus turns from the Son of God and joins those disloyal to Him. Rejecting the light of heaven likewise rejects Christ and the only means of cleansing from sin, leaving those who reject Him accountable to God, to be reckoned with at the final judgment. Rejecting truth when presented rejects Christ, chooses Barabbas over Him, and bears responsibility for His death, which is crucifying the Son of God afresh and putting Him to open shame.Ms 40, 1897, par. 51
The choice revealed character in contradiction to observed religious ceremonies.12MR 411.3–4 Outward appearance of sanctity deceived the people, yet a profession of piety and of love for God and a claim to know the Scriptures neither made men sons of God nor led them to represent His character.Ms 106, 1897, par. 5 They were as whited sepulchers, reviling One who came to save a perishing world and in whose heart zeal for right and justice and for the glory of God was the highest object.Ms 106, 1897, par. 5 Jesus rejects religious hypocrisy but never spurns a sincere penitent.12MR 411.3–4 Blindness came upon the people because they overlooked the word of Life and failed to search the Scriptures, and the same neglect in these last days causes many to be weighed in the balances and found wanting, when minds engrossed with things of little importance set aside eternal truth.Ms 1, 1869, par. 10–12
Their rejection shows why people hate God's word, because it exposes sin and troubles the conscience, since His pure life and holy teaching convicted them of sin.STE 59.3 Their treatment of the innocent Jesus tests professed love for Christ.SG1 170.1 The demand was part of the apostate effort to destroy Christ, the champion of God and truth, and to sever the world's communication with heaven.ST Apr 15, 1897 Yet His death was the perfect sacrifice for the sins of the whole world.Ms 56, 1894, par. 3–4
The same disloyal subjects exist now and would make the same demand were Christ on earth today in human form.MWISDAP 15.3–4 Their cry for His blood is like the demand of the Roman zealots that Luther be killed because he opposed their institutions and appealed to the Bible.ST Jun 21, 1883 That same eager cry for blood was repeated by the papacy against Luther when he was summoned to Worms, determined to stop the mouth of that fearless advocate of truth and to make him answer for his folly, ready to take any measure to silence him.SG4 275.3–276.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
94 sources
Pilate asked what wrong Jesus had done, and the crowd only shouted all the louder for him to be crucified.ST May 19, 1898RH Dec 15, 1863RH Dec 15, 1863 He protested that he could find no evil or fault in him, while the chief priests, elders and rulers stirred up the people to insist on crucifixion.ST May 19, 1898ST Oct 27, 1898ST Mar 28, 1906 His question exposes that Jesus was condemned as an innocent and harmless man, with no evil named or proven against him.RH Jan 23, 1900RH Nov 18, 1862RH Sep 15, 1868 That demand revealed the principles of Satan's rule in the great controversy between good and evil, turning the people into liars and murderers before heaven.ST Mar 26, 1894ST Mar 11, 1903 The judgment-hall choice between Christ and Barabbas stands for the final crisis to accept Christ the Truth or Satan the rebel, liar, robber and murderer.
Trial Words and Scene
The governor's question asks what evil Jesus has done, and the crowd answers only by crying out all the more that he be crucified.ST May 19, 1898RH Dec 15, 1863RH Dec 15, 1863RH Jun 13, 1871 The question protests that no evil can be identified in him, and the louder answer exposes the groundlessness of the hatred while bringing his innocence to mind.ST May 19, 1898RH Dec 15, 1863 The demand is a cry for the blood of the innocent Savior, arising from enmity against what is heavenly and divine, an opposition that can point to no evil he has done.RH Dec 15, 1863RH Jun 13, 1871
Pilate protests that Jesus has done no evil and that no fault or crime worthy of death is found in him, while the crowd, urged on and stirred up by the chief priests and elders and rulers, only cries more loudly and insistently for crucifixion.ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 19, 1898ST Mar 28, 1906 Their demand opposes the declarations of both Pilate and Herod that Jesus deserves no punishment, and it will not yield to law or justice or pity even for the beaten and bleeding Jesus.ST Oct 27, 1898 It follows the cry to release Barabbas, and Pilate yields to the pressure of the mob despite the failure to substantiate the charges.ST Jun 3, 1889
Having examined Jesus before the accusers, Pilate declares he finds no fault touching the accusations and that Herod has found nothing worthy of death in him.ST Mar 13, 1901 For the third time he asks what evil has been done and proposes to chastise Jesus and release him, still desiring his release.ST Nov 9, 1882ST Mar 13, 1901 This third appeal comes after the plan to turn Jesus over to Herod has failed and the offer of a Passover pardon has failed, and it attempts to shift responsibility for releasing an innocent prisoner onto the priests and rulers and people.ST Mar 13, 1901 Every wavering effort to throw off responsibility and appease a mob whose unreasoning wrath has been wrought into madness only strengthens the Jews, makes them more urgent, and makes the weight heavier and the situation harder.ST Mar 13, 1901
The crowd together with loud voices asks for Barabbas instead of Jesus, a noted criminal held and convicted for insurrection and robbery and murder, the same crime Jesus is charged with.ST Mar 13, 1901ST Mar 13, 1901 Pilate inconsistently leaves an innocent man's fate to the choice of his avowed enemies after declaring him innocent, as the chief priests incite the people to demand Barabbas's release while demanding Jesus' death. They demand not only death but death by crucifixion, and their loud voices prevail so that Pilate gives sentence that what they ask should be done.ST Mar 13, 1901ST Mar 13, 1901
Pilate has Jesus scourged and displayed beside Barabbas, hoping the sight of punishment will move the crowd to accept it as sufficient.ST Oct 7, 1886 Jesus' bloodied, exhausted appearance stands in stark contrast to Barabbas's hardened criminal character.ST Oct 7, 1886
Pilate declares he finds no fault in Jesus and washes his hands as innocent of his blood, yet delivers Christ to be led away and crucified.ST May 17, 1899RH Jun 15, 1911 The people cry for his blood to be on them and on their children, and their hands are not cleansed from the blood shed when they crucify the world's Redeemer.ST May 17, 1899 Those who shout have mingled their voices with the rabble throng and taken active part in his death, choosing a robber and murderer rather than the Son of God, while priests and rulers still bear abiding hatred toward Christ.ST May 17, 1899 The same people later tremble with conviction and anguish at Pentecost when the disciples declare by the Holy Spirit that the man humiliated, spit upon, smitten, crowned with thorns and crucified is the Prince of Life now sitting at the right hand of God.ST May 17, 1899 Pilate has repeatedly declared Jesus innocent and just, but the mob's howling prevails.RH Jun 15, 1911
The scene joins Jew and Gentile together in hatred against him as Jesus stands in the Roman hall at Pilate's judgment seat, mocked and beaten, crowned and wounded.RH Nov 12, 1872 He stands alone in mocking robes before the proud throne, the Root of David made a shameful sight, while priests and elders swell the demand that he be crucified.RH Mar 5, 1901 As his foes shout against him, he is left alone and finds no human friend in his hour of pain.RH Nov 17, 1910
Pilate would not have condemned Christ had he not feared the mad, thoughtless mob stirred up by the priests.ST Jun 26, 1893 Against his own judgment of Christ's innocence, the popular clamor moves him to condemn.ST Jun 26, 1893
Innocence and Unjust Verdict
The question puts on record a public trial ending in condemnation of an innocent and harmless man already declared innocent by his judge, with no evil named or proved against him.RH Jan 23, 1900RH Nov 18, 1862RH Sep 15, 1868RH Jun 12, 1866RH Jun 12, 1866 When challenged to state the wrong, the crowd gave no answer but only cried still louder for crucifixion, exposing the absence of any stated charge and showing how those who might once have favored him came to demand his execution.RH Sep 15, 1868RH Jun 12, 1866RH Feb 27, 1872 That condemnation was unjust and illegal, obtained when the Jewish council used threats and intimidation to gain the Roman governor's approval.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Mar 15, 1877 Pilate had found no basis for death under Jewish law for blasphemy, so the leaders pressed on and shifted the accusation to treason against Caesar, until political pressure moved him to sentence Jesus to death.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Mar 15, 1877
He whose death was demanded had done only good, healing the sick and the lame, giving sight to the blind, and giving hope and encouragement through words of love.ST Jul 11, 1878ST Oct 11, 1899 Yet the cry for his death followed the people's earlier praise of him as King, displaying rage and rejection of one who willingly went to suffering and death so even his enemies might be freed.ST Jul 11, 1878ST Oct 11, 1899 Pilate knew him to be innocent and just, having repeatedly declared him so, yet submitted the question of his life and the sentence to a lawless, furious, enraged mob.ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jul 11, 1878ST Jul 11, 1878 In doing so he revealed weakness and failure to uphold justice and to judge fairly, and his offer to punish instead of release exposed disregard for the duty of his office.ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jul 11, 1878ST Jul 11, 1878
His moral principles and sense of justice failed under pressure because they were not grounded in love for God and regard for his law, so that even a reluctant attempt to appear innocent could not undo his part in the condemnation.RH Aug 25, 1868ST Oct 7, 1886 By yielding his judgment to the crowd he abandoned the fair judgment his office required, and his earlier compromises of conscience left him nearly powerless before them.RH Aug 25, 1868ST Oct 7, 1886 The appeal in the verse was a third appeal, made after the plan to turn Jesus over to Herod had failed and the offer of a Passover pardon had failed, and it was an attempt to shift responsibility for releasing an innocent prisoner onto priests and rulers and to appease a mob whose unreasoning wrath had been wrought into madness by cowardly shirking of duty, by offering to have Jesus chastised and then set free.ST Mar 13, 1901 Every effort to throw off responsibility made the weight heavier and the situation harder, and his wavering only strengthened the Jews and made them more urgent, until after they rejected release and chose Barabbas, a noted criminal held for insurrection and murder, they demanded not only death but death by crucifixion.ST Mar 13, 1901
Amid the murderous clamor the voice of Pilate's wife was the only one raised in his defense, warning Pilate to shield and spare Jesus as guiltless blood.ST Oct 27, 1898RH Dec 14, 1911 The loud cry for crucifixion rose from scornful priests deriding and elders murmuring after Pilate had left his wife's side, and his failure to mark her prayer made the condemnation a horror and a stain and curse that ended his early joy and left him exiled with her under the skies of Gaul.ST Oct 27, 1898RH Dec 14, 1911 Meanwhile Jesus remains the Crucified, knelt to by all tribes and ages who believe in him that died, and who shall come to judge the living and the dead.ST Oct 27, 1898 The governor's challenge exposed the groundlessness of hatred against the Savior and brought his innocence to mind, but the crowd shut its ears and intensified its demand, presenting the demand for the innocent Savior's death as opposition that could point to no evil he had done.RH Dec 15, 1863RH Jun 13, 1871 So too no evil can be charged against the manifestations under discussion, just as the crowd could not name an evil he had done when asked.RH Jun 13, 1871RH Jun 13, 1871
Date Setting and Accuracy
The condemnation stands amid the events of the crucifixion day, the day above all others on which Christ showed His love for humanity by giving His life and bearing the curse for sinners.RH Feb 13, 1872 That crucifixion took place at the last Passover He attended, in A.D. 31.ST Dec 23, 1897 Counted as the endpoint of a three-and-a-half-year ministry begun at age thirty, that Passover date places His birth around September, not December 25.ST Dec 23, 1897 Read with what follows as one undivided narrative, the account shows that on the Sabbath day the Jews sought to have the sepulcher made sure lest His word that He would rise after three days come true, that Pilate told them to take a guard and secure it themselves, and that they sealed the stone and set the watch in the very closing part of the Sabbath day, before the dawn toward the first day of the week when Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the sepulcher.ST Jul 16, 1912
Crucifixion was already a familiar Roman method of executing criminals, as appears when the crowd, asked what should be done with Jesus, called for Him to be crucified.ST May 6, 1913 The trial narrative is true history told with minute accuracy in customs, opinions, political events, and circumstances.RH Feb 11, 1862 Pilate was governor of Judea at that time, a sentence from him was necessary before proceeding to execution, and the power of life and death was vested in the Roman governor.RH Feb 11, 1862 The surrounding details flow naturally and undesignedly, with nothing out of place or forced to give probability: the derision of the condemned, scourging before crucifixion, the written accusation affixed to the instrument of punishment in three languages as with public notices at Jerusalem, the condemned bearing His cross, and the body given up for burial at the request of friends.RH Feb 11, 1862 That minuteness and consistency throughout, matching the manners and institutions of the period, is strong evidence for the truth of the account.RH Feb 11, 1862
The release of Barabbas instead of Jesus may have followed Barabbas’s arrest as a leader in the same tumult associated with Pilate’s massacre of Galileans.ST Feb 16, 1882 The rejection, with the governor asking what evil Jesus had done while the crowd still demanded crucifixion, stands against Judas’s expectation that Jesus would lead Israel’s deliverance and his scheme involving Barabbas.ST Oct 4, 1910
Rejection and Cosmic Conflict
The governor's question proved no evil against Jesus, yet the crowd only cried the more for crucifixion, rejecting the sinless Christ and choosing violence and injustice, hating and destroying their best friend while preferring an evildoer.RH Jan 23, 1900RH Jul 2, 1861 That cry for the blood of the innocent Savior sprang from the carnal heart's inherent enmity against what is heavenly and divine, displaying the cruelty and madness of sin in the final events of his life.RH Dec 15, 1863RH Jun 10, 1862 The same people who one day honored him, hailed him as king and strewed his way with garments, the next day, led by demagogues and wrought into frenzy, became a weak, impulsive, degenerate mob demanding his death instead of remaining calm, thoughtful and self-controlled.ST Oct 8, 1896ST Sep 2, 1897ST Their Hosanna of one day became crucify him the next, showing how quickly praise turns and how uncertain human fame and approval are, and proving popular feeling no reliable standard of judgment.RH Feb 15, 1870RH Dec 2, 1862
Jealousy and fear that he would gain authority moved the leaders to arrange false testimony and seek his death, and their crime brought about what they sought to prevent, for through his death he became Redeemer and Saviour of the world, though God's providential use of their act for good did not lessen their guilt.ST Feb 5, 1880 After priests and rulers persuaded the people to choose Barabbas, a thief and murderer, instead of Christ, the unjust rejection and sentence rose in a cry heard in heaven, revealing the principles of Satan's rule as displayed in the great controversy between good and evil. Stirred up by priests and rulers, that cry and the abuse that followed showed how Satan's influence turns people into liars and murderers, witnessed by heaven and recorded for time and eternity, and those who rejected and crucified him will see him in glory as King of kings and Lord of lords.ST Mar 26, 1894 The last act on Calvary, when Judea with heart turned against her Lord cried for the Harmless One amid jeers from throats that lately praised him, was taught and driven by Satan, a cherub once endowed with glory, beauty, wisdom and knowledge of heaven's love and peace, now a malignant fiend warring against God.ST Mar 11, 1903 Watched with reverent suspense by countless peopled worlds, that act sealed the doom of evil and its king and forever exposes what cherished selfishness produces, inspiring dread and loathing of transgression as an eternal safeguard against renewed sin.ST Mar 11, 1903
The demand to crucify him was the culmination of Satan's effort to turn people against Christ and his love, and the rejection and cruelty exposed his malice and helped reveal his character to the loyal universe.ST Mar 12, 1885 Choosing Barabbas, a robber and murderer, over Christ the Son of God, the innocent Lamb condemned between criminals, was part of the apostate effort to destroy the champion of God and truth and sever the world's communication with heaven.ST Apr 15, 1897RH Jun 24, 1915 The priests who incited the people acted with dishonesty and perfidy from bigotry hating religious innovation and opposing interference with immemorial institutions, and from cupidity fearing loss of prestige and perquisites because Christ as mediator robbed them of their distinctive exclusive function.ST Sep 22, 1898 They repudiated him prematurely and maliciously refused to reconcile him with prophecy, becoming actively criminal when they incited the demand, for he who fires the perpetrator's brain is responsible for the crime.ST Sep 22, 1898 The clamoring for blood was malice following hatred rooted in envy, rebellion inspired by the priests against the most lovely personage ever to visit the globe, a deliberate self-deception grown into determined rebellion with no remedy.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 28, 1873
Those who mourned their ancestors' rejection of the prophets rejected and killed the Son when he came, after rejecting John's message, ignoring truths made known and covering them with error and confusion even while enlightening mankind.RH Jun 30, 1904ST Jul 4, 1878RH Jun 13, 1865 The same crime is committed with even greater light by those who reject religious reform, oppose God's holy law and the testimony on fulfilled prophecy, warn against those spreading last-day truths as heresy and fanaticism, and ignore grand truths made known for God's people in the last perilous days.RH Jun 13, 1865 Rejection of the true view of his kingdom led to enforcement of a religious creed by force and to his crucifixion, and Jerusalem's earthly hopes failed fully when the people chose Barabbas and Caesar over Christ and God, showing the hopelessness of salvation by human works and of hopes for his kingdom through the Jews' return to Palestine.ST Jul 6, 1915ST Apr 11, 1900 Choosing Barabbas instead of Christ brought consequences, for they came to suffer Barabbas' cruelty, and rejection of the Son preceded destruction of Jerusalem and the nation by the Romans under Titus.ST Aug 18, 1909
Many who swelled the cry Crucify him later realized the calamity when he was missing and dead, and would have cried Give us Jesus had he lived, mourning the sick and dying left without healing and showing a great light had gone out leaving an unsupplied blank.ST Aug 8, 1878 As he was brought toward the cross with his own nation clamoring for his blood, the fearsome sight of the beloved Teacher in wicked hands tested the disciples' faith and caused them to mourn.ST Jul 7, 1898 Yet those who joined the demand could still repent and receive mercy, for guilt did not place them beyond the gospel's offer.RH Jun 12, 1855 Many who took active part in his death with voices mingling in the throng, choosing a robber and murderer when asked whom to release and crying his blood be on them and their children though Pilate declared no fault and washed his hands, later trembled with conviction and anguish when they heard that the humiliated, spit upon, smitten, thorn-crowned and crucified man is the Prince of Life at God's right hand.ST May 17, 1899
Doctrinal Connections and Prophecy
The demand for crucifixion belongs to the death of Jesus as the great sacrifice for human sin that brought the sacrificial system to an end, and that death belongs to the story of Jesus whose coming was foretold in prophecy as the world's Saviour and perfect example.RH Jan 11, 1915 The difference between going with Jesus to the judgment hall and going with him to Calvary is that consecration means giving life and not merely enduring suffering for a time.ST Sep 12, 1900 The sacrificed animal represented the offerer, and its shed blood and consumed flesh signified complete consecration, because shedding of blood means giving of life and is necessary for remission.ST Sep 12, 1900 The stripping of his robe by the soldiers before that death pictures the seventh-day Sabbath stripped of the fourth commandment, and putting Sunday in its place and attaching that commandment to the new day is like choosing Barabbas instead of Christ.RH Feb 14, 1854
The governor's question and the louder cry for crucifixion show religious leaders using the state's power to condemn Jesus because he would not submit to their traditions made into civil law. Jewish leaders and crowd compelled the Roman governor to execute Christ, which is civil authority drawn into defining and punishing what they called sin and usurping God's place.ST Oct 9, 1907 The same scene shows how people with high claims of godliness can reject light and persecute the innocent while imagining they serve God.ST Sep 24, 1894 That pattern reaches to using civil penalties and imprisonment against Sabbathkeepers, and the same spirit that chose Barabbas over Jesus works in opposition and slander against those preaching present truth, which without protection of law could stop the message from being preached.ST Sep 24, 1894RH Mar 15, 1860
A majority can condemn the innocent and oppose what is right, as the crowd pressed for crucifixion even after being asked what evil had been done.ST Sep 9, 1889 Popular opinion, even when voiced by religious leaders and supported by the masses, can demand an unjust act that government then carries out.RH Jun 4, 1908 The growing insistence of the crowd was no proof its demand was just or right, for a majority can act tyrannically and the people's voice is not necessarily God's voice.ST Feb 10, 1887 Popular sentiment can therefore drive grave injustice, and popular opinion can oppose justice so that it must not be treated as an infallible guide, especially in religious matters.ST May 10, 1910RH Apr 14, 1874 Many who had welcomed Jesus with praise soon cried for his crucifixion, proving popular feeling is no reliable standard of judgment.RH Feb 15, 1870
The cry for his blood at a priest's signal shows how people with little religious understanding may follow religious leaders against truth, though some retain humane hearts and thinking minds.RH Apr 28, 1874 The same spirit appears in the demand of Roman zealots that Luther be killed because he opposed their institutions and appealed to the Bible.ST Jun 21, 1883 Abundant religious profession did not make the demanders' worship true, for their opposition displayed false religion persecuting those who obey God.RH Jul 10, 1860 Outward display of God's word upon the person did not make the hypocritical Pharisees better nor keep them from murder in demanding his crucifixion, proving a thing is not good or bad simply because it mentions God or omits mention of him.RH Nov 5, 1901
By yielding to the cry Pilate set himself against the Rock of God's word, among those who lifted puny hands against God's mighty plans and precepts with Nimrod, the Pharaohs, Sennacherib, Agag, Belshazzar, Herod and Judas Iscariot.ST Jul 15, 1908 His name is saved from oblivion only to live in infamy for opposition to truth, while the man is dead and the Rock stands, setting the choice between the word of God and human conclusions, between witnessing for the Bible and witnessing against it.ST Jul 15, 1908 The scene of Christ before Pilate depicts him as humble in contrast with the pope.RH Dec 21, 1911 Though utterly helpless before priests and rulers forcing even the Roman governor to work their will, he trusted the word of God and withstood the power of the whole world, giving an example of living faith by which the soul becomes a conquering power and righteousness triumphs.RH Nov 11, 1915
Christian perfection is shown in faithfully following Christ through unjust judgment and suffering even to crucifixion, rather than in extraordinary spiritual experiences.RH Aug 14, 1860 The judgment hall was unjust, and following him means resolutely taking the cross and following him through that trial toward Calvary, learning from him to bear the cross and not turn away from hardship.RH Mar 26, 1861RH Jul 30, 1867 His calm self-possession amid turmoil exemplifies Christian repose, a steady trust in God that remains composed under pressure and is sustained by faith in the Father and confidence in his promises.ST Jul 29, 1886 Before Pilate and the hostile crowd he remained undaunted, not yielding to fear, public pressure or the demand to abandon truth, joining courage with the gentleness and innocence of the Lamb without anger or haughtiness.RH May 5, 1863
Warning and Christian Living
The record of suffering in Matthew 27 subdues pride and casts out discontent, so that reading it steadies the fretful and lifts the gloomy Christian.ST Apr 17, 1879 The governor's question, finding no fault in Jesus, met only with louder cries for death, sets before every reader a choice between Christ and the world. To choose Christ is to give up worldly pleasures, riches, and fame, to follow His commandments and works, and to accept earthly hardship in hope of eternal life and a heavenly crown.
The judgment-hall choice between Christ and Barabbas stands for the final crisis of accepting Christ the Truth or Satan the rebel, liar, robber, and murderer. Rejecting the message of mercy concerning God's commandments and the faith of Jesus is turning from the Son of God and joining those disloyal to Him. Persisting in the demand to crucify, together with choosing Barabbas, is rejecting Christ, rejecting the light of heaven, and rejecting the only means of cleansing from sin. Those who reject Him are accountable to God for that choice, and His rejection will be reckoned with at the final judgment.
The cry for crucifixion is rejection of Jesus as Son of God and Messiah-King to whom all owe allegiance, so that to refuse Him as Lord is disloyalty to God and to refuse Him as Saviour is to miss eternal life.ST Mar 23, 1915 The rage fell upon One who had healed the lame and given sight to the blind, and it followed the same people's earlier praise of Him as King.ST Oct 11, 1899 Yet He willingly went to suffering and death so that even His enemies might be freed.ST Oct 11, 1899 As the cross draws near, the shouts of crucify pierce His wounded heart.ST Oct 11, 1899
Sources